New York City, in 1776, lay at the
end of Manhattan Island, in shape somewhat like an
arrow-head, with its point turned towards the sea and
its barbs extended at uneven lengths along the East
and Hudson rivers. It occupied no more space
than is now included within the five lower and smallest
of its twenty-four wards. Excepting a limited
district laid out on the east side, in part as far
as Grand street, the entire town stood below the line
of the present Chambers street, and covered an area
less than one mile square. Then, as now, Broadway
was its principal thoroughfare. Shaded with rows
of trees, and lined mainly with residences, churches,
and public-houses, it stretched something more than
a mile to the grounds of the old City Hospital, near
Duane street. Its starting-point was the Battery
at the end of the island, but not the Battery of to-day;
for, under the system of “harbor encroachments,”
the latter has more than trebled in size, and is changed
both in its shape and its uses. The city defences
at that time occupied the site. Here at the foot
of Broadway old Fort George had been erected upon
the base of the older Fort Amsterdam, to guard the
entrance to the rivers, and with its outworks was the
only protection against an attack by sea. It
was a square bastioned affair, with walls of stone,
each face eighty feet in length, and within it stood
magazines, barracks, and, until destroyed by fire,
the mansion of the colonial governors. For additional
security, about the time of the French war, an extensive
stone battery, with merlons of cedar joists,
had been built just below the fort along the water’s
edge, enclosing the point from river to river, and
pierced for ninety-one pieces of cannon.
At this period, the city represented
a growth of one hundred and sixty years. Give
it a population of twenty-five thousand souls more
rather than less and line its streets with
four thousand buildings, and we have its census statistics
approximately. The linear characteristics of
the old town are still sharply preserved. Upon
the west side, the principal streets running to the
North River Chambers, Warren, Murray, Barclay,
Vesey, Dey, and Cortlandt retain their names
and location; but the water-line was then marked by
Greenwich street. The present crowded section
to the west of it, including Washington and West streets
and the docks, is built on new ground, made within
the century. Behind Trinity Church, and as far
down as the Battery, the shore rose to a very considerable
bluff. Necessarily, much the greater part of
the city then lay east of Broadway. The irregular
streets to be found on this side are relics of both
the Dutch and English foundation; of their buildings,
however, as they stood in 1776, scarcely one remains
at the present time. New streets have been built
on the East River as well as on the North, materially
changing the water boundary of this part of the island.
Front and South streets had no existence at that date.
On the line of Wall street, the city has nearly doubled
in width since the Revolution.
Before its contraction, and in view
of its convenience and protection from storms, the
East River was the harbor proper of New York.
Most of the docks were on that side, and just above
Catherine street lay the ship-yards, where at times,
in colonial days, an eight-hundred-ton West Indiaman
might be seen upon the stocks.
What is now the City Hall Park was
called in 1776 “the Fields,” or “The
Common.” The site of the City Hall was occupied
by the House of Correction; the present Hall of Records
was the town jail, and the structure then on a line
with them at the corner of Broadway was the “Bridewell.”
The City Hall of that day stood in Wall street, on
the site of the present Custom-House, and King’s,
now Columbia, College in the square bounded by Murray,
Barclay, Church, and West Broadway. Queen, now
Pearl, was the principal business street; fashion was
to be found in the vicinity of the Battery, and Broad
and Dock streets; the Vauxhall Gardens were at the
foot of Reade; and to pass out of town, one would
have to turn off Broadway into Chatham street, which
extended through Park Row, and keep on to the Bowery.
John Adams has left us a brief description
of New York, as he saw it when passing through to
the first Congress at Philadelphia in 1774, in company
with Cushing, Paine, and Samuel Adams. His diary
runs:
“Saturday, Au. Lodged
at Cock’s, at Kingsbridge, a pretty place....
Breakfasted at Day’s [127th street], and arrived
in the city of New York at ten o’clock, at Hull’s,
a tavern, the sign the Bunch of Grapes. We rode
by several very elegant country-seats before we came
to the city.... After dinner, Mr. McDougall and
Mr. Platt came, and walked with us to every part of
the city. First we went to the fort, where we
saw the ruins of that magnificent building, the Governor’s
house [burned De, 1773]. From the Parade,
before the fort, you have a fine prospect of Hudson
River, and of the East River, or the Sound, and of
the harbor; of Long Island, beyond the Sound River,
and of New Jersey beyond Hudson’s River.
The walk round this fort is very pleasant, though
the fortifications are not strong. Between the
fort and the city is a beautiful ellipsis of land
[Bowling Green], railed in with solid iron, in the
centre of which is a statue of his majesty on horseback,
very large, of solid lead gilded with gold, standing
on a pedestal of marble, very high. We then walked
up the Broad Way, a fine street, very wide, and in
a right line from one end to the other of the city.
In this route we saw the old Church and the new Church
[Trinity]. The new is a very magnificent building cost
twenty thousand pounds, York currency. The prison
is a large and a handsome stone building; there are
two sets of barracks. We saw the New York College,
which is also a large stone building. A new hospital
is building, of stone. We then walked down to
a shipyard. Then we walked round through another
street, which is the principal street of business.
Saw the several markets. After this we went to
the coffee-house, which was full of gentlemen; read
the newspapers, etc.... The streets of this
town are vastly more regular and elegant than those
in Boston, and the houses are more grand, as well as
neat. They are almost all painted, brick buildings
and all.”
Other glimpses we get from English
sources. The traveler Smyth, while visiting this
city during the British occupation, has this to say:
“Nothing can be more delightful than the situation
of New York, commanding a variety of the most charming
prospects that can be conceived. It is built
chiefly upon the East River, which is the best and
safest harbour, and is only something more than half
a mile wide. The North River is better than two
miles over to Powles Hook, which is a strong work
opposite to New York, but is exposed to the driving
of the ice in winter, whereby ships are prevented
from lying therein during that season of the year.
The land on the North River side is high and bold,
but on the East River it gradually descends in a beautiful
declivity to the water’s edge.... Amongst
the multitude of elegant seats upon this island, there
are three or four uncommonly beautiful, viz.,
Governor Elliot’s, Judge Jones’s, Squire
Morris’s, and Mr. Bateman’s. And
opposite, upon the Continent, just above Hell-gates,
there is a villa named Morrisania, which is inferior
to no place in the world for the beauties, grandeur,
and extent of perspective, and the elegance of its
situation.” Eddis, who had been compelled
to leave Maryland on account of his loyal sentiments,
was hardly less impressed with the city’s appearance
when he stopped here on his way to England in 1777.
“The capital of this province,” he wrote,
August 16th, “is situated on the southern extremity
of the island; on one side runs the North, and on
the other the East River, on the latter of which,
on account of the harbour, the city is principally
built. In several streets, trees are regularly
planted, which afford a grateful shelter during the
intense heat of the summer. The buildings are
generally of brick, and many are erected in a style
of elegance.... Previous to the commencement of
this unhappy war, New York was a flourishing, populous,
and beautiful town.... Notwithstanding the late
devastation [fire of 1776], there are still many elegant
edifices remaining, which would reflect credit on any
metropolis in Europe."
Beyond the limits of the city, Manhattan
Island retained much of its primitive appearance.
Roads, farms, country-seats, interspersed it, but
not thickly; and as yet the salient features were hills,
marshes, patches of rocky land, streams, and woods.
Just upon the outskirts, midway between the rivers,
at about the corner of Grand and Centre Streets, the
ground rose to a commanding elevation on the farm of
William Bayard, which overlooked the city and the island
above a distance of more than three miles. Further
east, a little north of the intersection of Grand
and Division Streets, stood another hill, somewhat
lower, where Judge Jones lived, from which opened an
extensive view of the East River and harbor. On
the west side, on this line, the surface sank from
Bayard’s mount into a spreading marsh as far
as the Hudson, and over which now run portions of Canal
and Grand and their cross streets. Where we have
the Tombs and surrounding blocks, stood the “Fresh
Water” lake or “Collect,” several
fathoms deep, with high sloping banks on the north
and west, and on whose surface were made the earliest
experiments in steam navigation in 1796.
One nearly central highway, known
as the King’s Bridge or Post Road, ran the entire
length of the island. Where it left the city at
Chatham Square, it was properly the Bowerie or Bowery
Lane. Continuing along the present street by
this name, it fell off into the line of Fourth Avenue
as far as Fourteenth Street, crossed Union Square diagonally
to Broadway, and kept the course of the latter to
Madison Square at Twenty-third Street. Crossing
this square, also diagonally, the road stretched along
between Fourth and Second Avenues to Fifty-third Street,
passed east of Second Avenue, and then turning westerly
entered Central Park at Ninety-second Street.
Leaving the Park at a hollow in the hills known as
“McGowan’s Pass,” just above the
house of Andrew McGowan, on the line of One Hundred
and Seventh Street, west of Fifth Avenue, it followed
Harlem Lane to the end of the island. Here, on
the other side of King’s Bridge, then “a
small wooden bridge," the highway diverged easterly
to New England and northerly to Albany.
This portion of the island above the
city was known as its “Out-ward,” and
had been divided at an early date into three divisions,
under the names of the Bowery, Harlem, and Bloomingdale
divisions. Each contained points of settlement.
The Bowery section included that part of the city
laid out near Fresh Water Pond and around Chatham Square
below Grand Street, and the stretch of country above
beyond the line of Twenty-third Street. In this
division were to be found some of the notable residences
and country-seats of that day. James De Lancey’s
large estate extended from the Bowery to the East River,
and from Division nearly to the line of Houston Street.
The Rutgers’ Mansion stood attractively on the
slopes of the river bank about the line of Montgomery
Street, and above De Lancey’s, on the Bowery,
were the De Peysters, Dyckmans, and Stuyvesants.
The Harlem division of the Out-ward,
with which are associated some of the most interesting
events of 1776, included what is now known as Harlem,
with the island above it as far as King’s Bridge.
Dutch farmers had settled here a hundred years before
the Revolution. As early as 1658, the Director-General
and Council of New Netherland gave notice that “for
the further promotion of Agriculture, for the security
of this Island, and the cattle pasturing thereon, as
well as for the greater recreation and amusement of
this city of Amsterdam in New Netherland, they have
resolved to form a New Village or Settlement at the
end of the Island, and about the lands of Jochem Pietersen,
deceased, and those which adjoin thereto.”
