Stanley Fyles’s extreme satisfaction was less enduring than might have been expected.  Success, and the prospect of success, were matters calculated to affect him more nearly than anything else in his life.  That was the man, as he always had been; that was the man, who, in so brief a time, had raised himself to the commissioned ranks of his profession.  But, somehow, just now a slight undercurrent of thought and feeling had set in.  It was scarcely perceptible at first, but growing rapidly, it quickly robbed the tide of his satisfaction of quite half its strength, and came near to reducing it to the condition of slack water.

McBain was in the quarters attending to the detail which fell to his lot.  A messenger from Winter’s Crossing had come in announcing the arrival, at that camp, of the reinforcing patrol.  This was the culminating point of Fyles’s satisfaction.  From that moment the undercurrent set in.

The inspector had moved out of the bluff, which screened the temporary quarters from chance observation, and had taken up a position on the shoulder of the valley, where he sat himself upon a fallen fence post to consider the many details of the work he had in mind.

The sun was setting in a ruddy cauldron of summer cloud, and, already, the evening mists were rising from the heart of the superheated valley.  The wonderful peace of the scene might well have been a sedative to the stream of rapid thought pouring through his busy brain.

But its soothing powers seemed to have lost virtue, and, as his almost unconscious gaze took in the beauties spread out before it, a curious look of unrest replaced the satisfaction in his keen eyes.  His brows drew together in a peevish frown.  A discontent set the corners of his tightly compressed lips drooping, and once or twice he stirred impatiently, as though his irritation of mind had communicated itself to his physical nerves.

Once more the image of Kate Seton had risen up before his mind’s eye, and, for the first time it brought him no satisfaction.  For the first time he had associated the probable object of his plans with her.  Charlie Bryant was no longer a mere offender against the law in his mind.  In concentrating his official efforts against him he realized the jeopardy in which his own regard for Kate Seton placed him.  He saw that his success now in ridding the district of the whisky-runner would, at the same time, rob him of all possible chance of ever obtaining the regard of this woman he loved.  It meant an ostracism based upon the strongest antipathy the antipathy of a woman wounded in her tenderest emotions, that wonderful natural instinct which is perhaps beyond everything else in her life.

The more than pity of it.  Kate’s interest in Charlie Bryant had assumed proportions which threatened to overwhelm his whole purpose.  It became almost a tragedy.  Pondering upon this ominous realization a sort of panic came near to taking hold of him.  Apart from his own position, the pain and suffering he knew he must inflict upon her set him flinching.

Her protestations of Charlie’s innocence were very nearly absurd.  To a mind trained like his there was little enough doubt of the man’s offense.  He was a rank “waster,” but, as in the case of all such creatures, there was a woman ready to believe in him with all the might of feminine faith.  It was a bitter thought that in this case Kate Seton should be the woman.  She did believe.  He was convinced of her honesty in her declaration.  She believed from the bottom of her heart, she, a woman of such keen sense and intelligence.  It was yes, it was maddening.  Through it all he saw his duty lying plainly before him.  His whole career was at stake, that career for which only he had hitherto lived, and which, eventually, he had hoped to lay at Kate’s feet.

What could he do?  There was no other way.  He must go on.  His dream was wrecking.  It was being demolished before his eyes.  It was not being sent crushing at one mighty stroke, but was being torn to shreds and destroyed piecemeal.

He strove to stiffen himself before the blow, and his very attitude expressed something of his effort.  He told himself a dozen times that he must accept the verdict, and carry his duty through, his duty to himself as well as to his superiors.  But conviction was lacking.  The human nature in him was rebelling.  For all his discipline it would not be denied.  And with each passing moment it was gaining in its power to make itself felt and heard.

Its promptings came swiftly, and in a direction hardly conceivable in a man of his balance of mind.  But the more sure the strength of the man, the more sure the strength of the old savage lurking beneath the sanest thought.  The savage rose up in him now in a reckless challenge to all that was best and most noble in him.  A cruel suspicion swept through his mind and quickly permeated his whole outlook.  What if he had read Kate’s regard for the man Bryant wrong?  What if he had read it as she intended him to read it, seeking to blind him to the true facts?  He knew her for a clever woman, a shrewd woman, even a daring woman.  What if she had read through his evident regard for her, and had determined to turn it to account in saving her lover from disaster, by posing with a maternal, or sisterly regard for his welfare?  Such things he felt had been done.  He was to be a tool, a mere tool in her hands, the poor dupe whose love had betrayed him.

