1813: THE BEAVER DAMS, LAKE ERIE,
AND CHATEAUGUAY
The remaining operations of 1812 are
of quite minor importance. No more than two are
worthy of being mentioned between the greater events
before and after them. Both were abortive attempts
at invasion one across the upper Niagara,
the other across the frontier south of Montreal.
After the battle of Queenston Heights
Sheaffe succeeded Brock in command of the British,
and Smyth succeeded Van Rensselaer in command of the
Americans. Sheaffe was a harsh martinet and a
third-rate commander. Smyth, a notorious braggart,
was no commander at all. He did, however, succeed
in getting Sheaffe to conclude an armistice that fully
equalled Prevost’s in its disregard of British
interests. After making the most of it for a
month he ended it on November 19, and began manoeuvring
round his headquarters at Black Rock near Buffalo.
After another eight days he decided to attack the
British posts at Red House and Frenchman’s Creek,
which were respectively two and a half and five miles
from Fort Erie. The whole British line of the
upper Niagara, from Fort Erie to Chippawa, a distance
of seventeen miles by the road along the river, was
under the command of an excellent young officer, Colonel
Bisshopp, who had between five and six hundred men
to hold his seven posts. Fort Erie had the largest
garrison only a hundred and thirty men.
Some forty men of the 49th and two small guns were
stationed at Red House; while the light company of
the 41st guarded the bridge over Frenchman’s
Creek. About two o’clock in the morning
of the 28th one party of Americans pulled across to
the ferry a mile below Fort Erie, and then, sheering
off after being fired at by the Canadian militia on
guard, made for Red House a mile and a half lower
down. There they landed at three and fought a
most confused and confusing action in the dark.
Friend and foe became mixed up together; but the result
was a success for the Americans. Meanwhile, the
other party landed near Frenchman’s Creek, reached
the bridge, damaged it a little, and had a fight with
the 41st, who could not drive the invaders back till
reinforcements arrived. At daylight the men from
Chippawa marched into action, Indians began to appear,
and the whole situation was re-established. The
victorious British lost nearly a hundred, which was
more than a quarter of those engaged. The beaten
Americans lost more; but, being in superior numbers,
they could the better afford it.
Smyth was greatly disconcerted.
But he held a boat review on his own side of the river,
and sent over a summons to Bisshopp demanding the
immediate surrender of Fort Erie ‘to spare the
effusion of blood.’ Bisshopp rejected the
summons. But there was no effusion of blood in
consequence. Smyth planned, talked, and manoeuvred
for two days more, and then tried to make his real
effort on the 1st of December. By the time it
was light enough for the British to observe him he
had fifteen hundred men in boats, who all wanted to
go back, and three thousand on shore, who all refused
to go forward. He then held a council of war,
which advised him to wait for a better chance.
This closed the campaign with what, according to Porter,
one of his own generals, was ’a scene of confusion
difficult to describe: about four thousand men
without order or restraint discharging their muskets
in every direction.’ Next day ‘The
Committee of Patriotic Citizens’ undertook to
rebuke Smyth. But he retorted, not without reason,
that the affair at Queenston is a caution against relying
on crowds who go to the banks of the Niagara to look
at a battle as on a theatrical exhibition.’
The other abortive attempt at invasion
was made by the advance-guard of the commander-in-chief’s
own army. Dearborn had soon found out that his
disorderly masses at Greenbush were quite unfit to
take the field. But, four months after the declaration
of war, a small detachment, thrown forward from his
new headquarters at Plattsburg on Lake Champlain,
did manage to reach St Regis, where the frontier first
meets the St Lawrence, near the upper end of Lake
St Francis, sixty miles south-west of Montreal.
Here the Americans killed Lieutenant Rototte and a
sergeant, and took the little post, which was held
by a few voyageurs. Exactly a month later, on
November 23, these Americans were themselves defeated
and driven back again. Three days earlier than
this a much stronger force of Americans had crossed
the frontier at Odelltown, just north of which there
was a British blockhouse beside the river La Colle,
a muddy little western tributary of the Richelieu,
forty-seven miles due south of Montreal. The
Americans fired into each other in the dark, and afterwards
retired before the British reinforcements. Dearborn
then put his army into winter quarters at Plattsburg,
thus ending his much-heralded campaign against Montreal
before it had well begun.
