We have now come to the point where
an answer must be given to the question: If the
African Natives are on the whole endowed with a mental
capacity equal to that possessed by the Europeans why
have they never achieved any civilisation at all comparable
with those cultures which have been successively set
up by the people of Europe, Asia and Ancient America?
If we take it for granted that the
Africans have never achieved a civilisation similar
to those that date back beyond the limits of history,
a premiss by no means assured seeing that there are
signs of cycles of civilisations coming before those
of which we have written or monumental records and
of whose ethnic origin there is no certain knowledge,
then the question may appear to have no other answer
than the assumed lack of inherent capacity in the
black race, but let us consider the matter closely.
The question asked depends upon the
proposition that achievement is the sole test of capacity
or, in other words, that achievement must necessarily
follow capacity, and this is a proposition by no means
free from doubt. It is plain that a desire to
achieve is a condition precedent to achievement but
it is equally plain that there may well be ability
without ambition. The question why civilisation
has not followed apparent capacity may with equal
propriety be asked about races whose mental abilities
have never been doubted. Consider, for instance,
two such widely separated races as the Red Indians
of our own times and the Northmen who roamed over
the seas in the days of Alfred the Great.
The North American Indians, though
they achieved no civilisation to be compared with
the cultures of Mexico and Peru, yet conserved a very
high degree of initiative in other directions.
According to competent observers, these people have
shown a capacity for wiliness and a power of divination
of the obscured workings of nature and of the human
mind which have never been surpassed elsewhere.
That the high moral and mental status of these people
is fully recognised by their European successors is
proved by the fact that many Americans in high stations
to-day actually boast of having in their veins the
blood of the North American Indian. And yet these
highly gifted people had not when Columbus discovered
America attained to the knowledge of iron. Despite
the advantages of a most favourable environment and
a stimulating climate, the Red Indians were in point
of mechanical development behind the earliest Bantu;
they had no iron implements, no tillage and no settled
or permanent abodes, and whatever may have been the
cause of their lack of development, the fact remains
that there was no achievement despite undeniable capacity.
The early Scandinavians who lived
in a state of barbarism ages before and long after
Egypt, Mesopotamia, India, Greece and Rome developed
their various civilisations, furnish another illustration
of the fact that there may well be capacity without
accomplishment, for no one can doubt the keenness
of the minds of these people who have advanced to the
front ranks of human endeavour. These rude sea-rovers
must have lived in what is generally supposed to have
been a most stimulating climate during long ages while
other races in Southern Europe and in Asia built up
mighty civilisations within environments that seem
to have been far less incitative of progress.
Although the broad facts of history
are known to us the causes that have contributed in
the past to keep down some races while other peoples
who were no better endowed or situated rose to the
greatest heights of human effort cannot be stated
with certainty. It is easy to cite the circumstances
that are commonly conjectured as accounting for the
origin and growth of civilisation, such as soil, climate
and geographical position, but it is equally easy
to point to times and places when and where great
civilisations have arisen under conditions that have
concurred elsewhere with miserable stagnation in rude
barbarism.
Climate is, perhaps, the factor which
is most generally condescended upon as being the chief
of the causes that contribute to that collective accomplishment
which we call civilisation, but the connection between
the two things is far from clear, indeed it seems to
be often negatived by actual facts. Seeing, for
instance, that the easy fruition of desire which is
possible in tropical and sub-tropical latitudes does
away with the idea of necessity as the mother of invention
in those parts of the world it becomes difficult to
see how tool-using man, who is generally supposed
to have originated somewhere in the warm belts, came
to take the first and the most difficult steps in the
upward progress where there was so little, if any,
incentive to that sustained effort and concentration
of the mind which is required for the thinking out
of the most difficult of all thoughts, the first principles
of any art or craft. Why, we may well ask, should
the primitive African have worried about cultivating
the soil where edible roots and berries abounded?
Why should he have bothered about making fire where
there was no need of artificial warmth or for the
cooking of food? Why should he have cudgeled
his brains to fashion weapons and to contrive snares
for the killing of game of which he was in no more
need than his vegetarian cousins, the anthropoid apes?
Why should there have been progress where the environment
provided no stimuli therefore, in other words, why
should primitive man have moved forward where indulgent
nature allowed him to stand still?