He sprang from his seat.

No, a thousand times no, he told himself.  His memory of her beautiful, dark, fearless eyes was too plainly in his mind for that.  The honesty of her concern and regard for the man was too simply plain to hold any trace of the perfidy which his thought suggested.  He told himself these things.  He told himself again and again, and remained unconvinced.  The savage in him, the human nature was gaining an ascendancy that would not be denied, and from the astute, disciplined man he really was, at a leap, he became the veriest doubting lover.

He threw his powerful arms out, and stretched himself.  His movements were the movements of unconcern, but there was no unconcern within him.  A teeming, harassing thought was urging him, driving him to the only possible course whereby he could hope to obtain a resumption of his broken peace of mind.

He must see Kate.  He must see her again, without delay.

Kate Seton was sitting in the northern shadow of her little house the following morning when Stanley Fyles rode down the southern slope of the valley toward the old footbridge.  She had just dispatched Big Brother Bill on an errand to the village, and, with feminine tact, had requested him to discover Helen’s whereabouts, and send her, or bring her home.  She had no particular desire that Helen should return home.  In fact, she would rather she didn’t until mid-day dinner.  But she felt she was giving the man the excuse he evidently needed.

As a matter of fact, she had a good deal of work to do.  And the first hour after Bill had taken his departure she was fully occupied with her two villainous hired men.  After that she returned to the house, and wrote several letters, and, finally, took up her position in the shade, and devoted herself to a basket of long-neglected sewing.

At the sound of the approaching horseman she looked up with a start.  She had no expectation of a visitor, she had no desire for one just now.  Nevertheless, when she discovered the officer’s identity, she displayed no surprise, and more interest, than might have been expected.

She did not disguise from herself the feelings this man inspired.  On the contrary she rather reveled in them, especially as, in a way, just now, all her actions must be in direct antagonism to his efforts.

She felt that a battle, a big battle, must be fought and won between them.  It was a battle to be fought out openly and frankly.  It was her determination that this man should not wrong himself by committing a great wrong upon Charlie Bryant.

Kate was very busy at the moment Fyles rode up.  She was intent upon fitting a piece of lace, obviously too small, upon a delicate white garment of her sister’s, which was obviously too big.

For a moment, as she did not look up, Fyles sat leaning forward in the saddle with his arms resting upon its horn.  He was watching her with a smiling interest which was not without anxiety.

“There’s surely not a dandier picture in the world than a girl sitting in the shade sewing white things,” he said at last, by way of greeting.

Kate glanced up for the briefest of smiling glances.  Then her dark head bent over her sewing again.

“And there’s surely nothing calculated to upset things more than a man butting in, where the same girl’s fragment of brain is worrying to fit something that doesn’t fit anyway.”

“Meaning me?”

Fyles smiled in his confident way.

“Seeing there’s no one else around, I must have meant some other fellow.”

Kate laid the lace aside, and looked up with a sigh.  A gentle amusement shone in her fine dark eyes.

“Have you ever tried to make things fit that just won’t?” she demanded.

Fyles shook his head.

“Maybe I can help, though,” he hazarded.

“Help?” Kate’s amusement merged into a laugh.  “Say, when it comes to fitting things that don’t fit, two heads generally muss things right up.  All my life I’ve been trying to fit things that don’t fit, and I find, if you’re to succeed, you’ve got to do it to yourself, and by yourself.  It always takes a big lot of thinking which nobody else can follow.  Maybe your way of thinking is different from other folks, and so they can’t understand, and that’s why they can’t follow it.  Now here’s a bit of lace, and there’s a sleeve.  The lace is short by an inch.  Still there’s ways and ways of fixing it, but only one right way.  If I make the sleeve smaller the lace will fit, but poor Helen won’t get her arm through it.  If I tack on a bit more lace it’ll muss the job, and make it look bad.  Then there’s other ways, too, but there’s only one right way.”  She dropped the lace in her basket and began to fold the garment.  “I’ll get some new lace that does fit,” she declared emphatically.

