By this time the nature of the Slave-trade
had, in consequence of the labours of the commitee
and of their several correspondents, become generally
known throughout the kingdom. It had excited a
general attention, and there was among people a general
feeling in behalf of the wrongs of Africa. This
feeling had also, as may be collected from what has
been already mentioned, broken out into language:
for not only had the traffic become the general subject
of conversation, but public meetings had taken place,
in which it had been discussed, and of which the result
was, that an application to parliament had been resolved
upon in many places concerning it. By the middle
of February not fewer than thirty-five petitions had
been delivered to the commons, and it was known that
others were on their way to the same house.
This ferment in the public mind, which
had shown itself in the public prints even before
the petitions had been resolved upon, had excited the
attention of government. To coincide with the
wishes of the people on this subject, appeared to
those in authority to be a desirable thing. To
abolish the trade, replete as it was with misery,
was desirable also: but it was so connected with
the interest of individuals, and so interwoven with
the commerce and revenue of the country, that an hasty
abolition of it without a previous inquiry appeared
to them to be likely to be productive of as much misery
as good. The king, therefore, by an order of council,
dated February the eleventh, 1788, directed that a
commitee of privy council should sit as a board of
trade, “to take into their consideration the
present state of the African trade, particularly as
far as related to the practice and manner of purchasing
or obtaining slaves on the coast of Africa, and the
importation and sale thereof, either in the British
colonies and settlements, or in the foreign colonies
and settlements in America or the West-Indies; and
also as far as related to the effects and consequences
of the trade both in Africa and in the said colonies
and settlements, and to the general commerce of this
kingdom; and that they should report to him in council
the result of their inquiries, with such observations
as they might have to offer thereupon.”
Of this order of council Mr. Wilberforce,
who had attended to this great subject, as far as
his health would permit since I left him, had received
notice; but he was then too ill himself to take any
measures concerning it. He therefore wrote to
me, and begged of me to repair to London immediately
in order to get such evidence ready, as we might think
it eligible to introduce when the council sat.
At that time, as appears from the former chapter,
I had finished the additions to my Essay on the Slavery
and Commerce of the Human Species, and I had now proceeded
about half way in that of the Impolicy of it.
This summons, however, I obeyed, and returned to town
on the fourteenth of February, from which day to the
twenty-fourth of May I shall now give the history
of our proceedings.
My first business in London was to
hold a conversation with Mr. Pitt previously to the
meeting of the council, and to try to interest him,
as the first minister of state, in our favour.
For this purpose Mr. Wilberforce had opened the way
for me, and an interview took place. We were
in free conversation together for a considerable time,
during which we went through most of the branches
of the subject. Mr. Pitt appeared to me to have
but little knowledge of it. He had also his doubts,
which he expressed openly, on many points. He
was at a loss to conceive how private interest should
not always restrain the master of the slave from abusing
him. This matter I explained to him as well as
I could; and if he was not entirely satisfied with
my interpretation of it, he was at lease induced to
believe that cruel practices were more probable than
he had imagined. A second circumstance, of the
truth of which he doubted, was the mortality and usage
of seamen in this trade; and a third was the statement,
by which so much had been made of the riches of Africa,
and of the genius and abilities of her people; for
he seemed at a loss to comprehend, if these things
were so, how it had happened that they should not
have been more generally noticed before. I promised
to satisfy him upon these points, and an interview
was fixed for this purpose the next day.
At the time appointed I went with
my books, papers, and African productions. Mr.
Pitt examined the former himself. He turned over
leaf after leaf, in which the copies of the muster-rolls
were contained, with great patience; and when he had
looked over above a hundred pages accurately, and
found the name of every seaman inserted, his former
abode or service, the time of his entry, and what
had become of him, either by death, discharge or desertion,
he expressed his surprise at the great pains which
had been taken in this branch of the inquiry, and confessed,
with some emotion, that his doubts were wholly removed
with respect to the destructive nature of this employ;
and he said, moreover, that the facts contained in
these documents, if they had been but fairly copied,
could never be disproved. He was equally astonished
at the various woods and other productions of Africa,
but most of all at the manufactures of the natives
in cotton, leather, gold, and iron, which were laid
before him. These he handled and examined over
and over again. Many sublime thoughts seemed
to rush in upon him at once at the sight of these,
some of which he expressed with observations becoming
a great and a dignified mind. He thanked me for
the light I had given him on many of the branches of
this great question. And I went away under a
certain conviction that I had left him much impressed
in our favour.
My next visit was to Mr. (now Lord)
Grenville. I called upon him at the request of
Mr. Wilberforce, who had previously written to him
from Bath, as be had promised to attend the meetings
of the privy council during the examinations which
were to take place. I found in the course of our
conversation that Mr. Grenville had not then more knowledge
of the subject than Mr. Pitt; but I found him differently
circumstanced in other respects, for I perceived in
him a warm feeling in behalf of the injured Africans,
and that he had no doubt of the possibility of all
the barbarities which had been alleged against this
traffic. I showed him all my papers and some
of my natural productions, which he examined.
I was with him the next day, and once again afterwards,
so that the subject was considered in all its parts.
The effect of this interview with him was of course
different from that upon the minister. In the
former case I had removed doubts, and given birth
to an interest in favour of our cause. But I had
here only increased an interest which had already
been excited. I had only enlarged the mass of
feeling, or added zeal to zeal, or confirmed resolutions
and reasonings. Disposed in this manner originally
himself, and strengthened by the documents with which
I had furnished him, Mr. Grenville contracted an enmity
to the Slave-trade, which was never afterwards diminished.
A report having gone abroad, that
the commitee of privy council would only examine those
who were interested in the continuance of the trade,
I found it necessary to call upon Mr. Pitt again,
and to inform him of it, when I received an assurance
that every person, whom I chose to send to the council
in behalf of the commitee, should be heard. This
gave rise to a conversation relative to those witnesses
whom we had to produce on the side of the abolition.
And here I was obliged to disclose our weakness in
this respect. I owned with sorrow that, though
I had obtained specimens and official documents in
abundance to prove many important points, yet I had
found it difficult to prevail upon persons to be publicly
examined on this subject. The only persons, we
could then count upon, were Mr. Ramsay, Mr. H. Gandy,
Mr. Falconbridge, Mr. Newton, and the Dean of Middleham.
