There can be no sane discussion of
“crime” and “criminals” without
an investigation of the meaning of the words.
A large majority of men, even among the educated,
speak of a “criminal” as if the word had
a clearly defined meaning and as if men were divided
by a plain and distinct line into the criminal and
the virtuous. As a matter of fact, there is no
such division, and from the nature of things, there
never can be such a line.
Strictly speaking, a crime is an act
forbidden by the law of the land, and one which is
considered sufficiently serious to warrant providing
penalties for its commission. It does not necessarily
follow that this act is either good or bad; the punishment
follows for the violation of the law and not necessarily
for any moral transgression. No doubt most of
the things forbidden by the penal code are such as
are injurious to the organized society of the time
and place, and are usually of such a character as
for a long period of time, and in most countries, have
been classed as criminal. But even then it does
not always follow that the violator of the law is
not a person of higher type than the majority who
are directly and indirectly responsible for the law.
It is apparent that a thing is not
necessarily bad because it is forbidden by the law.
Legislators are forever repealing and abolishing criminal
statutes, and organized society is constantly ignoring
laws, until they fall into disuse and die. The
laws against witchcraft, the long line of “blue
laws,” the laws affecting religious beliefs and
many social customs, are well-known examples of legal
and innocent acts which legislatures and courts have
once made criminal. Not only are criminal statutes
always dying by repeal or repeated violation, but every
time a legislature meets, it changes penalties for
existing crimes and makes criminal certain acts that
were not forbidden before.
Judging from the kind of men sent
to the State legislatures and to Congress, the fact
that certain things are forbidden does not mean that
these things are necessarily evil; but rather, that
politicians believe there is a demand for such legislation
from the class of society that is most powerful in
political action. No one who examines the question
can be satisfied that a thing is intrinsically wrong
because it is forbidden by a legislative body.
Other more or less popular opinions
of the way to determine right or wrong are found to
be no more satisfactory. Many believe that the
question of whether an act is right or wrong is to
be settled by a religious doctrine; but the difficulties
are still greater in this direction. First of
all, this involves a thorough and judicial inquiry
into the merits of many, if not all, forms of religion,
an investigation which has never been made, and from
the nature of things cannot be made. The fact
is, that one’s religious opinions are settled
long before he begins to investigate and quite by
other processes than reason. Then, too, all religious
precepts rest on interpretation, and even the things
that seem the plainest have ever been subject to manifold
and sometimes conflicting construction. Few if
any religious commands can be, or ever were, implicitly
relied on without interpretation. The command,
“Thou shalt not kill,” seems plain, but
does even this furnish an infallible rule of conduct?
Of course this commandment could not
be meant to forbid killing animals. Yet there
are many people who believe that it does, or at least
should. No Christian state makes it apply to
men convicted of crime, or against killing in war,
and yet a considerable minority has always held that
both forms of killing violate the commandment.
Neither can it be held to apply to accidental killings,
or killings in self-defense, or in defense of property
or family. Laws, too, provide all grades of punishment
for different kinds of killing, from very light penalties
up to death. Manifestly, then, the commandment
must be interpreted, “Thou shalt not kill when
it is wrong to kill,” and therefore it furnishes
no guide to conduct. As well say: “Thou
shalt do nothing that is wrong.” Religious
doctrines do not and clearly cannot be adopted as the
criminal code of a state.
In this uncertainty as to the basis
of good and bad conduct, many appeal to “conscience”
as the infallible guide. What is conscience?
It manifestly is not a distinct faculty of the mind,
and if it were, would it be more reliable than the
other faculties? It has been often said that
some divine power implanted conscience in every human
being. Apart from the question of whether human
beings are different in kind from other organisms,
which will be discussed later, if conscience has been
placed in man by a divine power, why have not all peoples
been furnished with the same guide? There is
no doubt that all men of any mentality have what is
called a conscience; that is, a feeling that certain
things are right, and certain other things are wrong.
This conscience does not affect all the actions of
life, but probably the ones which to them are the
most important. It varies, however, with the individual.
What reason has the world to believe that conscience
is a correct guide to right and wrong?
The origin of conscience is easily
understood. One’s conscience is formed
as his habits are formed by the time and
place in which he lives; it grows with his teachings,
his habits and beliefs. With most people it takes
on the color of the community where they live.
With some people the eating of pork would hurt their
conscience; with others the eating of any meat; with
some the eating of meat on Friday, and with others
the playing of any game of chance for money, or the
playing of any game on Sunday, or the drinking of
intoxicating liquors. Conscience is purely a
matter of environment, education and temperament, and
is no more infallible than any habit or belief.
Whether one should always follow his own conscience
is another question, and cannot be confounded with
the question as to whether conscience is an infallible
guide to conduct.
Some seek to avoid the manifold difficulties
of the problem by saying that a “criminal”
is one who is “anti-social.” But does
this bring us nearer to the light? An anti-social
person is one whose life is hostile to the organization
or the society in which he lives; one who injures
the peace, contentment, prosperity or well-being of
his neighbors, or the political or social organization
in which his life is cast.
