A day in June, the kind
of day that poets have rhymed and lovers have craved
since time began. On the side porch of the parsonage,
in a wide hammock, lay Aunt Grace, looking languidly
through half-closed lids at the girls beneath her
on the step. Prudence, although her face was all
a-dream, bent conscientiously over the bit of linen
in her hands. And Fairy, her piquantly bright
features clouded with an unwonted frown, crumpled
a letter in her hand.
“I do think men are the most
aggravating things that ever lived,” she declared,
with annoyance in her voice.
The woman in the hammock smiled slightly,
and did not speak. Prudence carefully counted
ten threads, and solemnly drew one before she voiced
her question.
“What is he saying now?”
“Why, he’s still objecting
to my having dates with the other boys.”
Fairy’s voice was vibrant with grief. “He
does make me wild! Aunt Grace, you can’t
imagine. Last fall I mentioned casually that I
was sure he wouldn’t object to my having lecture
course dates I was too hard up to buy a
ticket for myself; they cost four dollars, and aren’t
worth it, either. And what did he do but send
me eight dollars to buy two sets of tickets!
Then this spring, when the baseball season opened,
he sent me season tickets to all the games suggesting
that my financial stringency could not be pleaded
as an excuse. Ever since he went to Chicago last
fall we’ve been fighting because the boys bring
me home from parties. I suppose he had to go
and learn to be a pharmacist, but it’s
hard on me. He wants me to patter along by myself
like a like like a hen!”
Fairy said “hen” very crossly!
“It’s a shame,”
said Prudence sympathetically. “That’s
just what it is. You wouldn’t say a word
to his taking girls home from things, would you?”
“Hum, that’s
a different matter,” said Fairy more thoughtfully.
“He hasn’t wanted to yet. You see,
he’s a man and can go by himself without having
it look as though nobody wanted to be seen with him.
And he’s a stranger over there, and doesn’t
need to get chummy with the girls. The boys here
all know me, and ask me to go, and a man,
you see, can just be passive and nothing happens.
But a girl’s got to be downright negative, and
it’s no joke. One misses so many good times.
You see the cases are different, Prue.”
“Yes, that’s so,”
Prudence assented absent-mindedly, counting off ten
more threads.
“Then you would object if he
had dates?” queried Aunt Grace smilingly.
“Oh, no, not at all, if
there was any occasion for it but there
isn’t. And I think I would be justified
in objecting if he deliberately made occasions for
himself, don’t you?”
“Yes, that would be different,”
Prudence chimed in, such “miles away” in
her voice, that Fairy turned on her indignantly.
“Prudence Starr, you make me
wild,” she said. “Can’t you
drop that everlasting hemstitching, embroidering,
tatting, crocheting, for ten minutes to talk to me?
What in the world are you going to do with it all,
anyhow? Are you intending to carpet your floors
with it?”
“This is a napkin,” Prudence
explained good-naturedly. “The set cost
me fifteen dollars.” She sighed.
“Did the veil come?” The
clouds vanished magically from Fairy’s face,
and she leaned forward with that joy of wedding anticipation
that rules in woman-world.
“Yes, it’s beautiful.
Come and see it. Wait until I pull four more
threads. It’s gorgeous.”
“I still think you’re
making a great mistake,” declared Fairy earnestly.
“I don’t believe in big showy church weddings.
You’d better change it yet. A little home
affair with just the family, that’s
the way to do it. All this satin-gown, orange-blossom
elaboration with curious eyes staring up and down ugh!
It’s all wrong.”
Prudence dropped the precious fifteen-dollar-a-set
napkin in her lap and gazed at Fairy anxiously.
“I know you think so, Fairy,” she said.
“You’ve told me so several times.”
Fairy’s eyes twinkled, but Prudence had no intention
of sarcasm. “But I can’t help it,
can I? We had quite settled on the home wedding,
but when the twins discovered that the members felt
hurt at being left out, father thought we’d better
change over.”
“Well, I can’t see that
the members have any right to run our wedding.
Besides, it wouldn’t surprise me if the twins
made it up because they wanted a big fuss.”
“But some of the members spoke to father.”
“Oh, just common members that
don’t count for much and it was mighty
poor manners of ’em, too, if you’ll excuse
me for saying so.”