There was one, however, who would be a host of himself,
if we could but gain him. I then mentioned Mr.
Norris. I told Mr. Pitt the nature and value
of the testimony which he had given me at Liverpool,
and the great zeal he had discovered to serve the
cause. I doubted, however, if he would come to
London for this purpose, even if I wrote to him; for
he was intimate with almost all the owners of slave-vessels
in Liverpool, and living among these he would not
like to incur their resentment, by taking a prominent
part against them. I therefore entreated Mr.
Pitt to send him a summons of council to attend, hoping
that Mr. Norris would then be pleased to come up,
as he would be enabled to reply to his friends, that
his appearance had not been voluntary. Mr. Pitt,
however, informed me, that a summons from a commitee
of privy council sitting as a board of trade was not
binding upon the subject, and therefore that I had
no other means left but of writing to him, and he
desired me to do this by the first post.
This letter I accordingly wrote, and
sent it to my friend William Rathbone, who was to
deliver it in person, and to use his own influence
at the same time; but I received for answer, that
Mr. Norris was then in London. Upon this I tried
to find him out, to entreat him to consent to an examination
before the council. At length I found his address;
but before I could see him, I was told by the Bishop
of London, that he had come up as a Liverpool delegate
in support of the Slave-trade. Astonished at this
information, I made the bishop acquainted with the
case, and asked him how it became me to act; for I
was fearful lest, by exposing Mr. Norris, I should
violate the rights of hospitality on the one hand,
and by not exposing him, that I should not do my duty
to the cause I had undertaken on the other. His
advice was, that I should see him, and ask him to explain
the reasons of his conduct. I called upon him
for this purpose, but he was out. He sent me,
however, a letter soon afterwards, which was full of
flattery, and in which, after having paid high compliments
to the general force of my arguments, and the general
justice and humanity of my sentiments on this great
question, which had made a deep impression upon his
mind, he had found occasion to differ from me, since
we had last parted, on particular points, and that
he had therefore less reluctantly yielded to the call
of becoming a delegate, though notwithstanding
he would gladly have declined the office if he could
have done it with propriety.
At length the council began their
examinations. Mr. Norris, Lieutenant Matthews,
of the navy, who had just left a slave-employ in Africa,
and Mr. James Penny, formerly a slave-captain, and
then interested as a merchant in the trade, (which
three were the delegates from Liverpool) took possession
of the ground first. Mr. Miles, Mr. Weuves, and
others, followed them on the same side. The evidence
which they gave, as previously concerted between themselves,
may be shortly represented thus: They denied that
kidnapping either did or could take place in Africa,
or that wars were made there, for the purpose of procuring
slaves. Having done away these wicked practices
from their system, they maintained positions which
were less exceptionable, or that the natives of Africa
generally became slaves in consequence of having been
made prisoners in just wars, or in consequence of
their various crimes. They then gave a melancholy
picture of the despotism and barbarity of some of
the African princes, among whom the custom of sacrificing
their own subjects prevailed. But, of all others,
that which was afforded by Mr. Morris on this ground
was the most frightful. The king of Dahomey,
he said, sported with the lives of his people in the
most wanton manner. He had seen at the gates of
his palace, two piles of heads like those of shot
in an arsenal. Within the palace the heads of
persons newly put to death were strewed at the distance
of a few yards in the passage which led to his apartment.
This custom of human sacrifice by the king of Dahomey
was not on one occasion only, but on many; such as
on the reception of messengers from neighbouring states,
or of white merchants, or on days of ceremonial.
But the great carnage was once a year, when the poll
tax was paid by his subjects. A thousand persons
at least were sacrificed annually on these different
occasions. The great men, too, of the country
cut off a few heads on festival-days. From all
these particulars the humanity of the Slave-trade
was inferred, because it took away the inhabitants
of Africa into lands where no such barbarities were
known. But the humanity of it was insisted upon
by positive circumstances also, namely, that a great
number of the slaves were prisoners of war, and that
in former times all such were put to death, whereas
now they were saved; so that there was a great accession
of happiness to Africa since the introduction of the
Trade.
These statements, and those of others
on the same side of the question, had a great effect,
as may easily be conceived, upon the feelings of those
of the council who were present. Some of them
began immediately to be prejudiced against us.
There were others who even thought that it was almost
unnecessary to proceed in the inquiry, for that the
Trade was actually a blessing. They had little
doubt that all our assertions concerning it would
be found false. The Bishop of London himself was
so impressed by these unexpected accounts, that he
asked me if Falconbridge, whose pamphlet had been
previously sent by the commitee to every member of
the council, was worthy of belief, and if he would
substantiate publicly what he had thus written.
But these impressions unfortunately were not confined
to those who had been present at the examinations.
These could not help communicating them to others.
Hence in all the higher circles (some of which I sometimes
used to frequent) I had the mortification to hear of
nothing but the Liverpool evidence, and of our own
credulity, and of the impositions which had been practised
upon us: of these reports the planters and merchants
did not fail to avail themselves. They boasted
that they would soon do away all the idle tales which
had been invented against them. They desired
the public only to suspend their judgment till the
privy council report should be out, when they would
see the folly and wickedness of all our allegations.
A little more evidence, and all would be over.
On the twenty-second of March, though the commitee
of council had not then held its sittings more than
a month, and these only twice or thrice a week, the
following paragraph was seen in a morning paper: “The
report of the commitee of privy council will be ready
in a few days. After due examination it appears
that the major part of the complaints against this
Trade are ill-founded. Some regulations, however,
are expected to take place, which may serve in a certain
degree to appease the cause of humanity.”
But while they who were interested
had produced this outcry against us, in consequence
of what had fallen from their own witnesses in the
course of their examinations, they had increased it
considerably by the industrious circulation of a most
artful pamphlet among persons of rank and fortune at
the West end of the metropolis, which was called, Scriptural
Researches on the Licitness of the Slave-trade.
