When La Boulaye recovered consciousness he was lying on his back in the middle of the courtyard of the Chateau de Bellecour.  From a great stone balcony above, a little group, of which Mademoiselle de Bellecour was the centre, observed the scene about the captive, who was being resuscitated that he might fittingly experience the Seigneur’s vengeance.

She had returned from the morning’s affair in the park with a conscience not altogether easy.  To have stood by whilst her father had struck Caron, and moreover, to have done so without any sense of horror, or even of regret, was a matter in which she asked herself whether she had done well.  Certainly La Boulaye had presumed unpardonably in speaking to her as he had spoken, and for his presumption it was fitting that he should be punished.  Had she interfered she must have seemed to sympathise, and thus the lesson might have suffered in salutariness.  And yet Caron La Boulaye was a man of most excellent exterior, and, when passion had roused him out of his restraint and awkwardness, of most ardent and eloquent address.  The very sombreness that ­be it from his mournful garments or from a mind of thoughtful habit ­seemed to envelop him was but an additional note of poetry in a personality which struck her now as eminently poetical.  In the seclusion of her own chamber, as she recalled the burning words and the fall of her father’s whip upon the young man’s pale face, she even permitted herself to sigh.  Had he but been of her own station, he had been such a man as she would have taken pride in being wooed by.  As it was ­she halted there and laughed disdainfully, yet with never so faint a note of regret.  It was absurd!  She was Mademoiselle de Bellecour, and he her father’s secretary; educated, if you will ­aye, and beyond his station ­but a vassal withal, and very humbly born.  Yes, it was absurd, she told herself again:  the eagle may not mate with the sparrow.

And when presently she had come from her chamber, she had been greeted with the story of a rebellion in the village, and an attempted assassination of her father.  The ringleader, she was told, had been brought to the Chateau, and he was even then in the courtyard and about to be hanged by the Marquis.  Curious to behold this unfortunate, she had stepped out on to the balcony where already an idle group had formed.  Inexpressible had been her shock upon seeing him that lay below, his white face upturned to the heavens, his eyes closed.

“Is he dead?” she asked, when presently she had overcome her feelings.

“Not yet Mademoiselle,” answered the graceful Chevalier de Jacquelin, toying with his solitaire.  “Your father is bringing him to life that he may send him back to death.”

And then she heard her father’s voice behind her.  The Marquis had stepped out on to the balcony to ascertain whether La Boulaye had yet regained consciousness.

“He seems to be even now recovering,” said someone.

“Ah, you are there, Suzanne,” cried Bellecour.  “You see your friend the secretary there.  He has chosen to present himself in a new rôle to-day.  From being my servant, it seems that he would constitute himself my murderer.”

However unfilial it might be, she could not stifle a certain sympathy for this young man.  She imagined that his rebellion, whatever shape it had assumed, had been provoked by that weal upon his face; and it seemed to her then that he had been less than a man had he not attempted to exact some reparation for the hurt the whip had inflicted at once upon his body and his soul.

“But what is it that he has done, Monsieur?” she asked, seeking more than the scant information which so far she had received.

“Enough, at least, to justify my hanging him,” answered Bellecour grimly.  “He sought to withstand my authority; he incited the peasants of Bellecour to withstand it; he has killed Blaise, and he would have killed me but that I preferred to let him kill my horse.”

“In what way did he seek to withstand your authority!” she persisted.

He stared at her, half surprised, half angry.

“What doers the manner of it signify?” he asked impatiently.  “Is not the fact enough?  Is it not enough that Blaise is dead, and that I have had a narrow escape, at his hands?”

“Insolent hound that he is!” put in Madame la Marquise ­a fleshly lady monstrously coiffed.  “If we allow such men as thus to live in France our days are numbered.”

“They say that you are going to hang him,” said Suzanne, heedless of her mother’s words, and there was the faintest note of horror in her voice.

“They are mistaken.  I am not.”

“You are not?” cried the Marquise.  “But what, then, do you intend to do?”

“To keep my word, madame,” he answered her.  “I promised that canaille that if he ever came within the grounds of Bellecour I would have him flogged to death.  That is what I propose.”

“Father,” gasped Suzanne, in horror, a horror that was echoed by the other three or four ladies present.  But the Marquise only laughed.

“He will be; richly served,” she approved, with a sage nod of her pumpkin-like head-dress ­“most richly served.”

A great pity arose now in the heart of Mademoiselle, as her father went below that he might carry out his barbarous design.  She was deaf to the dainty trifles which the most elegant Chevalier de Jacquelin was murmuring into her ear.  She stood, a tall, queenly figure, at the balcony’s parapet and watched the preparations that were being made.

She heard her father’s harshly-voiced commands.  She saw them literally tear the clothes from the unfortunate secretary’s back, and lash him ­naked to the waist ­to the pump that stood by the horse-trough at the far end of the yard.  His body was now hidden from her sight, but his head appeared surmounting the pillar of the pump, his chin seeming to rest upon its summit, and his face was towards her.  At his side stood a powerful knave armed with a stout, leather-thonged whip.

“How many strokes, Monseigneur?” she heard the man inquire.

“How many?” echoed the Marquise.  “Do I know how many it will take to make an end of him?  Beat him to death, man.  Allons!  Set about it.”