The American government was much disappointed
at the failure of its efforts to make war without
armies. But it found a convenient scapegoat in
Hull, who was far less to blame than his superiors
in the Cabinet. These politicians had been wrong
in every important particular wrong about
the attitude of the Canadians, wrong about the whole
plan of campaign, wrong in separating Hull from Dearborn,
wrong in not getting men-of-war afloat on the Lakes,
wrong, above all, in trusting to untrained and undisciplined
levies. To complete their mortification, the
ridiculous gunboats, in which they had so firmly believed,
had done nothing but divert useful resources into
useless channels; while, on the other hand, the frigates,
which they had proposed to lay up altogether, so as
to save themselves from ’the ruinous folly of
a Navy,’ had already won a brilliant series
of duels out at sea.
There were some searchings of heart
at Washington when all these military and naval misjudgments
stood revealed. Eustis soon followed Hull into
enforced retirement; and great plans were made for
the campaign of 1813, which was designed to wipe out
the disgrace of its predecessor and to effect the
conquest of Canada for good and all.
John Armstrong, the new war secretary,
and William Henry Harrison, the new general in the
West, were great improvements on Eustis and Hull.
But, even now, the American commanders could not decide
on a single decisive attack supported by subsidiary
operations elsewhere. Montreal remained their
prime objective. But they only struck at it last
of all. Michilimackinac kept their enemy in touch
with the West. But they left it completely alone.
Their general advance ought to have been secured by
winning the command of the Lakes and by the seizure
of suitable positions across the line. But they
let the first blows come from the Canadian side; and
they still left Lake Champlain to shift for itself.
Their plan was undoubtedly better than that of 1812.
But it was still all parts and no whole.
The various events were so complicated
by the overlapping of time and place all along the
line that we must begin by taking a bird’s-eye
view of them in territorial sequence, starting from
the farthest inland flank and working eastward to
the sea. Everything west of Detroit may be left
out altogether, because operations did not recommence
in that quarter until the campaign of the following
year.
In January the British struck successfully
at Frenchtown, more than thirty miles south of Detroit.
They struck unsuccessfully, still farther south, at
Fort Meigs in May and at Fort Stephenson in August;
after which they had to remain on the defensive, all
over the Lake Erie region, till their flotilla was
annihilated at Put-in Bay in September and their army
was annihilated at Moravian Town on the Thames in
October. In the Lake Ontario region the situation
was reversed. Here the British began badly and
ended well. They surrendered York in April and
Fort George, at the mouth of the Niagara, in May.
They were also repulsed in a grossly mismanaged attack
on Sackett’s Harbour two days after their defeat
at Fort George. The opposing flotillas meanwhile
fought several manoeuvring actions of an indecisive
kind, neither daring to risk battle and possible annihilation.
But, as the season advanced, the British regained
their hold on the Niagara peninsula by defeating the
Americans at Stoney Creek and the Beaver Dams in June,
and by clearing both sides of the Niagara river in
December. On the upper St Lawrence they took
Ogdensburg in February. They were also completely
successful in their defence of Montreal. In June
they took the American gunboats at Isle-aux-Noix
on the Richelieu; in July they raided Lake Champlain;
while in October and November they defeated the two
divisions of the invading army at Chateauguay and
Chrystler’s Farm. The British news from
sea also improved as the year wore on. The American
frigate victories began to stop. The Shannon
beat the Chesapeake. And the shadow of
the Great Blockade began to fall on the coast of the
Democratic South.
The operations of 1813 are more easily
understood if taken in this purely territorial way.
But in following the progress of the war we must take
them chronologically. No attempt can be made
here to describe the movements on either side in any
detail. An outline must suffice. Two points,
however, need special emphasis, as they are both markedly
characteristic of the war in general and of this campaign
in particular. First, the combined effect of
the American victories of Lake Erie and the Thames
affords a perfect example of the inseparable connection
between the water and the land. Secondly, the
British victories at the Beaver Dams and Chateauguay
are striking examples of the inter-racial connection
among the forces that defended Canada so well.