The first settlers were to receive lots to cultivate,
be furnished with a guard of soldiers, and allowed
a ferry across the Harlem River, for “the better
and greater promotion of neighborly correspondence
with the English of the North." In 1776, the division
was interspersed with houses and fields, especially
in the stretch of plains or flat land just above One
Hundred and Tenth Street, and from the East River to
the line of Ninth Avenue. The church and centre
of the village were on the east side, in the vicinity
of One Hundred and Twenty-fifth Street, and the old
road by which they were reached from the city branched
off from the main highway at McGowan’s Pass.
Bloomingdale was a scattered settlement,
containing nearly all the houses to be found along
the Bloomingdale Road, but the name appears to have
identified principally the upper section beyond Fiftieth
Street. Here lived the Apthorpes at Ninety-second
Street; the Strikers, Joneses, and Hogelands above;
and, lower down, the Somerindykes and Harsens.
As fixed by law, at that time, this road started from
the King’s Bridge Road, at the house of John
Horn, now the corner of Twenty-third Street and Fifth
Avenue, and followed the line of the present Broadway
and the recent Bloomingdale Road to the farm of Adrian
Hogeland, at One Hundred and Eighth Street. Nearly
on a line with Hogeland, but considerably east of him,
lived Benjamin Vandewater; and these two were the
most northerly residents in the division.
Still another suburb of the city was
the village of Greenwich, overlooking the Hudson on
the west side, in the vicinity of Fourteenth Street,
to which the Greenwich Road, now Greenwich Street,
led along the river bank in nearly a straight line.
The road above continued further east about as far
as Forty-fifth Street, and there connected, by a lane
running south-westerly, with the Bloomingdale Road
at Forty-third Street. Among the country-seats
in this village were those of the Jeaunceys, Bayards,
and Clarkes; and above, at Thirty-third Street and
Ninth Avenue, stood the ample and conspicuous residence
of John Morin Scott, one of the leading lawyers of
the city, and a powerful supporter of the American
cause.
Across the East River, the “Sister
City” of Brooklyn in 1776 was as yet invisible
from New York. A clump of low buildings at the
old ferry, and an occasional manor-seat, were the
only signs of life apparent on that side. Columbia
Heights, whose modern blocks and row of wharves and
bonded stores suggest commercial activity alone, caught
the eye a century ago as “a noble bluff,”
crowned with fields and woods, and meeting the water
at its base with a shining beach. The parish
or village proper was the merest cluster of houses,
nestled in the vicinity of the old Dutch church, which
stood in the middle of the road a little below Bridge
Street. The road was the King’s highway,
and it ran from Fulton Ferry where we have
had a ferry for two hundred and forty years at least along
the line of Fulton Street, and on through Jamaica
to the eastern end of Long Island. Besides the
settlements that had grown up at these two points the
church and the ferry, which were nearly a mile and
a half apart a village centre was to be
found at Bedford, further up the highway, another in
the vicinity of the Wallabout, and still another,
called Gowanus, along the branch road skirting the
bay. These all stood within the present municipal
limits of Brooklyn.
As it had been for more than a century
before, the population on the Long Island side was
largely Dutch at the time of the Revolution. The
first-comers, in 1636 and after, introduced themselves
to the soil and the red man as the Van Schows, the
Cornelissens, the Manjes, and the like good
Walloon patronimics and the Dutch heritage
is still preserved in the names of old families, and
even more permanently in the name of the place itself;
for the word Brooklyn is but the English corruption
of Breukelen, the ancient Holland village of which
our modern city appears to have been the namesake.
Smyth, the English traveler, makes the general statement
towards the close of the Revolution, that two thirds
of the inhabitants of Long Island, especially those
on the west end, were of Dutch extraction, who continued
“to make use of their customs and language in
preference to English,” which, however, they
also understood. “The people of King’s
County [Brooklyn],” he says, “are almost
entirely Dutch. In Queen’s County, four
fifths of the people are so likewise, but the other
fifth, and all Suffolk County, are English as they
call themselves, being from English ancestors, and
using no other language.” Major Baurmeister,
one of the officers of the Hessian division which
participated in the battle of Long Island, leaves us
something more than statistics in the case. He
appears to have noted every thing with lively appreciation.
To a friend in Germany, for instance, we find him
writing as follows: “The happiness of the
inhabitants, whose ancestors were all Dutch, must
have been great; genuine kindness and real abundance
is everywhere; any thing worthless or going to ruin
is nowhere to be perceived. The inhabited regions
resemble the Westphalian peasant districts; upon separate
farms the finest houses are built, which are planned
and completed in the most elegant fashion. The
furniture in them is in the best taste, nothing like
which is to be seen with us, and besides so clean and
neat, that altogether it surpasses every description.
The female sex is universally beautiful and delicately
reared, and is finely dressed in the latest European
fashion, particularly in India laces, white cotton
and silk gauzes; not one of these women but would consider
driving a double team the easiest of work. They
drive and ride out alone, having only a negro riding
behind to accompany them. Near every dwelling-house
negroes (their slaves) are settled, who cultivate the
most fertile land, pasture the cattle, and do all the
menial work." That the English element, however,
had crept in to a considerable extent around Brooklyn
at this time, is a matter of record.
The topography of this section of
Long Island was peculiar, presenting strong contrasts
of high and low land. Originally, and indeed within
the memory of citizens still living, that part of Brooklyn
lying south and west of the line of Nevins Street
was practically a peninsula, with the Wallabout Bay
or present Navy Yard on one side of the neck, and
on the other, a mile across, the extensive Gowanus
creek and marsh, over which now run Second, Third,
and Fourth Avenues. The creek set in from the
bay where the Gowanus Canal is retained, and rendered
the marsh impassable at high-water as far as the line
of Baltic Street. Blocks of buildings now stand
on the site of mills that were once worked by the
ebb and flow of the tides. The lower part of
what is known as South Brooklyn was largely swamp land
in 1776. Here the peninsula terminated in a nearly
isolated triangular piece of ground jutting out into
the harbor, called Red Hook, which figured prominently
in the military operations. From this projection
to the furthest point on the Wallabout was a distance
of three miles, and the scenery along the bank presented
a varied and attractive appearance to the resident
of New York. The “heights” rose conspicuously
in all the beauty of their natural outline; lower
down the shore might be seen a quaint Dutch mill or
two; on the bluffs opposite the Battery, the mansions
of Philip and Robert Livingston were prominent; and
not far from where the archway crosses Montague Street
stood the Remsen and, nearer the ferry, the Colden
and Middagh residences. From every point of view
the perspective was rural and inviting.
Vastly changed to-day is all this
region, which was now to be disturbed by the din and
havoc of war. Its picturesqueness long since
disappeared. Upon Manhattan Island, the city’s
push “uptown"-ward has been like the cut of
a drawing knife, a remorseless process of levelling
and “filling-in.” Forty times in population
and twenty in area has it expanded beyond the growth
of 1776. Brooklyn is a new creation. Would
its phlegmatic denizen of colonial times recognize
the site of his farms or his mills? Even the
good Whig ferryman, Waldron, might be at a loss to
make out his bearings, for the green banks of the
East River have vanished, and its points become confused.
The extent of its contraction he could learn from
the builders of the bridge, who have set the New York
pier eight hundred feet out from the high-water mark
of 1776, and the Brooklyn pier two hundred or more,
narrowing the stream at that point to a strait of but
sixteen hundred feet in width.
The first active steps looking to
the occupation of New York were taken by the Americans
early in January of this year. Reports had reached
Washington’s headquarters that the British were
fitting out an expedition by sea, whose destination
was kept a profound secret. In Boston, rumors
were afloat that it was bound for Halifax or Rhode
Island. In reality it was the expedition with
which Sir Henry Clinton was to sail to North Carolina,
and there meet Cornwallis, from England, to carry
out the southern diversion. Ignorant of the British
plans, and suspecting that Clinton might suddenly appear
at New York, Washington on the 4th of January called
the attention of Congress to the movement, and suggested
that it would be “consistent with prudence”
to have some New Jersey troops thrown into the city
to prevent the “almost irremediable” evil
which would follow its occupation by the enemy.
Two days later, General Charles Lee, holding rank
in the American army next to Washington, pressed a
plan of his own, to the effect that he be sent himself
by the commander-in-chief to secure New York, and
that the troops for the purpose (there being none
to spare from the force around Boston) be hastily raised
in Connecticut. This was approved at headquarters,
and on the 8th inst. Lee received instructions
as follows:
“Having undoubted intelligence
of the fitting out of a fleet at Boston, and
of the embarkation of troops from thence, which,
from the season of the year and other circumstances,
must be destined for a southern expedition; and
having such information as I can rely on, that
the inhabitants, or a great part of them, on
Long Island in the colony of New York, are not
only inimical to the rights and liberties of America,
but by their conduct and public professions have discovered
a disposition to aid and assist in the reduction of
that colony to ministerial tyranny; and as it is a
matter of the utmost importance to prevent the
enemy from taking possession of the City of New
York and the North River, as they will thereby
command the country, and the communication with
Canada it is of too much consequence to
hazard such a post at so alarming a crisis....
“You will therefore, with such
volunteers as are willing to join you, and can
be expeditiously raised, repair to the City of
New York, and calling upon the commanding officer of
the forces of New Jersey for such assistance as
he can afford, and you shall require, you are
to put that city into the best posture of defence
which the season and circumstances will admit,
disarming all such persons upon Long Island and
elsewhere (and if necessary otherwise securing
them), whose conduct and declarations have rendered
them justly suspected of designs unfriendly to
the views of Congress.... I am persuaded
I need not recommend dispatch in the prosecution
of this business. The importance of it alone
is a sufficient incitement."
Washington wrote at the same time
to Governor Trumbull, of Connecticut, Colonel Lord
Stirling, of New Jersey, and the New York Committee
of Safety, urging them to give Gen. Lee all the assistance
in their power.
Lee, who had been an officer in the
British army, serving at one time under Burgoyne in
Portugal, had already established a reputation for
himself in Washington’s camp as a military authority,
and enjoyed the full confidence of the commander-in-chief,
despite certain eccentricities of manner and an over-confidence
in his own judgment and experience. The defects
and weaknesses of his character, which eventually
brought him into disgrace as a soldier, were not as
yet displayed or understood. At the present time
he was eager to be of essential service to the colonies,
and he entered into the New York project with spirit.