If we believe, with Darwin and other
students, that our primitive ancestors emerged from
somewhere within the warm zones, we cannot avoid the
difficulty of reconciling that supposition with the
theory that civilisation is in the first instance
the result of a stimulating environment. If on
the other hand, we surmise that homo sapiens
originated in the colder parts of the world we still
have to account for the fact that his further progress
was made not in those parts but in warmer latitudes
where a genial climate afforded no apparent provocation
for continued effort in the way of invention and general
development.
It would seem that the innate tendency
to conservatism latent in man, the disposition to
leave things as they are and to stick to the familiar
devil rather than fly to unknown gods, is in itself
sufficient to account for those lapses in mass-achievement
and those long periods of stagnation which mark the
course of mankind everywhere. We see how Egypt
hovered for centuries on the brink of the discovery
of the alphabet but never attained thereto. The
exponents of the so-called “pulsatory hypothesis”
can hardly claim that a change in the climate will
explain the fact seeing that the neighbouring people
were able to accomplish this great feat under very
similar climatic conditions. We see how China
developed a wonderful civilisation while the Western
world lay steeped in barbarism, and then went to sleep
till now. The size of that great country made
possible always the friction between people coming
from widely separated localities, which we believe
to be conducive to progress, and the climate and general
environment seems to have been no less favourable
than in Europe and America. We see how the Arabs
made great conquests and enriched the world with many
patient and accurate observations and then came to
a standstill and remained as they are to-day in serene
contentment, strangers to the very idea of progress.
Can it be said that mental capacity and collective
will-power were lacking in any of these people?
On the contrary, it is admitted that they were possessed
of mental powers as great as those of the restless
Europeans of to-day who are rushing onward in a ceaseless
pursuit of change, a pursuit made possible only by
continuous victory over the forces of conservatism,
and this victory, as I think, is gained not through
the outward circumstances of climate and geographical
surroundings, but through a “divine discontent”
which is kindled, we know not how, in the leaders
of the world, regardless of time and place, as says
the poet of one whom he hails as the deliverer of his
country:
“A flaming coal
Lit at the stars and sent
To burn the sin of patience
from her soul,
The scandal of content.”
It is this inward fire rather than
any outward pressure that prompts the captive spirit
to break loose from the fetters of the unmoving giant,
custom, the greatest of all tyrants, who grows stronger
as he grows older. The difficulty of reversing
the ways and conditions that have been induced from
birth is tremendous, and progress has never been possible
without breaking away, always at great risk to the
innovators, the stoned prophets of all ages, from
the powerful grip of hoary and hallowed custom, which
is the essence of conservatism. Initiative implies
the breaking of the commandment which enjoins everyone
to honour his father and mother that he may live long
in the land, a sanction which entails continued adherence
to the ancestral ways and ideas, and which, being
rooted in instinctive fear of innovation, has power
over us all.
Progress, then, has everywhere been
the result, in the beginning, of individual initiative
in men who were possessed of the power of personality,
the “born” leaders of the world who, whether
they figured as chiefs or kings, witchdoctors or priests,
prophets or lawgivers, were all reformers in their
various ways. We see how these restless spirits
have appeared everywhere at irregular intervals, not
only in localities favoured by nature, but often in
the most unlikely places, and there is no reason for
thinking that this sporadic cropping up of new leaders
will ever cease.
But although we believe that progress
has been started always and everywhere by the efforts
of reformers that have occurred as spontaneous variations
from the dead level of their fellows independent of
time and circumstances, we need not deny the effect
of environment, especially the effect of an inimical
environment, upon a new movement after it has been
started, and it may well be that the physical disadvantages
of the great “dark” continent may have
made difficult, if not impossible, in the past that
meeting and friction of different cultures which seem
to be essential to the birth of intellectual life,
so that here the admitted isolation of the inhabitants
during many centuries may have served to squelch initiative
and foster stagnation. Nevertheless the influence
of environment must not be over-rated for we see that
general contentment with resulting inertia have existed
for untold ages in places where now the sounds and
shocks of daily progress reverberate in a thousand
fields of civilised activity without any change being
discernible either in the bodily or mental calibre
of the people themselves, and this must surely teach
us that it is not incapacity nor yet unfavourable
physical environment, but that, more than anything
else, it is the dead weight of human conservatism that
holds down a nation or a race to its particular level;
that it is the human element in the general milieu
that determines human development, a lesson that has
been well summed up in the Chinese aphorism “A
man is more like the age he lives in than he is like
his father and mother.”