This they had procured to be written by R. Harris,
who was then clerk in a slave-house in Liverpool, but
had been formerly a clergyman and a Jesuit. As
they had maintained in the first instance, as has
been already shown, the humanity of the traffic, so,
by means of this pamphlet they asserted its consistency
with revealed religion. That such a book should
have made converts in such an age is surprising; and
yet many, who ought to have known better, were carried
away by it; and we had now absolutely to contend,
and almost to degrade ourselves by doing so, against
the double argument of the humanity and the holiness
of the trade.
By these means, but particularly by
the former, the current of opinion in particular circles
ran against us for the first month, and so strong,
that it was impossible for me to stem it at once:
but as some of the council recovered from their panic,
and their good sense became less biassed by their
feelings, and they were in a state to hear reason,
their prejudices began to subside. It began now
to be understood among them, that almost all the witnesses
were concerned in the continuance of the Trade.
It began to be known also, (for Mr. Pitt and the Bishop
of London took care that it should be circulated,)
that Mr. Morris had but a short time before furnished
me at Liverpool with, information, all of which he
had concealed from the council, but all of which
made for the abolition of it. Mr. Devaynes also,
a respectable member of parliament, who had been in
Africa, and who had been appealed to by Mr. Norris,
when examined before the privy council, in behalf
of his extraordinary facts, was unable, when summoned,
to confirm them to the desired extent. From this
evidence the council collected, that human sacrifices
were not made on the arrival of White traders, as
had been asserted; that there was no poll-tax in Dahomey
at all; and that Mr. Norris must have been mistaken
on these points, for he must have been there at the
time of the ceremony of watering the graves, when
about sixty persons suffered. This latter custom
moreover appeared to have been a religious superstition
of the country, such as at Otaheite, or in Britain
in the time of the Druids, and to have had nothing
to do with the Slave-trade. With respect to
prisoners of war, Mr. Devaynes allowed that the old,
the lame, and the wounded, were often put to death
on the spot; but this was to save the trouble of bringing
them away. The young and the healthy were driven
off for sale; but if they were not sold when offered,
they were not killed, but reserved for another market,
or became house-slaves to the conquerors, Mr. Devaynes
also maintained, contrary to the allegations of the
others, that a great number of persons were kidnapped
in order to be sold to the ships, and that the government,
where this happened, was not strong enough to prevent
it. But besides these draw-backs from the weight
of the testimony which had been given, it began to
be perceived by some of the lords of the council, that
the cruel superstitions which, had been described,
obtained only in one or two countries in Africa, and
these of insignificant extent; whereas at the time,
when their minds were carried away as it were by their
feelings, they had supposed them to attach to the
whole of that vast continent. They perceived
also, that there were circumstances related in the
evidence by the delegates themselves, by means of
which, if they were true, the inhumanity of the trade
might be established, and this to their own disgrace.
They had all confessed that such slaves as the White
traders refused to buy were put to death; and yet
that these, traders, knowing that this would be the
case, had the barbarity uniformly to reject those whom
it did not suit them to purchase. Mr. Matthews
had rejected one of this description himself, whom
he saw afterwards destroyed. Mr. Penny had known
the refuse thrown down Melimba rock. Mr. Norris
himself, when certain prisoners of war were offered
to him for sale, declined buying them because they
appeared unhealthy; and though the king then told him
that he would put them to death, he could not be prevailed
upon to take them, but left them to their hard fate;
and he had the boldness to state afterwards, that
it was his belief that many of them actually suffered.
These considerations had the effect
of diminishing the prejudices of some of the council
on this great question: and when this was perceived
to be the case, it was the opinion of Mr. Pitt, Mr.
Grenville, and the Bishop of London, that we should
send three or four of our own evidences for examination,
who might help to restore matters to an equilibrium.
Accordingly Mr. Falconbridge, and some others, all
of whom were to speak to the African part of the subject,
were introduced. These produced a certain weight
in the opposite scale. But soon after these had
been examined, Dr. Andrew Spaarman, professor of physic,
and inspector of the museum of the royal academy at
Stockholm, and his companion, C.B. Wadstrom, chief
director of the assay-office there, arrived in England.
These gentlemen had been lately sent to Africa by
the late king of Sweden, to make discoveries in botany,
mineralogy, and other departments of science.
For this purpose the Swedish ambassador at Paris had
procured them permission from the French government
to visit the countries bordering on the Senegal, and
had ensured them protection there. They had been
conveyed to the place of their destination, where
they had remained from August 1787 to the end of January
1788; but meeting with obstacles which they had not
foreseen, they had left it, and had returned to Havre
de Grace, from whence they had just arrived in London,
in their way home. It so happened, that by means
of George Harrison, one of our commitee, I fell in
unexpectedly with these gentlemen. I had not
long been with them before I perceived the great treasure
I had found. They gave me many beautiful specimens
of African produce. They showed me their journals,
which they had regularly kept from day to day.
In these I had the pleasure of seeing a number of
circumstances minuted down, all relating to the Slave-trade,
and even drawings on the same subject. I obtained
a more accurate and satisfactory knowledge of the manners
and customs of the Africans from these, than from
all the persons put together whom I had yet seen.
I was anxious, therefore, to take them before the
commitee of council, to which they were pleased to
consent; and as Dr. Spaarman was to leave London in
a few days, I procured him an introduction first.
His evidence went to show, that the natives of Africa
lived in a fruitful and luxuriant country, which supplied
all their wants, and that they would be a happy people
if it were not for the existence of the Slave-trade.
He instanced wars which he knew to have been made by
the Moors upon the Negros (for they were entered upon
wholly at the instigation of the White traders) for
the purpose of getting slaves, and he had the pain
of seeing the unhappy captives brought in on such occasions,
and some of them in a wounded state. Among them
were many women and children, and the women were in
great affliction. He saw also the king of Barbesin
send out his parties on expeditions of a similar kind,
and he saw them return with slaves. The king
had been made intoxicated on purpose, by the French
agents, or he would never have consented to the measure.
He stated also, that in consequence of the temptations
held out by slave-vessels coming upon the coast, the
natives seized one another in the night, when they
found opportunity; and even invited others to their
houses, whom they treacherously detained, and sold
at these times; so that every enormity was practised
in Africa, in consequence of the existence of the Trade.