She saw the man uncoil his lash and step forward.  In that instant Caron’s eyes were raised, and they met hers across the intervening space.  He smiled a valedictory smile that seemed to make her heart stand still.  She and her mother were now the only women on the balcony.  The others had made haste to withdraw as soon as La Boulaye had been pilloried.  The Marquise remained because she seemed to find entertainment in the spectacle.  Suzanne remained because horror rooted her to the spot ­horror and a great pity for this unfortunate who had looked so strong and brave that morning, when he had had the audacity to tell her that he loved her.

The lash sang through the air, quivered, hummed, and cut with a sickening crackle into the young man’s flesh.

The hideous sound roused her.  She shuddered from head to foot, and turning she put her hands to her face and rushed within, followed by the Marquise’s derisive laughter.

“Mon Dieu!  It is horrible!  Horrible!” she cried as she sank into the nearest chair, and clapped her hands to her ears.  But she could not shut it out.  Still she heard the humming of the whip and the cruel sound of the falling blows.  Mechanically she counted them, unconsciously almost, and at twenty she heard them cease.  Was it over?  Was he dead, this poor unfortunate?  Moved by a curiosity that was greater than her loathing, she rose and went to the threshold of the balcony.

“Is it ended?” she asked.

“Ended?” echoed Monsieur de Jacquelin, with a shrug.  “It is scarce begun, it seems.  The executioner is pausing for breath, that is all.  The fellow has not uttered a sound.  He is as obstinate as a mule.”

“As enduring as a Spartan,” more generously put in the Vicomte, her brother.  “Look at him, Suzanne.”

Almost involuntarily she obeyed, and moved forward a step that she might behold him.  A face, deathly pale, she saw, which in the sunshine glistened with the sweat of agony that bedewed it; but the lips were tightly closed and the countenance grimly expressionless.  Even as she looked she heard her father command the man to lay on anew.  Then, as before, his eyes met hers; but this time no smile did she see investing them.

Again the whip cracked and fell.  She drew back, but his glance seemed to haunt her even when she no longer saw his face.  A sudden resolution moved her, and in a frenzy of anger and compassion she flung out of the room.  A moment later she burst like a beautiful virago into the courtyard.

“Stop!” she commanded shrilly, causing both her father and the executioner to turn, and the latter pausing in his hideous work.  But a glance from the Marquis bade him resume, and resume he did, as though there had been no interruption.

“What is this?” demanded Bellecour, half amused, half vexed, whilst a sudden new light leapt to the eyes of La Boulaye, which but a moment back had been so full of agony.

But Mademoiselle never paused to answer her father.  Seeing the executioner proceeding, despite her call to cease, she sprang upon him, caught him by the arms and wrested the whip from hands that dared not resist her.

“Did I not bid you stop?” she blazed, her face white, her eyes on fire; and raising the whip she brought it down upon his head and shoulders, not once but half-a-dozen times in quick succession, until he fled, howling, to the other side of the horse trough for shelter.  “It stings you, does it” she cried, whilst the Marquis, from angered that at first he had been, now burst into a laugh at her fury and at this turning of tables upon the executioner.  She made shift to pursue the fellow to his place of refuge, but coming of a sudden upon the ghastly sight presented by La Boulaye’s lacerated back, she drew back in horror.  Then, mastering herself ­for girl though she was, her courage was of a high order ­she turned to her father.

“Give this man to me, Monsieur,” she begged.

“To you!” he exclaimed.  “What will you do with him?”

“I will see that you are rid of him,” she promised.  “What more can you desire?  You have tortured him enough.”

“Maybe.  But am I to blame that he dies so hard?”

She answered him with renewed insistence, and unexpectedly she received an ally in M. des Cadoux ­an elderly gentleman who had been observing the flogging with disapproval, and who had followed her into the courtyard.

“He is too brave a man to die like this, Bellecour,” put in the newcomer.  “I doubt if he can survive the punishment he has already received.  Yet I would ask you, in the name of courage, to give him the slender chance he may have.”

“I promised him he should be flogged to death ­” began the Marquis, when Des Cadoux and Mademoiselle jointly interrupted him to renew their intercessions.

“But, sangdieu,” the Marquis protested “you seem to forget that he has killed one of my servants.”

“Why, then, you should have hanged him out of hand, not tortured him thus,” answered Des Cadoux shortly.

For a moment it almost seemed as if the pair of them would have fallen a-quarrelling.  Their words grew more heated, and then, while they were still wrangling, the executioner came forward to solve matters with the news that the secretary had expired.  To Bellecour this proved a very welcome conclusion.

“Most opportunely!” he laughed “Had the rascal lived another minute I think we had quarrelled, Cadoux.”  He turned to the servant, “You are certain that it is so?” he asked.

“Look, Monsieur,” said the fellow, as he pointed with his whip to the pilloried figure of La Boulaye.  The Marquis looked, and saw that the secretary had collapsed, and hung limp in his bonds, his head fallen back upon his shoulders and his eyes closed.

With a shrug and a short laugh Bellecour turned to his daughter.

“You may take the carrion, if you want to.  But I think you can do no more than order it to be flung into a ditch and buried there.”

But she had no mind to be advised by him.  She had the young man’s body cut down from the pump, and she bade a couple of servants convey it to the house of Master Duhamel, she for remembered that La Boulaye and the old pedagogue were friends.

“An odd thing is a woman’s heart,” grumbled the Marquis, who begrudged La Boulaye even his last act of mercy.  “She may care never a fig for a man, and yet, if he has but told her that he loves her, be he never so mean and she never so exalted, he seems thereby to establish some measure of claim to her.”