Now that the twins had attained to the dignity of eighteen years, and were respectable students at the thoroughly respectable Presbyterian college, they had dates very frequently. And it was along about this time that Mr. Starr developed a sudden interest in the evening callers at his home. He bobbed up unannounced in most unexpected places and at most unexpected hours. He walked about the house with a sharp sly look in his eyes, in a way that could only be described as Carol said, by “downright nosiness.” The girls discussed this new phase of his character when they were alone, but decided not to mention it to him, for fear of hurting his feelings. “Maybe he’s got a new kind of a sermon up his brain,” said Carol. “Maybe he’s beginning to realize that his clothes are wearing out again,” suggested Lark. “He’s too young for second childhood,” Connie thought. So they watched him curiously.

Aunt Grace, too, observed this queer devotion on the part of the minister, and finally her curiosity overcame her habit of keeping silent.

“William,” she said gently, “what’s the matter with you lately? Is there anything on your mind?”

Mr. Starr started nervously. “My mind? Of course not. Why?”

“You seem to be looking for something. You watch the girls so closely, you’re always hanging around, and

He smiled broadly. “Thanks for that. ‘Hanging around,’ in my own parsonage. That is the gratitude of a loving family!”

Aunt Grace smiled. “Well, I see there’s nothing much the matter with you. I was seriously worried. I thought there was something wrong, and

“Sort of mentally unbalanced, is that it? Oh, no, I’m just watching my family.”

She looked up quickly. “Watching the family! You mean

“Carol,” he said briefly.

“Carol! You’re watching

“Oh, only in the most honorable way, of course. You see,” he gave his explanation with an air of relief, “Prudence always says I must keep an eye on Carol. She’s so pretty, and the boys get stuck on her, and that’s what Prudence says. I forgot all about it for a while. But lately I have begun to notice that the boys are older, and we don’t want Carol falling in love with the wrong man. I got uneasy. I decided to watch out. I’m the head of this family, you know.”

“Such an idea!” scoffed Aunt Grace, who was not at all of a scoffing nature.

“Carol was born for lovers, Prudence says so. And these men’s girls have to be watched, or the wrong fellow will get ahead, and

“Carol doesn’t need watching not any more at least.”

“I’m not really watching her, you know. I’m just keeping my eyes open.”

“But Carol’s all right. That’s one time Prudence was away off.” She smiled as she recognized a bit of Carol’s slang upon her lips. “Don’t worry about her. You needn’t keep an eye on her any more. She’s coming, all right.”

“You don’t think there’s any danger of her falling in love with the wrong man?”

“No.”

“There aren’t many worth-having fellows in Mount Mark, you know.”

“Carol won’t fall in love with a Mount Mark fellow.”

“You seem very positive.”

“Yes, I’m positive.”

He looked thoughtful for a while. “Well, Prudence always told me to watch Carol, so I could help her if she needed it.”

“Girls always need their fathers,” came the quick reply. “But Carol does not need you particularly. There’s only one of them who will require especial attention.”

“That’s what Prudence says.”

“Yes, just one not Carol.”

“Not Carol!” He looked at her in astonishment. “Why, Fairy and Lark are different. They’re all right. They don’t need attention.”

“No. It’s the other one.”

“The other one! That’s all.”

“There’s Connie.”

“Connie?”

“Yes.”

“Connie?”

“Yes.”

“You don’t mean Connie.”

Aunt Grace smiled.

“Why, Grace, you’re you’re off. Excuse me for saying it, but you’re crazy. Connie why, Connie has never been any trouble in her life. Connie!”

“You’ve never had any friction with Connie, she’s always been right so far. One of these days she’s pretty likely to be wrong, and Connie doesn’t yield very easily.”

“But Connie’s so sober and straight, and

“That’s the kind.”

“She’s so conscientious.”

“Yes, conscientious.”

“She’s look here, Grace, there’s nothing the matter with Connie.”

“Of course not, William. That isn’t what I mean. But you ought to be getting very, very close to Connie right now, for one of these days she’s going to need a lot of that extra companionship Prudence told you about. Connie wants to know everything. She wants to see everything. None of the other girls ever yearned for city life. Connie does. She says when she is through school she’s going to the city.”

“What city?”

“Any city.”

“What for?”

“For experience.”

Mr. Starr looked about him helplessly. “There’s experience right here,” he protested feebly. “Lots of it. Entirely too much of it.”

“Well, that’s Connie. She wants to know, to see, to feel. She wants to live. Get close to her, get chummy. She may not need it, and then again she may. She’s very young yet.”