In Connecticut the governor promptly seconded his
efforts, by calling out two regiments of volunteers
to serve for six weeks under the general, and appointed
Colonels David Waterbury, of Stamford, and Andrew
Ward, of Guilford, to their command. By the 20th,
Lee found himself ready to proceed; but while on his
way, near Stamford, he received a communication from
the Committee of Safety at New York, representing
that the rumors of his coming had created great alarm
in the city, and earnestly requesting him to halt his
troops on the Connecticut border, until his object
were better known to the committee. Here was
something of a dilemma, and it may be asked how it
should have arisen. Why, indeed, was it necessary
to organize a force outside of New York to secure
it? Was not this the time for the city to prepare
for her defence, and welcome assistance from whatever
quarter offered? The answer is to be found in
the exceptional political temperament of New York
at this time. Her population contained a large
and powerful loyalist element, which hoped, with the
assistance of the three or four British men-of-war
then in the harbor, to be able to give the place,
at the proper moment, into the hands of the king’s
troops. Only a short time before, Governor Tryon
had informed Howe that it only needed the presence
of a small force to secure it, and develop a strong
loyal support among the inhabitants of both the city
and colony. The patriotic party had abated none
of its zeal, but it recognized the danger of precipitating
matters, and accordingly pursued what appeared to
colonists elsewhere to be a temporizing and timid
policy, but which proved the wisest course in the
end. The city was at the mercy of the men-of-war.
Any attempt to seize it could be answered with a bombardment.
The situation required prudent management; above all,
it required delay on the part of the Americans until
they were ready for a decisive step. That the
Committee of Safety was thoroughly true to the country,
no one can doubt a moment after reading their daily
proceedings. In their letter to Lee they say:
“This committee and the Congress whose place
we fill in their recess, are, we flatter ourselves,
as unanimously zealous in the cause of America as
any representative body on the continent: so
truly zealous, that both the one and the other will
cheerfully devote this city to sacrifice for advancing
that great and important cause.” But knowing
the state of affairs in their midst better than others,
they urged caution instead of haste in bringing the
war to New York. In this case, they informed
Lee that no works had been erected in the city, that
they had but little powder, that they were sending
out ships for more without molestation from the men-of-war,
their object being kept secret, and that a general
alarm then in the dead of winter, driving women and
children into the country, would work great distress.
“For these reasons,” continue the committee,
“we conceive that a just regard to the public
cause, and our duty to take a prudent care of this
city, dictate the impropriety of provoking hostilities
at present, and the necessity of saving appearances
with the ships of war till at least the month of March.
Though we have been unfortunate in our disappointments
with respect to some of our adventures, yet be assured,
sir, we have not been idle. Our intrenching tools
are almost completed to a sufficient number; we are
forming a magazine of provisions for five thousand
men for a month in a place of safety, and at a convenient
distance from this city; we have provided ourselves
with six good brass field-pieces; have directed carriages
to be made for our other artillery, and are raising
a company of artillery for the defence of the colony
on the Continental establishment. These things,
when accomplished, with other smaller matters, and
with the arrival of some gunpowder, the prospect of
which is not unpromising, will enable us to face our
enemies with some countenance.” Lee, with
due consideration, replied to the committee that he
should comply with their request about the troops,
and do nothing that could endanger the city.
It was not until the 4th of February
that the general entered New York. On the same
day Clinton arrived in the harbor from Boston, with
his southern expedition, but only to make a brief stay.
The coming of these officers threw the city into great
excitement. Many of the inhabitants expected
an immediate collision, and began to leave the place.
One Garish Harsin, writing from New York to William
Radclift at Rhyn Beck, sums up in a single sentence
the effect of the harbor news: “It is impossible
to describe the confusion the place was in on account
of the regulars being come.” And when rumors
magnified Clinton’s two or three transports
into a British fleet of nineteen sail, Harsin informs
his friend that the people were taking themselves
out of town “as if it were the Last Day.”
Pastor Shewkirk, of the Moravian Church, in his interesting
diary of passing events, tells us that “the
inhabitants began now to move away in a surprising
manner,” and that “the whole aspect of
things grew frightful, and increased so from day to
day.” To add to the discomfort and suffering
of the people, the weather was very cold, and the rivers
full of ice.
The Committee of Safety, in their
anxiety as to the effect of Lee’s occupation
of the city, had already written to the Continental
Congress on the subject, and that body at once sent
up a committee, consisting of Messrs. Harrison, Lynch,
and Allen, to advise with Lee and the New York Committee.
The latter accepted the situation, consented to the
entry of the troops into town, and at a conference
with Lee and the Congress Committee on the 6th, agreed
to the immediate prosecution of defensive measures.
Upon his arrival, the general sent
his engineer, Captain William Smith, “an excellent,
intelligent, active officer,” to survey and
report upon the salient points of the position, especially
around Hell Gate and on Long Island. Lee and
Stirling also went over the ground several times.
As a result of these inspections, the general became
convinced that to attempt a complete defence of the
city would be impracticable, because the ample sea-room
afforded by the harbor and rivers gave the enemy every
advantage, enabling them, with their powerful fleet,
to threaten an attack in front and flank. Lee
saw this at once, and reported his views to Washington,
February 19th. “What to do with the city,”
he wrote, “I own, puzzles me. It is so encircled
with deep navigable waters, that whoever commands the
sea must command the town;” and to the New York
Committee he said that it would be impossible to make
the place absolutely secure. In view of this,
he proposed to construct a system of defences that
should have an alternative object, namely, that in
case they should prove inadequate for the city’s
protection, they should at least be sufficient to
prevent the enemy from securing a permanent foothold
in it.
Under this plan, the line of the East
River required the principal attention, as here it
seemed possible to offer the best resistance to British
attempts upon the city. First, to cut off the
enemy’s communication between the Sound and
the river, it was proposed to blockade the passage
at Hell Gate by a fort on Horn’s Hook, at the
foot of East Eighty-eighth Street, as well as by works
opposite, on the present Hallet’s Point.
A further object of these forts was to secure safe
transit between Long Island and New York. In the
next place, batteries were planned for both sides
of the river at its entrance into the harbor, where
the city was chiefly exposed. On the New York
side, a battery was located at the foot of Catherine
Street at the intersection of Cherry, and where the
river was narrowest. This was called Waterbury’s
Battery. To cover its fire a stronger work was
ordered to be built on Rutgers’ “first
hill,” just above, which was named Badlam’s
Redoubt, after Captain Badlam, then acting as Lee’s
chief artillery officer. Lower down a battery
was sunk in a cellar on Ten Eyck’s wharf, Coenties
Slip, a short distance below Wall Street, and called
Coenties Battery. These three, with part of the
Grand Battery and Fort George, included all the works
planned by Lee to guard the East River from the New
York side.
In connection with these, works were
laid out on the bank opposite on Long Island, the
importance of which was apparent. Not only was
the site well adapted for guns to sweep the channel
and prevent the enemy’s ships from remaining
in the river long enough to do the city serious damage,
but it also commanded the city, so as to make it untenable
by the British should they succeed in occupying it.
This bluff, “Columbia Heights,” was in
fact the key to the entire situation. Lee considered
its possession and security of “greater importance”
than New York; and to hold it he proposed establishing
there an intrenched camp for three or four thousand
men, fortified by “a chain of redoubts mutually
supporting each other.” Of these redoubts,
one was located on the edge of the bluff opposite the
Coenties Battery, and stood on the line of Columbia
Street, at about the foot of the present Clark Street.
This came to be known as Fort Stirling. In its
rear, near the corner of Henry and Pierrepont streets,
it was proposed to erect a large citadel; but this,
although begun, was never completed. Lee’s
scheme of defence did not include the fortifying of
either Red Hook or Governor’s Island.
The East River thus provided for,
attention was paid to the city and the North River
side. Lee examined Fort George and the Grand Battery,
but gave it as his opinion that neither of them could
be held under the concentrated fire of large ships.
He advised, accordingly, that the northern face of
the fort be torn down, and a traverse built across
Broadway above it at the Bowling Green, from which
the interior of the work could be raked, should the
enemy attempt to land and hold it. As the North
River was “so extremely wide and deep,”
the general regarded the obstruction of its passage
to the ships as out of the question. Batteries,
however, could be erected at various points along
the west side where it rose to a ridge, and the power
of the ships to injure the town very considerably
diminished. All the streets leading up from the
water were ordered to be barricaded to prevent the
enemy from coming up on the flanks; forts were to
be erected on Jones’, Bayard’s, and Lispenard’s
hills, north of the town, covering the approach by
land from that direction; the roads obstructed to
artillery; and redoubts, redans, and flèches
thrown up at defensible points throughout the entire
island, as far as King’s Bridge. “I
must observe,” said Lee to the Committee of Safety,
“that New York, from its circumstances, can
with difficulty be made a regular tenable fortification;
but it may be made a most advantageous field of battle so
advantageous, indeed, that, if our people behave with
common spirit, and the commanders are men of discretion,
it must cost the enemy many thousands of men to get
possession of it.”
To construct these extensive works
Lee could muster, two weeks after his arrival, but
seventeen hundred men. Waterbury’s Connecticut
regiment was first on the ground; the First New Jersey
Continentals, as yet incomplete, under Colonel
the Earl of Stirling, soon followed; and from Westchester
County, New York, came two hundred minute-men under
Colonel Samuel Drake. Dutchess County sent down
Colonels Swartwout and Van Ness with about three hundred
more; and on the 24th Colonel Ward arrived with his
Connecticut regiment, six hundred strong, which had
rendezvoused at Fairfield. Stirling’s regiment
was quartered principally in the lower barracks at
the Battery; Waterbury’s at the upper, on the
site of the new Court House; Ward’s was sent
to Long Island; and Drake’s minute-men were posted
at Horn’s Hook, opposite Hell Gate, where they
began work on the first battery marked out for the
defence of New York City during the Revolution.
But Lee’s stay at this point
was to be brief. The Continental Congress appointed
him to the command of the newly created Department
of the South, and on the 7th of March he left New
York in charge of Lord Stirling, who, a month before,
had been promoted by Congress to the rank of brigadier-general.
This officer’s energy was conspicuous. His
predecessor had already found him “a great acquisition,”
and he pushed on the defences of the city as rapidly
as his resources would permit. The force under
his immediate command, according to the returns of
the 13th, amounted to a total of two thousand four
hundred and twenty-two officers and men, besides
the city independent companies under Colonels John
Lasher and William Heyer, and local militia, who
swelled the number to about four thousand. On
the 14th, Washington wrote to Stirling that the enemy
appeared to be on the point of evacuating Boston,
and that it was more than probable they would sail
southward. “I am of opinion,” he wrote,
“that New York is their place of destination.