In this sense many of the most venerated
men of history have been criminals; their lives and
teachings have been in greater or lesser conflict
with the doctrines, habits and beliefs of the communities
where they lived. From the nature of things the
wise man and the idealist can never be contented with
existing things, and their lives are a constant battle
for change. If the anti-social individual should
be punished, what of many of the profiteers and captains
of industry who manipulate business and property for
purely selfish ends? What of many of our great
financiers who use every possible reform and conventional
catch word as a means of affecting public opinion,
so that they may control the resources of the earth
and exploit their fellows for their own gain?
No two men have the same power of
adaptation to the group, and it is quite plain that
the ones who are the most servile and obedient to the
opinions and life of the crowd are the greatest enemies
to change and individuality. The fact is, none
of the generally accepted theories of the basis of
right and wrong has ever been the foundation of law
or morals. The basis that the world has always
followed, and perhaps always will accept, is not hard
to find.
The criminal is the one who violates
habits and customs of life, the “folk-ways”
of the community where he lives. These customs
and folk-ways must be so important in the opinion
of the community as to make their violation a serious
affair. Such violation is considered evil regardless
of whether the motives are selfish or unselfish, good
or bad. The folk-ways have a certain validity
and a certain right to respect, but no one who believes
in change can deny that they are a hindrance as well
as a good. Men did not arrive at moral ideas
by a scientific or a religious investigation of good
and bad, of right and wrong, of social or anti-social
life.
Man lived before he wrote laws, and
before he philosophized. He began living simply
and automatically; he adopted various “taboos”
which to him were omens of bad luck, and certain charms,
incantations and the like, which made him immune from
ill-fortune.
All sorts of objects, acts and phenomena
have been the subjects of taboo, and just as numerous
and weird have been the charms and amulets and ceremonies
that saved him from the dangers that everywhere beset
his way. The life of the primitive human being
was a journey down a narrow path; outside were infinite
dangers from which magic alone could make him safe.
All animal life automatically groups
itself more or less closely into herds. Buffaloes,
horses and wolves run in packs. Some of these
groups are knit closely together like ants and bees,
while the units of others move much more widely apart.
But whatever the group may be, its units must conform.
If the wolf gets too far from the pack it suffers or
dies; it matters not whether it be to the right or
the left, behind or ahead, it must stay with the pack
or be lost.
Men from the earliest time arranged
themselves into groups; they traveled in a certain
way; they established habits and customs and ways
of life. These “folk-ways” were born
long before human laws and were enforced more rigidly
than the statutes of a later age. Slowly men
embodied their “taboos,” their incantations,
their habits and customs into religions and statutes.
A law was only a codification of a habit or custom
that long ago was a part of the life of a people.
The legislator never really makes the law; he simply
writes in the books what has already become the rule
of action by force of custom or opinion, or at least
what he thinks has become a law.
One class of men has always been anxious
to keep step with the crowd. The way is easier
and the rewards more certain. Another class has
been skeptical and resentful of the crowd. These
men have refused to follow down the beaten path; they
strayed into the wilderness seeking new and better
ways. Sometimes others have followed and a shorter
path was made. Often they have perished because
they left the herd. In the sight of the organized
unit and the society of the time and place, the man
who kept the path did right. The man who tried
to make a new path and left the herd did wrong.
In its last analysis, the criminal is the one who leaves
the pack. He may lag behind or go in front, he
may travel to the right or to the left, he may be
better or worse, but his fate is the same.
The beaten path, however formed or
however unscientific, has some right to exist.
On the whole it has tended to preserve life, and it
is the way of least resistance for the human race.
On the other hand it is not the best, and the way
has ever been made easier by those who have violated
precepts and defied some of the concepts of the time.
Both ways are right and both ways are wrong.
The conflict between the two ways is as old as the
human race.
Paths and customs and institutions
are forever changing. So are ideas of right and
wrong, and so, too, are statutes. The law, no
doubt, makes it harder for customs and habits to be
changed, for it adds to the inertia of the existing
thing.
Is there, then, nothing in the basis
of right and wrong that answers to the common conception
of these words? There are some customs that have
been forbidden longer and which, it seems, must necessarily
be longer prohibited; but the origin of all is the
same. A changing world has shown how the most
shocking crimes punished by the severest penalties
have been taken from the calendar and no longer even
bear the suspicion of wrong. Religious differences,
witchcraft and sorcery have probably brought more
severe punishments than any other acts; yet a change
of habit and custom and belief has long since abolished
all such crimes. So, too, crimes come and go
with new ideals, new movements and conditions.
The largest portion of our criminal code deals with
the rights of property; yet nearly all of this is
of comparatively modern growth. A new emotion
may take possession of man which will result in the
repeal of many if not all of these statutes, and place
some other consideration above property, which seems
to be the controlling emotion of today.
Crime, strictly speaking, is only
such conduct or acts as are forbidden by the law and
for which penalties are prescribed. The classification
of the act does not necessarily have relation to moral
conduct. This cannot be fixed by any exact standard.
There is no straight clear line between the good and
bad, the right and wrong. The general ways of
determining good and bad conduct are of little value.
The line between the two is always uncertain and shifting.
And, in the last analysis, good or bad conduct rests
upon the “folk-ways,” the habits, beliefs
and customs of a community. While this is the
real basis of judging conduct, it is always changing,
and from the nature of things, if it could be made
stable, it would mean that society was stratified and
all hope of improvement dead.