Though I had not seen my distant relative
for years not, in fact, since he was obliged
to give Vancouver Island up as a bad job I
knew him at once, when, with head a little on one
side, and tea-cup held high, as if, to confer a blessing,
he said: “Hallo!” across the Club
smoking-room.
Thin as a lath not one
ounce heavier tall, and very upright, with
his pale forehead, and pale eyes, and pale beard,
he had the air of a ghost of a man. He had always
had that air. And his voice that
matter-of-fact and slightly nasal voice, with its thin,
pragmatical tone was like a wraith of optimism,
issuing between pale lips. I noticed; too, that
his town habiliments still had their unspeakable pale
neatness, as if, poor things, they were trying to stare
the daylight out of countenance.
He brought his tea across to my bay
window, with that wistful sociability of his, as of
a man who cannot always find a listener.
“But what are you doing in town?”
I said. “I thought you were in Yorkshire
with your aunt.”
Over his round, light eyes, fixed
on something in the street, the lids fell quickly
twice, as the film falls over the eyes of a parrot.
“I’m after a job,”
he answered. “Must be on the spot just
now.”
And it seemed to me that I had heard
those words from him before.
“Ah, yes,” I said, “and do you think
you’ll get it?”
But even as I spoke I felt sorry,
remembering how many jobs he had been after in his
time, and how soon they ended when he had got them.
He answered:
“Oh, yes! They ought to
give it me,” then added rather suddenly:
“You never know, though. People are so
funny!”
And crossing his thin legs, he went
on to tell me, with quaint impersonality, a number
of instances of how people had been funny in connection
with jobs he had not been given.
“You see,” he ended, “the
country’s in such a state capital
going out of it every day. Enterprise being
killed all over the place. There’s practically
nothing to be had!”
“Ah!” I said, “you
think it’s worse, then, than it used to be?”
He smiled; in that smile there was a shade of patronage.
“We’re going down-hill
as fast as ever we can. National character’s
losing all its backbone. No wonder, with all
this molly-coddling going on!”
“Oh!” I murmured, “molly-coddling?
Isn’t that excessive?”
“Well! Look at the way
everything’s being done for them! The working
classes are losing their self-respect as fast as ever
they can. Their independence is gone already!”
“You think?”
“Sure of it! I’ll
give you an instance ” and
he went on to describe to me the degeneracy of certain
working men employed by his aunt and his eldest brother
Claud and his youngest brother Alan.
“They don’t do a stroke
more than they’re obliged,” he ended; “they
know jolly well they’ve got their Unions, and
their pensions, and this Insurance, to fall back on.”
It was evidently a subject on which he felt strongly.
“Yes,” he muttered, “the nation
is being rotted down.”
And a faint thrill of surprise passed
through me. For the affairs of the nation moved
him so much more strongly than his own. His voice
already had a different ring, his eyes a different
look. He eagerly leaned forward, and his long,
straight backbone looked longer and straighter than
ever. He was less the ghost of a man. A
faint flush even had come into his pale cheeks, and
he moved his well-kept hands emphatically.
“Oh, yes!” he said:
“The country is going to the dogs, right enough;
but you can’t get them to see it. They
go on sapping and sapping the independence of the
people. If the working man’s to be looked
after, whatever he does what on earth’s
to become of his go, and foresight, and perseverance?”
In his rising voice a certain piquancy
was left to its accent of the ruling class by that
faint twang, which came, I remembered, from some slight
defect in his tonsils.
“Mark my words! So long
as we’re on these lines, we shall do nothing.
It’s going against evolution. They say
Darwin’s getting old-fashioned; all I know is,
he’s good enough for me. Competition is
the only thing.”
“But competition,” I said,
“is bitter cruel, and some people can’t
stand against it!” And I looked at him rather
hard: “Do you object to putting any sort
of floor under the feet of people like that?”
He let his voice drop a little, as
if in deference to my scruples.
“Ah!” he said; “but
if you once begin this sort of thing, there’s
no end to it. It’s so insidious.
