Keith’s first vision, as he entered the office of the Inspector of Police, was not of McDowell, but of a girl.  She sat directly facing him as he advanced through the door, the light from a window throwing into strong relief her face and hair.  The effect was unusual.  She was strikingly handsome.  The sun, giving to the room a soft radiance, lit up her hair with shimmering gold; her eyes, Keith saw, were a clear and wonderful gray-and they stared at him as he entered, while the poise of her body and the tenseness of her face gave evidence of sudden and unusual emotion.  These things Keith observed in a flash; then he turned toward McDowell.

The Inspector sat behind a table covered with maps and papers, and instantly Keith was conscious of the penetrating inquisition of his gaze.  He felt, for an instant, the disquieting tremor of the criminal.  Then he met McDowell’s eyes squarely.  They were, as Conniston had warned him, eyes that could see through boiler-plate.  Of an indefinable color and deep set behind shaggy, gray eyebrows, they pierced him through at the first glance.  Keith took in the carefully waxed gray mustaches, the close-cropped gray hair, the rigidly set muscles of the man’s face, and saluted.

He felt creeping over him a slow chill.  There was no greeting in that iron-like countenance, for full a quarter-minute no sign of recognition.  And then, as the sun had played in the girl’s hair, a new emotion passed over McDowell’s face, and Keith saw for the first time the man whom Derwent Conniston had known as a friend as well as a superior.  He rose from his chair, and leaning over the table said in a voice in which were mingled both amazement and pleasure: 

“We were just talking about the devil-and here you are, sir!  Conniston, how are you?”

For a few moments Keith did not see.  He had won!  The blood pounded through his heart so violently that it confused his vision and his senses.  He felt the grip of McDowell’s hand; he heard his voice; a vision swam before his eyes-and it was the vision of Derwent Conniston’s triumphant face.  He was standing erect, his head was up, he was meeting McDowell shoulder to shoulder, even smiling, but in that swift surge of exultation he did not know.  McDowell, still gripping his hand and with his other hand on his arm, was wheeling him about, and he found the girl on her feet, staring at him as if he had newly risen from the dead.

McDowell’s military voice was snapping vibrantly, “Conniston, meet Miss Miriam Kirkstone, daughter of Judge Kirkstone!”

He bowed and held for a moment in his own the hand of the girl whose father he had killed.  It was lifeless and cold.  Her lips moved, merely speaking his name.  His own were mute.  McDowell was saying something about the glory of the service and the sovereignty of the law.  And then, breaking in like the beat of a drum on the introduction, his voice demanded, “Conniston-did you get your man?”

The question brought Keith to his senses.  He inclined his head slightly and said, “I beg to report that John Keith is dead, sir.”

He saw Miriam Kirkstone give a visible start, as if his words had carried a stab.  She was apparently making a strong effort to hide her agitation as she turned swiftly away from him, speaking to McDowell.

“You have been very kind, Inspector McDowell.  I hope very soon to have the pleasure of talking with Mr. Conniston-about-John Keith.”

She left them, nodding slightly to Keith.

When she was gone, a puzzled look filled the Inspector’s eyes.  “She has been like that for the last six months,” he explained.  “Tremendously interested in this man Keith and his fate.  I don’t believe that I have watched for your return more anxiously than she has, Conniston.  And the curious part of it is she seemed to have no interest in the matter at all until six months ago.  Sometimes I am afraid that brooding over her father’s death has unsettled her a little.  A mighty pretty girl, Conniston.  A mighty pretty girl, indeed!  And her brother is a skunk.  Pst!  You haven’t forgotten him?”

He drew a chair up close to his own and motioned Keith to be seated.  “You’re changed, Conniston!”