Some years ago a theory was advanced
which assumed the presence from the beginning of an
inherently superior race of blond Europeans who, it
was supposed, left their lairs in the North from time
to time to harass and conquer essentially inferior
people in the South whom they innervated through intermarriage
with their superior mentality, and thereby succeeded
in rearing those mighty civilisations that waned and
fell when the “blue” blood of the invaders
became absorbed and lost in the old autochthonous
streams. Apart from the lack of cogent evidence
this theory, if it may be so called, is unsatisfactory
in that it does not explain why these putative super-men
failed to establish within their own stimulating environment
any of those great cultures that were set up in places
and under climatic conditions which are supposed to
have been far less provocative to progress. To-day
the theories of Gobineau and Houston Chamberlain who
both held up the Teutons as being at all times the
greatest and noblest of human kind, do not impress
the non-Teuton part of the world, nor do the later
apostles of the more recent “Nordic” race
faith, like Madison Grant, and others of his school,
succeed in persuading thinking men and women that
the Scandinavians and the English are the only people
that ever could initiate and sustain great civilisations.
The fact that great civilisations have been built up
and are now being developed by people who were and
are neither blond nor Nordic makes it impossible to
believe these pretensions to exclusive racial genius
and merit. “All the talk,” says Professor
Flinders Petrie, “about Nordic supremacy is
vanity when we look at the facts in Europe. Dark
Iberians and Picts, Asiatics, Gaels and Celts, are
the basis of our peoples. Further, it is in the
time of stress and difficulty that the older stocks
come again to the top. The majority of the men
of power among the Allies have not been fair Nordics
but dark men of the underlying races."
Recent study has indeed dissipated
that fascinating idyl about the old race of tall,
blond Aryans as the originators of our present civilisation,
for it has been shown that the so-called Aryan civilisation
was inferior in many ways to the primitive culture
of neolithic times, and it can now hardly be doubted
that our classical civilisation is of Mediterranean
origin though Aryanised in speech. It is now
generally accepted that history points not to Scandinavia
and Germany, but to the lands lying round the Mediterranean
Sea as furnishing the matrix out of which civilisation
has sprung. It is to the South rather than to
the North, to the early people of Egypt, Palestine,
Greece and Rome, and not to the primitive inhabitants
of Scandinavia and Germany, that we must look for
those great men whose intellect and character were
strong enough to overcome the natural conservatism
of their times. The mind of the early white men
of the North never soared higher than a valhalla peopled
with puerile deities and blood-stained warriors whereas
the swarthy thinkers of the South discovered the unseen
God, invented art and philosophy and developed law
and government. And though the Church proclaims
the highest of all born leaders, Christ himself, to
be the very son of God, yet was he a native of Palestine
and not a fair-haired, blue-eyed Teuton as represented
by mediaeval painters of Germany and Holland.
It is no doubt true that the invaders
and the immigrants have often achieved more in their
new surroundings than in their homelands, as the Moors
in Spain and the Irish in America, but it must not
be forgotten that the civilisation which the new-comers
have enriched by virtue of their new found freedom
from home conservatism has not been of their making;
they may have added thereto but they did not beget
it; the spade-work, which is the hardest part, had
been done before they arrived.
Looking, round the world to-day we
see clearly that race is not the determining factor
in contemporary progress. In Japan we see a people,
admittedly not white, who until yesterday were stagnating
under a system of childish feudalism, now developing
at a great pace a culture similar with and not inferior
to that of modern Europe, while in Western Ireland
we see white people living in a state of sloth and
squalor below that of many “raw” Bantu
tribes in South Africa. These facts show that
any race, white black, or yellow, may be kept down
simply by the forces of conservatism, chief among
which is priestcraft operating through prejudice and
superstition in the name of religion. To say this
is not to cavil at the priests of any particular time
or creed. We must have priests as well as prophets.