“All right, I will. It is well I have some one to steer me along the proper road.” He looked regretfully out of the window. “I ought to be able to see these things for myself, but the girls seem perfectly all right to me. They always have. I suppose it’s because they’re mine.”

Aunt Grace looked at him affectionately. “It’s because they’re the finest girls on earth,” she declared. “That’s why. But we want to be ready to help them if they need it, just because they are so fine. They will every one be splendid, if we give them the right kind of a chance.”

He sat silent a moment. “I’ve always wanted one of them to marry a preacher,” he said, laughing apologetically. “It is very narrow-minded, of course, but a man does make a hobby of his own profession. I always hoped Prudence would. I thought she was born for it. Then I looked to Fairy, and she turned me down. I guess I’ll have to give up the notion now.”

She looked at him queerly. “Maybe not.”

“Connie might, I suppose.”

“Connie,” she contradicted promptly, “will probably marry a genius, or a rascal, or a millionaire.”

He looked dazed at that.

She leaned forward a little. “Carol might.”

“Carol

“She might.” She watched him narrowly, a smile in her eyes.

“Carol’s too worldly.”

“You don’t believe that.”

“No, not really. Carol she why, you know when I think of it, Carol wouldn’t be half bad for a minister’s wife. She has a sense of humor, that is very important. She’s generous, she’s patient, she’s unselfish, a good mixer, some of the ladies might think her complexion wasn’t real, but Grace, Carol wouldn’t be half bad!”

“Oh, William,” she sighed, “can’t you remember that you are a Methodist minister, and a grandfather, and grow up a little?”

After that Mr. Starr returned to normal again, only many times he and Connie had little outings together, and talked a great deal. And Aunt Grace, seeing it, smiled with satisfaction. But the twins and Fairy settled it in their own minds by saying, “Father was just a little jealous of all the beaux. He was looking for a pal, and he’s found Connie.”

But in spite of his new devotion to Connie, Mr. Starr also spent a great deal of time with Fairy. “We must get fast chums, Fairy,” he often said to her. “This is our last chance. We have to get cemented for a lifetime, you know.”

And Fairy, when he said so, caught his hand and laughed a little tremulously.

Indeed, he was right when he said it was his last chance with Fairy in the parsonage. Two weeks before her commencement she had slipped into the library and closed the door cautiously behind her.

“Father,” she said, “would you be very sorry if I didn’t teach school after all?”

“Not a bit,” came the ready answer.

“I mean if I you see, father, since you sent me to college I feel as if I ought to work and help out.”

“That’s nonsense,” he said, drawing the tall girl down to his knees. “I can take care of my own family, thanks. Are you trying to run me out of my job? If you want to work, all right, do it, but for yourself, and not for us. Or if you want to do anything else,” he did not meet her eyes, “if you want to stay at home a year or so before you get married, it would please us better than anything else. And when you want to marry Gene, we’re expecting it, you know.”

“Yes, I know,” she fingered the lapel of his coat uneasily. “Do you care how soon I get married?”

“Are you still sure it is Gene?”

“Yes, I’m sure.”

“Then I think you should choose your own time. I am in no hurry. But any time, it’s for you, and Gene, to decide.”

“Then you haven’t set your heart on my teaching?”

“I set my heart on giving you the best chance possible. And I have done it. For the rest, it depends on you. You may work, or you may stay at home a while. I only want you to be happy, Fairy.”

“But doesn’t it seem foolish to go clear through college, and spend the money, and then marry without using the education?”

“I do not think so. They’ve been fine years, and you are finer because of them. There’s just as much opportunity to use your fineness in a home of your own as in a public school. That’s the way I look at it.”

“You don’t think I’m too young?”

“You’re pretty young,” he said slowly. “I can hardly say, Fairy. You’ve always been capable and self-possessed. When you and Gene get so crazy about each other you can’t bear to be apart any longer, it’s all right here.”

She put her arm around his neck and rubbed her fingers over his cheek lovingly.

“You understand, don’t you, father, that I’m just going to be plain married when the time comes? Not a wedding like Prudence’s. Gene, and the girls, and Prue and Jerry, and you, father, that is all.”

“Yes, all right. It’s your day, you know.”

“And we won’t talk much about it beforehand. We all know how we feel about things. It would be silly for me to try to tell you what a grand sweet father you’ve been to us. I can’t tell you, if I tried I’d only cry. You know what I think.”