The words came out of him like a shot.  So unexpected were they that Keith felt the effect of them in every nerve of his body.  He sensed instantly what McDowell meant.  He was not like the Englishman; he lacked his mannerisms, his cool and superior suavity, the inimitable quality of his nerve and sportsmanship.  Even as he met the disquieting directness of the Inspector’s eyes, he could see Conniston sitting in his place, rolling his mustache between his forefinger and thumb, and smiling as though he had gone into the north but yesterday and had returned today.  That was what McDowell was missing in him, the soul of Conniston himself-Conniston, the ne plus ultra of presence and amiable condescension, the man who could look the Inspector or the High Commissioner himself between the eyes, and, serenely indifferent to Service regulations, say, “Fine morning, old top!” Keith was not without his own sense of humor.  How the Englishman’s ghost must be raging if it was in the room at the present moment!  He grinned and shrugged his shoulders.

“Were you ever up there-through the Long Night-alone?” he asked.  “Ever been through six months of living torture with the stars leering at you and the foxes barking at you all the time, fighting to keep yourself from going mad?  I went through that twice to get John Keith, and I guess you’re right.  I’m changed.  I don’t think I’ll ever be the same again.  Something-has gone.  I can’t tell what it is, but I feel it.  I guess only half of me pulled through.  It killed John Keith.  Rotten, isn’t it?”

He felt that he had made a lucky stroke.  McDowell pulled out a drawer from under the table and thrust a box of fat cigars under his nose.

“Light up, Derry-light up and tell us what happened.  Bless my soul, you’re not half dead!  A week in the old town will straighten you out.”

He struck a match and held it to the tip of Keith’s cigar.

For an hour thereafter Keith told the story of the man-hunt.  It was his Iliad.  He could feel the presence of Conniston as words fell from his lips; he forgot the presence of the stern-faced man who was watching him and listening to him; he could see once more only the long months and years of that epic drama of one against one, of pursuit and flight, of hunger and cold, of the Long Nights filled with the desolation of madness and despair.  He triumphed over himself, and it was Conniston who spoke from within him.  It was the Englishman who told how terribly John Keith had been punished, and when he came to the final days in the lonely little cabin in the edge of the Barrens, Keith finished with a choking in his throat, and the words, “And that was how John Keith died-a gentleman and a man!”

He was thinking of the Englishman, of the calm and fearless smile in his eyes as he died, of his last words, the last friendly grip of his hand, and McDowell saw the thing as though he had faced it himself.  He brushed a hand over his face as if to wipe away a film.  For some moments after Keith had finished, he stood with his back to the man who he thought was Conniston, and his mind was swiftly adding twos and twos and fours and fours as he looked away into the green valley of the Saskatchewan.  He was the iron man when he turned to Keith again, the law itself, merciless and potent, by some miracle turned into the form of human flesh.

“After two and a half years of that even a murderer must have seemed like a saint to you, Conniston.  You have done your work splendidly.  The whole story shall go to the Department, and if it doesn’t bring you a commission, I’ll resign.  But we must continue to regret that John Keith did not live to be hanged.”

“He has paid the price,” said Keith dully.

“No, he has not paid the price, not in full.  He merely died.  It could have been paid only at the end of a rope.  His crime was atrociously brutal, the culmination of a fiend’s desire for revenge.  We will wipe off his name.  But I can not wipe away the regret.  I would sacrifice a year of my life if he were in this room with you now.  It would be worth it.  God, what a thing for the Service-to have brought John Keith back to justice after four years!”

He was rubbing his hands and smiling at Keith even as he spoke.  His eyes had taken on a filmy glitter.  The law!  It stood there, without heart or soul, coveting the life that had escaped it.  A feeling of revulsion swept over Keith.

A knock came at the door.

McDowell’s voice gave permission, and the door slowly opened.  Cruze, the young secretary, thrust in his head.

“Shan Tung is waiting, sir,” he said.

An invisible hand reached up suddenly and gripped at Keith’s throat.  He turned aside to conceal what his face might have betrayed.  Shan Tung!  He knew what it was now that had pulled him back, he knew why Conniston’s troubled face had traveled with him over the Barrens, and there surged over him with a sickening foreboding, a realization of what it was that Conniston had remembered and wanted to tell him-when it was too late.  They had forgotten Shan Tung, the Chinaman!