“And you must admit, Fairy,
that it is lovely of the Ladies’ Aid to give
that dinner at the hotel for us.”
“Well, they’ll get their
money’s worth of talk out of it afterward.
It’s a big mistake. What on earth
are the twins doing out there? Is that Jim Forrest
with them? Listen how they are screaming with
laughter! Would you ever believe those twins
are past fifteen, and nearly through their junior
year? They haven’t as much sense put together
as Connie has all alone.”
“Come and see the veil,”
said Prudence, rising. But she dropped back on
the step again as Carol came rushing toward them at
full speed, with Lark and a tall young fellow trailing
slowly, laughing, behind her.
“The mean things!” she
gasped. “They cheated!” She dropped
a handful of pennies in her aunt’s lap as she
lay in the hammock. “We’ll take ’em
to Sunday-school and give ’em to the heathen,
that’s what we’ll do. They cheated!”
“Yes, infant, who cheated, and
how, and why? And whence the startling array
of pennies? And why this unwonted affection for
the heathen?” mocked Fairy.
“Trying to be a blank verse,
Fairy? Keep it up, you haven’t far to go! There
they are! Look at them, Aunt Grace. They
cheated. They tried to get all my hard-earned
pennies by nefarious methods, and
“And so Carol stole them all,
and ran! Sit down, Jim. My, it’s hot.
Give me back my pennies, Carol.”
“The heathen! The heathen!”
insisted Carol. “Not a penny do you get.
You see, Aunt Grace, we were matching pennies, you’d
better not mention it to father. We’ve
turned over a new leaf now, and quit for good.
But we were matching and they made a bargain
that whenever it was my turn, one of them would throw
heads and one tails, and that way I never could win
anything. And I didn’t catch on until I
saw Jim wink, and so of course I thought it was only
right to give the pennies to the heathen.”
“Mercy, Prudence,” interrupted
Lark. “Are you doing another napkin?
This is the sixteenth dozen, isn’t it?
You’d better donate some of them to the parsonage,
I think. I was so ashamed when Miss Marsden came
to dinner. She opened her napkin out wide, and
her finger went right through a hole. I was mortified
to death and Carol laughed. It seems
to me with three grown women in the house we could
have holeless napkins, one for company, anyhow.”
“How is your mother, Jim?”
“Just fine, Miss Prudence, thank
you. She said to tell you she would send a basket
of red Junes to-morrow, if you want them. The
twins can eat them, I know. Carol ate twenty-two
when they were out Saturday.”
“Yes, I did, and I’m glad
of it,” said Carol stoutly. “Such
apples you never saw, Prudence. They’re
about as big as a thimble, and two-thirds core.
They’re good, they’re fine, I’ll
say that, but there’s nothing to
them. I could have eaten as many again if Jim
hadn’t been counting out loud, and I got kind
of ashamed because every one was laughing. If
I had a ranch as big as yours, Jim, I’ll bet
you a dollar I’d have apples bigger than a dime!”
“‘Bet you a dollar,’” quoted
Fairy.
“Well, I’ll wager my soul,
if that sounds more like Shakespeare. Don’t
go, Jim, we’re not fighting. This is just
the way Fairy and I make love to each other.
You’re perfectly welcome to stay, but be careful
of your grammar, for now that Fairy’s a senior will
be next year, if she lives she even tries
to teach father the approved method of doing a ministerial
sneeze in the pulpit.”
“Think I’d better go,”
decided the tall good-looking youth, laughing as he
looked with frank boyish admiration into Carol’s
sparkling face. “With Fairy after my grammar,
and you to criticize my manner and my morals, I see
right now that a parsonage is no safe place for a
farmer’s son.” And laughing again,
he thrust his cap into his pocket, and walked quickly
out the new cement parsonage walk. But at the
gate he paused to call back, “Don’t make
a mistake, Carol, and use the heathen’s pennies
for candy.”
The girls on the porch laughed, and
five pairs of eyes gazed after the tall figure rapidly
disappearing.
“He’s nice,” said Prudence.
“Yes,” assented Carol.
“I’ve got a notion to marry him after a
little. That farm of his is worth about ten thousand.”
“Are you going to wait until he asks you?”