It is an object worthy of their attention, and it is
the place that we must use every endeavor to keep from
them. For, should they get that town, and the
command of the North River, they can stop the intercourse
between the Northern and Southern colonies, upon which
depends the safety of America. My feelings upon
this subject are so strong, that I would not wish to
give the enemy a chance of succeeding at your place....
The plan of defence formed by General Lee is, from
what little I know of the place, a very judicious
one. I hope, nay, I dare say, it is carrying into
execution with spirit and industry. You may judge
of the enemy’s keeping so long possession of
the town of Boston against an army superior in numbers,
and animated with the noble spirit of liberty; I say,
you may judge by that how much easier it is to keep
an enemy from forming a lodgment in a place, than
it will be to dispossess them when they get themselves
fortified.” Stirling immediately sent urgent
appeals for troops in every direction. He ordered
over the Third New Jersey Continental Regiment under
Colonel Dayton, and wrote for three hundred picked
men from each of the six nearest counties of that
State. Ward’s and Waterbury’s regiments,
which were impatient to return home to attend to their
spring farming, were many of them induced to remain
two weeks beyond their term of enlistment until Governor
Trumbull could supply their places with troops under
Colonels Silliman and Talcott. Congress also
ordered forward five or six Pennsylvania regiments.
Meanwhile the New York Committee of Safety co-operated
zealously with the military authorities. At Stirling’s
request they voted to call out all the male inhabitants
of the city, black and white, capable of doing “fatigue
duty,” to work on the fortifications the
blacks to work every day, the whites every other day;
and the same orders were conveyed to the committee
of King’s County, where the inhabitants were
directed to report to Colonel Ward, with spades, hoes
and pickaxes. To troops needing quarters the
committee turned over the empty houses in the city,
or those that were “least liable to be injured;”
coarse sheets were ordered for the straw beds in the
barracks; the upper story of the “Bridewell”
was converted into a laboratory or armory for repairing
guns and making cartridges; and all necessary details
provided for as far as possible. In case of an
alarm, the troops were to parade immediately at the
Battery, in the Common, and in front of Trinity Church.
To annoy expected British men-of-war, the committee
despatched Major William Malcolm, of the Second city
battalion, to dismantle the Sandy Hook Light, which
the major effected in a thorough manner, breaking
what glasses he could not move, and carrying off the
oil. On Long Island, a guard of King’s County
troopers was posted at the Narrows, and another at
Rockaway, to report the approach of ships; and in
the city, cannon were mounted in the batteries as fast
as they were completed. On the 20th, Stirling
could report that everybody turned to “with
great spirit and industry,” and that the work
went on “amazingly well.”
On the same date Brigadier-General
Thompson, of Pennsylvania, reported at New York, and
held the command until the arrival, a few days later,
of Brigadier-General Heath, of Massachusetts, who in
turn was relieved, April 4th, by Major-General Putnam.
Affairs at Boston now reached a crisis.
The siege, which the provincial troops had so successfully
maintained for ten months, terminated to their own
unbounded credit and the secret mortification of the
enemy. On the 17th of March the city was evacuated
by the British, and immediately occupied by the Americans an
event that had been foreseen and provided for at a
council of war held on the 13th, at General Ward’s
headquarters in Roxbury. The commander-in-chief
there stated that every indication pointed to an early
departure of the enemy from Boston, with the probability
that they were destined for New York, and he questioned
whether it was not advisable to send a part of the
army to that point without delay. The council
coincided in this opinion, and on the following day
the rifle regiment under Lieutenant-Colonel Hand,
and the three companies of Virginia riflemen, under
Captain Stephenson, were put on the march southward.
These were followed on the 18th by five regiments
under Brigadier-General Heath, who had been ordered
to march by way of Providence, Norwich, New London,
and the Sound. As the enemy’s transports
lingered around Boston for several days, no more troops
were sent southward until the 29th, when six regiments
were ordered on, under Brigadier-General Sullivan.
On the same date Major-General Putnam received orders
to proceed to New York, assume command, and continue
the work of fortifying the city upon the plan adopted
by General Lee. On the 1st of April, Brigadier-General
Greene’s brigade moved in the same direction,
and was followed in a day or two by General Spencer’s.
Five regiments remained at Boston, under Major-General
Ward.
Waiting until all the troops were
on the march, Washington, on April 4th, himself set
out from Cambridge for New York. Crowned with
his first honors as the deliverer of Boston, he was
greeted on his route with respectful admiration and
enthusiasm. He had come to New England comparatively
unknown “a Mr. Washington, of Virginia;”
he left it secure in the affections and pride of its
people. Expecting him at Providence the next
day, the 5th, General Greene, who had been delayed
at that place, ordered two regiments of his brigade Hitchcock’s
Rhode Island and Little’s Massachusetts to
appear in their best form and escort the general into
the city. The minuteness of Greene’s directions
on the occasion furnishes us with the material for
a picture of the personal appearance of the early
Continental soldier when on parade. As preserved
among the papers of the Massachusetts colonel, the
order runs as follows:
“Providence April 4, 1776. Colo.
Hitchcock’s and Colo. Little’s
regiments are to turn out to-morrow morning to
escort his Excellency into town, to parade at 8 o’clock,
both officers & men dressed in uniform, & none to
turn out except those dressed in uniform, & those
of the non-commissioned officers & soldiers that
turn out to be washed, both face & hands, clean,
their beards shaved, their hair combed & powdered,
& their arms cleaned. The General hopes
that both officers & soldiers will exert themselves
for the honour of the regiment & brigade to which
they belong. He wishes to pay the honours
to the Commander in Chief in as decent & respectable
a manner as possible."
Governor Cooke, of Rhode Island, was
not less attentive, and in addition to calling out
“the several companies of cadets, of grenadiers,
and light infantry” in Providence to meet the
commander-in-chief, he had a house prepared for his
reception and the accommodation of his suite, which,
besides his officers, included Lady Washington and
Mr. and Mrs. Custis. Passing on to New London,
where he hurried the embarkation of the troops, Washington
kept on along the shore road, reached New Haven on
the 11th, and on the 13th arrived at the city of New
York. Putnam had come ten days earlier.
Owing to insufficient transportation and slow sailing
on the Sound, it was April 24th before the last of
the soldiers reported on the ground.
The new military base in this vicinity
was thus fairly established, and the commander-in-chief,
after personally inspecting the position, urged on
the work of defence. As the regiments on their
arrival had been quartered at haphazard in the city,
he first arranged the army into five brigades, with
the view of putting them into suitable and permanent
camps. To the command of these he assigned Heath,
Spencer, Sullivan, Greene, and Stirling, in the order
of their rank. The twenty-five battalions which
made up the force at this date numbered together not
quite ten thousand men.
But hardly were the orders for this
new arrangement issued before events required its
modification. Our affairs proving to be in a bad
way in the direction of Canada, it became necessary
to despatch General Sullivan with six regiments to
the northward, and on the 29th of April the troops
in New York were formed anew into four brigades, and
assigned to their respective camps. Heath’s
first brigade was posted on the Hudson, just without
the city above the Canal Street marsh and about Richmond
Hill; Spencer’s second, on the East River, around
the Rutgers’ farm and Jones’ Hill; and
Stirling’s fourth, in the centre, near Bayard’s
Hill and the Bowery Road; while Greene’s third
brigade was assigned to “the ground marked out
upon Long Island.” But one work now lay
before these soldiers, namely, to put New York and
its vicinity in a complete state of defence in the
shortest possible time. Howe and his Boston army,
it was now known, had gone to Halifax instead of sailing
for New York; but he could still reach, and, with
reinforcements from England, attack the city before
the Americans were ready to receive him. The situation,
accordingly, admitted of no delays, and digging was
made the order of the day. No one could have
anticipated, however, that preparations were to be
continued full four months longer before active campaigning
opened.
This interval of fortifying is not
without its interest; and we may cross, first, with
Greene to Long Island, to note what further was done
towards securing that “capital” point in
the general system of defence.
From the orders of April 24th and
25th it would appear that it was Washington’s
original intention to give the Brooklyn command, not
to Greene, but to Sullivan. The latter was assigned
to the Third Brigade before going to Canada, and on
the 25th the encampment of this brigade was ordered
to be marked out “upon Long Island.”
The fact that Sullivan was senior to Greene in rank,
and was entitled, as between the two, to the honor
and responsibility of the separate command, was doubtless
the ground of his assignment in this case. But
a greater responsibility was reserved for Sullivan
in Canada, and Greene was sent to Long Island.
Owing to bad weather, it was the 3d or 4th of May
before the latter crossed with troops. He took
with him his old brigade, consisting of Colonel Edward
Hand’s Pennsylvania Riflemen, his two favorite
Rhode Island regiments under Colonels James Mitchell
Varnum and Daniel Hitchcock, and Colonel Moses Little’s
regiment from Massachusetts. These ranked as
the First, Ninth, Eleventh, and Twelfth of the Continental
Establishment, and were as well armed and under as
good discipline as any troops in Washington’s
army. Hand’s regiment, numbering four hundred
and seventy officers and men, was already on Long
Island, having come from Boston in advance of the brigades,
and was engaged in scouting and patrol duty at the
Narrows and along the coast. Varnum’s,
Hitchcock’s, and Little’s, having an average
strength of three hundred and eighty each, were the
only troops around Brooklyn. The Long Island militia
were not as yet in the field, and the small company
of Brooklyn troopers under Captain Waldron and Lieutenant
Boerum, which had patrolled the coast during the early
spring, do not appear on duty again until late in the
season.
It now remained for these regiments
to go on fortifying the water-front of this site to
keep the ships out of the river, and, in addition,
to secure themselves against an attack by land.
What Lee’s plan was in reference to Columbia
Heights has already been seen. Here he proposed
to establish a camp with Fort Stirling and the Citadel
among its defences, the former of which had been nearly
completed and the latter begun by Ward’s regiment
and the inhabitants. In consequence, however,
of a move made by General Putnam soon after his arrival,
it had evidently become necessary to enlarge this plan.
