The growing belief that crime comes
largely from the subnormal has created a more or less
definite demand for the isolation of the moron before
the commission of crime and for the sterilization of
certain misfits, especially after conviction.
Both of these methods are very drastic, and while
society must and will adopt any way that seems to be
necessary to protect itself, still before accepting
such drastic remedies it should be very clear that
the danger is sufficiently great to justify the means,
that the desired result will follow and that no other
means will bring about the end.
In this discussion it should be remembered
that the mental classification of children and grown-ups
is only in its infancy, that much that is freely stated
is still in the realm of theory, and that time and
patience in making investigations and classifying facts
are most important in arriving at correct results.
The really intelligent are as abnormal
as the defective. The great masses of men are
rather mediocre, and those above and below are exceptions.
This depends on how broad is the class included in
the normal. There are no sharp divisions anywhere;
above, the normal shades imperceptibly into those
of unusual intelligence, and below it fades just as
gradually into the sub-normal. While defectives
are more apt to commit crimes, in the main this is
because their environment is too hard for their machine.
The sub-normal are probably more tractable
and less disposed to the emotions that lead to criminal
acts than are the more intelligent. Their crimes
are especially noticed because they seem to be without
any serious motive and often shockingly brutal.
City life most readily uncovers the sub-normal.
This is true because the strain is far greater in
the city than the country. There are exceptions
to this rule, particularly those portions of the country
that are barren and unproductive territory into which
the venturesome and obvious unfits are drawn.
The prisons are not the only places
which are inhabited by the sub-normal and the misfit.
The hardest and most disagreeable and most poorly
paid labor is largely done by this class of people.
Very few people of superior intelligence and education
do manual labor and the more disagreeable the manual
labor, the more certain it is that the job is done
by the sub-normal and the misfit. A large part
of the farm labor, the odd jobs and common labor in
small towns, the cheaper labor on railroads, in factories
and all industrial plants is given to this sort of
men. In the country and small village, where life
is easy, this class seldom makes trouble and is hardly
known. These men and women easily and naturally
fall into a place in the industry and society of the
village and are often among the most useful members.
A general examination of all men to
discover the defective and the sub-normal, coupled
with a demand that all such be sent to some place of
confinement, would meet with such a protest from all
classes seriously affected as to end not only the
demand but the further agitation of the subject.
Any such law, if carried out, would not only seriously
increase the cost of all industry, but in many instances
would make it impossible to carry it on. It is
hardly conceivable that above the idiot, society shall
make examinations and tests and confine or sterilize
large classes of people who have not yet developed
anti-social tendencies, but who on account of feeble
intellects might sometime commit crime.
The world has ample data at hand to
show more humane and at the same time much cheaper
ways, even methods that will yield a profit. These
ways have been abundantly illustrated by history and
can be witnessed in operation every day.
England was repeatedly conquered and
settled by brigands and misfits. When her people
grew more homogeneous and orderly she sent her anti-social
to New Zealand and to Virginia. In New Zealand
with its opportunities these outcasts and their descendants
prospered and were as orderly and conventional as
the English society that banished them for England’s
good. The colonies in Virginia with access to
land and a chance to make homes for themselves established
a social order and formed communities more prosperous
than the ones that sent them out. Many of their
descendants are now successful and important members
of every western state.
In fact, most of the European immigrants
who have settled in the United States were the poor
and the outcast, the misfits of European countries.
With better opportunities and a chance to build up
homes in a new land, their descendants are at least
the equals of those who stayed behind. The growth
and development of the United States westward from
the Atlantic seaboard has been effected by the poorer
and less intelligent, but often the more venturesome,
who constantly turned West to get cheaper land and
a better chance. The residents of these western
states compare very favorably with those who still
reside in the sections of the country which these
pioneers left behind. It cannot be shown that
the less intelligent have criminal natures. All
that can be shown is that they have a poorer equipment
to meet the stress and strain of life. To make
most of this class safe, all that is needed is fairer
conditions and an easier environment. If society
could only recover from the obsession that what is
necessary to regulate man is plenty of prisons and
harder punishments, it would be fairly easy and infinitely
cheaper to improve the environment from which crime
springs than to visit vengeance on the victim.
The effect of education is very great.
Many a subnormal and backward person has been educated
so he could take a place in life that those with a
much greater natural ability could not fill.
Beyond the segregation of the imbecile,
the insane and those who have committed crime, it
is dangerous to go. The course of preventing crime
lies in the other direction, better opportunity and
an easier life.