The prophet of a new faith begins his mission by breaking
the images of the priests before him and is succeeded
by his own priests who set up new images and dogmas
wherewith to conserve the new-found creed until it
in turn becomes too old when, in the never-ceasing
course of evolution, the law of variation bids a new
prophet arise. The priest must needs be to preserve
the world from the anarchy of too many reformers,
but his power, if long continued, tends to inhibit
the divine spirit of discontent which makes for human
advancement. It is the priest’s duty to
preserve the old and to hinder the new, and when he
finds he can no longer ignore the new inventions that
are made around him he will at most accept the new
learning as a means only to preserve the old order
whose servant he is. The founder of the Society
of Jesus enjoined his followers: “Let us
all think in the same way, let us all speak in the
same manner, if possible,” and it is reported
of him that he said that were he to live five hundred
years he would always repeat “no novelties in
theology, in philosophy or logic, not even in grammar.”
In Africa priestcraft, in its primitive form of witchcraft,
has continued for unnumbered ages to perpetuate the
elementary creed of ancestor worship whose chief article
is that the ways of the fathers must remain the ways
of the children, and that to depart from the old and
established order is sinful and wicked, and under
this baneful authority progress has been impossible.
But although the heavy conservatism
enforced by this primitive cult has smothered initiative
during many centuries it does not follow that the
mind and character of the African people have been
impaired thereby beyond the life of each generation.
The mental sloth in which the Western world lay steeped
during the dark ages before the Reformation did not
become a heritable defect. But apart from the
question of the possibility of the transmission of
acquired characters we have the fact that within the
scope of his daily life the conservative and uncivilised
African has to face and solve as many difficult problems
as the civilised European in his different surroundings.
That these problems are made up of elements differing
from those that constitute the problems of the civilised
man in his daily avocation proves only a difference
of content, not of difficulty. The mental strain
involved in leading the so-called simple life of the
so-called savage is, on the whole, no less intense
than that suffered by the civilised man in maintaining
his civilised existence. In the all-surrounding
air of superstition and mutual suspicion in which
the African moves and has his being he requires cunning
to circumvent the cunning of his fellows, and
very deep cunning it sometimes is, so deep,
indeed, that the intellectual European has difficulty
in following the dark and devious ways thereof.
Vigilance and resourcefulness, careful observation,
prudence, forethought, caution, judicious apprizement
of character and intelligent calculation of probabilities
are required for the planning of the primitive African’s
daily campaign against the forces of darkness with
which he is surrounded, and to carry out these plans
he must have courage, firmness of will and self-control
in no less measure than the average European city-dweller.
To avoid the ever-present chance of being found guilty
of witchcraft, which in the past meant always death,
the African has had to develop the faculty of lying
to a high point of efficiency, and no one who knows
him will contend that he is inferior to the European
in this respect. The natural education of the
Natives include the art of lying as the education
of Spartan boys included the practice of larceny.
Lying, we know, develops the memory, for a good memory
is essential to successful lying. Some of the
ruses and stratagems thought out by Natives fleeing
from the king’s wrath or the witch doctor’s
doom, of which I have heard from the Natives themselves,
have seemed to me to be in subtilty of design and in
daring of execution as admirable as any that may be
found in contemporary detective fiction, while the
fortitude with which defeat and death has been accepted
by some of the unfortunate fugitives would evoke admiration
in the least impressionable of men. I say therefore
that those who deny to the Africans the capacity for
sustained collective and purposive effort of mind
and body because these qualities have so far not been
shown by them in the building up of a civilisation
of their own must consider the fact that the nations
which to-day lead the world in all the ways of civilisation
remained for thousands of years without leaders and
without achievement while the people who now lag behind
produced those mighty men that led and paved the way
to the great civilisations of the past, and I think
that we must recognise in that fact a lesson to teach
us that present inferiority is no proof of permanent
inability, wherefore it may well be that the Natives
of Africa will some day rise and compete with their
present overlords in the mastery of all the arts and
crafts of a modern state.
“But,” says the white
South African, voicing the general opinion, “this
is all very well; the Native may have the brains, but
he does not, even now when he has the chance of proving
himself, show the same capacity for strenuous and
continued effort that the white man has shown.