The Indians did all the real fighting at the Beaver
Dams. The French Canadians fought practically
alone at Chateauguay.
The first move of the invaders in
the West was designed to recover Detroit and cut off
Mackinaw. Harrison, victorious over the Indians
at Tippecanoe in 1811, was now expected to strike
terror into them once more, both by his reputation
and by the size of his forces. In midwinter he
had one wing of his army on the Sandusky, under his
own command, and the other on the Maumee, under Winchester,
a rather commonplace general. At Frenchtown stood
a little British post defended by fifty Canadians
and a hundred Indians. Winchester moved north
to drive these men away from American soil. But
Procter crossed the Detroit from Amherstburg on the
ice, and defeated Winchester’s thousand whites
with his own five hundred whites and five hundred
Indians at dawn on January 22, making Winchester a
prisoner. Procter was unable to control the Indians,
who ran wild. They hated the Westerners who made
up Winchester’s force, as the men who had deprived
them of their lands, and they now wreaked their vengeance
on them for some time before they could be again brought
within the bounds of civilized warfare. After
the battle Procter retired to Amherstburg; Harrison
began to build Fort Meigs on the Maumee; and a pause
of three months followed all over the western scene.
But winter warfare was also going
on elsewhere. A month after Procter’s success,
Prevost, when passing through Prescott, on the upper
St Lawrence, reluctantly gave Colonel Macdonell of
Glengarry provisional leave to attack Ogdensburg,
from which the Americans were forwarding supplies
to Sackett’s Harbour, sending out raiding parties,
and threatening the British line of communication to
the west. No sooner was Prevost clear of Prescott
than Macdonell led his four hundred regulars and one
hundred militia over the ice against the American
fort. His direct assault failed. But when
he had carried the village at the point of the bayonet
the garrison ran. Macdonell then destroyed the
fort, the barracks, and four vessels. He also
took seventy prisoners, eleven guns, and a large supply
of stores.
With the spring came new movements
in the West. On May 9 Procter broke camp and
retired from an unsuccessful siege of Fort Meigs (now
Toledo) at the south-western corner of Lake Erie.
He had started this siege a fortnight earlier with
a thousand whites and a thousand Indians under Tecumseh;
and at first had seemed likely to succeed. But
after the first encounter the Indians began to leave;
while most of the militia had soon to be sent home
to their farms to prevent the risk of starvation.
Thus Procter presently found himself with only five
hundred effectives in face of a much superior and
constantly increasing enemy. In the summer he
returned to the attack, this time against the American
position on the lower Sandusky, nearly thirty miles
east of Fort Meigs. There, on August 2, he tried
to take Fort Stephenson. But his light guns could
make no breach; and he lost a hundred men in the assault.
Meanwhile Dearborn, having first moved
up from Plattsburg to Sackett’s Harbour, had
attacked York on April 27 with the help of the new
American flotilla on Lake Ontario. This flotilla
was under the personal orders of Commodore Chauncey,
an excellent officer, who, in the previous September,
had been promoted from superintendent of the New York
Navy Yard to commander-in-chief on the Lakes.
As Chauncey’s forte was building and organization,
he found full scope for his peculiar talents at Sackett’s
Harbour. He was also a good leader at sea and
thus a formidable enemy for the British forces at
York, where the third-rate Sheaffe was now in charge,
and where Prevost had paved the way for a British
defeat by allowing the establishment of an exposed
navy yard instead of keeping all construction safe
in Kingston. Sheaffe began his mistakes by neglecting
to mount some of his guns before Dearborn and Chauncey
arrived, though he knew these American commanders
might come at any moment, and though he also knew
how important it was to save a new British vessel
that was building at York, because the command of
the lake might well depend upon her. He then
made another mistake by standing to fight in an untenable
position against overwhelming odds. He finally
retreated with all the effective regulars left, less
than two hundred, burning the ship and yard as he
passed, and leaving behind three hundred militia to
make their own terms with the enemy. He met the
light company of the 8th on its way up from Kingston
and turned it back. With this retreat he left
the front for good and became a commandant of bases,
a position often occupied by men whose failures are
not bad enough for courts-martial and whose saving
qualities are not good enough for any more appointments
in the field.