It has grown to be a commonplace in
the discussion of crime to speak of isolation and
sterilization as the proper treatment of the criminal
and defective. This is generally done without
any clear understanding of the laws of heredity.
The laws of the transmission from
parent to child of traits and tendencies are not yet
well enough known to justify any attempt to interfere
with the function of life, except in the case of the
idiotic. It is plain that crime cannot be inherited.
Certain defects in the brain and nervous system can
be and are inherited. No brain or nervous system
is perfect, so the problem is one of the incapacity
which causes the maladjustment. Crime results
from defective heredity when applied to the environment.
It comes from the inability of the machine to make
the necessary adjustments of life. The making
of the criminal is largely a question of his fortune
or misfortune in the environment where he is placed.
It is absurd to say that one inherits the tendency
to rob or rape or burglarize or kill. He may
inherit an unstable organization that in certain hostile
environments will lead him to any of these crimes.
For that matter all men inherit the organization that
will bring these results if the environment is sufficiently
hard. Society may in many ways place too high
a value on human life. Still we punish men who
place too low a value on the lives of others, and
the state should be very slow to destroy life or the
capacity for life.
There is much to learn, much to explain
about the mysterious workings of heredity, before
man can undertake to say that he has the wisdom or
justice to choose the ones who should be the bearers
of life to the future.
It is most common to find in the same
family various degrees of intelligence. Now and
then a man of such high powers and faculties is born
that he is regarded by scientists as a “sport”
who defies all known laws in his origin. Often
one person in a family is of commanding strength,
while the rest are commonplace.
The insanity and disease that afflict
many men of genius is well known. Grasset
in his book The Semi-Insane and the Semi-Responsible
has given a long list of eminent names. Many
great authors have depicted insanity in their most
gifted characters. Genius is frequently an indication
of insanity. It is a wide departure from the
normal.
The obscure and lowly origin of many
of the world’s greatest men seems to point to
the fact that Nature has methods that man cannot comprehend
and with which it is not wise for him to interfere.
The fact is that genius, or even great strength or
ability in the parent, is by no means sure to be handed
down. In fact, it is very rare indeed that such
unusual traits persist. That sterilization should
follow as a punishment for sex crimes is without any
sort of logic except that sterilization relates to
sex. The whole idea is born of the hatred or loathing
of certain crimes.
Generalizations have been made from
a few poorly authenticated cases, and these generalizations
have gone far beyond anything that the evidence can
justify. It does not follow that because the father
and son have black hair, or the mother and daughter
have blue eyes, or that their mannerisms are similar,
that inheritance is responsible for character, much
less for crime. Certain things are clearly traceable
to heredity. Other things may be the result of
association or what to us must still be accident.
Often the fact is pointed out that
great progress has been made in the culture of plants
and the breeding of animals. This is true.
No intelligent farmer to-day would think of raising
any but the best stock. He takes pains with the
breeding of his cattle. If he wants rich milk
and butter, he breeds Jerseys or Guernseys. If
he wants a larger quantity of milk and a fair beef
animal, he breeds Holsteins. If he wants beef
only, perhaps he raises Durhams. At any rate he
knows what he wants and breeds that kind. Similarly
the horse-raiser will breed for race horses or dray
horses as the case may be, and the system works with
almost mechanical certainty. He gets what he wants
and would never think of raising scrubs and taking
a chance on results. The effect of selective
breeding and culture is beyond dispute, and to many
it seems obvious that all that is needed to perfect
the human race and wipe out misery and crime is to
supervise human breeding in the same way, so that
the species may be controlled.
At first glance this seems to be the
logical thing to do, especially as the effects of
heredity can no more be doubted in man than in animals.
Still there are important questions to be asked and
grave dangers to be encountered. When we say
that the well-bred Berkshire hog is better than the
“razor-back,” we mean that it will produce
more meat for food. In other words the hog is
better for man. If we were to ask which would
be the better, if the hog were to be considered, the
answer would probably be the “razor-back.”
The fact that the food consumed by the Berkshire produces
a large quantity of fat, makes him unfitted to live
if he were living for his own sake. Turn both
hogs out to run wild, and the “razor-back”
will live and the Berkshire die. Nature will make
her selection and adapt the hog to his environment.
The Berkshire will produce more lard, but it will
not run so fast; it has no more brains and cannot
adapt what it has so well to the preservation of life.