“Certainly not! Anybody
can marry a man after he asks her. The thing to
do, if you want to be really original and interesting,
is to marry him before he asks you and surprise him.”
“Yes,” agreed Lark, “if
you wait until he asks you he’s likely to think
it over once too often and not ask you at all.”
“Doesn’t that sound exactly
like a book, now?” demanded Carol proudly.
“Fairy couldn’t have said that!”
“No,” said Fairy, “I
couldn’t. Thank goodness! I have
what is commonly known as brains. Look it up
in the dictionary, twins. It’s something
you ought to know about.”
“Oh, Prudence,” cried
Lark dramatically, “I forgot to tell you.
You can’t get married after all.”
For ten seconds Prudence, as well
as Fairy and their aunt, stared in speechless amazement.
Then Prudence smiled.
“Oh, can’t I? What’s the joke
now?”
“Joke! It’s no joke.
Carol’s sick, that’s what’s the joke.
You can’t be married without Carol, can you?”
A burst of gay laughter greeted this announcement.
“Carol sick! She acts sick!”
“She looks sick!”
“Where is she sick?”
Carol leaned limply back against the
pillar, trying to compose her bright face into a semblance
of illness. “In my tummy,” she announced
weakly.
This called forth more laughter. “It’s
her conscience,” said Fairy.
“It’s matching pennies. Maybe she
swallowed one.”
“It’s probably those two
pieces of pie she ate for dinner, and the one that
vanished from the pantry shortly after,” suggested
Aunt Grace.
Carol sat up quickly. “Welcome
home, Aunt Grace!” she cried. “Did
you have a pleasant visit?”
“Carol,” reproved Prudence.
“I didn’t mean it for
impudence, auntie,” said Carol, getting up and
bending affectionately over the hammock, gently caressing
the brown hair just beginning to silver about her
forehead. “But it does amuse me so to hear
a lady of your age and dignity indulge in such lavish
conversational exercises.”
Lark swallowed with a forced effort.
“Did it hurt, Carol? How did you get it
all out in one breath?”
“Lark, I do wish you wouldn’t
gulp that way when folks use big words,” said
Fairy. “It looks awful.”
“Well, I won’t when I
get to be as old and crabbed as father,”
said Lark. “Sit down, Carol, and remember
you’re sick.”
Carol obediently sat down, and looked sicker than
ever.
“You can laugh if you like,”
she said, “I am sick, at least, I was this afternoon.
I’ve been feeling very queer for three or four
days. I don’t think I’m quite over
it yet.”
“Pie! You were right, Aunt
Grace! That’s the way pie works.”
“It’s not pie at all,”
declared Carol heatedly. “And I didn’t
take that piece out of the pantry, at least, not exactly.
I caught Connie sneaking it, and I gave her a good
calling down, and she hung her head and slunk away
in disgrace. But she had taken such big bites
that it looked sort of unsanitary, so I thought I’d
better finish it before it gathered any germs.
But it’s not pie. Now that I think of it,
it was my head where I was sick. Don’t
you remember, Lark, I said my head ached?”
“Yes, and her eyes got red and
bleary when she was reading. And and
there was something else, too, Carol, what
“Your eyes are bloodshot, Carol.
They do look bad.” Prudence examined them
closely. “Now, Carol Starr, don’t
you touch another book or magazine until after the
wedding. If you think I want a bloodshot bridesmaid,
you’re mistaken.”
They all turned to look across the
yard at Connie, just turning in. Connie always
walked, as Carol said, “as if she mostly wasn’t
there.” But she usually “arrived”
by the time she got within speaking distance of her
sister.
“Goodness, Prue, aren’t
you going to do anything but eat after you move to
Des Moines? Carol and I were counting
the napkins last night, was it a hundred
and seventy-six, Carol, or some awful number
I know. Carol piled them up in two piles and
we kneeled on them to say our prayers, and I
can’t say for sure, but I think Carol pushed
me. Anyhow, I lost my balance, and usually I’m
pretty well balanced. I toppled over right after
‘God save,’ and Carol screamed ’the
napkins’ Prue’s wedding napkins!
It was an awful funny effect; I couldn’t finish
my prayers.”
“Carol Starr! Fifteen years old and
“That’s a very much exaggerated
story, Prue. Connie blamed it on me as usual.
