Crimes against persons are not always
as easy to classify and understand as crimes against
property. These acts are so numerous and come
from so many different emotions and motives, that
often the cause is obscure and the explanation not
easy to find. Still here, as everywhere in Nature,
nothing can happen without a cause, and even where
limited knowledge does its best and cannot find causes,
our recognition of the connection between cause and
effect and the all-inclusiveness of law can leave no
doubt that complete knowledge would bring complete
understanding.
It is always to be borne in mind in
considering this class of crimes that the motive power
of life is not reason but instinct. If men lived
by reason the race would not survive. The primal
things that preserve the race, the hunger for food,
drink, sex, are instinctive and not only are not awakened
or satisfied by reason, but oftentimes in violation
of it. Nature, first of all, sees to the preservation
of the species, and acts in a broad way that life
may not perish. Nature knows nothing about right
and wrong in the sense in which man uses these words.
All of our moral conceptions are purely of social
origin and hence not instinctive in human life, and
are forever giving way to the instincts on which Nature
depends. The preservation of life has called for
the emotions of hate, fear and love, among the other
emotions that move men. The animal fears danger
and runs away, and thus life is preserved. The
weaker animal is almost entirely dependent for life
upon his fear. He is sometimes afraid when there
is no danger, but without fear he would be destroyed.
Sometimes the animal hates and kills and thus preserves
himself. The love of offspring is the cause of
the care bestowed upon it which preserves its life.
The herd instinct in animal species develops packs
and clans and tribes and states. Man is the heir
to all the past, and the instincts and emotions of
the primitive animal are strong in his being.
These may have been strengthened or diluted as the
ages have come and gone, but the same instincts furnish
the motive power for all his acts. Man fears
and hates, and runs or kills and saves his life.
He loves, and preserves his offspring.
Man sees an object. Instinctively
he may fear it or he may hate it. He may run
from it or destroy it. He gathers impressions
through his senses. The nerves carry them to
the brain. He comes to fear certain persons and
things, to hate certain other persons or things, and
to love still others. If the hatred is strong
enough or the danger great enough or the desire sufficient,
he may kill. Whether he plans the method or deliberates
upon the act can make no difference. He is prompted
by the instinct, and the reflection simply means the
consideration of reasons for and against, or the reaching
of inhibitions. If he acts, it is one of the
primal emotions that causes the act. He is the
“machine” through which certain emotions
find their path and do their work. Infinite are
the causes and circumstances that give rise to an
emotion strong enough to take human life.
Killings which result from a sudden
passion are easily understood. Everyone has been
overwhelmed by rage, where reason and judgment and
all acquired restraints are entirely submerged.
The primitive man with his primitive emotion reasserts
himself. It is mainly accident or the lack of
some particular circumstance that prevents a murder.
Of course some people are overwhelmed more easily
than others. Some natures are less stable, some
nervous systems less perfect, and the built up barriers
are weaker. The whole result of stimuli is determined
by the strength of the feeling acting upon the machine.
Such a person is not ordinarily dangerous to the community.
The act itself would generally assure that it could
never happen again. Some killings, however, are
more deliberate. They are preceded by a settled
hatred which preys upon the mind and fights against
the preventive influences that training and habit
have formed. Under a certain combination of circumstances
these restrictions are swept aside and the emotions
have their way.
There are, of course, certain broad
classifications of homicides. A considerable
number, perhaps more than any other, come through the
commission of robbery, burglary and larceny. In
the midst of the act the offender is caught, and kills
in an effort to escape. These murders fall under
the heading of property crimes; the cause is the same,
and the rules governing them are the same. The
second group, with respect to numbers, grows from
the relations of men and women. Wives kill husbands
and husbands kill wives; sweethearts kill each other.
Jealousy and revenge are commonly mixed with sex life
and sex association. Many socialists have argued
that under an equal distribution of property, where
women were freed from fear of want, these crimes would
disappear. But this argument does not take human
nature into account. Jealousy is inevitably associated
with sex relations. The close contact of men and
women over long periods of time inevitably causes friction
and misunderstanding. These conditions often
grow chronic, and in marriage are aggravated by the
necessity of close association regardless of the real
feelings that may exist. Certain claims are made
by husbands and by wives, which are probably inherent
in the relationship; sometimes they flow from habit
and custom, but, from whatever cause, such claims
are so exacting that either the husband or wife finds
them hard to meet.
Because of the fact that the feelings
of men and women for each other are deeper and more
fundamental than those of any other relation, they
are more subject to misfortune and tragedy. The
hatreds born from the deepest affection are most beyond
control. Then the desire of possession is overwhelming.
It would be strange if more killings did not result
from the relations of men and women than from any other
cause. It is easy to understand why this is true.
It is likewise easy to understand how laws, reason
and judgment are powerless to prevent. Juries
seem to understand this when women kill husbands and
lovers, but a long-established code of chivalry and
a cultivated attitude toward women, which is partly
right and partly wrong, make it impossible to see
that men are just as helpless under strong feelings
as women. No doubt a public opinion that would
favor divorces on a greater number of grounds and
make them easily obtainable would prevent large numbers
of such killings, but the cause can not be altogether
removed.
The law has long singled out killing
as the greatest crime, doubtless because man prizes
life first of all. Of course every effort should
be made to protect life. Still, in measuring
the character of the offender, in determining his
possibilities as a useful citizen, homicide is probably
one of the lesser crimes. Many times it implies
no moral turpitude, even with those who believe in
moral turpitude. It may imply very little lack
of physical stability. Homicide practically never
becomes an occupation. Most killings are accidental
in the sense that they are casual and dependent on
circumstances, and there is as a rule much less danger
of repetition than there is of the original commission
of a homicide by one of a defective nervous system
who has never before committed an unlawful act.
A large number of men convicted of murder are used
as “trusties” in our penal institutions,
even when their imprisonment is for a long term, or
for life. This shows from the experience of prison
officials that this class of offenders is, as a rule,
of a better fibre than almost any other class.
Doubtless no sort of treatment will
ever entirely get rid of homicide. Brains and
nervous systems are so made, that inhibitions are unable
to protect in all cases. Nations and men readily
engage in killing, either from sport or because of
a real or fancied wrong. Mob psychology shows
how whole communities are turned into ravenous beasts,
hunting for their prey. The world war, and all
wars, show cases of mob psychology that have led large
masses of men to take an active part in killing.
The pursuit of those charged with crime shows that
all people like the chase when the emotions are thoroughly
aroused. Under certain impulses, communities
gloat over hangings and commend judges and juries because
they have the courage to hang, when, in fact, they
were too cowardly not to hang and when their reason
did not approve the verdict and judgment. Men
who do not kill often wish others might die and are
pleased and happy when they do die. We approve
of death when it is the right one who dies. Whether
all persons are murderers or not may depend upon a
definition of murder. But, beyond doubt, all persons
are potential murderers, needing only time and circumstances,
and a sufficiently overwhelming emotion that will
triumph over the weak restraints that education and
habit have built up, to control the powerful surging
instincts and feelings that Nature has laid at the
foundation of life.