The same thing is doubtless true of other animals
and likewise of plant life. The Jersey cow would
not survive in a natural state. She gives too
much milk and for too long a time. Man has made
of her a milk-machine. Turn all thoroughbred
horses out on the plains to shift for themselves,
and they would either die or gradually be modified
until they were adapted to the free and wild life
of the plains. This would not be so good for
man, but would be better for the horses. In plants
and animals, man can by selection breed or cultivate
any characteristics that he may choose, but he cannot
produce a horse which is both a draft horse and a
running horse; he cannot produce cattle that are the
best both for milk and beef. He is urged to try
scientific breeding on the human race. How would
he have man changed? Would he experiment for more
intellect, or a bigger and stronger physique?
Would he breed for art and civilization or would he
breed for strength and physical endurance? What
qualities are desirable for the human race? This
would be a very hard question even to entrust to a
popular vote. While the capacity of cattle to
produce milk can be increased, cattle cannot increase
their own capacity or improve their own quality.
This can be done only by the slow and patient processes
of Nature in the line of adapting the animal to its
environment. The rapid change that is to come
about by breeding must be directed and controlled
by man. The cattle have nothing to say about the
process. No doubt a higher order of beings who
could control man might, and perhaps would change
him by selective mating. How they would change
him would depend on the use they wished to make of
him, not on what the man himself would like to do.
The contemplation of a higher order of beings experimenting
with the human race is not a pleasant one for intelligent
men.
Can we imagine men, through government,
forcibly experimenting with each other? Who would
settle the kind of man that was to be evolved or the
specific changes that would be required? Or, what
was to be done and how? Who could prophesy what
man would be like when he should be made over in the
likeness of something else? Who are the people
with the breadth and tolerance and infinite wisdom,
in whose hands it would be safe to place the remodeling
of man? It is hard to conceive that it can be
seriously considered.
Nature in her own way is a eugenist.
By her slow processes she is continually wiping out
the unfit and adapting man to the environment where
he must live. Perhaps by saving too many of the
unfit man is more or less interfering with the processes
of Nature, and it may be that the interference with
her method of work is bad. But Nature is mindful
of this tendency and if it is not in accordance with
the profoundest laws of being, Nature will have her
way in spite of man’s meddling. Any change
that can be brought about by selective mating must
come by natural processes aided by the education of
each individual through a closer study of the origin
and evolution of life. This must leave everyone
free to do his own selecting, rather than to trust
it to the state. Society can do much toward giving
man an environment which will more or less be adjusted
to his heredity. To give him a heredity that
will conform to his environment is quite another thing
and probably must be kept practically free from the
theories, vagaries and experiments of man. It
would seem so absurd and dangerous as not to be worth
discussing except for the fact that the movement,
both for sterilizing and some degree of control of
mating has already gone far in some of the states.
There is no limit that fanaticism or hatred will respect.
No doubt the popular opinion that
in some way crime and pauperism are inherited has
been strengthened by the literature concerning the
family that has been given the name of “The
Jukes.” The first extensive study of this
family was made by Richard L. Dugdale, who was connected
with the New York Prison Association. It was
first published in 1877 and may almost be regarded
as the “Uncle Tom’s Cabin” of the
scientific study of crime in America.
Mr. Dugdale was evidently a careful
student, an honest investigator and a humane man.
Strange to say, deductions have been freely and carelessly
made from his book, which the investigations do not
warrant, and against which he carefully cautioned
the reader. No one can examine Mr. Dugdale’s
book without being impressed with the quiet unassuming
modesty and worth of the author, and yet in the hands
of those who have so often carelessly and unscientifically
generalized from his studies, it has possibly brought
more harm than good.
The book covers investigations made
by Dugdale between 1850 and 1870, a period in which
little was known about the laws that govern inheritance,
and necessarily, much evidence was pure hearsay without
the data of careful investigation at hand. The
case, however, does show a surprising number of criminals,
paupers, harlots and misfits, descending from their
original ancestor. From time to time further investigation
has brought the history of the family down to 1918.
The ancestor with whom the investigation
begins was born some time between 1720 and 1740.
In the report the original is called “Max.”
He has been described as a “hunter and fisher,”
“a hard drinker,” “not fond of work,”
fairly intelligent and leaving no record of crime.
He probably left behind a large family, some of whom
were legitimate and some illegitimate. The family
came from a barren, rocky, lake region in New York
and several generations grew up in the vicinity.