These specific instances made a proper impression
upon the lords of the council in their turn:
for Dr. Spaarman was a man of high character; he possessed
the confidence of his sovereign; he had no interest
whatever in giving his evidence on this subject, either
on one or the other side; his means of information
too had been large; he had also recorded the facts
which had come before him, and he had his journal,
written in the French language, to produce. The
tide therefore, which had run so strongly against us,
began now to turn a little in our favour.
While these examinations were going
on, petitions continued to be sent to the house of
commons, from various parts of the kingdom. No
less than one hundred and three were presented in
this session, The city of London, though she was drawn
the other way by the cries of commercial interest,
made a sacrifice to humanity and justice. The
two Universities applauded her conduct by their own
example. Large manufacturing towns and whole
counties expressed their sentiments and wishes in a
similar manner. The Established Church in separate
diocèses, and the Quakers and other Dissenters,
as separate religious bodies, joined in one voice upon
this occasion.
The commitee in the interim were not
unmindful of the great work they had undertaken, and
they continued to forward it in its different departments.
They kept up a communication by letter with most of
the worthy persons who have been mentioned to have
written to them, but particularly with Brissot and
Claviere, from whom they had the satisfaction of learning,
that a society had at length been established at Paris
for the Abolition of the Slave-Trade in France.
The learned Marquis de Condorcet had become the president
of it. The virtuous Duc de la Rochefoucauld,
and the Marquis de la Fayette, had sanctioned it by
enrolling their names as the two first members.
Petion, who was placed afterwards among the mayors
of Paris, followed. Women also were not thought
unworthy of being honorary and assistant members of
this humane institution; and among these were found
the amiable Marchioness of la Fayette, Madame
de Poivre, widow of the late intendant of
the Isle of France, and Madame Necker, wife of the
first minister of state.
The new correspondents, who voluntarily
offered their services to the commitee during the
first part of the period now under consideration, were,
S. Whitcomb, esq., of Gloucester; the reverend D. Watson,
of Middleton Tyas, Yorkshire; John Murlin, esq., of
High Wycomb; Charles Collins, esq., of Swansea; Henry
Tudor, esq., of Sheffield; the reverend John Hare,
of Lincoln; Samuel Tooker, esq., of Moorgate, near
Rotherham; the reverend G. Walker, and Francis Wakefield,
esq., of Nottingham; the reverend Mr. Hepworth, of
Burton-upon-Trent; the reverend H. Dannett, of St.
John’s, Liverpool; the reverend Dr. Oglander,
of New College, Oxford; the reverend H. Coulthurst,
of Sidney College, Cambridge; R. Selfe, esq., of Cirencester;
Morris Birkbeck, of Hanford, Dorsetshire; William Jepson,
of Lancaster; B. Kaye, of Leeds; John Patison, esq.,
of Paisley; J.E. Dolben, esq., of Northamptonshire;
the reverend Mr. Smith, of Wendover; John Wilkinson,
esquire, of Woodford; Samuel Milford, esquire, of Exeter;
Peter Lunel, esquire, treasurer of the commitee at
Bristol; James Pemberton, of Philadelphia; and the
President of the Society at New York.
The letters from new correspondents
during the latter part of this period were the following:
One from Alexander Alison, esquire,
of Edinburgh, in which he expressed it to be his duty
to attempt to awaken the inhabitants of Scotland to
a knowledge of the monstrous evil of the Slave-trade,
and to form a commitee there to act in union with
that of London, in carrying the great object of their
institution into effect.
Another from Elhanan Winchester, offering
the commitee one hundred of his sermons, which he
had preached against the Slave-trade, in Fairfax county
in Virginia, so early as in the year 1774.
Another from Dr. Frossard, of Lyons,
in which he offered his services for the South of
France, and desired different publications to be sent
him, that he might be better qualified to take a part
in the promotion of the cause.
Another from professor Bruns, of Helmstadt
in Germany, in which he desired to know the particulars
relative to the institution of the commitee, as many
thousands upon the continent were then beginning to
feel for the sufferings of the oppressed African race.
Another from the reverend James Manning,
of Exeter, in which he stated himself to be authorised
by the dissenting ministers of Devon and Cornwall,
to express their high approbation of the conduct of
the commitee, and to offer their services in the promotion
of this great work of humanity and religion.
Another from William Senhouse, esquire,
of the island of Barbadoes. In this he gave the
particulars of two estates, one of them his own and
the other belonging to a nobleman, upon each of which
the slaves, in consequence of humane treatment, had
increased by natural population only. Another
effect of this humane treatment had been, that these
slaves were among the most orderly and tractable in
that island. From these and other instances he
argued, that if the planters would, all of them, take
proper care of their slaves, their humanity would
be repaid in a few years by a valuable increase in
their property, and they would never want supplies
from a traffic, which had been so justly condemned.
Two others, the one from Travers Hartley,
and the other from Alexander Jaffray, esquires, both
of Dublin, were read. These gentlemen sent certain
resolutions, which had been agreed upon by the chamber
of commerce and by the guild of merchants there relative
to the abolition of the Slave-trade. They rejoiced
in the name of those, whom they represented, that Ireland
had been unspotted by a traffic, which they held in
such deep abhorrence, and promised, if it should be
abolished in England, to take the most active measures
to prevent it from finding an asylum in the ports of
that kingdom.
The letters of William Senhouse, and
of Travers Hartley, and of Alexander Jaffray, esquires,
were ordered to be presented to the commitee of privy
council and copies of them to be left there.
The business of the commitee having
almost daily increased within this period, Dr. Baker,
and Bennet Langton esquire, who were the two first
to assist me in my early labours, and who have been
mentioned among the forerunners and coadjutors of
the cause, were elected members of it. Dr. Kippis
also was added to the list.
The honorary and corresponding members
elected within the same period, were the Dean of Middleham,
T.W. Coke esquire, member of parliament, of Holkham
in Norfolk, and the reverend William Leigh, who has
been before mentioned, of Little Plumstead in the
same county. The latter had published several
valuable letters in the public papers under the signature
of Africanus. These had excited great notice,
and done much good. The worthy author had now
collected them into a publication, and had offered
the profits of it to the commitee. Hence this
mark of their respect was conferred upon him.