Governor’s Island, just off the edge of which
were moored the British men-of-war, had not been occupied
by either Lee or Stirling; but it lay within cannon-shot
of the Battery and Columbia Heights, and an enemy
once lodged there could work us mischief. General
Putnam noticed its position, and he had not been here
three days before he wrote, April 7th, to the President
of Congress: “After getting the works [in
New York] in such forwardness as will be prudent to
leave, I propose immediately to take possession of
Governor’s Island, which I think a very important
post. Should the enemy arrive here, and get post
there, it will not be possible to save the city, nor
could we dislodge them without great loss." On
the very next night he carried out his proposal, as
appears from the following account of the manoeuvre
preserved among the papers of Colonel G. Selleck Silliman,
of Fairfield, Connecticut, who had recently come down
to relieve the troops under Ward and Waterbury:
“Tuesday Morning, 9th April. Last
Evening Draughts were made from a Number of Regiments
here, mine among the Rest, to the Amount of 1,000
Men. With these and a proper Number of Officers
Genl Putnam at Candle lighting embarked on Board of
a Number of Vessels with a large Number of intrenching
Tools and went directly on the Island a little below
the City called Nutten [Governor’s] Island where
they have been intrenching all Night and are now at
work, and have got a good Breast Work there raised
which will cover them from the fire of the Ships;
and it is directly in the Way of the Ship coming up
to the Town. The Asia has fallen down out of
Gun Shot from this Place and it deprives the Ships
of the only Watering Place they have here without going
down toward the Hook." There was something of
the Bunker Hill flavor about this move, and it was
Prescott’s Bunker Hill regiment that was first
stationed on the Island, which subsequently became
one of the strongest posts of the position. At
the same time another party occupied Red Hook,
on Long Island, which commanded the channel between
the Hook and Governor’s Island.
The occupation by Putnam of these
two points, which was clearly necessary for a more
effective defence of the East River, required, or
at least resulted in, the modification of Lee’s
plan, and the adoption of a new line on Long Island.
It was now decided to hold the Brooklyn peninsula
with a chain of works thrown up across the neck from
Wallabout Bay to the Gowanus Marsh; and it was in this
vicinity that the encampment for Greene’s brigade
was marked out by Mifflin, the quartermaster-general,
and afterwards approved by Washington. By the
fortunate recovery of the daily orders issued by General
Greene on Long Island, and also of original sketches
of the site, it has become possible to fix the location
of this line and the names of the works with almost
entire accuracy.
To defend the approach between the
bay and marsh, the engineers laid out three principal
forts and two redoubts, with breastworks connecting
them. The site occupied was a favorable one.
On the left rose the high ground, now known as Fort
Greene Place or Washington Park, one hundred feet
above the sea-level; and on the right, between the
main road and the marsh, were lower elevations on lands
then owned by Rutgert Van Brunt and Johannes Debevoise.
The flanks were thus well adapted for defence, and
they were near enough each other to command the ground
between them. Two of the works were erected on
the right of the road, and received the names of Fort
Greene and Fort Box; three were on the left, and were
known as the Oblong Redoubt, Fort Putnam, and the
redoubt “on its left.” In view of
the fact that local historians heretofore have put
but three fortifications on this line, where, it is
now well established, there were five, a more particular
description of them becomes necessary. Extending
from right to left, they were laid out as follows:
FORT BOX. It has been supposed
that the fort by this name occupied an independent
site south-west of the main line, with the object of
defending Gowanus Creek where it was crossed by a mill-dam.
That it stood, however, on the right of the line is
beyond question. Thus the letter of a spectator
of the battle says: “Our lines fronted
the east. On the left, near the lowest part of
the above-described bay [Wallabout], was Fort Putnam,
near the middle Fort Greene, and towards the creek
Fort Box.” In his order of June 1st, General
Greene directs five companies to take post “upon
the right in Fort Box;” and on August 16th a
fatigue party is detailed “to form the necessary
lines from Fort Box to Fort Putnam,” clearly
indicating that the two were on the same continuous
line. To confirm the correctness of this locality,
we have the fort and its name distinctly indicated
on the outline map sketched by President Stiles, of
Yale College, in his Diary of Revolutionary Events.
By reference to the fac-simile of the sketch here
presented, it will be seen that although there are
errors in the drawing, the relative position of the
principal works is preserved, and the site of Fort
Box finally determined. It stands nearest Gowanus
Creek, and on the right of the other forts. The
work appears to have been of a diamond shape, and
was situated on or near the line of Pacific Street,
a short distance above Bond.
As to its name, we must assume that
it was called Fort Box in honor of Major Daniel Box,
Greene’s brigade-major (an office corresponding
to the present assistant adjutant-general), whose
services were then highly appreciated. Box first
appears as an old British soldier, who had been wounded
in the French war, and afterwards as an organizer and
drill-master of Independent companies in Rhode Island,
which subsequently furnished many fine officers to
the Continental army. In a letter to Colonel Pickering
in 1779, Greene speaks of him in flattering terms,
as having been invaluable in the earlier years of
the war. That he was something of an engineer,
as well as an excellent brigade-major, is evident
from the fact that he assisted in marking out the
lines around Boston in 1775, and later superintended
the construction of Fort Lee, on the Jersey side.
No doubt he had much to say about the building of
the Brooklyn lines, and of the work in particular
which bore his name.
FORT GREENE. About three
hundred yards to the left of Fort Box, a short distance
above Bond Street, between State and Schermerhorn,
stood Fort Greene, star-shaped, mounting six guns,
and provided with a well and magazines. Colonel
Little, its commander, describes it as the largest
of the works on Long Island; and this statement is
corroborated by the fact that its garrison consisted
of an entire regiment, which was not the case with
the other forts, and that it was provided with nearly
double the number of pikes. It occupied an important
position on one of the small hills near the centre
of that part of the line lying south-west of Washington
Park, and its guns commanded the approach by the Jamaica
highway. Being the principal work on the line,
the engineers, or possibly Little’s regiment,
named it after their brigade commander.
OBLONG REDOUBT. Still further
to the left, and on the other side of the road, a
small circular redoubt, called the “Oblong Redoubt,”
was thrown up on what was then a piece of rising ground
at the corner of De Kalb and Hudson avenues.
The reason of its name is not apparent. Greene’s
orders refer to it as the “Oblong Square”
and the “Oblong Redoubt.” Major Richard
Thorne, of Colonel Remsen’s Long Island militia,
speaks of being on guard at “Fort Oblong”
all night a short time before the battle. This
redoubt had very nearly direct command of the road,
and in connection with Fort Greene was depended upon
to defend the centre of the line.
FORT PUTNAM. From the Oblong
Redoubt, the line ascended north-easterly to the top
of the hill included in Washington Park, where the
fourth in the chain of works was erected. This
was Fort Putnam. Star-shaped like Fort Greene,
it was somewhat smaller than the latter, and mounted
four or five garrison guns. Its strong natural
position, however, made it the salient point of the
line, and it became, as will be seen, the main object
of attack by the British during and after the battle.
The fort may have taken its name, as usually supposed,
from Major-General Israel Putnam; but it is altogether
more probable that it was named after Colonel Rufus
Putnam, the chief engineer, who marked out many of
the works on Long Island as well as in New York, and
who must have frequently crossed to give directions
in their construction.
REDOUBT ON THE LEFT. At
the eastern termination of the hill, a short distance
from Fort Putnam, and on a lower grade, stood the last
of the works, which is identified in the orders and
letters of the day as the “redoubt on the left.”
It was a small affair, and occupied a point at about
the middle of the present Cumberland Street, nearly
midway between Willoughby and Myrtle avenues; but
in 1776 the site was twenty feet higher, and appeared
as a well-defined spur extending out from Fort Putnam.
As it was commanded by the latter, its capture by the
enemy would bring them no advantage, while as an American
defence it could materially assist in protecting the
left.
Between these five works a line of
connecting intrenchments was laid out, while on the
right it was to be continued from Fort Box to the
marsh, and on the left from the Fort Putnam Hill, “in
a straight line,” to the swamp at the edge of
Wallabout Bay. Anticipating their construction,
we may say that each work became a complete fortification
in itself, being surrounded with a wide ditch, provided
with a sally-port, its sides lined with sharpened stakes,
the garrison armed with spears to repel storming parties,
and the work supplied with water and provisions to
withstand a siege if necessary. The greater part
of the line was picketed with abattis, and the
woods cut down to give full sweep to the fire of the
guns. As every thing depended upon holding this
front, the necessity of making it as strong as possible
was fully realized, and at the time of the engagement
in August it was considered a sufficient barrier to
the enemy’s advance.
FORT COBBLE HILL. Passing
to the remaining works on Long Island, we find a redoubt
on the crest of a cone-shaped hill, which stood alone
near the intersection of the present Court and Atlantic
streets, and which was known by the Dutch inhabitants
as Punkiesberg. As it does not appear
to have been called Cobble Hill before this date, the
reasonable inference may be drawn that it was so named
by Greene’s troops because of its close resemblance
to the Cobble Hill which formed one of the fortified
points in the siege of Boston, but a short distance
from Winter Hill, where Greene’s brigade was
posted. In the orders of the day, the redoubt
is known as “Smith’s barbette,”
Captain William Smith, the engineer whom Lee brought
with him, having it in charge. The work mounted
four guns, and, from its central interior position,
could have prevented the enemy from securing a foothold
on the peninsula in the rear or flank of the main line
in case they effected a landing back of Red Hook or
crossed Gowanus Creek above. This hill was long
since cut away.
REDOUBT AT THE MILL. Near
the corner of the present Degraw and Bond streets,
a small battery or breastwork, in the form of a right
angle, mounting one gun, was thrown up to cover the
narrow passage over a mill-dam which here crossed
Gowanus Creek. It stood at the extremity of a
long low sand-hill, and the dam connected this point
with a tongue of land on the opposite side, on which
two mills were built, known as the upper or yellow,
and lower mills. The upper mill was immediately
opposite the redoubt, and it was here that the Port
Road came down to the edge of the creek.
RED HOOK FORT DEFIANCE. This
work, already referred to, was originally a single
water battery, mounting four eighteen-pounders, en
barbette, to prevent the passage of ships east
of Governor’s Island, as well as to keep the
enemy from landing at the southern extremity of the
peninsula. Washington speaks of it in May as being
“a small, but exceedingly strong” fort.
Lieutenant Samuel Shaw, of Knox’s artillery,
who was stationed there most of the summer, states
that it was named “Fort Defiance,” and
subsequently strengthened by additional works, which,
from the Hessian map and the Stiles draft, appear to
have consisted of a second and larger redoubt connected
with the first by an intrenchment or inclosed way.