His face was against hers, and his eyes were away from her, so Fairy did not see the moisture in his eyes when he said in a low voice:

“Yes, I know Fairy. And I don’t need to say what fine girls you are, and how proud I am of you. You know it already. But sometimes,” he added slowly, “I wonder that I haven’t been a bigger man, and haven’t done finer work, with a houseful of girls like mine.”

Her arm pressed more closely about his neck. “Father,” she whispered, “don’t say that. We think you are wonderfully splendid, just as you are. It isn’t what you’ve said, not what you’ve done for us, it’s just because you have always made us so sure of you. We never had to wonder about father, or ask ourselves we were sure. We’ve always had you.” She leaned over and kissed him again. “There never was such a father, they all say so, Prudence and Connie, and the twins, too! There couldn’t be another like you! Now we understand each other, don’t we?”

“I guess so. Anyhow, I understand that there’ll only be three daughters in the parsonage pretty soon. All right, Fairy. I know you will be happy.” He paused a moment. “So will I.”

But the months passed, and Fairy seemed content to stay quietly at home, embroidering as Prudence had done, laughing at the twins as they tripped gaily, riotously through college. And then in the early spring, she sent an urgent note to Prudence.

“You must come home for a few days, Prue, you and Jerry. It’s just because I want you and I need you, and I know you won’t go back on me. I want you to get here on the early afternoon train Tuesday, and stay till the last of the week. Just wire that you are coming the three of you. I know you’ll be here, since it is I who ask it.”

It followed naturally that Prudence’s answer was satisfactory. “Of course we’ll come.”

Fairy’s plans were very simple. “We’ll have a nice family dinner Tuesday evening, we’ll get Mrs. Green to come and cook and have her niece to serve it, that’ll leave us free to visit every minute. I’ll plan the dinner. Then we’ll all be together, nice and quiet, just our own little bunch. Don’t have dates, twins, of course Gene will be here, but he’s part of the family, and we don’t want outsiders this time. His parents will be in town, and I’ve asked them to come up. I want a real family reunion just for once, and it’s my party, for I started it. So you must let me have it my own way.”

Fairy was generally willing to leave the initiative to the eager twins, but when she made a plan it was generally worth adopting, and the other members of the family agreed to her arrangements without demur.

After the first confusion of welcoming Prudence home, and making fun of “daddy Jerry,” and testing the weight and length of little Fairy, they all settled down to a parsonage home-gathering. Just a few minutes before the dinner hour, Fairy took her father’s hand.

“Come into the lime-light,” she said softly, “I want you.” He passed little Fairy over to the outstretched arms of the nearest auntie, and allowed himself to be led into the center of the room.

“Gene,” said Fairy, and he came to her quickly, holding out a slender roll of paper. “It’s our license,” said Fairy. “We think we’d like to be married now, father, if you will.”

He looked at her questioningly, but understandingly. The girls clustered about them with eager outcries, half protest, half encouragement.

“It’s my day, you know,” cried Fairy, “and this is my way.”

She held out her hand, and Gene took it very tenderly in his. Mr. Starr looked at them gravely for a moment, and then in the gentle voice that the parsonage girls insisted was his most valuable ministerial asset, he gave his second girl in marriage.

It surely was Fairy’s way, plain and sweet, without formality. And the dinner that followed was just a happy family dinner. Fairy’s face was so glowing with content, and Gene’s attitude was so tender, and so ludicrously proud, that the twins at last were convinced that this was right, and all was well.

But that evening, when Gene’s parents had gone away, and after Fairy and Gene themselves had taken the carriage to the station for their little vacation together, and Jerry and Prudence were putting little Fairy to bed, the three girls left in the home sat drearily in their bedroom and talked it over.

“We’re thinning out,” said Connie. “Who next?”

“We’ll stick around as long as we like, Miss Connie, you needn’t try to shuffle us off,” said Lark indignantly.

“Prudence, and Fairy, it was pretty cute of Fairy, wasn’t it?”

“Let’s go to bed,” said Carol, rising. “I suppose we’ll feel better in the morning. A good sleep is almost as filling as a big meal after a blow like this. Well, that’s the end of Fairy. We have to make the best of us. Come on, Larkie. You’ve still got us to boss you, Con, so you needn’t feel too forlorn. My, but the house is still! In some ways I think this family is positively sickening. Good night, Connie. And, after this, when you want to eat candy in bed, please use your own. I got chocolate all over my foot last night. Good night, Connie. Well, it’s the end of Fairy. The family is going to pieces, sure enough.”