I remember how Hugh Glynn stepped within the door of John Snow’s kitchen that night, and how he bent his head to step within; and, bending his head, took off his cap; and how he bowed to John Snow, Mrs. Snow, and Mary Snow in turn, and, facing John Snow, made as if to speak; but how his voice would not come, not until he had lifted his head yet higher and cleared his throat. And beginning again, he took a step nearer the middle of the floor, to where the light of the bracket lamp above the kitchen table shone full on his face. He was a grand man to look at, not only his face but the height and build of him, and he was fresh in from sea.

“John Snow-and you, Mrs. Snow-the Arbiter’s to anchor in the stream, and her flag’s to half-mast. And knowing that, maybe there’s no need to say anything more.”

Mrs. Snow said nothing, Mary Snow said nothing, but I remember how from under John Snow’s brows the deep eyes glowed out.

“Go on,” said John Snow at last.

Hugh Glynn went on. “Well, he was a good boy, your Arthur-maybe you’d like to be told that, even by me, though of course you that was his father, John Snow, and you that was his mother, Mrs. Snow, know better than anybody else what he was. Three nights ago it was, and we to the south’ard of Sable Island in as nasty a breeze as I’d been in for some time. A living gale it was, a November no’wester-you know what that is, John Snow-but I’d all night been telling the crew to be careful, for a sea there was to sweep to eternity whoever it could’ve caught loose around deck. I could’ve hove her to and let her lay, but I was never one to heave to my vessel-not once I’d swung her off for home. And there, God help me, is maybe my weakness.

“She was under her gaff tops’l, but I see she couldn’t stand it. ‘Boys,’ says I, ‘clew up that tops’l.’ Which they did, and put it in gaskets, and your Arthur, I mind, was one of the four men to go aloft to clew it up. Never a lad to shirk was Arthur. Well, a stouter craft of her tonnage than the Arbiter maybe never lived, nor no gear any sounder, but there are things o’ God’s that the things o’ man were never meant to hold out against. Her jib flew to ribbons. ‘Cut it clear!’ I says, and nigh half the crew jump for’ard. Half a dozen of the crew to once, but Arthur,-your Arthur, your boy, Mrs. Snow, your son, John Snow-he was quick enough to be among the half-dozen. Among a smart crew he was never left behind. It looked safe for us all then, coming on to morning, but who can ever tell? Fishermen’s lives, they’re expected to go fast, but they’re men’s lives for all that, and ‘Have a care!’ I called to them, myself to the wheel at the time, where, God knows, I was careful.

“Well, I saw this big fellow coming, a mountain of water with a snow-white top to it against the first light of the morning. And I made to meet it. A better vessel than the Arbiter the hand o’ man never turned out-all Gloucester knows that-but, her best and my best, there was no lifting her out of it. Like great pipe-organs aroaring this sea came, and over we went. Over we went, and I heard myself saying: ’God in heaven! You great old wagon, but are you gone at last?’ And said it again when maybe there was a fathom of water over my head-her quarter was buried that deep and she that long coming up. Slow coming up she was, though up she came at last. But a man was gone.”

He had stopped; but he went on. “It was Arthur, John Snow, and you, Mrs. Snow, who was gone. The boy you were expecting to see in this very room by now, he was gone. Little Arthur that ten years ago, when first I saw him, I could’ve swung to the ceiling of this room with my one finger-little Arthur was gone. Well, ‘Over with a dory!’ I said. And, gale and all, we over with a dory, with three of us in it. We looked and looked in that terrible dawn, but no use-no man short o’ the Son o’ God himself could a’ stayed afloat, oilskins and red jacks, in that sea. But we had to look, and coming aboard the dory was stove in-smashed, like ’twas a china teacup and not a new banker’s double dory, against the rail. And it was cold. Our frost-bitten fingers slipped from her ice-wrapped rail, and the three of us nigh came to joining Arthur, and Lord knows-a sin, maybe you’ll say, to think it, John Snow-but I felt then as if I’d just as soon, for it was a hard thing to see a man go down to his death, maybe through my foolishness. And to have the people that love him to face in the telling of it-that’s hard, too.”

He drew a great breath. “And”-again a deep breath and a deepened note of pain-“that’s what I’ve come to tell you, John Snow, and you, Mrs. Snow-how your boy Arthur was lost.”