On the 5th of July, Greene wrote to Washington that
he regarded Red Hook as “a post of vast importance,”
and proposed stationing a considerable force there
permanently, as in that case the commanding officer
would be “more industrious to have every thing
in readiness, and obstinate in defence” when
the attack came; and on the 8th we find the order for
“Col. Varnum’s regiment to remove
their encampment to Red Hook, and do the duty of that
post.”
FORT STIRLING. The first
work laid out on Long Island, as we have seen, was
Fort Stirling, which, in connection with batteries
on the New York side, was designed to command the
East River channel. Its exact site has been a
point of dispute. Several writers and old inhabitants
associate the name with the remains of a large fortification
which stood at the corner of Henry and Pierrepont
streets as late as 1836. It is clear, however,
that this was a work erected by the British during
the latter part of the Revolution. General Robertson,
acting as Governor of New York in 1780, wrote to Lord
Germaine, May 18th, that, among other works thrown
up to make New York more secure against an attack
by the Americans, “a large square fort is built
at Brooklyn Heights." The traveller Smyth, writing
in the same year, says, “The town [New York]
is entirely commanded by a considerable eminence in
Long Island, directly opposite to it, named Brookland
Heights, on which a strong regular fort with four bastions
has lately been erected by the British troops.”
This exactly describes the work in question. The
corner of Henry and Pierrepont streets, moreover,
being a thousand feet back from the river’s edge,
could not have been selected at that time as the site
for a strictly water battery intended for effective
resistance. The fort must be looked for nearer
the edge of the bluff, and there we find it. Both
the Stiles and the Hessian maps place it directly
on the bank of the river the latter, a
little north of what was then known as the Bamper House,
or at about the intersection of Clark and Columbia
streets.
The fort was a strong inclosed work,
mounting eight guns. Ward’s men broke ground
for it about the 1st of March, and continued digging,
as their major, Douglas, writes, through “cold,
tedious weather,” until other troops took their
place.
Greene’s soldiers, whose experience
around Boston had made them veterans, at least in
the use of the spade, now went to work to throw up
these lines. He reminded them early of the importance
of the post, and the necessity of preparation and
vigilance. “As the security of New York
greatly dependeth on this pass,” runs
his order of May 5th, “while these works are
constructing, the general hopes the troops will carefully
forward the same as fast as possible;” and this
he followed up with the caution that if any soldier
left his work without liberty, he should do fatigue
duty for a whole week. Orders from headquarters
in New York at the same time directed General Greene
to report “all extraordinaries” to the
commander-in-chief; the officers at Red Hook and Governor’s
Island to do the same; and the officer commanding the
riflemen on Long Island to “constantly report
all extraordinaries to General Greene.”
Although no enemy had yet appeared, every regiment
in the army was ordered to mount a picket every evening,
to lie on their arms, and be ready to turn out at
a moment’s notice.
It is possible to follow the troops
on Long Island in their routine of camp life all through
the tedious summer they were to spend on this ground.
Digging was the main thing at first, and they had so
much of this that the officers complained of their
inability to keep the men in clothes, they wore them
out so fast, and they made themselves so begrimed
with dirt at the trenches, that the allowance of soap
would not clean them; all which moved Greene to write
to Washington that it would be no more than “a
piece of justice to the troops” to allow them
a double quantity of soap. Their encampment, in
the rear of the lines, appears to have been a pleasant
one. The soldiers lived in bell-shaped tents
with board floors, and varied their regulation fare
with the produce of the Dutch farms; with the permission
of their field-officers they could occasionally cross
on a visit to the city. Their general, however,
held them closely to duty, and we find in these early
orders the beginnings of that strictness which subsequently
made him known, with his other soldierly qualities,
as a thorough disciplinarian. No enemy being
near them, the men, when put on guard, perhaps relaxed
even ordinary vigilance; but they were soon brought
up sharply by the general, with the direction that
every part of camp duty must be done with as much
exactness as if the British were in their front, for
bad habits once contracted, they are told, “are
difficult to get over, and doing duty in a slovenly
manner is both disgraceful and dangerous to officers
and men.” They were sure of being watched,
too, by Lieutenant-Colonel Cornell, of Hitchcock’s
regiment, whose habit of reprimanding the men for every
neglect had won for him the title of “Old Snarl”
throughout the camp; but his subsequent promotion
to offices of responsibility showed that in other
quarters his particular qualities were appreciated.
As the warm season came on, Greene cautioned his soldiers
about their health. The “colormen”
were to keep the camps clean, and look after the hospitals.
Many soldiers being down with fever in July, the general
recommends “the strictest attention to the cookery,
and that broiling and frying meat, so destructive
to health, be prohibited;” going into the water
in the heat of the day is also forbidden. A neglect
of these matters at this critical season, Greene continues,
“may be attended with dreadful consequences.”
Occasionally it was found necessary
to give the soldiers a sharp reproof for insulting
the inhabitants or trespassing on their property.
When the complaint was brought to Greene that some
of his men had been stealing watermelons, he promptly
issued an order that such practices must be punished.
“A few unprincipled rascals,” he said,
“may ruin the reputation of a whole corps of
virtuous men;” and on another occasion he called
upon the soldiers to behave themselves “with
that decency and respect that became the character
of troops fighting for the preservation of the rights
and liberties of America.” Perhaps the
offenders found an excuse for their conduct in the
Tory character of the complainants; but Greene, though
no friend himself to such people, could never accept
this as a provocation to justify a breach of military
discipline.
The Tory element in the population
required other and sterner treatment. It had developed
to such an extent in Kings and Queens counties as
to require its suppression by the civil and military
power combined. The refusal of the majority of
the voters in Queens to send delegates to the New
York Provincial Convention in 1775 indicated not only
a confidence on their part that the Home Government
would succeed in crushing the rebellion, but a secret
intention as well to give the British troops upon
their arrival all the aid and comfort in their power.
As they provided themselves with arms and the British
fleet with provisions, the Continental Congress took
up the matter, ordered the arrest of the leaders,
and dispatched Colonel Heard, of New Jersey, with
a regiment of militia to execute the business.
Arrests were made, but the complete suppression of
the loyalists here was never effected.
While Lee was in command he saw no
solution of the problem other than to remove the entire
Tory population to some other quarter where they could
do less mischief in the event of active operations;
but Congress, to the regret of Washington, could not
sanction so radical a method. Greene did his
best to root out this element, but we may imagine
that it was uncongenial work, and that he took far
more interest in the progress of his redoubts than
in chasing suspected persons on the island.
By the 1st of June the works around
Brooklyn appear to have so far progressed as to admit
of the mounting of some of the cannon, and on the
evening of that date the troops were ordered to parade
with arms and man the lines. On the 17th the
general assigned them to permanent positions as follows:
“Colonel Varnum’s regiment
is to take Fort Box and the Oblong Redoubt for
their alarm-posts Fort Box, six companies;
Oblong Redoubt, two companies. Captain Wolverton’s
Independent Company to join those in the redoubt,
and to receive orders from Colonel Varnum.
Colonel Hitchcock’s
regiment to take Fort Putnam and the
fort or redoubt on the
left of it for their alarm-posts.
Colonel Little’s
regiment to take Fort Greene for their
alarm-posts.”
To impress his soldiers with his own
sense of the great importance of the Long Island front,
Greene added the determined words: “In case
of an attack, all these posts are to be defended
to the last extremity.” And Colonel
Little, who had proved his fitness to command the
post assigned him by his cool and soldierly conduct
at Bunker Hill, quietly resolved that if the enemy
assaulted Fort Greene it should never be surrendered
while he was alive.
Guards were now stationed at the forts
and greater vigilance enjoined about the camp.
Even as early as May 25th, when the works were still
far from complete, the orders were strict that none
but a general officer should be admitted to them without
special leave. The lines were to be manned every
morning “between day and sunrise,” and
the troops exercised at parapet firing. The orders
of July 1st directed the commanding officers of the
regiments “to make a line round each of the
forts and fortifications for the troops to begin a
fire on the enemy if they attempt to storm the works,
and the troops are to be told not to fire sooner than
the enemy’s arrival at these lines, unless commanded.
The line should be about eighty yards from the parapet.”
The officers of the guards were to be accountable for
every thing in the forts, but particularly for the
rum lodged there for the use of the men in time of
action. Provisions also were to be supplied to
each alarm-post “in case of siege,” and
the water-casks kept constantly full of fresh water.
To assure the effectiveness of the means of defence,
one hundred spears were to be placed in Fort Greene,
thirty in the works to the right, twenty in the Oblong
Redoubt, fifty in Fort Putnam, and twenty to the left
of it.
And so the work went on under Greene’s
eye, and by the middle of summer his troops had
inclosed themselves on the Brooklyn peninsula, with
lines which, though unfinished, were still of very
respectable strength.
Recrossing the river to New York,
we find the other brigades there at work as uninterruptedly
as Greene’s on Long Island. The many well-known
“general orders” issued by the commander-in-chief
during this season testify to the great amount of
fatigue duty performed by the troops. Washington
regretted that the necessity for it left so little
opportunity for drilling and he urged his officers
to make the most of what time they had for this purpose.
But his chief anxiety was to have the defences pushed
on, and by the middle of June the principal works
were completed or well under way. The location
and names of these are indicated in the orders and
maps of the day. Beginning on the North River
side and continuing around the city, they were as
follows:
GRENADIER BATTERY. This
was a “beautiful” circular battery, situated
on the bank of the North River where it ran out into
a well-defined bluff, at the corner of the present
Washington and Harrison streets. Captain Abraham
Van Dyck’s Grenadier Company of New York City
Independents built it while Lee and Stirling were in
command, and received the thanks of Washington in
general orders for the skilful manner in which they
had executed their work. The fort mounted two
twelve-pounders and two mortars. The grenadier
company was organized by Stirling a few years before,
when he lived in New York, and he watched the construction
of the battery with considerable pride. The Pennsylvania
Gazette of May 8th, 1776, contains a letter from
Captain Van Dyck to Stirling, informing him of the
completion of the work, and desiring “the approbation
of their former captain.” Stirling replied
that he had frequently admired the battery, and reflected
with “real satisfaction” on the hour when
he formed the company.
JERSEY BATTERY. A short
distance below, on the line of Reade Street, just
west of Greenwich, stood the Jersey Battery a
five-sided work, mounting two twelve and three thirty-two
pounders. A line of intrenchments connected these
two batteries, and, extending beyond on either side,
made the position a particularly strong one. Their
guns had the range of the bank up and down the river,
and could enfilade an enemy attempting to land in
that vicinity.
