Grundtvig’s later years present
a striking contrast to the years of his earlier manhood.
The lonely Defender of the Bible became a respected
sage and the acknowledged leader of a fast growing
religious and folk movement, both in Denmark and the
other Scandinavian countries. His long years
of continuous struggles were followed by years of fruitful
work and an extensive growth of his religious and
educational ideals until he was generally recognized
as one of the most vital spiritual leaders of Scandinavia.
The first break in the wall of isolation
that surrounded him came with an invitation from a
group of students to “the excellent historian,
N. F. S. Grundtvig, who has never asked for a reward
but only for a chance to do good,” to deliver
a series of historical lectures at Borch’s Collegium
in Copenhagen. These lectures seventy-one
in all were delivered before packed audiences
during the summer and fall of 1838, and were so enthusiastically
received that the students, on the evening of the
concluding lecture, arranged a splendid banquet for
the speaker, at which one of them sang:
Yes, through years of lonely
struggle
Did you bravely fight,
Bearing scorn without complaining
Till your hair turned white.
During his most lonely years Grundtvig
once comforted himself with the words of a Greek sage:
“Speak to the people of yesterday, and you will
be heard by the people of tomorrow.” Thus
it was, no doubt, a great satisfaction to him that
the first public honor bestowed upon him should be
accorded him by his nation’s youth.
From that day his reputation and influence
grew steadily. He became an honored member of
several influential societies, such as the Society
for Northern Studies, and the Scandinavian Society,
an association of academicians from all the Scandinavian
countries for the purpose of effecting a closer spiritual
and cultural union between them. He also received
frequent invitations to lecture both on outstanding
occasions and before special groups. His work
as a lecturer probably reached its culmination at
a public meeting on the Skamlingsbanke, a wooded hill
on the borders of Slesvig, where he spoke to thousands
of profoundly stirred listeners, and at a great meeting
of Scandinavian students at Oslo, Norway, in 1851,
to which he was invited as the guest of honor and
acclaimed both by the students and the Norwegian people.
When Denmark became a constitutional kingdom in 1848,
he was a member of the constitutional assembly and
was elected several times to the Riksdag.
Meanwhile he worked ceaselessly for
the development of his folk and educational ideals.
After his conversion, he felt for a time that his new
outlook was incompatible with his previous enthusiasm
for the heroic life and ideals of the old North, and
that he must now devote himself solely to the preaching
of the Gospel. But the formerly mentioned decline
of all phases of Danish life during the early part
of the nineteenth century and the failure of his preaching
to evoke any response from an indifferent people caused
him to suspect a closer relationship between a people’s
religious and national or folk-life than he had hitherto
recognized. Was not the folk life of a people,
after all, the soil in which the Word of God must
be sown, and could the Word bear fruit in a soil completely
hardened and unprepared to receive it? If it could
not, was not a folk awakening a necessary preparation
for a Christian?
Under the spur of this question he
undertook the translation of the sagas and developed
his now widely recognized ideas of folk life and folk
education, which later were embodied in the Grundtvigian
folk schools. The first of these schools was
opened at Roedding, Slesvig in 1844. The war
between Denmark and Germany from 1848 to 1850 delayed
the establishment of other similar schools. But
in 1851, Christian Kold, the man who more than any
other realized Grundtvig’s idea of a school for
life as the folk schools were frequently
called opened his first school at Ryslinge,
Fyn. From there the movement spread rapidly not
only to all parts of Denmark but also to Norway, Finland
and Sweden. The latter country now has more schools
of the Grundtvigian type than Denmark, and Norway
and Finland have about have as many.
To extend the influence of the movement
lecture societies, reading circles, gymnastic societies,
choral groups and the like were organized in almost
every parish of Denmark. Thus before Grundtvig
died, he had the satisfaction of seeing his work bear
fruit in one of the most vital folk and educational
movements of Scandinavia, a movement which has made
a tremendous imprint upon all phases of life in the
Northern countries and which today is spreading to
many other parts of the world.
Grundtvig held that the life of a
nation, Christian as well as national, never rose
above the real culture of its common people. To
be real, a culture had to be national, had to be based
on a people’s natural characteristics and developed
in accordance with native history and traditions.