The commitee ordered a new edition
of three thousand of the Dean of Middleham’s
Letters to be printed. Having approved of a manuscript
written by James Field Stanfield, a mariner, containing
observations upon a voyage which he had lately made
to the coast of Africa for slaves, they ordered three
thousand of these to be printed also. By this
time the subject having been much talked of, and many
doubts and difficulties having been thrown in the
way of the abolition by persons interested in the continuance
of the trade, Mr. Ramsay, who has been often so honourably
mentioned, put down upon paper all the objections
which were then handed about, and also those answers
to each, which he was qualified from his superior knowledge
of the subject to suggest. This he did, that
the members of the legislature might see the more
intricate parts of the question unravelled, and that
they might not be imposed upon by the spurious arguments
which were then in circulation concerning it.
Observing also the poisonous effect which The Scriptural
Researches on the Licitness of the Slave-trade had
produced upon the minds of many, he wrote an answer
on scriptural grounds to that pamphlet. These
works were sent to the press, and three thousand copies
of each of them were ordered to be struck off.
The commitee, in their arrangement
of the distribution of their books, ordered Newton’s
Thoughts, and Ramsay’s Objections and Answers,
to be sent to each member of both houses of parliament.
They appointed also three sub-commitees
for different purposes: one to draw up such facts
and arguments respecting the Slave-trade, with a view
of being translated into other languages, as should
give foreigners a suitable knowledge of the subject;
another to prepare an answer to certain false reports
which had been spread relative to the object of their
institution, and to procure an insertion of it in
the daily papers; and a third to draw up rules for
the government of the Society.
By the latter end of the month of
March, there was an anxious expectation in the public,
notwithstanding the privy council had taken up the
subject, that some notice should be taken in the lower
house of parliament of the numerous petitions which
had been presented there. There was the same
expectation in many of the members of it themselves.
Lord Penrhyn, one of the representatives for Liverpool,
and a planter also, had anticipated this notice, by
moving for such papers relative to ships employed,
goods exported, produce imported, and duties upon
the same, as would show the vast value of the trade,
which it was in contemplation to abolish. But
at this time Mr. Wilberforce was ill, and unable to
gratify the expectations which had been thus apparent.
The commitee, therefore, who partook of the anxiety
of the public, knew not what to do. They saw that
two-thirds of the session had already passed.
They saw no hope of Mr. Wilberforce’s recovery
for some time. Rumours too were afloat, that other
members, of whose plans they knew nothing, and who
might even make emancipation their object, would introduce
the business into the house. Thus situated, they
waited as patiently as they could till the eighth
of April, when they resolved to write to Mr. Wilberforce,
to explain to him their fears and wishes, and to submit
it to his consideration, whether, if he were unable
himself, he would appoint some one, in whom he could
confide, to make some motion in parliament on the
subject.
But the public expectation became
now daily more visible. The inhabitants of Manchester,
many of whom had signed the petition for that place,
became impatient, and they appointed Thomas Walker
and Thomas Cooper, esquires, as their delegates, to
proceed to London to communicate with the commitee
on this subject, to assist them, in their deliberations
upon it, and to give their attendance while it was
under discussion by the legislature.
At the time of the arrival of the
delegates, who were received as such by the commitee,
a letter came from Bath, in which it was stated that
Mr. Wilberforce’s health was in such a precarious
state, that his physicians dared not allow him to
read any letter, which related to the subject of the
Slave-trade.
The commitee were now again at a loss
how to act, when they were relieved from this doubtful
situation by a message from Mr. Pitt, who desired a
conference with their chairman. Mr. Sharp accordingly
went, and on his return made the following report:
“He had a full opportunity,” he said, “of
explaining to Mr. Pitt that the desire of the commitee
went to the entire abolition of the Slave-trade.
Mr. Pitt assured him that his heart was with the commitee
as to this object, and that he considered himself pledged
to Mr. Wilberforce, that the cause should not sustain
any injury from his indisposition; but at the same
time observed, that the subject was of great political
importance, and it was requisite to proceed in it with
temper and prudence. He did not apprehend, as
the examinations before the privy council would yet
take up some time, that the subject could be fully
investigated in the present session of parliament;
but said he would consider whether the forms of the
house would admit of any measures, that would be obligatory
on them to take it up early in the ensuing session.”
In about a week after this conference,
Mr. Morton Pitt was deputed by the minister to write
to the commitee, to say that he had found precedents
for such a motion as he conceived to be proper, and
that he would submit it to the House of Commons in
a few days.
At the next meeting, which was on
the sixth of May, and at which major Cartwright and
the Manchester delegates assisted, Mr. Morton Pitt
attended as a member of the commitee, and said that
the minister had fixed his motion for the ninth.
It was then resolved, that deputations should be sent
to some of the leading members of parliament, to request
their support of the approaching motion. I was
included in one of these, and in that which was to
wait upon Mr. Fox. We were received by him in
a friendly manner. On putting the question to
him, which related to the object of our mission, Mr.
Fox paused for a little while, as if in the act of
deliberation; when he assured us unequivocally, and
in language which could not be misunderstood, that
he would support the object of the commitee to its
fullest extent, being convinced that there was no remedy
for the evil, but in the total abolition of the trade.
At length, the ninth, or the day fixed
upon, arrived, when this important subject was to
be mentioned in the House of Commons for the first
time, with a view to the public discussion of it.
It is impossible for me to give within the narrow
limits of this work all that was then said upon it;
and yet as the debate, which ensued, was the first
which took place upon it, I should feel inexcusable
if I were not to take some notice of it.
Mr. Pitt rose. He said he intended
to move a resolution relative to a subject, which
was of more importance than any which had ever been
agitated in that house. This honour he should
not have had, but for a circumstance, which he could
not but deeply regret, the severe indisposition of
his friend Mr. Wilberforce, in whose hands every measure,
which belonged to justice, humanity, and the national
interest, was peculiarly well placed. The subject
in question was no less than that of the Slave-trade.
It was obvious from the great number of petitions,
which had been presented concerning it, how much it
had engaged the public attention, and consequently
how much it deserved the serious notice of that house,
and how much it became their duty to take some measure
concerning it. But whatever was done on such
a subject, every one would agree, ought to be done
with the maturest deliberation. Two opinions
had prevailed without doors, as appeared from the
language of the different petitions. It had been
pretty generally thought that the African Slave-trade
ought to be abolished. There were others, however,
who thought that it only stood in need of regulations.