She piled them up herself to see if there were two
feet of them, she put her stockings on
the floor first so the dust wouldn’t rub off.
It was Lark’s turn to sweep and you know how
Lark sweeps, and Connie was very careful, indeed,
and
“Come on, Fairy, and see the veil!”
“The veil! Did it come?”
With a joyous undignified whoop the
parsonage girls scrambled to their feet and rushed
indoors in a fine Kilkenny jumble. Aunt Grace
looked after them, thoughtfully, smiling for a second,
and then with a girlish shrug of her slender shoulders
she slipped out and followed them inside.
The last thing that night, before
she said her prayers, Prudence carried a big bottle
of witch hazel into the twins’ room. Both
were sleeping, but she roused Carol, and Lark turned
over to listen.
“You must bathe your eyes with
this, Carol. I forgot to tell you. What
would Jerry say if he had a bleary-eyed bridesmaid!”
And although the twins grumbled and
mumbled about the idiotic nonsense of getting-married
folks, Carol obediently bathed the bloodshot eyes.
For in their heart of hearts, every one of the parsonage
girls held this wedding to be the affair of prime
importance, national and international, as well as
just plain Methodist.
The twins were undeniably lazy, and
slept as late of mornings as the parsonage law allowed.
So it was that when Lark skipped into the dining-room,
three minutes late for breakfast, she found the whole
family, with the exception of Carol, well in the midst
of their meal.
“She was sick,” she began
quickly, then interrupting herself, “Oh,
good morning! Beg pardon for forgetting my manners.
But Carol was sick, Prudence, and I hope you and Fairy
are ashamed of yourselves and auntie, too for
making fun of her. She couldn’t sleep all
night, and rolled and tossed, and her head hurt and
she talked in her sleep, and
“I thought she didn’t sleep.”
“Well, she didn’t sleep
much, but when she did she mumbled and said things
and
Then the dining-room door opened again,
and Carol her hair about her shoulders,
her feet bare, enveloped in a soft and clinging kimono
of faded blue stalked majestically into
the room. There was woe in her eyes, and her
voice was tragic.
“It is gone,” she said. “It
is gone!”
Her appearance was uncanny to say
the least, and the family gazed at her with some concern,
despite the fact that Carol’s vagaries were so
common as usually to elicit small respect.
“Gone!” she cried, striking her palms
together. “Gone!”
“If you do anything to spoil
that wedding, papa’ll whip you, if you are fifteen
years old,” said Fairy.
Lark sprang to her sister’s
side. “What’s gone, Carrie?”
she pleaded with sympathy, almost with tears.
“What’s gone? Are you out of your
head?”
“No! Out of my complexion,” was the
dramatic answer.
Even Lark fell back, for the moment,
stunned. “Y-your complexion,” she
faltered.
“Look! Look at me, Lark.
Don’t you see? My complexion is gone my
beautiful complexion that I loved. Look at me!
Oh, I would gladly have sacrificed a leg, or an arm,
a rib or an eye, but not my dear complexion!”
Sure enough, now that they looked
carefully, they could indeed perceive that the usual
soft creaminess of Carol’s skin was prickled
and sparred with ugly red splotches. Her eyes
were watery, shot with blood. For a time they
gazed in silence, then they burst into laughter.
“Pie!” cried Fairy.
“It’s raspberry pie, coming out, Carol!”
The corners of Carol’s lips
twitched slightly, and it was with difficulty that
she maintained her wounded regal bearing. But
Lark, always quick to resent an indignity to this
twin of her heart, turned upon them angrily.
“Fairy Starr! You are a
wicked unfeeling thing! You sit there and laugh
and talk about pie when Carol is sick and suffering her
lovely complexion all ruined, and it was the joy of
my life, that complexion was. Papa, why
don’t you do something?”
But he only laughed harder than ever.
“If there’s anything more preposterous
than Carol’s vanity because of her beauty, it’s
Lark’s vanity for her,” he said.
Aunt Grace drew Carol to her side,
and examined the ruined complexion closely. Then
she smiled, but there was regret in her eyes.
“Well, Carol, you’ve spoiled
your part of the wedding sure enough. You’ve
got the measles.”
Then came the silence of utter horror.
