After all, the advent of a chaperon made surprisingly little difference in the life of the parsonage family, but what change there was, was all to the good. Their aunt assumed no active directorate over household matters. She just slipped in, happily, unobtrusively, helpfully. She was a gentle woman, smiling much, saying little. Indeed, her untalkativeness soon became a matter of great merriment among the lively girls.

“A splendid deaf and dumb person was lost to the world in you, Aunt Grace,” Carol assured her warmly. “I never saw a woman who could say so much in smiles, and be so expressive without words.”

Fairy said, “She carries on a prolonged discussion, and argues and orates, without saying a word.”

The members of the Ladies’ Aid, who hastened to call, said, “She is perfectly charming such a fine conversationalist!”

She was always attractively dressed, always self-possessed, always friendly, always good-natured, and the girls found her presence only pleasing. She relieved Prudence, admired Fairy, laughed at the twins, adored Connie. Between her and Mr. Starr there was a frank camaraderie, charming, but seldom found between brothers- and sisters-in-law.

“Of course, Aunt Grace,” Prudence told her sweetly, “we aren’t going to be selfish with you. We don’t expect you to bury yourself in the parsonage. Whenever you want to trip away for a while, you must feel free to go. We don’t intend to monopolize you, however much we want to do so. Whenever you want to go, you must go.”

“I shan’t want to go,” said Aunt Grace quickly.

“Not right away, of course,” Prudence agreed. “But you’ll find our liveliness tiring. Whenever you do want to go

“I don’t think I shall want to go at all,” she answered. “I like it here. I I like liveliness.”

Then Prudence kissed her gratefully.

For several weeks after her initiation in the parsonage, life rolled along sweetly and serenely. There were only the minor, unavoidable mishaps and disciplinary measures common to the life of any family. Of course, there were frequent, stirring verbal skirmishes between Fairy and the twins, and between the twins and Connie. But these did not disturb their aunt. She leaned back in her chair, or among the cushions, listening gravely, but with eyes that always smiled.

Then came a curious lull.

For ten entire and successive days the twins had lived blameless lives. Their voices rang out gladly and sweetly. They treated Connie with a sisterly tenderness and gentleness quite out of accord with their usual drastic discipline. They obeyed the word of Prudence with a cheerful readiness that was startlingly cherubimic. The most distasteful of orders called forth nothing stronger than a bright, “Yes, Prudence.” They no longer developed dangerous symptoms of physical disablement at times of unpleasant duties. Their devotion to the cause of health was beautiful. Not an ache disturbed them. Not a pain suggested a substitute.

Prudence watched them with painful solicitude. Her years of mothering had given her an almost supernatural intuition as to causes, and effects.

On Wednesday morning, Mr. Starr bade his family good-by and set out on a tour of Epworth League conventions. He was to be away from home until the end of the following week. A prospective Presbyterian theologian had been selected from the college to fill his pulpit on the Sabbath, and the girls, with their aunt, faced an unusually long period of running the parsonage to suit themselves.

At ten o’clock the train carried their father off in the direction of Burlington, and at eleven o’clock the twins returned to the parsonage. They had given him a daughterly send-off at the station, and then gone to the library for books. Prudence, Fairy and Aunt Grace sat sewing on the side porch as they cut across the parsonage lawn, their feet crinkling pleasantly through the drift of autumn leaves the wind had piled beneath the trees.

“We’re out of potatoes, twins,” said Prudence, as they drew near. “You’ll have to dig some before dinner.”

For one instant their complacent features clouded. Prudence looked up expectantly, sure of a break in their serene placidity.

One doubtful second, then

“Certainly, Prudence,” said Carol brightly.

And Lark added genially, “We’d better fill the box, I guess so we’ll have enough for the rest of the week.”

And singing a light but unharmonic snatch of song, the twins went in search of basket and hoe.

The twins were not musical. They only sang from principle, to emphasize their light-heartedness when it needed special impressing.

Prudence’s brows knitted in anxious frowns, and she sighed a few times.

“What is the matter, Prue? You look like a rainy Christmas,” said Fairy.

“It’s the twins,” was the mournful answer.

“The twins!” ejaculated Fairy. “Why, they’ve acted like angels lately.”

Even Aunt Grace lifted mildly inquiring eyebrows.

“That’s it! That’s just it. When the twins act like angels I get uneasy right away. The better they act, the more suspicious I feel.”