The aim of all true folk-education was the awakening
and enrichment of life and not a mere mental or practical
training. The natural means for the attainment
of this aim was a living presentation of a people’s
own cultural heritage, their native tradition, history,
literature and folk life. But in all cases the
medium of this presentation was the living, that is
the spoken word by men and women who were themselves
spiritually alive. Christianity, in his opinion,
had not come to destroy but to cleanse and vivify
the folk life of a people, and, since the latter was
the soil in which the former had to grow, the fruitfulness
of both demanded a living inter-action so that national
life might become Christian and Christianity national.
In the practical application of these
educational theories, Grundtvig took no active part.
Aside from his conception of the idea and the development
of much of the material used in the folk-school, his
greatest contributions to their work are probably,
his innumerable Biblical, historical and folk songs
that were and are used in the schools.
Meanwhile he by no means neglected
his religious work. Rationalism had been defeated,
a sound Evangelical movement was fast revitalizing
the church, and he could therefore concentrate his
energy on a further development of the view that had
come to him during his years of struggle. Among
innumerable other works, he produced during his later
years the splendid Enlightenment of the Church,
published 1840-1844; Teachings of Our Christian
Childhood, published 1855-1862; The Seven Stars
of the Churches, published 1854-1855; and The
Church Mirror, a series of lectures on the main
currents of church history, published 1861-1863.
Although Grundtvig’s views,
and especially his distinction between the “living”
and the “written” word, were strongly opposed
by many, his profoundly spiritual conception of the
church, as the body of Christ, and of the sacraments,
as its true means of life, has greatly influenced all
branches of the Danish church. In emphasizing
the true indwelling of Christ in the creed and sacraments,
he visualized the real presence of Him in the church
and underscored the vital center of congregational
worship with a realism that no theological dissertation
can ever convey. Nor did he feel that in so doing
he was in any sense diverging from true Lutheranism.
The fact that Luther himself chose the creed and the
words of institution of the sacrament as a basis for
his catechism, showed, he contended, that the great
Reformer also had recognized their distinction.
Despite frequent charges to the contrary,
Grundtvig had no desire to engender a separatist movement
in the church. He constantly warned his followers
against any such tendency. In a closing speech
to the Meeting of Friends in 1863, he said, “You
can no more forbid the world to call you Grundtvigians
than those whom Luther called to the Lord could forbid
anyone to call them Lutherans, but do not yourself
adopt that name. For history shows that some
have let themselves be called Lutherans until they
have almost lost the name of Christians. If anyone
wishes to name us after any other than Christ, we
ought to tell them that we accept nothing unto salvation
except what the Christian church has taught and confessed
from generation to generation. To or from that
we neither add nor detract. We acknowledge without
reservation that word of faith which Paul says is
believed to righteousness and confessed unto salvation.
The manner of teaching and believing that faith so
that the Old Adam may be put off and the new put on,
we hold to be a matter of enlightenment in which we
shall be guided by Grundtvig, as we are guided by Luther,
only in so far as we are convinced that he has been
guided by Scripture and the Spirit. We also disclaim
any intention of making our conception of Scripture
an article of faith which must be accepted by the church.”
Grundtvig’s followers would, no doubt, have profited
greatly by remembering this truly liberal view of
their leader.
Thus his years passed quietly onward,
filled with fruitful labor even unto the end.
In contrast to his often stormy public career, Grundtvig’s
private life was quite peaceful and commonplace, subject
only to the usual trials and sorrows of human existence.
During the greater part of his life he was extremely
poor, subsisting on a small government pension, the
meager returns from his writings and occasional gifts
from friends. For his own part this did not trouble
him; his wants were few and easily satisfied.
But he “liked to see shining faces around him,”
as he once wrote, and he had discovered that the face
of a child could often be brightened by a small gift,
which he was frequently too poor to give. “But
if we would follow the Lord in these days,” he
wrote to a friend, “we must evidently be prepared
to renounce all things for His sake and cast out all
these heathen worries for dross and chaff with which
we as Christians often distress ourselves.”
Grundtvig was thrice married.
His first wife, Lise Grundtvig, died January 4, 1851,
after a long illness. Her husband said at her
grave, “I stand here as an old man who is taking
a decided step toward my own grave by burying the
bride of my youth and the mother of my children who
for more than forty years with unfailing loyalty shared
all my joys and sorrows and mostly latter.”
But Grundtvig did not appear to be
growing old. During the following summer he attended
the great meeting of Scandinavian students at Oslo,
where he was hailed as the youngest of them all.