McDOUGALL’S AND THE OYSTER BATTERY. The
works next below on the Hudson consisted of two batteries
situated on the high ground in the rear and to the
south of Trinity Church. The one on the bluff
near the church, or on the line of the present Rector
Street, a little east of Greenwich, was known under
Stirling as McDougall’s Battery; but this name
does not appear in the return of June 10th, and in
its place in the order of the works we have the “Oyster”
Battery. It is possible that this was the work
a little south of McDougall’s, at the intersection
of the present Morris and Greenwich streets. Its
location is described by Putnam in May as “behind
General Washington’s head-quarters." It
mounted two thirty-two-pounders and three twelve-pounders.
In March, McDougall’s Battery was provided with
six guns.
FORT GEORGE AND THE GRAND BATTERY. These
works at the lower end of the city had been pronounced
almost useless by Lee, but as it was of course necessary
to include that point in the system of defence they
were repaired and greatly strengthened under Washington.
In Fort George were mounted two twelve-pounders and
four thirty-two-pounders. The walls of the Grand
Battery were banked up from within, and mounted thirteen
thirty-two-pounders, one twenty-four-pounder, three
eighteen-pounders, two twelve-pounders, one thirteen-inch
brass mortar, two eight-inch and one ten-inch iron
mortars.
WHITEHALL BATTERY. A small
work on the Whitehall dock on the East River, and
practically a continuation of the Grand Battery.
It carried two thirty-two-pounders.
WATERBURY’S BATTERY. On
the dock at the north-east angle of Catherine and
Cherry streets, mounting, in June, two twelve-pounders.
BADLAM’S REDOUBT. On
the hill above, south of Market and between Madison
and Monroe streets. It mounted seven guns in March,
but appears not to have been occupied later in the
season.
SPENCER’S REDOUBT. This
was either the horseshoe redoubt at the intersection
of Monroe and Rutgers streets, or the larger star redoubt
between Clinton and Montgomery, east of Henry Street.
It mounted two twelve-pounders and four field-pieces.
JONES’ HILL. From
Spencer’s Redoubt a line of intrenchments extended
around along the crest of the high land above Corlear’s
Hook to a circular battery on the northern slope of
Jones’ Hill, a little north of the intersection
of Broome and Pitt streets, and was pierced for eight
guns. During Stirling’s command it was proposed
to call this fortification “Washington,”
but it was known subsequently simply as Jones’
Hill. From this battery the works continued along
the line of Grand Street to the Bowery, and included
two more circular batteries one on Grand
at the corner of Norfolk Street, and the other near
the corner of Grand and Eldridge streets.
BAYARD’S HILL REDOUBT. Upon
this commanding site, west of the Bowery, where Grand
and Mulberry streets intersect, was erected a powerful
irregular heptagonal redoubt, mounting eight nine-pounders,
four three pounders, and six royal and cohorn mortars.
It had the range of the city on one side and the approach
by the Bowery on the other. Lasher’s New
York Independent companies first broke ground for it
about the 1st of March, and continued digging there
as well as on the redoubt around the hospital until
May 16th, when they were relieved, with Washington’s
“thanks for their masterly manner of executing
the work on Bayard’s Hill." In the March
return this battery is called the “Independent
Battery,” and it also received the name of “Bunker
Hill,” which was retained by the British during
their occupation; but its proper name as an American
fort was “Bayard’s Hill Redoubt,”
this having been given to it officially in general
orders; and it was so called in letters and orders
repeatedly through the summer.
THOMPSON’S BATTERY. This
was the name given to the work thrown up at Horn’s
Hook by Colonel Drake’s Westchester minute-men
soon after Lee’s arrival. It mounted eight
pieces.
GOVERNOR’S ISLAND. The
forts erected on this island were among the strongest
around New York. According to a letter from Colonel
Prescott of July 3d, they consisted of a citadel with
outworks, and were garrisoned during the latter part
of the summer by Prescott’s and Nixon’s
regiments. The works mounted in June four thirty-two
and four eighteen pounders.
PAULUS OR POWLE’S HOOK. The
point of land on the New Jersey side, opposite the
city, and which is now the site in part of Jersey City.
Works were commenced here about May 20th, and in June
they mounted three thirty-two-pounders, three twelve-pounders,
and two three-pounder field-pieces.
In addition to these, several other
redoubts were erected north of the town, in which
no cannon were mounted, and which had no names.
They were probably thrown up to be ready for occupation
in case the enemy succeeded in landing above the city.
There was a circular battery at the corner of Broome
and Forsyth streets; another in the middle of Broadway,
opposite White Street; another, of octagonal shape,
near the corner of Spring and Mercer streets; a half-moon
battery above this, between Prince and Spring, on
the line of Thompson Street; another on the northwesterly
continuation of Richmond Hill, at McDougall and Houston
streets; and still another on the river-bank, near
the junction of Christopher and Greenwich streets.
The hospital on Duane Street was strongly fortified,
and breastworks were thrown up at numerous points
between and around the forts. On June 10th the
entire number of guns fit for service in and around
New York was one hundred and twenty-one, thirty-three
of which were held as a reserve for field service,
“to be run where the enemy shall make their greatest
efforts.” The mortars were nineteen in number.
As for barricades, the city was full
of them. Some were built of mahogany logs taken
from West India cargoes. Not a street leading
to the water on either side that was not obstructed
in this manner; so that, had the enemy been able to
gain a footing in the city under the fire of their
ships, they would still have found it, to use Lee’s
expression, “a disputable field of battle.”
The City Hall Park was almost entirely inclosed.
There was a barrier across Broadway in front of St.
Paul’s Church, another at the head of Vesey Street,
and others at the head of Barclay, Murray, and Warren.
On the Park Row or Chatham Street side a barricade
stretched across Beekman Street; another, in the shape
of a right angle, stood in Printing House Square, one
face opposite Spruce Street, the other looking across
the Presbyterian churchyard and Nassau Street;
another ran across Frankfort Street; another at the
entrance of Centre Street; and still another near
it, facing Chatham Street.
Another element in the defence was
a motley little fleet, made up of schooners,
sloops, row-galleys, and whale-boats, and placed
under the command of Lieutenant-Colonel Benjamin Tupper,
who had distinguished himself by a naval exploit or
two in Boston Harbor during the siege. Crews
were drafted from the regiments and assigned to the
various craft, whose particular mission was to scour
the waters along the New Jersey and Long Island coast,
to watch for the British fleets, and prevent communication
between the Tories and the enemy’s ships already
lying in the harbor. Tupper, as commodore, appears
first in the sloop Hester as his flag-ship, and later
in the season in the Lady Washington, while among
his fleet were to be found the Spitfire, General Putnam,
Shark, and Whiting. The gallant commodore’s
earliest cruises were made within the Narrows, along
the Staten Island shore, and as far down as Sandy
Hook, where he attempted the feat of destroying the
light-house. But he found this structure, which
the enemy had occupied since Major Malcom dismantled
it in March, a hard piece of masonry to reduce.
He attacked it confidently, June 21st, after demanding
its surrender, but retired when he found that an hour’s
bombardment made no impression upon its walls.
He kept a good lookout along these waters, gathered
information from deserters, and when reporting on
one occasion that the enemy’s fleet were short
of provisions and the men reduced to half allowance,
he added, with unction, “May God increase their
wants!” A little later we meet again with the
adventuresome Tupper and his flotilla.
As the soldiers went on with their
exacting duties, the monotony of the routine was now
and then relieved by some diversion or excitement.
One day there is “Tory-riding" in the city,
in which citizens appear to have figured principally.
Then the whole camp is startled by the report that
a “most accursed scheme” had come to light,
just “on the verge of execution,” by which
Washington and all his generals were to have been
murdered, the magazines blown up, and the cannon spiked
by hired miscreants in the army at the moment the enemy
made their grand attack upon the city. Again,
on the 9th of July, the brigades are all drawn up
on their respective parade-grounds, listen to the
reading for the first time of the Declaration of Independence,
and receive it, as Heath tells us, “with loud
huzzas;” and, finally, to celebrate the event,
a crowd of citizens, “Liberty Boys,” and
soldiers collect that evening at Bowling Green and
pull down the gilded statue of King George, which
is then trundled to Oliver Wolcott’s residence
at Litchfield, Ct., for patriotic ladies to convert
into bullets for the American soldiers.
But now occurred a much more stirring
and important event to engage the attention of the
army, and this was the arrival of the enemy. It
was full time for them to make their appearance.
Nearly three months and a half had elapsed since the
evacuation of Boston; the spring and a whole month
of summer had gone; the best season for active movements
was passing rapidly; and unless the British began operations
soon, all hope of conquering America “in one
campaign” would have to be abandoned. Rumors
of their coming took definite shape in the last week
of June, when word reached camp that an American privateer
had captured a British transport with more than two
hundred Highlanders as prisoners. On the 25th
and 26th three or four large ships arrived off Sandy
Hook, one of which proved to be the Greyhound, with
Sir William Howe on board; on the 29th a fleet of
forty-five sail anchored off the same point, and four
days later the number had increased to one hundred
and thirty. This was the fleet from Halifax with
Howe’s Boston veterans. Preparations were
made to land them on the Long Island coast near the
Narrows; but on being informed that the Americans
were posted on a ridge of hills not far distant, Howe
disembarked his troops opposite on Staten Island,
and there went into camp to wait the arrival of the
reinforcements from England under Admiral Howe.
The middle of July saw these also encamped on the
island, with the fleet increased to nearly three hundred
transports and ships of war. On the 1st of August
there was an unexpected arrival in the shape of the
discomfited expedition under Generals Clinton and
Cornwallis, that was to gain a foothold in the South;
and last of all, on the 12th of August came the British
Guards and De Heister’s Hessians, after a tedious
voyage of thirteen weeks from Spithead, completing
Howe’s force, and swelling the fleet in the Narrows
to more than four hundred ships. England had
never before this sent from her shores a more powerful
military and naval armament upon foreign service.