The more they have, the more they want; and all the
time they’re losing fighting power. I’ve
thought pretty deeply about this. It’s
shortsighted; it really doesn’t do!”
“But,” I said, “surely
you’re not against saving people from being
knocked out of time by old age, and accidents like
illness, and the fluctuations of trade?”
“Oh!” he said, “I’m
not a bit against charity. Aunt Emma’s
splendid about that. And Claud’s awfully
good. I do what I can, myself.” He
looked at me, so queerly deprecating, that I quite
liked him at that moment. At heart I
felt he was a good fellow. “All I think
is,” he went on, “that to give them something
that they can rely on as a matter of course, apart
from their own exertions, is the wrong principle altogether,”
and suddenly his voice began to rise again, and his
eyes to stare. “I’m convinced that
all this doing things for other people, and bolstering
up the weak, is rotten. It stands to reason that
it must be.”
He had risen to his feet, so preoccupied
with the wrongness of that principle that he seemed
to have forgotten my presence. And as he stood
there in the window the light was too strong for him.
All the thin incapacity of that shadowy figure was
pitilessly displayed; the desperate narrowness in
that long, pale face; the wambling look of those pale,
well-kept hands all that made him such a
ghost of a man. But his nasal, dogmatic voice
rose and rose.
“There’s nothing for it
but bracing up! We must cut away all this State
support; we must teach them to rely on themselves.
It’s all sheer pauperisation.”
And suddenly there shot through me
the fear that he might burst one of those little blue
veins in his pale forehead, so vehement had he become;
and hastily I changed the subject.
“Do you like living up there
with your aunt?” I asked: “Isn’t
it a bit quiet?”
He turned, as if I had awakened him from a dream.
“Oh, well!” he said, “it’s
only till I get this job.”
“Let me see how long is it since
you ?”
“Four years. She’s very glad to
have me, of course.”
“And how’s your brother Claud?”
“Oh! All right, thanks;
a bit worried with the estate. The poor old
gov’nor left it in rather a mess, you know.”
“Ah! Yes. Does he do other work?”
“Oh! Always busy in the parish.”
“And your brother Richard?”
“He’s all right.
Came home this year. Got just enough to live
on, with his pension hasn’t saved
a rap, of course.”
“And Willie? Is he still delicate?”
“Yes.”
“I’m sorry.”
“Easy job, his, you know.
And even if his health does give out, his college
pals will always find him some sort of sinecure.
So jolly popular, old Willie!”
“And Alan? I haven’t
heard anything of him since his Peruvian thing came
to grief. He married, didn’t he?”
“Rather! One of the Burleys.
Nice girl heiress; lot of property in
Hampshire. He looks after it for her now.”
“Doesn’t do anything else, I suppose?”
“Keeps up his antiquarianism.”
I had exhausted the members of his family.
Then, as though by eliciting the good
fortunes of his brothers I had cast some slur upon
himself, he said suddenly: “If the railway
had come, as it ought to have, while I was out there,
I should have done quite well with my fruit farm.”
“Of course,” I agreed;
“it was bad luck. But after all, you’re
sure to get a job soon, and so long as
you can live up there with your aunt you
can afford to wait, and not bother.”
“Yes,” he murmured. And I got up.
“Well, it’s been very jolly to hear about
you all!”
He followed me out.
“Awfully glad, old man,”
he said, “to have seen you, and had this talk.
I was feeling rather low. Waiting to know whether
I get that job it’s not lively.”
He came down the Club steps with me.
By the door of my cab a loafer was standing; a tall
tatterdemalion with a pale, bearded face. My
distant relative fended him away, and leaning through
the window, murmured: “Awful lot of these
chaps about now!”
For the life of me I could not help
looking at him very straight. But no flicker
of apprehension crossed his face.
“Well, good-by again!”
he said: “You’ve cheered me up a lot!”
I glanced back from my moving cab.