The only industry was rough work like quarrying stone,
logging and the like. Later a manufacturing plant
was located in the region. The Jukes early got
a bad name in the small community. Even when
they wanted to find employment it was hard to get
a job. They were socially ostracized and individually
boycotted. The region was poor, and for the most
part the family grew up in poverty. Often several
members of a family lived in one room and slept on
the floor indiscriminately, regardless of sex.
For several generations few of them wandered far from
the ancestral home. The locality was one that
naturally came to be the resort of the poor and the
outcast; these are always driven to the cheapest and
most barren land. Whether the community was related
by blood or not, the residents would almost inevitably
be of the same class. Rich people cluster closely
together for association and fellowship. The poor
and wretched do the same. Common observation
in city and country shows that this is inevitable.
It comes from deeper and more fundamental laws than
human statutes. It is born of the gregarious
instinct and fostered and developed by economic law.
In the main, lax habits grow from
surroundings and association. The tendency of
all human beings is to revert to the primal. It
is only association that keeps the individual units
up to the tension that civilization expects and demands.
Every community shows many examples of this inevitable
tendency. Nature is constant; civilization spasmodic.
Especially with sex relations, conditions are the chief
factor. Nature knows little or nothing of the
regulations fixed by society and custom. Poverty
and wretchedness reach outward through a community
and by association between the old and the young pass
down the generations. Nothing but a complete
change of environment can counteract the inevitable
tendency. When social classes arise and the cleavage
is clear and established, no great effort is made
by the superior members to aid the inferior.
In fact they are almost invariably left to themselves.
Poverty and wretchedness are not transmitted in the
blood, but in the environment.
It is not many years since physicians
and communities believed that tuberculosis was inherited.
In all communities there were instances of this dread
disease spreading out through families and down the
generations. It required the sacrifice of many
lives and the careful investigation of scientists
to discover that tuberculosis was the result of germs,
generally accompanied by an impoverished system.
These germs were transferred by close association
and lack of sanitary conditions. It is as easy
to transmit shiftlessness, idleness and lax habits
as disease.
Dugdale’s figures of delinquency
in the Jukes family are doubtless much too high.
A large percentage of facts was gained from gossip
and hearsay about those long since dead. The
details show that many crimes charged were not even
proved, others were evidently not crimes, and in any
small community suspicion would rest upon a member
of this family who was accused. Then too, the
poor in court and out have a hard time defending themselves.
They are frequently convicted when accused. The
evidence in regard to the subnormal and defective
is still less satisfactory. Without close examination
and thorough tests, illiteracy generally passes as
subnormality. Very few of the subjects were submitted
to a careful test. It is at least probable that
this family was not much different from the other
families who lived in like circumstances in the community.
Dugdale’s original examination
covered 709 cases out of about 1200 that were supposed
to be living at the time. Of this number, 180
are put down as having received institutional and
outdoor relief. The criminals and offenders are
put down at 140. Habitual thieves convicted and
unconvicted are listed at 60. Common prostitutes
are put down at 50.
After Dugdale’s investigation
the family, from industrial and other conditions,
became scattered and spread out over many states.
A record has lately been made of the descendants of
this family, the later record showing much improvement
in the stock. This must be due to environment.
It seems fairly certain that with time and opportunity,
it will not much longer be a marked family.
Quite aside from the history, it seems
certain that no results such as shown by Dugdale could
have followed from inheritance. Defectiveness
is a recessive factor; normality a dominant one.
If such were not true, this would be a world of feeble-minded.
If the Mendelian law held good in this regard, from
a union of a defective and a normal person, three
out of four would be normal, but as a matter of fact,
the percentage of normal is no doubt much greater.
It is only when both father and mother are feeble-minded
that feeble-mindedness is sure to show in the offspring.
With the modern care of this sort of defectives, the
chance of breeding is growing rapidly less.
The Kallikak family is cited as another
illustration showing the possible inheritance of criminality
and poverty through a defective strain. This
family, so far as shown, makes it still clearer that
what some authors have charged to heredity is simply
due to environment. These investigations do not
show the need of controlling birth but do prove the
necessity of improving environment. It is not
possible to speak with certainty as to heredity and
environment. The thorough investigation of these
two factors which make up life is still in its infancy,
but scientists are working out the problem, and we
may be confident that with the right attitude toward
crime, a remedy will be found for such cases as result
from environment.