Fyles nodded, but the amusement died out of his eyes.

“All of which is sound sense,” he said seriously, “and is leading us toward controversial er subjects.  Eh?”

Kate raised a pair of shoulders with pretended indifference.  But her eyes were smiling that challenge which Stanley Fyles always associated with her.

“Not a bad thing when the police are getting so very busy, and you are their chief in the district,” she said.

“I must once more remark, you are well informed,” smiled Fyles.

“And I must once more remark not as well informed as I could wish,” retorted Kate quickly.

Fyles had permitted his gaze to wander down the wooded course of the river.  Kate was watching him closely, speculatively.  And curious enough she was thinking more of the man than his work at that moment.

The man’s eyes came back abruptly to her face, and her expression was instantly changed to one of smiling irony.

“Well?” she demanded.

Fyles shook his head.

“It isn’t,” he said.  “May I ask how you know we are so very busy?”

“Sure,” cried Kate, with a frank laugh.  “You see, I have two of the worst scamps in the valley working for me, and they seem to think it more than necessary that they keep themselves posted as to your movements.”

“I see.”  Fyles’s lighter mood had entirely passed, and with its going Kate’s became more marked.  “I s’pose they spy out everything for the benefit of their chief.”

Kate clapped her hands.

“What reasoning.  I s’pose they have a chief?” she added slyly.

A frown of irritation crossed the policeman’s brow.

“Must we open up that old sore, Miss Kate?” he, asked almost sharply.  “They are known to be when not occupied with the work of your farm assisting Charlie Bryant in his whisky-running schemes.  They are two of his lieutenants.”

“And so, because they are so known among the village people here, you are prosecuting this campaign against a man whom you hope to catch red-handed.”

“I have sufficient personal evidence to prosecute my campaign,” said Fyles quickly.  “As you said just now, we are not idle.”

“Yes, I know,” Kate sighed, and her gaze was turned upon the western reaches of the valley.  “Your camp out there is full of activity.  So is Winter’s Crossing.  And the care with which you mask your coming and going is known to everybody.  It is a case of the hunter being hunted.  Yes, I say it without resentment, I am glad of these things, because I must know.”

“If we are against each other it is only natural you should wish to know.”

Kate’s eyes opened wider.

“Of course we are against each other, as long as you are against Charlie.  But only in our official capacities.”  A whimsical smile stole into the woman’s eyes.  “Oh, you are so so obstinate,” she cried in mock despair.  “In this valley it is no trouble for me to watch your every move, and, in Charlie’s interests, to endeavor to frustrate them.  But the worst of it is I’d I’d like to see you win out.  Instead of that I know you won’t.  You’ve had some news.  You had it yesterday, I suppose, by that patrol.  Maybe it’s news of another cargo coming in, and you are getting ready to capture it, and Charlie.  I’m not here to give any one away, I’m not here to tell you all I know, must know, living in the valley, but you are doomed, utterly doomed to failure, if you count the capture of Charlie success.”

In spite of the lightness of Kate’s manner her words were not without their effect upon Fyles.  There was a ring of sincerity in them that would not be denied.  But its effect upon him was not that which she could have wished.  His face set almost sternly.  The challenge of the woman had stirred him out of his calm assurance, but it was in a direction which she could scarcely have expected.  He thrust his sunburned face forward more aggressively, and challenged her in return.

“What is this man to you?” he demanded, his square jaws seeming to clip his question the more shortly.

In a moment Kate’s face was flushing her resentment.  Her dark eyes were sparkling with a sudden leaping anger.

“You have no right to ask me that,” she cried.  But Fyles had committed himself.  Nor would he draw back.

“Haven’t I?” he laughed harshly.  “All’s fair in love and war.  We are at war officially.”

The woman’s flushing cheeks remained, but the sparkle of her eyes had changed again to an ironical light.