But all had agreed that it ought not to remain as it
stood at present. But that measure, which it
might be the most proper to take, could only be discovered
by a cool, patient, and diligent examination of the
subject in all its circumstances, relations, and consequences.
This had induced him to form an opinion, that the
present was not the proper time for discussing it;
for the session was now far advanced, and there was
also a want of proper materials for the full information
of the house. It would, he thought, be better
discussed, when it might produce some useful debate,
and when that inquiry, which had been instituted by
His Majesty’s ministers, (he meant the examination
by a commitee of privy council,) should be brought
to such a state of maturity, as to make it fit that
the result of it should be laid before the house.
That inquiry, he trusted, would facilitate their investigation,
and enable them the better to proceed to a decision,
which should be equally founded on principles of humanity,
justice, and sound policy. As there was not a
probability of reaching so desirable an end in the
present state of the business, he meant to move a
resolution to pledge the house to the discussion of
the question early in the next session. If by
that time his honourable friend should be recovered,
which he hoped would be the case, then he (Mr. Wilberforce)
would take the lead in it; but should it unfortunately
happen otherwise, then he (the Chancellor of the Exchequer)
pledged himself to bring forward some proposition
concerning it. The house, however, would observe,
that he had studiously avoided giving any opinion
of his own on this great subject. He thought
it wiser to defer this till the time of the discussion
should arrive. He concluded with moving, after
having read the names of the places from whence the
different petitions had come, “That this house
will, early in the next session of parliament, proceed
to take into consideration the circumstances of the
Slave-trade complained of in the said petitions, and
what may be fit to be done thereupon.”
Mr. Fox began by observing, that he
had long taken an interest in this great subject,
which he had also minutely examined, and that it was
his intention to have brought something forward himself
in parliament respecting it: but when he heard
that Mr. Wilberforce had resolved to take it up, he
was unaffectedly rejoiced, not only knowing the purity
of his principles and character, but because, from
a variety of considerations as to the situations in
which different men stood in the house, there was
something that made him honestly think it was better
that the business should be in the hands of that gentleman,
than in his own. Having premised this, he said
that, as so many petitions, and these signed by such
numbers of persons of the most respectable character,
had been presented, he was sorry that it had been
found impossible that the subject of them could be
taken, up this year, and more particularly as he was
not able to see, as the Chancellor of the Exchequer
had done, that there were circumstances, which might
happen by the next year, which would make it more advisable
and advantageous to take it up then, than it would
have been to enter upon it in the present session.
For certainly there could be no information laid before
the house, through the medium of the Lords of the Council,
which could not more advantageously have been obtained
by themselves, had they instituted a similar inquiry.
It was their duty to advise the King, and not to ask
his advice. This the constitution had laid down
as one of its most essential principles; and though
in the present instance he saw no cause for blame,
because he was persuaded His Majesty’s ministers
had not acted with any ill intention, it was still
a principle never to be departed from, because it
never could be departed from without establishing a
precedent which might lead to very serious abuses.
He, lamented that the Privy Council, who had received
no petitions from the people on the subject, should
have instituted an inquiry, and that the House of Commons,
the table of which had been loaded with petitions
from various parts of the kingdom, should not have
instituted any inquiry at all. He hoped these
petitions would have a fair discussion in that house,
independently, of any information that could be given
to it by His Majesty’s ministers. He urged
again the superior advantages of an inquiry into such
a subject, carried on within those walls, over any
inquiry carried on by the Lords of the Council.
In inquiries carried on in that house, they had the
benefit of every circumstance of publicity; which
was a most material benefit indeed, and that which
of all others made the manner of conducting the parliamentary
proceedings of Great Britain the envy and the admiration
of the world. An inquiry there was better than
an inquiry in any other place, however respectable
the persons before and by whom it was carried on.
There, all that could be said for the abolition or
against it might be said. In that house, every
relative fact would have been produced, no information
would have been withheld, no circumstance would have
been omitted, which was necessary for elucidation;
nothing would have been kept back. He was sorry
therefore that the consideration of the question, but
more particularly where so much human suffering was
concerned, should be put off to another session, when
it was obvious that no advantage could be gained by
the delay.
He then adverted to the secrecy, which
the Chancellor of the Exchequer had observed relative
to his own opinion on this important subject.
Why did he refuse to give it? Had Mr. Wilberforce
been present, the house would have had a great advantage
in this respect, because doubtless he would have stated
in what view he saw the subject, and in a general way
described the nature of the project he meant to propose.
But now they were kept in the dark as to the nature
of any plan, till the next session. The Chancellor
of the Exchequer had indeed said, that it had been
a very general opinion that the African Slave-trade
should be abolished. He had said again, that others
had not gone so far, but had given, it as their opinion,
that it required to be revised and regulated.
But why did he not give his own sentiments boldly
to the world on this great question? As for himself,
he (Mr. Fox) had no scruple to declare at the outset,
that the Slave-trade ought not to be regulated, but
destroyed. To this opinion his mind was made up;
and he was persuaded that, the more the subject was
considered, the more his opinion would gain ground;
and it would be admitted, that to consider it in any
other manner, or on any other principles than those
of humanity and justice, would be idle and absurd.
If there were any such men, and he did not know but
that there were those, who, led away by local and interested
considerations, thought the Slave-trade might still
continue under certain modifications, these were the
dupes of error, and mistook what they thought their
interest, for what he would undertake to convince them
was their loss. Let such men only hear the case
further, and they would find the result to be, that
a cold-hearted policy was folly, when it opposed the
great principles of humanity and justice.
He concluded by saying that he would
not oppose the resolution, if other members thought
it best to postpone the consideration of the subject;
but he should have been better pleased, if it had
been discussed sooner; and he certainly reserved to
himself the right of voting for any question upon it
that should be brought forward by any other member
in the course of the present session.
The Chancellor of the Exchequer said,
that nothing he had heard had satisfied him of the
propriety of departing from the rule he had laid down
for himself, of not offering, but of studiously avoiding
to offer, any opinion upon the subject till the time
should arrive when it could be fully argued.