The Americans lost over two hundred
men by an explosion in a British battery at York just
as Sheaffe was marching off. Forty British had
also been blown up in one of the forts a little while
before. Sheaffe appears to have been a slack
inspector of powder-magazines. But the Americans,
who naturally suspected other things than slack inspection,
thought a mine had been sprung on them after the fight
was over. They consequently swore revenge, burnt
the parliament buildings, looted several private houses,
and carried off books from the public library as well
as plate from the church. Chauncey, much to his
credit, afterwards sent back all the books and plate
he could recover.
Exactly a month later, on May 27,
Chauncey and Dearborn appeared off Fort George, after
a run back to Sackett’s Harbour in the meantime.
Vincent, Sheaffe’s successor in charge of Upper
Canada, had only a thousand regulars and four hundred
militia there. Dearborn had more than four times
as many men; and Perry, soon to become famous on Lake
Erie, managed the naval part of landing them.
The American men-of-war brought the long, low, flat
ground of Mississauga Point under an irresistible
cross-fire while three thousand troops were landing
on the beach below the covering bluffs. No support
could be given to the opposing British force by the
fire of Fort George, as the village of Newark intervened.
So Vincent had to fight it out in the open. On
being threatened with annihilation he retired towards
Burlington, withdrawing the garrison of Fort George,
and sending orders for all the other troops on the
Niagara to follow by the shortest line. He had
lost a third of the whole force defending the Niagara
frontier, both sides of which were now possessed by
the Americans. But by nightfall on May 29 he
was standing at bay, with his remaining sixteen hundred
men, in an excellent strategical position on the Heights,
half-way between York and Fort George, in touch with
Dundas Street, the main road running east and west,
and beside Burlington Bay, where he hoped to meet
the British flotilla commanded by Yeo.
Captain Sir James Lucas Yeo was an
energetic and capable young naval officer of thirty,
whom the Admiralty had sent out with a few seamen
to take command on the Lakes under Prevost’s
orders. He had been only seventeen days at Kingston
when he sailed out with Prevost, on May 27, to take
advantage of Chauncey’s absence at the western
end of the lake. Arrived before Sackett’s
Harbour, the attack was planned for the 29th.
The landing force of seven hundred and fifty men was
put in charge of Baynes, the adjutant-general, a man
only too well fitted to do the ‘dirty work’
of the general staff under a weak commander-in-chief
like Prevost. All went wrong at Sackett’s
Harbour. Prevost was ’present but not in
command’; Baynes landed at the wrong place.
Nevertheless, the British regulars scattered the American
militiamen, pressed back the American regulars, set
fire to the barracks, and halted in front of the fort.
The Americans, thinking the day was lost, set fire
to their stores and to Chauncey’s new ships.
Then Baynes and Prevost suddenly decided to retreat.
Baynes explained to Prevost, and Prevost explained
in a covering dispatch to the British government,
that the fleet could not co-operate, that the fort
could not be taken, and that the landing party was
not strong enough. But, if this was true, why
did they make an attack at all; and, if it was not
true, why did they draw back when success seemed to
be assured?
Meanwhile Chauncey, after helping
to take Fort George, had started back for Sackett’s
Harbour; and Dearborn, left without the fleet, had
moved on slowly and disjointedly, in rear of Vincent,
with whom he did not regain touch for a week.
On June 5 the Americans camped at Stoney Creek, five
miles from the site of Hamilton. The steep zigzagging
bank of the creek, which formed their front, was about
twenty feet high. Their right rested on a mile-wide
swamp, which ran down to Lake Ontario. Their
left touched the Heights, which ran from Burlington
to Queenston. They were also in superior numbers,
and ought to have been quite secure. But they
thought so much more of pursuit than of defence that
they were completely taken by surprise when ‘704
firelocks’ under Colonel Harvey suddenly attacked
them just after midnight. Harvey, chief staff
officer to Vincent, was a first-rate leader for such
daring work as this, and his men were all well disciplined.