He cannot stand alone; if left to himself he will
sink back rapidly into savagery.”
That the South African Natives are
still in a stage where they cannot stand alone, so
that if left entirely to their own devices they would
lapse back into barbarism, is not, I agree, open to
doubt. But would not the same fate overtake any
nation or community, regardless of race, if it were
completely cut off from all outside help and influence.
The civilised Romans who conquered Britain in the
early Christian era, no doubt, looked upon the primitive
Britons as a feeble folk when compared with themselves,
but the erstwhile slaves have since demonstrated their
capacity for developing a civilisation utterly beyond
the imagination of their foreign masters. Rome
was not built in a day. The rearing of Western
civilisation required many centuries, and it can hardly
be doubted that if the early builders of the great
cultures had been left in isolation instead of being
stimulated continually from without through foreign
learning and influence neither Ancient Rome nor Modern
Europe would have come into being. Isolation has
always and everywhere been followed by stagnation
and regression and there is no reason for expecting
the Natives of South Africa to furnish an exception
to the universal rule.
That the average Native is lazy no
one who knows him will deny. He is certainly
no less lazy than the average European work-man who
must be compelled by economic pressure to do hard
labour. The rough and menial work of the world
has always been done through some sort of compulsion,
either slavery or some kind of economic coaction, for
it is not in human nature, white or black, to work
hard at uncongenial tasks unless superior force in
some shape or other supplies the driving power.
The manual workers of Europe are forced by the economic
conditions under which they live to do the heavy and
rough work that has to be done there are
very few, even among white men, who like rough work
for its own sake and when we consider how
small are the wants of the average South African Native
we are often surprised that he works as hard as he
does. The common expression “As lazy as
a kaffir” is counterbalanced by the equally
common saying used about a white man who works hard
at anything “He works like a nigger,” which
suggests that there is not much difference between
the two races in this respect.
Nevertheless the mental attitude of
the average Native undoubtedly enables him to enjoy
laziness more than the average European whose early
habits have been formed by different influences.
Primitive man is a lazy man whatever race he may belong
to, and civilisation, which has often been helped
on by direct slavery, is indeed itself a system of
slavery, under which the toilers are driven to their
tasks by the goad of necessity. The fact that
many Native youths frequently leave their studies
before completing the prescribed course, with the entry
“Left school tired” against their names,
is often cited as showing that the capacity of the
Native for sustained mental effort is not as great
as that of the average European, but here, again,
it must be remembered that the general conditions
and home influences under which the bulk of European
boys grow up tend to keep them at their studies whereas
the Native school boy is not fortified by similar
support. The dread of becoming an “unemployable”
through lack of education, which is a forcible spur
to effort in both parents and children among the whites,
is not felt by the Natives who can always find work
to do at wages that will satisfy their ordinary wants,
and, moreover, the Native’s chance of gaining
profit and preferment through being well educated are
still few in South Africa, so that where there is
neither penalty for failure nor reward for success
we cannot expect more effort than we find. When
education becomes as general in South Africa as it
is among the people of Europe then it will be possible
to institute fair comparisons. Education is the
discoverer of ability and without the opportunity it
gives genius will languish and die unknown, as said
that acute observer of human nature, Machiavelli,
in speaking about the leaders of antiquity, “Without
opportunity their powers of mind would have been extinguished
and without those powers the opportunity would have
come in vain."
Assuming that the capacity for acquiring
Western education and civilisation is no greater in
the American Negroes than in the Bantu we may note
the opinion of a recent student of the race question
in America, as being in point here. In his book
“Children of the Slaves,” Mr. Stephen
Graham says “The fact is, Negrodom has to a great
extent qualified to vote. Half the population
is sunk in economic bondage and illiteracy, but the
other half has more than average capacity for citizenship."
The opinion so often expressed in
South Africa that “Education is a kind of thing
that doesn’t agree with the Nigger” is
born of the same feeling that animated the power-holding
minorities against the illiterate majorities in Europe
not many years ago, and, in justice to the minorities,
it must be conceded that the effect of education upon
the masses has always been disturbing and often disastrous.