He thought that no discussion, which could take place
that session, could lead to any useful measure, and
therefore he had wished not to argue it till the whole
of it could be argued. A day would come, when
every member would have an opportunity of stating
his opinion; and he wished it might be discussed with
a proper spirit on all sides, on fair and liberal
principles, and without any shackles from local and
interested considerations.
With regard to the inquiries instituted
before the commitee of privy council, he was sure,
as soon as it became obvious that the subject must
undergo a discussion, it was the duty of His Majesty’s
ministers to set those inquiries on foot, which should
best enable them to judge in what manner they could
meet or offer any proposition respecting the Slave-trade.
And although such previous examinations by no means
went to deprive that house of its undoubted right
to institute those inquiries, or to preclude them,
they would be found greatly to facilitate them.
But, exclusive of this consideration, it would have
been utterly impossible to have come to any discussion
of the subject, that could have been brought to a conclusion
in the course of the present session. Did the
inquiry then before the privy council prove a loss
of time? So far from it, that, upon the whole,
time had been gained by it. He had moved the
resolution, therefore, to pledge the house to bring
on the discussion early in the next session, when they
would have a full opportunity of considering every
part of the subject: first, Whether the whole
of the trade ought be abolished; and, if so, how and
when. If it should be thought that the trade should
only be put under certain regulations, what those
regulations ought to be, and when they should take
place. These were questions which must be considered;
and therefore he had made his resolution as wide as
possible, that there might be room for all necessary
considerations to be taken in. He repeated his
declaration, that he would reserve his sentiments till
the day of discussion should arrive; and again declared,
that he earnestly wished to avoid an anticipation
of the debate upon the subject. But if such debate
was likely to take place, he would withdraw his motion,
and offer it another day.
A few words then passed between Mr.
Pitt and Mr. Fox in reply to each other; after which
Lord Penrhyn rose. He said there were two classes
of men, the African merchants, and the planters, both
whose characters had been grossly calumniated.
These wished that an inquiry might be instituted,
and this immediately, conscious that the more their
conduct was examined the less they would be found
to merit the opprobrium with which they had been loaded.
The charges against the Slave-trade were either true
or false. If they were true, it ought to be abolished;
but if upon inquiry they were found to be without
foundation, justice ought to be done to the reputation
of those who were concerned in it. He then said
a few words, by which he signified, that, after all,
it might not be an improper measure to make regulations
in the trade.
Mr. Burke said, the noble lord, who
was a man of honour himself, had reasoned from his
own conduct, and, being conscious of his own integrity,
was naturally led to imagine that other men were equally
just and honourable. Undoubtedly the merchants
and planters had a right to call for an investigation
of their conduct, and their doing so did them great
credit. The Slave-trade also ought equally to
be inquired into. Neither did he deny that it
was right His Majesty’s ministers should inquire
into its merits for themselves. They had done
their duty; but that house, who had the petitions
of the people on their table, had neglected it, by
having so long deferred an inquiry of their own.
If that house wished to preserve their functions,
their understandings, their honour, and their dignity,
he advised them to beware of commitees of privy council.
If they suffered their business to be done by such
means, they were abdicating their trust and character,
and making way for an entire abolition of their functions,
which they were parting with one after another.
Thus,
“Star after star goes out, and all
is night.”
If they neglected the petitions of
their constituents, they must fall, and the privy
council be instituted in their stead. What would
be the consequence? His Majesty’s ministers,
instead of consulting them, and giving them the opportunity
of exercising their functions of deliberation and
legislation, would modify the measures of government
elsewhere, and bring down the edicts of the privy
council to them to register. Mr. Burke said,
he was one of those who wished for the abolition of
the Slave-trade. He thought it ought to be abolished,
on principles of humanity and justice. If, however,
opposition of interests should render its total abolition
impossible, it ought to be regulated, and that immediately.
They need not send to the West Indies to know the
opinions of the planters on the subject. They
were to consider first of all, and abstractedly from
all political, personal, and local considerations,
that the Slave-trade was directly contrary to the
principles of humanity and justice, and to the spirit
of the British constitution; and that the state of
slavery, which followed it, however mitigated, was
a state so improper, so degrading, and so ruinous
to the feelings and capacities of human nature, that
it ought not to be suffered to exist. He deprecated
delay in this business, as well for the sake of the
planters as of the slaves.
Mr. Gascoyne, the other member for
Liverpool, said he had no objection that the discussion
should stand over to the next session of parliament,
provided it could not come on in the present, because
he was persuaded it would ultimately be found that
his constituents, who were more immediately concerned
in the trade, and who had been so shamefully calumniated,
were men of respectable character. He hoped the
privy council would print their Report when they had
brought their inquiries to a conclusion, and that they
would lay it before the house and the public, in order
to enable all concerned to form a judgment of what
was proper to be done relative to the subject, next
session. With respect, however, to the total abolition
of the Slave-trade, he must confess that such a measure
was both unnecessary, visionary, and impracticable;
but he wished some alterations or modifications to
be adopted. He hoped that, when the house came
to go into the general question, they would not forget
the trade, commerce, and navigation, of the country.
Mr. Rolle said, he had received instructions
from his constituents to inquire if the grievances,
which had been alleged to result from the Slave-trade,
were well founded, and, if it should appear that they
were, to assist in applying a remedy. He was
glad the discussion had been put off till next session,
as it would give all of them an opportunity of considering
the subject with more mature deliberation.
Mr. Martin desired to say a few words
only. He put the case, that, supposing the slaves
were treated ever so humanely, when they were carried
to the West Indies, what compensation could be made
them for being torn from their nearest relations,
and from every thing that was dear to them in life?
He hoped no political advantage, no national expediency,
would be allowed to weigh in the scale against the
eternal rules of moral rectitude. As for himself,
he had no hesitation to declare, in this early stage
of the business, that he should think himself a wicked
wretch if he did not do every thing in his power to
put a stop to the Slave-trade.