“What have they been doing?”

“Nothing! Not a thing! That’s why I’m worried. It must be something terrible!”

Fairy laughed and returned to her embroidery. Aunt Grace smiled and began plying her needles once more. But Prudence still looked troubled, and sighed often.

There was no apparent ground for her alarm. The twins came back with the potatoes, peeled some for luncheon, and set the table, their faces still bright and smiling. Prudence’s eyes, often fastened upon their angelic countenances, grew more and more troubled.

In the afternoon, they joined the little circle on the porch, but not to sew. They took a book, and lay down on a rug with the book before them, reading together. Evidently they were all absorbed. An hour passed, two hours, three. At times Carol pointed to a line, and said in a low voice, “That’s good, isn’t it?” And Lark would answer, “Dandy! Have you read this?”

Prudence, in spite of her devotion to the embroidering of large S’s on assorted pieces of linen, never forgot the twins for a moment.

“What are you reading?” she asked at last aimlessly, her only desire to be reassured by the sound of their voices.

There was an almost imperceptible pause. Then Carol answered, her chin was in her palms which may have accounted for the mumbling of the words.

“Scianceanelth.”

“What?”

Another pause, a little more perceptible this time. “Science and Health,” Carol said at last, quite distinctly.

“Science and Health,” Prudence repeated, in a puzzled tone. “Is it a doctor book?”

“Why something of the sort, yes,” said Carol dubiously.

“Science and Health? Science and Health,” mused Fairy. “You don’t mean that Christian Science book, do you? You know what I mean, Prudence Mary Baker Eddys book Science and Health, that’s the name of it. That’s not what you twins are devouring so ravenously, is it?”

Carol answered with manifest reluctance, glancing nervously at Prudence, “Y-yes, that’s what it is.”

Ominous silence greeted this admission. A slow red flush mantled the twins’ cheeks. Aunt Grace’s eyes twinkled a little, although her face was grave. Fairy looked surprised. Prudence looked dumfounded. When she spoke, her words gave no sign of the cataclysmic struggle through which she had passed.

“What are you reading that for?”

“Why it’s very interesting,” explained Lark, coming to Carol’s rescue. Carol was very good at meeting investigation, but when it came to prolonged explanation, Lark stood preeminent. “Of course, we don’t believe it yet. But there are some good things in it. Part of it is very beautiful. We don’t just understand it, it’s very deep. But some of the ideas are very fine, and er uplifting, you know.”

Prudence looked most miserable. “But twins, do you think minister’s daughters ought to read things like that?”

“Why, Prudence, I think minister’s daughters ought to be well-informed on every subject,” declared Lark conscientiously. “How can we be an influence if we don’t know anything about things? And I tell you what it is, Prue, I don’t think it’s right for all of us church people to stand back and knock Christian Science when we don’t know anything about it. It’s narrow-minded, that’s what it is. It’s downright un-Christian. When you get into the book you will find it just full of fine inspiring thoughts something like the Bible, only er and very good, you know.”

Prudence looked at Fairy and her aunt in helpless dismay. This was something entirely new in her experience of rearing a family.

“I I don’t think you ought to read it,” she said slowly. “But at the same time

“Of course, if you command us not to read it, we won’t,” said Carol generously.

“Yes. We’ve already learned quite a lot about it,” amended Lark, with something of warning in her tone.

“What do you think about it, Aunt Grace?”

“Why, I don’t know, Prudence. You know more about rearing twins than I do.”

Prudence at that moment felt that she knew very little about it, indeed. She turned to Fairy. There was a strange intentness in Fairy’s fine eyes as she studied the twins on the floor at her feet.

“You aren’t thinking of turning Christian Scientists, yourselves, are you?” asked Prudence rather humbly.

“Oh, of course, we aren’t Scientists, Prudence,” was the quick denial. “We don’t know anything about it yet, really. But there are lots of very helpful things in it, and people talk about it so much, and they have made such wonderful cures, you know, and we’d thought we’d just study up a little.”

“You take the book and read it yourself, Prue,” urged Carol hospitably. “You’ll see what we mean.”

Prudence drew back quickly as though the book would sear her fingers. She looked very forlorn. She realized that it would be bad policy to forbid the twins to read it. On the other hand, she realized equally strongly that it was certainly unwise to allow its doctrines to take root in the minds of parsonage daughters. If only her father were at home, ten days between herself and the lifting of responsibility!