And on October 4 of the same year, he rejoiced his
enemies and grieved many of his friends by marrying
Marie Toft, of Rennebeck’s Manor, a wealthy widow
and his junior by thirty years. And despite dire
predictions to the contrary, the marriage was very
happy. Marie Toft was a highly intelligent and
spiritual-minded woman who wholeheartedly shared her
husband’s spiritual views and ideals; and her
death in 1854 came, therefore, as an almost overwhelming
blow. In a letter to a friend a few weeks after
her death, Grundtvig writes, “It was wonderful
to be loved as unselfishly as Marie loved me.
But she belonged wholly to God. He gave and He
took; and despite all objections by the world and
our own selfish flesh, the believing heart must exclaim,
His name be praised. When I consider the greatness
of the treasure that the Lord gave to me by opening
this loving heart to me in my old age, I confess that
it probably would have proved beyond my strength continuously
to bear such good days; for had I not already become
critical of all that were not like her, and indifferent
to all things that were not concerned with her?”
The last remark, perhaps, refers to
a complaint by his friends that he had become so absorbed
in his wife that he neglected other things. If
this had been the case, he now made amends by throwing
himself into a whirl of activity that would have taxed
the strength of a much younger man. During the
following years, he wrote part of his formerly mentioned
books on the church and Christian education, delivered
a large number of lectures, resumed his seat in the
Riksdag and, of course, attended to his growing work
as a pastor. As he was also very neglectful of
his own comfort in other ways, it was evident to all
that such a strenuous life must soon exhaust his strength
unless someone could be constantly about him and minister
to his need. For this reason a high-minded young
widow, the Baroness Asta Tugendreich Reetz, entered
into marriage with him that she might help to conserve
the strength of the man whom she considered one of
the greatest assets her country possessed.
Grundtvig once said of his marriages
that the first was an idyl, the second a romance and
the third a fairy-tale. Others said harsher things.
But Asta Grundtvig paid no attention to the scandal
mongers. A very earnest Christian woman herself,
she devoted all her energy to create a real Christian
home for her husband and family. As Grundtvig
had always lived much by himself, she wished especially
to make their home a ready gathering place for all
his friends and co-workers. In this she succeeded
so well that their modest dwelling was frequently crowded
with visitors from far and near, many of whom later
counted their visit with Grundtvig among the richest
experiences of their life.
Grundtvig’s fiftieth anniversary
as a pastor was celebrated with impressive festivities
on May 29, 1861. The celebration was attended
by representatives from all departments of government
and the church as well as by a host of people from
all parts of Scandinavia; and the celebrant was showered
with gifts and honors. The king conferred upon
him the title of bishop; the former queen, Carolina
Amalia, presented him with a seven armed candlestick
of gold from women in Norway, Sweden and Denmark; his
friend, Pastor P. A. Fenger, handed him a gift of three
thousand dollars from friends in Denmark and Norway
to finance a popular edition of his Hymns and Songs
for the Danish Church; and another friend, Gunni
Busck, presented him with a plaque of gold engraved
with his likeness and a line from his hymns, a gift
from the congregation of Vartov.
Many of those who participated in
this splendid jubilee felt that it would be of great
benefit to them to meet again for mutual fellowship
and discussion of pressing religious and national
questions. And with the willing cooperation of
Asta Grundtvig, it was decided to invite all who might
be interested to a meeting in Copenhagen on Grundtvig’s
eightieth birthday, September 8, the following year.
This Meeting of Friends as it was named proved
so successful that it henceforth became an annual
event, attended by people from all parts of Scandinavia.
Although Grundtvig earnestly desired that these meetings
should actually be what they were designed to be,
meetings of friends for mutual help and enlightenment,
his own part in them was naturally important.
His powers were still unimpaired, and his contributions
were rich in wisdom and spiritual insight. Knowing
himself surrounded by friends, he often spoke with
an appealing heartiness and power that made the Meetings
of Friends unforgettable experiences to many.
Thus the once loneliest man in Denmark
found himself in his old age honored by his nation,
surrounded by friends, and besieged by visitors and
co-workers, seeking his help and advice. He was
always very approachable. In his younger days
he had frequently been harsh and self-assertive in
his judgment of others; but in his latter years he
learned that kindness is always more fruitful than
wrath. Sitting in his easy chair and smoking
his long pipe, he talked frankly and often wittily
with the many who came to visit him. Thus Bishop
H. Martensen, the theologian, tells us that his conversation
was admirably eloquent and interspersed with wit and
humor. And a prominent Swedish author, P. Wisselgren,
writes: “Some years ago I spent one of the
most delightful evenings of my life with Bishop Grundtvig.
