By far the largest class of crimes
may be called crimes against property. Strictly
speaking, these are crimes in relation to the ownership
of property; criminal ways of depriving the lawful
owner of its possession.
Many writers claim that nearly all
crime is caused by economic conditions, or in other
words that poverty is practically the whole cause
of crime. Endless statistics have been gathered
on this subject which seem to show conclusively that
property crimes are largely the result of the unequal
distribution of wealth. But crime of any class
cannot safely be ascribed to a single cause. Life
is too complex, heredity is too variant and imperfect,
too many separate things contribute to human behavior,
to make it possible to trace all actions to a single
cause. No one familiar with courts and prisons
can fail to observe the close relation between poverty
and crime. All lawyers know that the practice
of criminal law is a poor business. Most lawyers
of ability refuse such practice because it offers
no financial rewards. Nearly all the inmates
of penal institutions are without money. This
is true of almost all men who are placed on trial.
Broad generalizations have been made from statistics
gathered for at least seventy-five years. It
has been noted in every civilized country that the
number of property crimes materially increases in
the cold months and diminishes in the spring, summer
and early autumn. The obvious cause is that employment
is less regular in the winter time, expenses of living
are higher, idle workers are more numerous, wages
are lower, and, in short, it is harder for the poor
to live. Most men and women spend their whole
lives close to the line of want; they have little
or nothing laid by. Sickness, hard luck, or lack
of work makes them penniless and desperate. This
drives many over the uncertain line between lawful
and unlawful conduct and they land in jail. There
are more crimes committed in hard times than in good
times. When wages are comparatively high and work
is steady fewer men enter the extra-hazardous occupation
of crime. Strikes, lockouts, panics and the like
always leave their list of unfortunates in the prisons.
Every lawyer engaged in criminal practice has noticed
the large numbers of prosecutions and convictions
for all sorts of offences that follow in the wake
of strikes and lockouts.
The cost of living has also had a
direct effect on crime. Long ago, Buckle, in
his “History of Civilization,” collected
statistics showing that crime rose and fell in direct
ratio to the price of food. The life, health
and conduct of animals are directly dependent upon
the food supply. When the pasture is poor cattle
jump the fences. When food is scarce in the mountains
and woods the deer come down to the farms and villages.
And the same general laws that affect all other animal
life affect men. When men are in want, or even
when their standard of living is falling, they will
take means to get food or its equivalent that they
would not think of adopting except from need.
This is doubly true when a family is dependent for
its daily bread upon its own efforts.
Always bearing in mind that most criminals
are men whose equipment and surroundings have made
it difficult for them to make the adjustments to environment
necessary for success in life, we may easily see how
any increase of difficulties will lead to crime.
Most men are not well prepared for life. Even
in the daily matter of the way to spend their money,
they lack the judgment necessary to get the most from
what they have. As families increase, debts increase,
until many a man finds himself in a net of difficulties
with no way out but crime. Men whose necessities
have led them to embezzlement and larceny turn up so
regularly that they hardly attract attention.
Neither does punishment seem to deter others from
following the same path although the danger of detection,
disgrace and prison is perfectly clear.
Sometimes, of course, men of education
and apparent lack of physical defect commit property
crimes. Bankers often take money on deposit after
the bank is insolvent. Not infrequently they forge
notes to cover losses and in various ways manipulate
funds to prevent the discovery of insolvency.
As a rule the condition of the bank is brought about
by the use of funds for speculation, with the intention
of repaying from what seems to be a safe venture.
Sometimes it comes through bad loans and unforeseen
conditions. Business men and bankers frequently
shock their friends and the community by suicide,
on disclosures showing they have embezzled money to
use on some financial venture that came to a disastrous
end.
These cases are not difficult to understand.
The love of money is the controlling emotion of the
age. Just as religion, war, learning, invention
and discovery have been the moving passions of former
ages, so now the accumulation of large fortunes is
the main object that moves man. It does not follow
that this phase will not pass away and give place
to something more worth while, but while it lasts it
will claim its victims, just as other strong emotions
in turn have done. The fear of poverty, especially
by those who have known something of the value of
money, the desire for the power that money brings,
the envy of others, the opportunities that seem easy,
all these feelings are too strong for many fairly
good “machines,” and bring disaster when
plans go wrong.
Only a small portion of those who
have speculated with trust funds are ever prosecuted.
Generally the speculation is successful or at least
covered up. Many men prefer to take a chance of
disgrace or punishment or death rather than remain
poor. These are not necessarily dishonest or
bad. They may be more venturesome, or more unfortunate;
at any rate, it is obvious that the passion for money,
the chance to get it, the dread of poverty, the love
of wealth and power were too strong for their equipment,
otherwise the pressure would have been resisted.
The same pressure on some other man would not have
brought disaster.
The restrictions placed around the
accumulation of property are multiplying faster than
any other portions of the criminal code. It takes
a long time for new customs or habits or restraints
to become a part of the life and consciousness of
man so that the mere suggestion of the act causes
the reaction that doing it is wrong. No matter
how long some statutes are on the books, and how severe
the penalties, many men never believe that doing the
forbidden act is really a crime. For instance,
the violations of many revenue laws, game laws, prohibition
laws, and many laws against various means of getting
property are often considered as not really criminal.
In fact, a large and probably growing class of men
disputes the justice of creating many legal rules in
reference to private property.
Primitive peoples, as a rule, held
property in common. Their inhibitions were few
and simple. They took what they needed and wanted
in the easiest way. There is a strong call in
all life to hark back to primitive feelings, customs
and habits. Many new laws are especially painful
and difficult to a large class of weak men who form
the bulk of our criminal class.
To understand the constant urge to
throw off the shackles of civilization, one need but
think of the number of men who use liquor or drugs.
One need only look at the professional and business
man, who at every opportunity leaves civilization
and goes to the woods to kill wild animals or to the
lakes and streams to fish.
The call to live a simple life, free
from the conventions, customs and rules, to kill for
the sake of killing, to get to the woods and streams
and away from brick buildings and stone walls, is strong
in the constitution of almost every man. Probably
the underlying cause of the world war was the need
of man to relax from the hard and growing strain of
the civilization that is continually weaving new fetters
to bind him. There must always come a breaking
point, for, after all, man is an animal and can live
only from and by the primitive things.
Children have no idea of the rights
of property. It takes long and patient teaching,
even to the most intelligent, to make them feel that
there is a point at which the taking of property is
wrong. Nowhere in Nature can we see an analogy
to our property rights. Plants and animals alike
get their sustenance where and how they can. It
is not meant here to discuss the question of how many
of the restrictions that control the getting of property
are wise and how many are foolish; it is only meant
to give the facts as they affect life and conduct.
It is certainly true that the child
learns very slowly and very imperfectly to distinguish
the ways by which he may and may not get property.
His nature always protests against it as he goes along.
Only a few can ever learn it in anything like completeness.
Many men cannot learn it, and if they learned the
forbidden things they would have no feeling that to
disobey was wrong. Even the most intelligent ones
never know or feel the whole code, and in fact, lawyers
are forever debating and judges doubting as to whether
many ways of getting property are inside or outside
the law. No doubt many of the methods that intelligent
and respected men adopt for getting property have more
inherent criminality than others that are directly
forbidden by the law. It must always be remembered
that all laws are naturally and inevitably evolved
by the strongest force in a community, and in the last
analysis made for the protection of the dominant class.