John Snow, at the kitchen table, I remember, one finger still in the pages of the black-lettered Bible he had been reading when Hugh Glynn stepped in, dropped his head on his chest and there let it rest. Mrs. Snow was crying out loud. Mary Snow said nothing, nor made a move, except to sit in her chair by the window and look to where, in the light of the kitchen lamp, Hugh Glynn stood.

There was a long quiet. Hugh Glynn spoke again. “Twenty years, John Snow, and you, Mrs. Snow-twenty good years I’ve been fishing out o’ Gloucester, and in that time not much this side the western ocean I haven’t laid a vessel’s keel over. From Greenland to Hatteras I’ve fished, and many smart seamen I’ve been shipmates with-dory, bunk, and watch mates with in days gone by-and many a grand one of ’em I’ve known to find his grave under the green-white ocean, but never a smarter, never an abler fisherman than your boy Arthur. Boy and man I knew him, and, boy and man, he did his work. I thought you might like to hear that from me, John Snow. And not much more than that can I say now, except to add, maybe, that when the Lord calls, John Snow, we must go, all of us. The Lord called and Arthur went. He had a good life before him-if he’d lived. He’d ’ve had his own vessel soon-could’ve had one before this-if he’d wanted. But ‘No,’ he says, ’I’ll stay with you yet a while, Captain Hugh.’ He loved me and I loved him. ’I’ll stay with you yet a while, Captain Hugh,’ he says, but, staying with me, he was lost, and if I was old enough to have a grown son o’ my own, if ’twas that little lad who lived only long enough to teach me what it is to have hope of a fine son and then to lose him, if ‘twas that little lad o’ mine grown up, I doubt could I feel it more, John Snow.”

John Snow let slip his book and stood up, and for the first time looked fair at Hugh Glynn. “We know, Captain Glynn,” John Snow said, “and I’m thanking you now. It’s hard on me, hard on us all-our only son, captain-our only child. But, doubtless, it had to come. Some goes young and some goes old. It came to him maybe earlier than we ever thought for, or he thought for, no doubt, but-it come. And what you have told us, captain, is something for a man to be hearing of his son-and to be hearing it from you. And only this very night, with the word of you come home, my mind was hardening against you, Captain Glynn, for no denying I’ve heard hard things even as I’ve heard great things of you. But now I’ve met you, I know they mixed lies in the telling, Captain Glynn. And as for Arthur-” John Snow stopped.

“As for Arthur”-’twas something to listen to, the voice of Hugh Glynn then, so soft there was almost no believing it-“as for Arthur, John Snow, he went as all of us will have to go if we stop long enough with the fishing.”

“Ay, no doubt. As you may go yourself, captain?”

“As I expect to go, John Snow. To be lost some day-what else should I look forward to?”

“A black outlook, captain.”

“Maybe, maybe. And yet a man’s death at the last.”

“So ’tis, captain-so ’tis.”

John Snow and Hugh Glynn gripped hands, looked into each other’s eyes, and parted-Hugh Glynn out into the night again and John Snow, with Mrs. Snow, to their room, from where I could hear her sobbing. I almost wanted to cry myself, but Mary Snow was there. I went over and stood behind her. She was looking after some one through the window.

It was Hugh Glynn walking down the steep hill. Turning the corner below,
I remember how he looked back and up at the window.

For a long silence Mary Snow sat there and looked out. When she looked up and noticed me, she said: “It’s a hard life, the bank fishing, Simon. The long, long nights out to sea, the great gales; and when you come home, no face, it may be, at the door to greet you.”

“That it is, Mary.”

“I saw his wife one day, Simon,” said Mary Snow softly, “and the little boy with her. But a week before they were killed together that was; six years ago, and he, the great, tall man, striding between them. A wonderful, lovely woman and a noble couple, I thought. And the grand boy! And I at that heedless age, Simon, it was a rare person, be it man or woman, I ran ahead to see again.”

“Come from the window, Mary,” I said to that, “and we’ll talk of things more cheerful.”

“No, no, Simon-don’t ask me to talk of light matters to-night.” With that and a “Good night” she left me for her room.

Out into the street I went. John Snow’s house stood at the head of a street atop of a steep hill, and I remember how I stood on the steps of John Snow’s house and looked down the slope of the hill, and below the hill to the harbor, and beyond the harbor to clear water. It was a cold winter moonlight, and under the moon the sea heaved and heaved and heaved. There was no break in the surface of that sea that night, but as it heaved, terribly slow and heavy, I thought I could feel the steps beneath me heaving with it.