“War yes.  Perhaps you’re right.  The only courtesies recognized in war are observed in the prize ring, and in international warfare.  Our warfare must be less exalted, and permits hitting below the belt.  I’ve told you what Charlie is to me, and I have told you truly.  I am trying to defend an innocent man, who is no more to me than a brother, or or son.  I am doing so because of his peculiar ailments which make him well-nigh incapable of helping himself.  You see, he does not care.  His own safety, his own welfare, are nothing to him.  It is for that reason, for the way he acts in consequence of these things, that all men believe him a rogue, and a a waster.  I tell you he is neither.”

She finished up a little breathlessly.  She had permitted her loyalty and anxiety to carry her beyond the calm fencing she had intended.

But Fyles remained unmoved, except that the harshness had gone out of his manner.

“It is not I who am obstinate,” he said soberly.  “It is you, Miss Kate.  What if I told you I had irrefutable circumstantial evidence against him?  Would that turn you from your faith in him?”

The woman shook her head.

“It would be merely circumstantial evidence,” she said.  “God knows how circumstance has filled our penitentiaries wrongfully,” she added bitterly.

“And but for circumstance our population of wrongdoers at large would be greater by a thousand per cent.,” retorted the officer.

“That is supposition,” smiled Kate.

“Which does not rob it of its possibility in fact.”

The two sat looking at each other, silently defiant.  Kate was smiling.  A great excitement was thrilling her, and she liked this man all the better for his blunt readiness for combat, even with her.

Fyles was wondering at this woman, half angry, half pleased.  Her strength and readiness appealed to him as a wonderful display.

He was the first to speak, and, in doing so, he felt he was acknowledging his worsting in the encounter.

“It’s it’s impossible to fight like this,” he said lamely.  “I am not accustomed to fight with women.”

“Does it matter, so long as a woman can fight?” Kate cried quickly.  “Chivalry?” she went on contemptuously.  “That’s surely a survival of ages when the old curfew rang, and a lot of other stupid notions filled folks’ minds.  I I just love to fight.”

Her smile was so frankly infectious that Fyles found himself responding.  He heaved a sigh.

“It’s no good,” he said almost hopelessly.  “You must stick to your belief, and I to mine.  All I hope, Miss Kate, is that when I’ve done with this matter the pain I’ve inflicted on you will not be unforgivable.”

The woman’s eyes were turned away.  They had become very soft as she gazed over at the distant view of Charlie’s house.

“I don’t think it will be,” she said gently.  Then with a quick return to her earlier manner:  “You see, you will never get the chance of hurting Charlie.”  A moment later she inquired naively:  “When is the cargo coming in?”

But Fyles’s exasperation was complete.

“When?” he cried.  “Why, when this scamp is ready for it.  It’s it’s no use, Miss Kate.  I can’t stop, or or I’ll be forgetting you are a woman, and say ‘Damn!’ I admit you have bested me, but young Bryant hasn’t.  I ” he broke off, laughing in spite of his annoyance, and Kate cordially joined in.

“But he will,” she cried, as Peter began to move away.  “Good-bye, Mr. Fyles,” she added, in her ironical fashion as she picked up her sewing.  “I can get on with these important matters now.”

The man’s farewell was no less cordial, and his better sense told him that in accepting his defeat at her hands he had won a good deal in another direction where he hoped to finally achieve her capitulation.

While the skirmish between Stanley Fyles and Kate Seton was going on, the object of it was discussing the doings of the police and the prospect of the coming struggle with Big Brother Bill on the veranda of his house.

He was leaning against one of its posts while Bill reposed on the hard seat of a Windsor chair, seeking what comfort he could find in the tremendous heat by abandoning all superfluous outer garments.

Charlie’s face was darkly troubled.  His air was peevishly irritable.

“Bill,” he said, with a deep thrill of earnestness in his voice, as he thrust his brown, delicate hands into the tops of his trousers.  “All the trouble in the world’s just about to start, if I’m a judge of the signs of things.  There’s a whole crowd of the police in the valley now.  They’re camped higher up.  They think we don’t know, but we do all of us.  I wonder what they think they’re going to do?”