“When father comes home ” she began. And then suddenly Fairy spoke.

“I think the twins are right,” she said emphatically, and the twins looked at her with a surprised anxiety that mated Prudence’s own. “It would be very narrow-minded of us to refuse to look into a subject as important as this. Let them go on and study it; we can decide things later.”

Prudence looked very doubtful, but a warning movement of Fairy’s left eyelash the side removed from the twins comforted her.

“Well ” she said.

“Of course, Prudence, we know it would nearly break father’s heart for us to go back on our own church, but don’t you think if folks become truly convinced that Christian Science is the true and good religion, they ought to stand by it and suffer, just like the martyrs of old?” suggested Lark, and the suggestion brought the doubt-clouds thick about Prudence’s head once more.

“We may not be convinced, of course,” added Carol, “but there is something rather assuring about it.”

“Oh, twins,” Prudence cried earnestly, but stopped as she caught again the slight suggestive movement of Fairy’s left eyelash.

“Well, let it go for this afternoon,” she said, her eyes intent on Fairy’s face. “I must think it over.”

The twins, with apparent relish, returned to their perusal of the book.

Fairy rose almost immediately and went into the house, coming back a moment later with her hat and gloves.

“I’m going for a stroll, Prue,” she said. “I’ll be back in time for supper.”

Prudence gazed yearningly after her departing back. She felt a great need of help in this crisis, and Fairy’s nonchalance was sometimes very soothing. Aunt Grace was a darling, of course, but she had long ago disclaimed all responsibility for the rearing of the twins.

It was two hours later when Fairy came back. Prudence was alone on the porch.

“Where are the twins?” asked Fairy softly.

“Up-stairs,” was the whispered reply. “Well?”

Then Fairy spoke more loudly, confident that the twins, in their up-stairs room, could hear every word she said. “Come up-stairs, Prue. I want to talk this over with you alone.” And then she whispered, “Now, you just take your cue from me, and do as I say. The little sinners! We’ll teach them to be so funny!”

In their own room she carefully closed the door and smiled, as she noted a creaking of the closet door on the twins’ side of the wall. Eavesdropping was not included among the cardinal sins in the twins’ private decalogue, when the conversation concerned themselves.

“Now, Prudence,” Fairy began, speaking with an appearance of softness, though she took great pains to turn her face toward the twins’ room, and enunciated very clearly indeed. “I know this will hurt you, as it does me, but we’ve got to face it fairly. If the twins are convinced that Christian Science is the right kind of religion, we can’t stand in their way. It might turn them from all religion and make them infidels or atheists, or something worse. Any religion is better than none. I’ve been reading up a little myself this afternoon, and there are some good points in Christian Science. Of course, for our sakes and father’s, the twins will be generous and deny that they are Scientists. But at heart, they are. I saw it this afternoon. And you and I, Prudence, must stand together and back them up. They’ll have to leave the Methodist church. It may break our hearts, and father’s, too, but we can’t wrong our little sisters just for our personal pride and pleasure in them. I think we’ll have them go before the official board next Sunday while father is gone then he will be spared the pain of it. I’ll speak to Mr. Lauren about it to-morrow. We must make it as easy for them as we can. They’ll probably dismiss them I don’t suppose they’ll give them letters. But it must be all over before papa comes back.”

Then she hissed in Prudence’s ear, “Now cry.”

Prudence obediently began sniffing and gulping, and Fairy rushed to her and threw her arms about her, sobbing in heart-broken accents, “There, there, Prue, I know I felt just the same about it. But we can’t stand between the twins and what they think is right. We daren’t have that on our consciences.”

The two wept together, encouraged by the death-like stillness in the closet on the other side of the wall.

Then Fairy said, more calmly, though still sobbing occasionally, “For our sakes, they’ll try to deny it. But we can’t let the little darlings sacrifice themselves. They’ve got to have a chance to try their new belief. We’ll just be firm and insist that they stand on their rights. We won’t mention it to them for a day or two we’ll fix it up with the official board first. And we must surely get it over by Sunday. Poor old father and how he loves ” Fairy indulged in a clever and especially artistic bit of weeping. Then she regained control of her feelings by an audible effort. “But it has its good points, Prue. Haven’t you noticed how sweet and sunny and dear the twins have been lately? It was Science and Health working in them. Oh, Prudence dear, don’t cry so.”