“Not the measles,” begged
Carol, wounded afresh. “Give me diphtheria,
or smallpox, or or even leprosy, and I’ll
bear it bravely and with a smile, but it shall not
be said that Carol’s measles spoiled the wedding.”
“Oh, Carol,” wailed Prudence,
“don’t have the measles, please
don’t. I’ve waited all my life for
this wedding, don’t spoil it.”
“Well, it’s your own fault,
Prue,” interrupted Lark. “If you hadn’t
kept us all cooped up when we were little we’d
have had measles long ago. Now, like as not the
whole family’ll have ’em, and serve you
right. No self-respecting family has any business
to grow up without having the measles.”
“What shall we do now?” queried Constance
practically.
“Well, I always said it was a mistake,”
said Fairy. “A big wedding
“Oh, Fairy, please don’t
tell me that again. I know it so well. Papa,
whatever shall we do? Maybe Jerry hasn’t
had them either.”
“Why, it’s easily arranged,”
said Lark. “We’ll just postpone the
wedding until Carol’s quite well again.”
“Bad luck,” said Connie.
“Too much work,” said Fairy.
“Well, she can’t get married without Carol,
can she?” ejaculated Lark.
“Are you sure it’s measles, Aunt Grace?”
“Yes, it’s measles.”
“Then,” said Fairy, “we’ll
get Alice Bird or Katie Free to bridesmaid with Lark.
They are the same size and either will do all right.
She can wear Carol’s dress. You won’t
mind that, will you, Carol?”
“No,” said Carol moodily,
“of course I won’t. The only real
embroidery dress I ever had in my life and
haven’t got that yet! But go ahead and
get anybody you like. I’m hoodooed, that’s
what it is. It’s a punishment because you
and Jim cheated yesterday, Lark.”
“What did you do?” asked
Connie. “You seem to be getting the punishment!”
“Shall we have Alice or Katie?
Which do you prefer, Lark?”
“You’ll have to get them
both,” was the stoic answer. “I won’t
bridesmaid without Carol.”
“Don’t be silly, Lark. You’ll
have to.”
“Then wait for Carol.”
“Papa, you must make her.”
“No,” said Prudence slowly,
with a white face. “We’ll postpone
it. I won’t get married without the whole
family.”
“I said right from the start
“Oh, yes, Fairy, we know what
you said,” interjected Carol. “We
know how you’ll get married. First man
that gets moonshine enough into his head to propose
to you, you’ll trot him post haste to the justice
before he thinks twice.”
In the end, the wedding was postponed
a couple of months, for both Connie and
Fairy took the measles. But when at last, the
wedding party, marshalled by Connie with a huge white
basket of flowers, trailed down the time-honored aisle
of the Methodist church, it was without one dissenting
voice pronounced the crowning achievement of Mr. Starr’s
whole pastorate.
“I was proud of us, Lark,”
Carol told her twin, after it was over, and Prudence
had gone, and the girls had wept themselves weak on
each other’s shoulders. “We get so
in the habit of doing things wrong that I half expected
myself to pipe up ahead of father with the ceremony.
It seems awful without Prudence, but
it’s a satisfaction to know that she was the
best married bride Mount Mark has ever seen.”
“Jerry looked awfully handsome,
didn’t he? Did you notice how he glowed
at Prudence? I wish you were artistic, Carol,
so you could illustrate my books. Jerry’d
make a fine illustration.”
“We looked nice, too. We’re
not a bad-looking bunch when you come right down to
facts. Of course, it is fine to be as smart as
you are, Larkie, but I’m not jealous. We’re
mighty lucky to have both beauty and brains in our
twin-ship, and since one can’t have
both, I may say I’d just as lief be pretty.
It’s so much easier.”
“Carol!”
“What?”
“We’re nearly grown up
now. We’ll have to begin to settle down.
Prudence says so.”
For a few seconds Carol wavered, tremulous.
Then she said pluckily, “All right. Just
wait till I powder my nose, will you? It gets
so shiny when I cry.”
“Carol!”
“What?”
“Isn’t the house still?”
“Yes ghastly.”
“I never thought Prudence was
much of a chatter-box, but listen!
There isn’t a sound.”
Carol held out a hand, and Lark clutched it desperately.
“Let’s let’s
go find the folks. This is awful!
Little old Prudence is gone!”