But the whole enterprise might have failed, for all
that. Some of the men opened fire too soon, and
the nearest Americans began to stand to their arms.
But, while Harvey ran along re-forming the line, Major
Plenderleath, with some of Brock’s old regiment,
the 49th, charged straight into the American centre,
took the guns there, and caused so much confusion
that Harvey’s following charge carried all before
it. Next morning, June 6, the Americans began
a retreat which was hastened by Yeo’s arrival
on their lakeward flank, by the Indians on the Heights,
and by Vincent’s reinforcements in their rear.
Not till they reached the shelter of Fort George did
they attempt to make a stand.
The two armies now faced each other
astride of the lake-shore road and the Heights.
The British left advanced post, between Ten and Twelve
Mile Creeks, was under Major de Haren of the 104th,
a regiment which, in the preceding winter, had marched
on snow-shoes through the woods all the way from the
middle of New Brunswick to Quebec. The corresponding
British post inland, near the Beaver Dams, was under
Lieutenant FitzGibbon of the 49th, a cool, quick-witted,
and adventurous Irishman, who had risen from the ranks
by his own good qualities and Brock’s recommendation.
Between him and the Americans at Queenston and St
David’s was a picked force of Indian scouts with
a son of the great chief Joseph Brant. These Indians
never gave the Americans a minute’s rest.
They were up at all hours, pressing round the flanks,
sniping the sentries, worrying the outposts, and keeping
four times their own numbers on the perpetual alert.
What exasperated the Americans even more was the wonderfully
elusive way in which the Indians would strike their
blow and then be lost to sight and sound the very
next moment, if, indeed, they ever were seen at all.
Finally, this endless skirmish with an invisible foe
became so harassing that the Americans sent out a
flying column of six hundred picked men under Colonel
Boerstler on June 24 to break up FitzGibbon’s
post at the Beaver Dams and drive the Indians out
of the intervening bush altogether.
But the American commanders had not
succeeded in hiding their preparations from the vigilant
eyes of the Indian scouts or from the equally attentive
ears of Laura Secord, the wife of an ardent U. E.
Loyalist, James Secord, who was still disabled by
the wounds he had received when fighting under Brock’s
command at Queenston Heights. Early in the morning
of the 23rd, while Laura Secord was going out to milk
the cows, she overheard some Americans talking about
the surprise in store for FitzGibbon next day.
Without giving the slightest sign she quietly drove
the cattle in behind the nearest fence, hid her milk-pail,
and started to thread her perilous way through twenty
miles of bewildering bypaths to the Beaver Dams.
Keeping off the beaten tracks and always in the shadow
of the full-leaved trees, she stole along through
the American lines, crossed the no-man’s-land
between the two desperate enemies, and managed to
get inside the ever-shifting fringe of Indian scouts
without being seen by friend or foe. The heat
was intense; and the whole forest steamed with it
after the tropical rain. But she held her course
without a pause, over the swollen streams on fallen
tree-trunks, through the dense underbrush, and in and
out of the mazes of the forest, where a bullet might
come from either side without a moment’s warning.
As she neared the end of her journey a savage yell
told her she was at last discovered by the Indians.
She and they were on the same side; but she had hard
work to persuade them that she only wished to warn
FitzGibbon. Then came what, to a lesser patriot,
would have been a crowning disappointment. For
when, half dead with fatigue, she told him her story,
she found he had already heard it from the scouts.
But just because this forestalment was no real disappointment
to her, it makes her the Anglo-Canadian heroine whose
fame for bravery in war is worthiest of being remembered
with that of her French-Canadian sister, Madeleine
de Vercheres.