Speaking now from my own experience
I can say that I have found no ill-effects from education
in Natives; on the contrary, I have found, as a rule,
that the Native who has had an ordinary school education
is generally more amenable to precept and admonition
than the raw kaffir though less bovinely submissive
and therefore more resentful of indignities offered
to him. The fact that the educated kaffir comes
more often in the way of committing theft and dishonesty
than his illiterate brother is in itself sufficient
to account for the not unduly large number of theftuous
crimes with which he is credited as a class; but on
the other hand, the propensity in the primitive male
that leads to sexual assaults upon women is undoubtedly
checked and lessened by education and school-discipline.
Education will bring out and give scope to all that
is good and all that is bad in the Native as it has
done with the white man. If the Natives have
not sunk to those depths of infamy which are disclosed
daily in the criminal courts of Europe and America
it is not because of want of the usual percentage of
criminally disposed people among them but because
of want of education and opportunity. Commercial
immorality and developed swindling are impossible
without a commerce, but the cupidity that begets these
forms of vice is not lacking amongst the Natives and
waits only for the opportunities which developed commerce
affords. The potential capacity for criminality
and immorality is indeed no less among the Natives
than among Europeans. Theft, arson, murder and
rape are the most common forms of crime committed
by the Natives to-day because the opportunities for
perpetrating systematic fraud are as yet few among
them. Unnatural immorality is common enough in
the kraals and in the “compounds,”
for the Natives have their “perverts”
as well as the whites. At the Native “beer-drinks”
crapulous lewdness is as common as it is in the bucolic
orgies of European peasantry. There is no “Native”
innocence nor is there any “Native” vice,
the virtue and the vice, the capacity and the character
of the Native are the human qualities and failings
that are common to mankind.
The Native is no more able to withstand
the enervating effects of isolation than the European,
he is no more anxious to work hard for small wages,
no more and no less capable of honesty and thrift,
no more and no less endowed with human virtue, no
more and no less cursed with the vices of the world,
no more human and no less divine than is his master,
the white man.
When Machiavelli asserts in general
of men that “they are ungrateful, fickle, false,
cowards, covetous, and as long as you succeed they
are yours entirely; they will offer you their blood,
property, life and children when the need
is far distant; but when it approaches they turn against
you.” He thought, no doubt, of white men
only, but to me his appreciation of the baser side
of human nature seems no less applicable to the black
people of South Africa, and when, on the other hand,
Shakespeare declaims:
“What a piece
of work is man! How noble in reason! How
infinite in
faculty!”
he also, we may be sure, thought of
his own kind, but to me, again, the beautiful words,
which usage cannot cheapen, express the wonder I have
often felt at the wealth of imagery, the mental grasp,
the wisdom and the natural dignity in very many untutored
natives I have met with, and it is this experience
which makes me believe that the present difference
between the Europeans and the Native race is one of
degree and not of kind, and that, in the fullness
of time, achievement will follow the latent genius
with which, as I hold, nature has endowed, in equal
degree with ourselves, the great Bantu branch of the
human family.
Yet I am no encomiast of the Natives,
for I know them to be no better than other people,
but search as I may, I cannot find that Native character
which is alleged to be inherently different from the
white man’s character. Did not Mark Twain
find, as the most conspicuous result of his travels,
that “there is a good deal of human nature everywhere,”
and is it not true that human nature is everywhere
the same?
We are far too apt to exaggerate both
in our disparagement and in our praise of backward
people. Many people still think, if they think
at all, of the South African Native as a being of
the kind imagined by Hobbes when he wrote: “Man
in his natural state is towards man as a wolf,”
and, on the other hand, there are still many who regard
him, after the fancy of Rousseau, as a sort of primitive
man-child existing in a state of natural innocence
from which he is being driven by the corrupting influence
of the civilised invaders. But all this is wrong.
The Native is not a savage. Even before the whites
came to South Africa the Bantu lived in social order
under a political system in which the principles of
constitutionalism were clearly recognised. To-day
the Bantu are simply a race of barbarians in various
stages of transition from a crude civilisation to
a highly developed civilisation, and we shall do well
to remember that the process of transition which we
are now witnessing is one in which individual mistakes
and failures will be more conspicuous, though no more
significant, than the general advance.