Prudence caught her cue again and began weeping afresh. They soothed and caressed and comforted each other for a while, and then went down-stairs to finish getting supper.

In the meantime, the shocked and horrified twins in the closet of their own room, were clutching each other with passionate intensity. Little nervous chills set them aquiver, their hands were cold, their faces throbbing hot. When their sisters had gone down-stairs, they stared at each other in agony.

“They they wo-won’t p-p-put us out of the ch-ch-church,” gasped Carol.

“They will,” stammered Lark. “You know what Prudence is! She’d put the whole church out if she thought it would do us any good.”

“Pa-p-pa’ll papa’ll ” began Carol, her teeth chattering.

“They’ll do it before he gets back.” Then with sudden reproach she cried, “Oh, Carol, I told you it was wicked to joke about religion.”

This unexpected reproach on the part of her twin brought Carol back to earth. “Christian Science isn’t religion,” she declared. “It’s not even good sense, as far’s I can make out. I didn’t read a word of it, did you? I I just thought it would be such a good joke on Prudence with father out of town.”

The good joke was anything but funny now.

“They can’t make us be Scientists if we don’t want to,” protested Lark. “They can’t. Why, I wouldn’t be anything but a Methodist for anything on earth. I’d die first.”

“You can’t die if you’re a Scientist anyhow, you oughtn’t to. Millie Mains told me

“It’s a punishment on us for even looking at the book good Methodists like we are. I’ll burn it. That’s what I’ll do.”

“You’ll have to pay for it at the library if you do,” cautioned frugal Carol.

“Well, we’ll just go and tell Prudence it was a joke, Prudence is always reasonable. She won’t

“She’ll punish us, and it’ll be such a joke on us, Larkie. Even Connie’ll laugh.”

They squirmed together, wretchedly, at that.

“We’ll tell them we have decided it is false.”

“They said we’d probably do that for their sakes.”

“It it was a good joke while it lasted,” said Carol, with a very faint shadow of a smile. “Don’t you remember how Prudence gasped? She kept her mouth open for five minutes!”

“It’s still a joke,” added Lark gloomily, “but it’s on us.”

“They can’t put us out of the church!”

“I don’t know. You know we Methodists are pretty set! Like as not they’ll say we’d be a bad influence among the members.”

“Twins!”

The call outside their door sounded like the trump of doom to the conscience-smitten twins, and they clutched each other, startled, crying out. Then, sheepishly, they stepped out of the closet to find Fairy regarding them quizzically from the doorway. She repressed a smile with difficulty, as she said quietly:

“I was just talking to Mrs. Mains over the phone. She’s going to a Christian Science lecture to-night, and she said she wished I wasn’t a minister’s daughter and she’d ask me to go along. I told her I didn’t care to, but said you twins would enjoy it. She’ll be here in the car for you at seven forty-five.”

“I won’t go,” cried Carol. “I won’t go near their old church.”

“You won’t go.” Fairy was astonished. “Why I told her you would be glad to go.”

“I won’t,” repeated Carol, with nervous passion. “I will not. You can’t make me.”

Lark shook her head in corroborative denial.

“Well, that’s queer.” Fairy frowned, then she smiled.

Suddenly, to the tempest-tossed and troubled twins, the tall splendid Fairy seemed a haven of refuge. Her eyes were very kind. Her smile was sweet. And with a cry of relief, and shame, and fear, the twins plunged upon her and told their little tale.

“You punish us this time, Fairy,” begged Carol. “We we don’t want the rest of the family to know. We’ll take any kind of punishment, but keep it dark, won’t you? Prudence will soon forget, she’s so awfully full of Jerry these days.”

“I’ll talk it over with Prudence,” said Fairy. “But I think we’ll have to tell the family.”

Lark moved her feet restlessly. “Well, you needn’t tell Connie,” she said. “Having the laugh come back on us is the very meanest kind of a punishment.”

Fairy looked at them a moment, wondering if, indeed, their punishment had been sufficient.

“Well, little twins,” she said, “I guess I will take charge of this myself. Here is your punishment.” She stood up again, and looked down at them with sparkling eyes as they gazed at her expectantly.

“We caught on that it was a joke. We knew you were listening in the closet. And Prudence and I acted our little parts to give you one good scare. Who’s the laugh on now? Are we square? Supper’s ready.” And Fairy ran down-stairs, laughing, followed by two entirely abashed and humbled twins.