Boerstler’s six hundred had
only ten miles to go in a straight line. But
all the thickets, woods, creeks, streams, and swamps
were closely beset by a body of expert, persistent
Indians, who gradually increased from two hundred
and fifty to four hundred men. The Americans
became discouraged and bewildered; and when FitzGibbon
rode up at the head of his redcoats they were ready
to give in. The British posts were all in excellent
touch with each other; and de Haren arrived in time
to receive the actual surrender. He was closely
followed by the 2nd Lincoln Militia under Colonel
Clark, and these again by Colonel Bisshopp with the
whole of the advanced guard. But it was the Indians
alone who won the fight, as FitzGibbon generously
acknowledged: ’Not a shot was fired on
our side by any but the Indians. They beat the
American detachment into a state of terror, and the
only share I claim is taking advantage of a favourable
moment to offer protection from the tomahawk and scalping
knife.’
June was a lucky month for the British
at sea as well as on the land; and its ‘Glorious
First,’ so called after Howe’s victory
nineteen years before, now became doubly glorious
in a way which has a special interest for Canada.
The American frigate Chesapeake was under orders
to attack British supply-ships entering Canadian waters;
and the victorious British frigate Shannon was
taken out of action and into a Canadian port by a
young Canadian in the Royal Navy.
The Chesapeake had a new captain,
Lawrence, with new young officers. She carried
fifty more men than the British frigate Shannon.
But many of her ship’s company were new to her,
on recommissioning in May; and some were comparatively
untrained for service on board a man-of-war.
The frigates themselves were practically equal in size
and armament. But Captain Broke had been in continuous
command of the Shannon for seven years and had
trained his crew into the utmost perfection of naval
gunnery. The vessels met off Boston in full view
of many thousands of spectators. Not one British
shot flew high. Every day in the Shannon’s
seven years of preparation told in that fight of only
fifteen minutes; and when Broke led his boarders over
the Chesapeake’s side her fate had been sealed
already. The Stars and Stripes were soon replaced
by the Union Jack. Then, with Broke severely wounded
and his first lieutenant killed, the command fell
on Lieutenant Wallis, who sailed both vessels into
Halifax. This young Canadian, afterwards known
as Admiral-of-the-Fleet Sir Provo Wallis, lived to
become the longest of all human links between the
past and present of the Navy. He was by far the
last survivor of those officers who were specially
exempted from technical retirement on account of having
held any ship or fleet command during the Great War
that ended on the field of Waterloo. He was born
before Napoleon had been heard of. He went through
a battle before the death of Nelson. He outlived
Wellington by forty years. His name stood on
the Active List for all but the final decade of the
nineteenth century. And, as an honoured centenarian,
he is vividly remembered by many who were still called
young a century after the battle that brought him
into fame.
The summer campaign on the Niagara
frontier ended with three minor British successes.
Fort Schlosser was surprised on July 5. On the
11th Bisshopp lost his life in destroying Black Rock.
And on August 24 the Americans were driven in under
the guns of Fort George. After this there was
a lull which lasted throughout the autumn.
Down by the Montreal frontier there
were three corresponding British successes. On
June 3 Major Taylor of the 100th captured two American
gunboats, the Growler and the Eagle,
which had come to attack Isle-aux-Noix in the
Richelieu river, and renamed them the Broke
and the Shannon. Early in August Captains
Pring and Everard, of the Navy, and Colonel Murray
with nine hundred soldiers, raided Lake Champlain.
They destroyed the barracks, yard, and stores at Plattsburg
and sent the American militia flying home. But
a still more effective blow was struck on the opposite
side of Lake Champlain, at Burlington, where General
Hampton was preparing the right wing of his new army
of invasion. Stores, equipment, barracks, and
armaments were destroyed to such an extent that Hampton’s
preparations were set back till late in the autumn.
The left wing of the same army was at Sackett’s
Harbour, under Dearborn’s successor, General
Wilkinson, whose plan was to take Kingston, go down
the St Lawrence, meet Hampton, who was to come up
from the south, and then make a joint attack with
him on Montreal.