The arrival of the enemy hastened
Washington’s preparations. The troops which
Congress had called out to reinforce his army were
coming in too slowly, and expresses were sent to governors,
assemblies, and committees of safety, announcing the
appearance of the enemy, and urging in the most pressing
terms the instant march of the reinforcements to New
York. To his soldiers with him the commander-in-chief
issued both warning and inspiring orders. On the
2d of July, a few days after Howe arrived, he reminded
them that the time was at hand which would probably
determine whether Americans were to be freemen or
slaves. “The fate of unborn millions,”
he said, “will now depend, under God, on the
courage and conduct of this army. Our cruel and
unrelenting enemy leaves us no choice but a brave resistance
or the most abject submission. This is all we
can expect. We have, therefore, to resolve to
conquer or die. Our country’s honor calls
upon us for a vigorous and manly exertion, and if we
now shamefully fail we shall become infamous to the
whole world. Let us, therefore, rely upon the
goodness of the cause and the aid of the Supreme Being,
in whose hands victory is, to animate and encourage
us to great and noble actions. The eyes of all
our countrymen are now upon us, and we shall have
their blessings and praises, if happily we are the
instruments of saving them from the tyranny meditated
against them.... Any officer or soldier, or any
particular corps, distinguishing themselves by any
acts of bravery and courage, will assuredly meet with
notice and rewards; and, on the other hand, those who
behave ill will as certainly be exposed and punished:
the general being resolved, as well for the honor
and safety of the country as of the army, to show
no favor to such as refuse or neglect their duty at
so important a crisis.”
The digging still went on; the troops
were ordered to keep their arms in condition for immediate
use; the officers cautioned to look after the health
of their men, as the season was excessively warm and
sickly; and every attention to necessary details enjoined.
In addition to their military and
naval commands, the two Howes were invested by their
government with extraordinary powers as civil commissioners.
They were authorized to issue pardons, and to open
up the question of reconciliation and a peaceable
settlement of the troubles; but their first advances
in a civil capacity completely failed, though not
without furnishing an entertaining episode. On
the 14th of July they dispatched an officer in a barge
with a communication for General Washington.
The barge was detained by one of Commodore Tupper’s
boats in the harbor until Washington’s pleasure
in regard to it could be known. Suspecting, by
previous experience at Boston, that Howe would not
recognize his military title, Washington consulted
a few of his officers in the matter, and it was the
unanimous opinion that should the communication be
addressed to him as a private individual it could
not, with propriety, be received. Colonel Reed,
the adjutant-general, and Colonel Knox immediately
went down the bay and met the British officer.
The latter, with hat in hand, bowed politely and said
to Colonel Reed, “I have a letter from Lord
Howe to Mr. Washington.” “Sir,”
replied Reed, “we have no person in our army
with that address.” “But will you
look at the address?” continued the officer,
at the same time taking out of his pocket a letter
marked
“GEORGE WASHINGTON, ESQ.,
NEW YORK.
HOWE.”
“No, sir,” said Reed,
“I cannot receive that letter.” “I
am very sorry,” returned the officer, “and
so will be Lord Howe, that any error in the superscription
should prevent the letter being received by General
Washington.” “Why, sir,”
replied Reed, whose instructions were positive not
to accept such a communication, “I must obey
orders;” and the officer, finding it useless
to press the matter, could only repeat the sentiment,
“Oh! yes, sir, you must obey orders, to be sure.”
Then, after exchanging letters from prisoners, the
officers saluted and separated. The British barge
had gone but a short distance when it quickly put
about, and the officer asked by what particular title
Washington chose to be addressed. Colonel Reed
replied, “You are sensible, sir, of the rank
of General Washington in our army.” “Yes,
sir, we are,” said the officer; “I am sure
my Lord Howe will lament exceedingly this affair,
as the letter is quite of a civil nature, and not
of a military one. He laments exceedingly that
he was not here a little sooner.” Reed and
Knox supposed this to be an allusion to the Declaration
of Independence, but making no reply, they again bowed,
and parted, as Knox says, “in the most genteel
terms imaginable."
But Howe was unwilling to have the
matter dropped in this fashion, and on the 20th he
sent his adjutant-general, Lieutenant-Colonel Patterson,
to hold an interview with Washington in person, if
possible, and urge him to receive the letter and also
to treat about the exchange of prisoners. Patterson
landed at the Battery, and was conducted to Colonel
Knox’s quarters at the Kennedy House, without
the usual formality of having his eyes blindfolded.
Washington, “very handsomely dressed" and
making “a most elegant appearance,” received
him with his suite, and listened attentively while
Patterson, interspersing his words at every other
breath with “May it please your Excellency,”
explained the address on the letter by saying that
the etc. etc. appended meant every thing.
“And, indeed, it might mean any thing,”
replied Washington, as Patterson then proceeded to
say, among other things, that the benevolence of the
king had induced him to appoint General and Admiral
Howe his commissioners to accommodate the unhappy
disputes; that it would give them great pleasure to
effect such an accommodation, and that he (Colonel
Patterson) wished to have that visit considered as
preliminary to so desirable an object. Washington
replied that he himself was not vested with any authority
in the case; that it did not appear that Lord Howe
could do more than grant pardons, and that those who
had committed no fault wanted no pardons, as they
were simply defending what they deemed their indisputable
rights. Further conversation followed, when Patterson,
rising to leave, asked, “Has your Excellency
no particular commands with which you would please
to honor me to Lord and General Howe?” “Nothing,”
replied Washington, “but my particular compliments
to both;” and, declining to partake of a collation
prepared for the occasion, the British adjutant-general
took his departure. Again the king’s “commissioners”
had failed, and Washington had preserved the dignity
of the young nation and his own self-respect as the
commander of its armies.
An incident, of greater moment as
a military affair, and which disturbed Washington
as much as the Patterson interview must have diverted
him, was the easy passage, on the 12th of July, of
two of the British men-of-war, the Rose and Phoenix,
past all the batteries, unharmed, up the North River.
Taking advantage of a brisk breeze and running tide,
the ships with their tenders sailed rapidly up from
the Narrows, and to avoid the fire of the batteries
as much as possible kept near the Jersey shore.
The American artillerists opened upon them with all
their guns along the river, but could do them no serious
damage, while by accident, in their haste to load the
pieces, six of their own gunners were killed.
The ships sent many shots into the city, some crashing
through houses but doing no other injury, while the
roar of the cannon frightened the citizens who had
not already moved away, and caused more to go.
At the upper end of the island, around Fort Washington,
where the batteries and river obstructions were as
yet incomplete, the ships suffered still less harm,
and sailing by, anchored safely in the broad Tappan
Bay above. Their object was to cut off the supplies
which came down the river to Washington’s army,
and, as supposed, to encourage the loyalists in the
upper counties and supply them with arms. Washington
acknowledged that the event showed the weakness and
inadequacy of the North River line of defences, and
reported to Congress that it developed a possible
plan of attack by the British upon his rear. Measures
were taken to annoy if not destroy the ships, and,
on the 3d of August, Commodore Tupper, with four of
his sloops and schooners, boldly attacked the
enemy, but though, as Washington wrote, “our
officers and men, during the whole affair, behaved
with great spirit and bravery,” neither side
sustained serious damage. On the night of the
16th two fire-rafts were directed against the ships,
which were successful so far as to destroy one of
the tenders; and on the 18th the enemy weighed anchor
and returned to the Narrows as readily as they came
up.
It was now apparent that the great
struggle between the two armies could be postponed
no longer, and no day after the arrival of the Hessians
passed that the British attack was not looked for.
The orders of August 8th cautioned the men to be at
their quarters, “especially early in the morning
or upon the tide of flood,” when the enemy’s
fleet might be expected, and every preparation was
made to resist the landing of the British at any point
upon Manhattan Island.
Upon Long Island General Greene and
his men were still at work on the defences, and, since
the arrival of the enemy, doubly vigilant. Hand’s
riflemen kept close watch at the Narrows and reported
every suspicious movement of the fleet. Word
was brought in on the 9th that a large number of regulars
were drawn up at the Staten Island ferry, and Greene
immediately sent around the order for “no officer
or soldier to stir from his quarters, that we may
be ready to march at a moment’s warning, if
necessary.” Upon another alarm, when probably
he himself was indisposed, he directed Colonel Little,
the senior regimental officer present, to superintend
the disposition of the troops. His hastily written
letter, penned apparently not long after midnight,
runs as follows:
THURSDAY MORNING [August
8 or 15?]
DEAR SIR By Express from
Col Hand and from Red Hook, and from on board
the Sloop at Governor’s Island it is very evident
there was a General Imbarcation of the Troops last
evening from Statten Island doubtless
they’l make a dessent this morning.
Youl please to order all the troops fit for duty
to be at their Alarm posts near an hour sooner than
is common let their flints arms and
ammunition be examined and everything held in
readiness to defend the works or go upon a detachment.
A few minutes past received an Express from Head
Quarters. Youl acquaint the Commanding officers
of Col Hitchcock’s Regiment and Col Forman’s
Regiment of this, and direct them to observe
the same orders, also the Artillery officers.
I am ys,
N. GREENE.
[Addressed to Col.
Little.]
Greene had been promoted to the rank
of major-general on the 9th, and his old brigade on
Long Island given to Brigadier-General John Nixon,
of Massachusetts, who was promoted from a colonelcy
at the same time. A new arrangement of the army
was effected, and Brigadier-General Heard’s
brigade of five New Jersey regiments was ordered to
Long Island to reinforce Greene. His division,
now consisting of these two brigades Nixon’s
and Heard’s numbered, August 15th,
two thousand nine hundred men fit for duty. Parts
of two Long Island militia regiments under Colonels
Smith and Remsen which joined him about this date,
and Colonel Gay’s Connecticut levies, who had
been on that side since the 1st of August, increased
this number to something over thirty-five hundred.
But Greene was not to be a participator
in the approaching scenes. The prevailing fever
which had prostrated so many officers and men seized
him with all but a fatal hold, and he was obliged to
relinquish his command. He clung to it, however,
to the last moment in hopes of a change for the better.
“I am very sorry,” he wrote to Washington
on the 15th, “that I am under the necessity
of acquainting you that I am confined to my bed with
a raging fever. The critical situation of affairs
makes me the more anxious, but I hope, through the
assistance of Providence, to be able to ride before
the presence of the enemy may make it absolutely necessary;”
and he assured the commander-in-chief that his men
appeared to be “in exceeding good spirits,”
and would no doubt be able to render a very good account
of the enemy should they land on Long Island.
On the 16th there was no change for the better in
his condition, but on the contrary Livingston, his
aid, reported that he had “a very bad night
of it;” and in a day or two he was removed to
New York, to the house of John Inglis now the intersection
of Ninth Street and Broadway where with rest and care
he slowly passed the crisis of his illness.
On the 20th Washington gave orders
to General Sullivan, who had recently returned from
Canada, to take the command upon Long Island, until
General Greene’s state of health should permit
him to resume it.