I doubt that I have ever met a greater poet of conversation.
Each thought was an inspiration and his heart was
in every word he said.”
Grundtvig’s outward appearance,
especially during his later years, was extremely charming.
His strong countenance framed by long white locks and
a full beard bore the imprint of a profound spiritual
intellect and a benevolent calmness. The queen,
Caroline Amalia, after her first meeting with him
wrote, “Grundtvig has a most beautiful countenance,
and he attracted me at once by his indescribably kind
and benevolent appearance. What an interesting
man he is, and what a pleasure it is to listen to his
open and forthright conversation.”
And so, still active and surrounded
by friends, he saw his long, fruitful life drawing
quietly toward its close. In 1871, he opened the
annual Meeting of Friends by speaking from the text:
“See, I die, but the Lord shall be with you,”
and said in all likelihood this meeting would be the
last at which he would be present. He lived, however,
to prepare for the next meeting, which was to be held
on September 11, 1872. On September 1, he conducted
his service at Vartov as usual, preaching an exceptionally
warm and inspiring sermon. But the following morning
he passed away quietly while sitting in his easy chair
and listening to his son read for him.
He was buried September 11, three
days after his 89th birthday, in the presence of representatives
from all departments of the government, one fourth
of the Danish clergy and a vast assembly of people
from all parts of Scandinavia.
An American writer recently named
Grundtvig “The Builder of Modern Denmark.”
And there are few phases of modern Danish life which
he has not influenced. His genius was so unique
and his work so many-sided that with equal justice
one might call him a historian, a poet, an educator,
a religious philosopher, a hymnologist and a folk-leader.
Yet there is an underlying unity of thought and purpose
in all his work which makes each part of it merely
a branch of the whole. This underlying unity is
his clear conception of the spiritual and of man as
a spiritual being who can attain his fullest development
only through the widest possible realization of the
spiritual in all his divine and human relationships.
In every part of his work Grundtvig, therefore, invariably
seeks to discover the spiritual realities. The
mere form of a thing, the form of religion, of knowledge,
of education, of government, of all human institutions
and endeavors have no intrinsic value, are only skeletons
and dead bones until they become imbued and vivified
by the spirit. Thus Professor Martensen, who
by no means belonged to the Grundtvigian party, writes,
“But among the many things I owe to Grundtvig,
I cherish above all his conception of the spiritual
as the reality besides which all other things are
nothing but shadows, and of the spirit inspired word
as the mightiest power in human life. And he
gave that to me not as a theory but as a living truth,
a spiritual reality about which there could be not
even a shadow of doubt.”
Grundtvig found the spiritual in many
things, in the myth of the North, in history, literature
and, in fact, in all things through which man has
to express his god-given nature. He had no patience
with the Pietists who looked upon all things not directly
religious as evils with which a Christian could have
nothing to do. Yet he believed above all in the
Holy Spirit as the “Spirit of spirits,”
the true agent of God in the world. The work
of the Spirit was indispensable to man’s salvation,
and the fruit of that work, the regenerated Christian
life, the highest expression of the spiritual.
Since he believed furthermore, that the Holy Spirit
works especially in the church through the word and
sacraments, the church was to him the workshop of
the Spirit.
In his famous hymn to the church bell,
his symbol for the church, he writes “that among
all noble voices none could compare with that of the
ringing bell.” Despite the many fields in
which he traced the imprint of the spiritual, the
church remained throughout his long life his real
spiritual home, a fact which he beautifully expresses
in the hymn below.
Hallowed Church Bell, not
for worldly centers
Wast thou made, but for the
village small
Where thy voice, as home and
hearth it enters,
Blends with lullabies at evenfall.
When a child and in the country
dwelling,
Christmas morning was my heaven
on earth,
And thy chimes, like angel
voices swelling,
Told with joy of my Redeemer’s
birth.
Louder still thy joyful chimes
resounded,
When on wings of early morning
borne,
They proclaimed: Awake
with joy unbounded,
Christ arose this blessed
Easter morn.
Sweeter even were thy tolls
when blending
With the calm of summer eventide
And, as though from heaven
above descending,
Bid me cast all grief and
care aside.
Hence when now the day is
softly ending,
Shadows fall and birds ascend
their nest,
Like the flowers my head in
silence bending,
I am chanting with my soul
at rest:
When at last, O Church Bell,
thou art tolling
O’er my grave while
loved grieve and sigh,
Say to them, their troubled
heart consoling,
He is resting with his Lord
on high.