In September the scene of action shifted
to the West, where the British were trying to keep
the command of Lake Erie, while the Americans were
trying to wrest it from them. Captain Oliver
Perry, a first-rate American naval officer of only
twenty-eight, was at Presqu’isle (now Erie)
completing his flotilla. He had his troubles,
of course, especially with the militia garrison, who
would not do their proper tour of duty. ’I
tell the boys to go, but the boys won’t go,’
was the only report forthcoming from one of several
worthless colonels. A still greater trouble for
Perry was getting his vessels over the bar. This
had to be done without any guns on board, and with
the cumbrous aid of ‘camels,’ which are
any kind of air-tanks made fast to the sides low down,
in order to raise the hull as much as possible.
But, luckily for Perry, his opponent, Captain Barclay
of the Royal Navy, an energetic and capable young
officer of thirty-two, was called upon to face worse
troubles still. Barclay was, indeed, the first
to get afloat. But he had to give up the blockade
of Presqu’isle, and so let Perry out, because
he had the rawest of crews, the scantiest of equipment,
and nothing left to eat. Then, when he ran back
to Amherstburg, he found Procter also facing a state
of semi-starvation, while thousands of Indian families
were clamouring for food. Thus there was no other
choice but either to fight or starve; for there was
not the slightest chance of replenishing stores unless
the line of the lake was clear.
So Barclay sailed out with his six
little British vessels, armed by the odds and ends
of whatever ordnance could be spared from Amherstburg
and manned by almost any crews but sailors. Even
the flagship Detroit had only ten real seamen,
all told. Ammunition was likewise very scarce,
and so defective that the guns had to be fired by
the flash of a pistol. Perry also had a makeshift
flotilla, partly manned by drafts from Harrison’s
army. But, on the whole, the odds in his favour
were fairly shown by the number of vessels in the
respective flotillas, nine American against the British
six.
Barclay had only thirty miles to make
in a direct south-easterly line from Amherstburg to
reach Perry at Put-in Bay in the Bass Islands, where,
on the morning of September 10, the opposing forces
met. The battle raged for two hours at the very
closest quarters till Perry’s flagship Lawrence
struck to Barclay’s own Detroit.
But Perry had previously left the Lawrence for
the fresh Niagara; and he now bore down on
the battered Detroit, which had meanwhile fallen
foul of the only other sizable British vessel, the
Queen Charlotte. This was fatal for Barclay.
The whole British flotilla surrendered after a desperate
resistance and an utterly disabling loss. From
that time on to the end of the war Lake Erie remained
completely under American control.
Procter could hardly help seeing that
he was doomed to give up the whole Lake Erie region.
But he lingered and was lost. While Harrison
was advancing with overwhelming numbers Procter was
still trying to decide when and how to abandon Amherstburg.
Then, when he did go, he carried with him an inordinate
amount of baggage; and he retired so slowly that Harrison
caught and crushed him near Moravian Town, beside
the Thames, on the 5th of October. Harrison had
three thousand exultant Americans in action; Procter
had barely a thousand worn-out, dispirited men, more
than half of them Indians under Tecumseh. The
redcoats, spread out in single rank at open order,
were ridden down by Harrison’s cavalry, backed
by the mass of his infantry. The Indians on the
inland flank stood longer and fought with great determination
against five times their numbers till Tecumseh fell.
Then they broke and fled. This was their last
great fight and Tecumseh was their last great leader.
The scene now shifts once more to
the Montreal frontier, which was being threatened
by the converging forces of Hampton from the south
and Wilkinson from the west. Each had about seven
thousand men; and their common objective was the island
of Montreal. Hampton crossed the line at Odelltown
on September 20. But he presently moved back
again; and it was not till October 21 that he began
his definite attack by advancing down the left bank
of the Chateauguay, after opening communications with
Wilkinson, who was still near Sackett’s Harbour.
Hampton naturally expected to brush aside all the
opposition that could be made by the few hundred British
between him and the St Lawrence. But de Salaberry,
the commander of the British advanced posts, determined
to check him near La Fourche, where several little
tributaries of the Chateauguay made a succession of
good positions, if strengthened by abattis and
held by trained defenders.