Sir William Dolben said, that he did
not then wish to enter into the discussion of the
general question of the abolition of the Slave-trade,
which the Chancellor of the Exchequer was so desirous
of postponing; but he wished to say a few words on
what he conceived to be a most crying evil, and which
might be immediately remedied, without infringing upon
the limits of that question. He did not allude
to the sufferings of the poor Africans in their own
country, nor afterwards in the West India islands,
but to that intermediate state of tenfold misery which
they underwent in their transportation. When
put on board the ships, the poor unhappy wretches were
chained to each other, hand and foot, and stowed so
close, that they were not allowed above a foot and
a half for each individual in breadth. Thus crammed
together like herrings in a barrel, they contracted
putrid and fatal disorders; so that they who came
to inspect, them in a morning had occasionally to
pick dead slaves out of their rows, and to unchain
their carcases from the bodies of their wretched fellow-sufferers,
to whom they had been fastened. Nor was it merely
to the slaves that the baneful effects of the contagion
thus created were confined. This contagion affected
the ships’ crews, and numbers of the seamen
employed in the horrid traffic perished. This
evil, he said, called aloud for a remedy, and that
remedy ought to be applied soon; otherwise no less
than ten thousand lives might be lost between this
and the next session. He wished therefore this
grievance to be taken into consideration, independently
of the general question; and that some regulations,
such as restraining the captains from taking above
a certain number of slaves on board, according to the
size of their vessels, and obliging them to let in
fresh air, and provide better accommodation for the
slaves during their passage, should be adopted.
Mr. Young wished the consideration
of the whole subject to stand over to the next session.
Sir James Johnstone, though a planter,
professed himself a friend to the abolition of the
Slave-trade. He said it was highly necessary that
the house should do something respecting it; but whatever
was to be done should be done soon, as delay might
be productive of bad consequences in the islands.
Mr. L. Smith stood up a zealous advocate
for the abolition of the Slave-trade. He said
that even Lord Penrhyn and Mr. Gascoyne, the members
for Liverpool, had admitted the evil of it to a certain
extent; for regulations or modifications, in which
they seemed to acquiesce, were unnecessary where abuses
did not really exist.
Mr. Grigby thought it his duty to
declare, that no privy council report, or other mode
of examination, could influence him. A traffic
in the persons of men was so odious, that it ought
everywhere, as soon as ever it was discovered, to
be abolished.
Mr. Bastard was anxious that the house
should proceed to the discussion of the subject in
the present session. The whole country, he said,
had petitioned; and was it any satisfaction to the
country to be told, that the commitee of privy council
were inquiring? Who knew any thing of what was
doing by the commitee of privy council, or what progress
they were making? The inquiry ought to have been
instituted in that house, and in the face of the public,
that every body concerned might know what was going
on. The numerous petitions of the people ought
immediately to be attended to. He reprobated
delay on this occasion; and as the honourable baronet,
Sir William Dolben, had stated facts which were shocking
to humanity, he hoped he would move that a commitee
might be appointed to inquire into their existence,
that a remedy might be applied, if possible, before
the sailing of the next ships for Africa.
Mr. Whitbread professed himself a
strenuous advocate for the total and immediate abolition
of the Slave-trade. It was contrary to nature,
and to every principle of justice, humanity, and religion.
Mr. Pelham stated, that he had very
maturely considered the subject of the Slave-trade;
and had he not known that the business was in the hands
of an honourable member, (whose absence from the house,
and the cause of it, no man lamented more sincerely
than he did,) he should have ventured to propose something
concerning it himself. If it should be thought
that the Trade ought not to be entirely done away,
the sooner it was regulated the better. He had
a plan for this purpose, which appeared to him to be
likely to produce some salutary effects. He wished
to know if any such thing would be permitted to be
proposed in the course of the present session.
The Chancellor of the Exchequer said
he should be happy, if he thought the circumstances
of the house were such as to enable them to proceed
to an immediate discussion of the question; but as
that did not appear, from the reasons he had before
stated, to be the case, he could only assure the honourable
gentleman, that the same motives which had induced
him to propose an inquiry into the subject early in
the next session of parliament, would make him desirous
of receiving any other light which could be thrown
upon it.
The question having been then put,
the resolution was agreed to unanimously. Thus
ended the first debate that ever took place in the
commons, on this important subject. This debate,
though many of the persons concerned in it abstained
cautiously from entering into the merits of the general
question, became interesting, in consequence of circumstances
attending it. Several rose up at once to give
relief, as it were, to their feelings by utterance;
but by so doing they were prevented, many of them,
from being heard. They who were heard spoke with
peculiar energy, as if warmed in an extraordinary
manner by the subject. There was an apparent
enthusiasm in behalf of the injured Africans.
It was supposed by some, that there was a moment,
in which, if the Chancellor of the Exchequer had moved
for an immediate abolition of the Trade, he would have
carried it that night; and both he and others, who
professed an attachment to the cause, were censured
for not having taken a due advantage of the disposition
which was so apparent. But independently of the
inconsistency of doing this on the part of the ministry,
while the privy council were in the midst of their
inquiries, and of the improbability that the other
branches of the legislature would have concurred in
so hasty a measure; What good would have accrued to
the cause, if the abolition had been then carried?
Those concerned in the cruel system would never have
rested quietly under the stigma under which they then
laboured. They would have urged, that they had
been condemned unheard. The merchants would have
said, that they had had no notice of such an event,
that they might prepare a way for their vessels in
other trades. The planters would have said, that
they had had no time allowed them to provide such
supplies from Africa as might enable them to keep
up their respective stocks. They would, both of
them, have called aloud for immediate indemnification.
They would have decried the policy of the measure
of the abolition; and where had it been
proved? They would have demanded a reverse of
it; and might they not, in cooler moments, have succeeded?
Whereas, by entering into a patient discussion of the
merits of the question; by bringing evidence upon
it; by reasoning upon that evidence night after night,
and year after year, land thus by disputing the ground
inch as it were by inch, the Abolition of the Slave-trade
stands upon a rock, upon which it never can be shaken.
Many of those who were concerned in the cruel system
have now given up their prejudices, because they became
convinced in the contest. A stigma too has been
fixed upon it, which can never be erased: and
in a large record, in which the cruelty and injustice
of it have been recognised in indelible characters,
its impolicy also has been eternally enrolled.