Some monetary transaction was passing between him
and the loafer, but, short-sighted as I am, I found
it difficult to decide which of those tall, pale,
bearded figures was giving the other one a penny.
And by some strange freak an awful vision shot up
before me of myself, and my distant relative,
and Claud, and Richard, and Willie, and Alan, all
suddenly relying on ourselves. I took out my
handkerchief to mop my brow; but a thought struck me,
and I put it back. Was it possible for me, and
my distant relatives, and their distant relatives,
and so on to infinity of those who be longed to a class
provided by birth with a certain position, raised by
Providence on to a platform made up of money inherited,
of interest, of education fitting us for certain privileged
pursuits, of friends similarly endowed, of substantial
homes, and substantial relatives of some sort or other,
on whom we could fall back was it possible
for any of us ever to be in the position of having
to rely absolutely on ourselves? For several
minutes I pondered that question; and slowly I came
to the conclusion that, short of crime, or that unlikely
event, marooning, it was not possible. Never,
never try as we might could any
single one of us be quite in the position of one of
those whose approaching pauperisation my distant relative
had so vehemently deplored. We were already pauperised.
If we served our country, we were pensioned....
If we inherited land, it could not be taken from
us. If we went into the Church, we were there
for life, whether we were suitable or no. If
we attempted the more hazardous occupations of the
law, medicine, the arts, or business, there were always
those homes, those relations, those friends of ours
to fall back on, if we failed. No! We
could never have to rely entirely on ourselves; we
could never be pauperised more than we were already!
And a light burst in on me. That explained
why my distant relative felt so keenly. It bit
him, for he saw, of course, how dreadful it would be
for these poor people of the working classes when
legislation had succeeded in placing them in the humiliating
position in which we already were the dreadful
position of having something to depend on apart from
our own exertions, some sort of security in our lives.
I saw it now. It was his secret pride, gnawing
at him all the time, that made him so rabid on the
point. He was longing, doubtless, day and night,
not to have had a father who had land, and had left
a sister well enough off to keep him while he was
waiting for his job. He must be feeling how horribly
degrading was the position of Claud inheriting
that land; and of Richard, who, just because he had
served in the Indian Civil Service, had got to live
on a pension all the rest of his days; and of Willie,
who was in danger at any moment, if his health always
delicate gave out, of having a sinecure
found for him by his college friends; and of Alan,
whose educated charm had enabled him to marry an heiress
and live by managing her estates. All, all sapped
of go and foresight and perseverance by a cruel Providence!
That was what he was really feeling, and concealing,
be cause he was too well-bred to show his secret grief.
And I felt suddenly quite warm toward him, now that
I saw how he was suffering. I understood how
bound he felt in honour to combat with all his force
this attempt to place others in his own distressing
situation. At the same time I was honest enough
to confess to myself sitting there in the cab that
I did not personally share that pride of his, or feel
that I was being rotted by my own position; I even
felt some dim gratitude that if my powers gave out
at any time, and I had not saved anything, I should
still not be left destitute to face the prospect of
a bleak and impoverished old age; and I could not
help a weak pleasure in the thought that a certain
relative security was being guaranteed to those people
of the working classes who had never had it before.
At the same moment I quite saw that to a prouder
and stronger heart it must indeed be bitter to have
to sit still under your own security, and even more
bitter to have to watch that pauperising security coming
closer and closer to others for the generous
soul is always more concerned for others than for
himself. No doubt, I thought, if truth were known,
my distant relative is consumed with longing to change
places with that loafer who tried to open the door
of my cab for surely he must see, as I
do, that that is just what he himself having
failed to stand the pressure of competition in his
life would be doing if it were not for
the accident of his birth, which has so lamentably
insured him against coming to that.
“Yes,” I thought, “you
have learnt something to-day; it does not do, you
see, hastily to despise those distant relatives of
yours, who talk about pauperising and molly-coddling
the lower classes. No, no! One must look
deeper than that! One must have generosity!”
And with that I stopped the cab and
got out for I wanted a breath of ai