His manner became more excited, and his voice grew deeper and deeper.

“They think they’re going to get a big haul of liquor.  They think they’re going to get me.  I tell you, Bill, that for men trained to smelling things out, they’re blunderers.  Their methods are clumsy as hell.  I could almost laugh, if if I didn’t feel sick at their coming around.”

Bill stirred uneasily.

“If there were no whisky-running here they wouldn’t be around,” he said pointedly.

Charlie eyed him curiously.

“No,” he said.  Then he added, “And if there were no whisky-running there’d be no village here.  If there were no village here we shouldn’t be here.  Kate and her sister wouldn’t be here.  Nothing would be here, but the old pine that goes on forever.  This village lives on the prohibition law.  Fyles may have a reputation, but he’s clumsy damned clumsy.  I’d like to see ahead the next few days.”

“He’s smelling a cargo coming in, isn’t he?” Bill’s tact was holding him tight.

Again Charlie looked at him curiously before he replied.

“That’s how they reckon,” he said guardedly, at last.

Bill had turned away, vainly searching his unready wit for the best means of carrying on the discussion.  Suddenly his eyes lit, and he pointed across at the Seton’s house.

“Say, who’s that on that horse?  Isn’t it Fyles?  He’s talking to some one.  Looks like ”

He broke off.  Charlie was staring out in the direction indicated, and, in a moment, his excitement passed, swallowed up in a frowning, brooding light that had suddenly taken possession of his dark eyes.

Bill finally broke the uncomfortable silence.

“It’s Fyles?” he said.

“Yes, it’s Fyles,” said Charlie, with a sudden suppressed fury.  “It’s Fyles curse him, and he’s talking to Kate.”

At the sound of his brother’s tone, even Bill realized his blundering.  He knew he had fired a train of passion that was to be deplored, even dreaded in his brother.  He blamed himself bitterly for his lack of forethought, his absurd want of discretion.

But the mischief was done.  Charlie had forgotten everything else.

Bill stirred again in his chair.

“What does he want down there?” he demanded, for lack of something better to say.

“What does he want?” Charlie laughed.  It was an unpleasant laugh, a savage laugh.  It was a laugh that spoke of sore heart, and feelings crowding with bitterness.  “I guess he wants something he’ll never get while I’m alive.”

He relapsed into moody silence, and a new expression grew in his eyes till it even dominated that which had shone in them before.  Bill thought he recognized it.  The word “funk” flashed through his mind, and left him wondering.  What could Charlie have to fear from Fyles talking to Kate?  Did he believe that Kate would let the officer pump her with regard to his, Charlie’s, movements!

Yes, that must be it.

“He won’t get more than five cents for his dollar out of her,” he said, in an effort to console.

Charlie was round on him in a flash.

“Five cents for a dollar?  No,” he cried, “nor one cent, nor a fraction of a cent.  Fyles is dealing with the cleverest, keenest woman I’ve ever met in all my life.  I’m not thinking that way.  I’m thinking how almighty easy it is for a man walking a broken trail to trip and smash himself right up.  The more sure he is the worse is his fall, because he takes big chances, and big chances mean big falls.  You’ve hit it, Bill, I’m scared scared to death just now.  If I know Fyles there’s going to be one hell of a time around here, and, if you value your future, get clear while you can.  I’m scared, Bill, scared and mad.  I can’t stand to watch that man talking to Kate.  I’m not scared of man or devil, but I’m scared scared to death when I see that.  I must get out of this.  I must get away, or ”

He moved off the veranda in a frantic state of nervous passion.

Bill sprang from his seat and was at his brother’s side in two great strides, and his big hand fell with no little force upon the latter’s arm and held it.

“What do you mean?” he cried apprehensively.  “Where where are you going?”

With surprising strength Charlie flung him off.  He turned, facing him with angry eyes and flushed face.

“Don’t you dare lay hand on me like that again, Bill,” he cried dangerously.  “I don’t stand for that from anybody.  I’m going down the village, since you want to know.  I’m going down to O’Brien’s.  And you can get it right now that I wouldn’t stand the devil himself butting in to stop me.”