The British force was very small when
Hampton began his slow advance; but ‘Red George’
Macdonell marched to help it just in time. Macdonell
was commanding a crack corps of French Canadians,
all picked from the best ’Select Embodied Militia,’
and now, at the end of six months of extra service,
as good as a battalion of regulars. He had hurried
to Kingston when Wilkinson had threatened it from
Sackett’s Harbour. Now he was urgently needed
at Chateauguay. ‘When can you start?’
asked Prevost, who was himself on the point of leaving
Kingston for Chateauguay. ’Directly the
men have finished their dinners, sir!’ ‘Then
follow me as quickly as you can!’ said Prevost
as he stepped on board his vessel. There were
210 miles to go. A day was lost in collecting
boats enough for this sudden emergency. Another
day was lost en route by a gale so terrific
that even the French-Canadian voyageurs were unable
to face it. The rapids, where so many of Amherst’s
men had been drowned in 1760, were at their very worst;
and the final forty miles had to be made overland
by marching all night through dense forest and along
a particularly difficult trail. Yet Macdonell
got into touch with de Salaberry long before Prevost,
to whom he had the satisfaction of reporting later
in the day: ‘All correct and present, sir;
not one man missing!’
The advanced British forces under
de Salaberry were now, on October 25, the eve of battle,
occupying the left, or north, bank of the Chateauguay,
fifteen miles south of the Cascade Rapids of the St
Lawrence, twenty-five miles south-west of Caughnawaga,
and thirty-five miles south-west of Montreal.
Immediately in rear of these men under de Salaberry
stood Macdonell’s command; while, in more distant
support, nearer to Montreal, stood various posts under
General de Watteville, with whom Prevost spent that
night and most of the 26th, the day on which the battle
was fought.
As Hampton came on with his cumbrous
American thousands de Salaberry felt justifiable confidence
in his own well-disciplined French-Canadian hundreds.
He and his brothers were officers in the Imperial
Army. His Voltigeurs were regulars. The
supporting Fencibles were also regulars, and of ten
years’ standing. Macdonell’s men were
practically regulars. The so-called ‘Select
Militia’ present had been permanently embodied
for eighteen months; and the only real militiamen
on the scene of action, most of whom never came under
fire at all, had already been twice embodied for service
in the field. The British total present was 1590,
of whom less than a quarter were militiamen and Indians.
But the whole firing line comprised no more than 460,
of whom only 66 were militiamen and only 22 were Indians.
The Indian total was about one-tenth of the whole.
The English-speaking total was about one-twentieth.
It is therefore perfectly right to say that the battle
of Chateauguay was practically fought and won by French-Canadian
regulars against American odds of four to one.
De Salaberry’s position was
peculiar. The head of his little column faced
the head of Hampton’s big column on a narrow
front, bounded on his own left by the river Chateauguay
and on his own right by woods, into which Hampton
was afraid to send his untrained men. But, crossing
a right-angled bend of the river, beyond de Salaberry’s
left front, was a ford, while in rear of de Salaberry’s
own column was another ford which Hampton thought he
could easily take with fifteen hundred men under Purdy,
as he had no idea of Macdonell’s march and no
doubt of being able to crush de Salaberry’s
other troops between his own five thousand attacking
from the front and Purdy’s fifteen hundred attacking
from the rear. Purdy advanced overnight, crossed
to the right bank of the Chateauguay, by the ford
clear of de Salaberry’s front, and made towards
the ford in de Salaberry’s rear. But his
men lost their way in the dark and found themselves,
not in rear of, but opposite to, and on the left flank
of, de Salaberry’s column in the morning.
They drove in two of de Salaberry’s companies,
which were protecting his left flank on the right,
or what was now Purdy’s, side of the river;
but they were checked by a third, which Macdonell
sent forward, across the rear ford, at the same time
that he occupied this rear ford himself. Purdy
and Hampton had now completely lost touch with one
another. Purdy was astounded to see Macdonell’s
main body of redcoats behind the rear ford. He
paused, waiting for support from Hampton, who was
still behind the front ford. Hampton paused,
waiting for him to take the rear ford, now occupied
by Macdonell. De Salaberry mounted a huge tree-stump
and at once saw his opportunity. Holding back
Hampton’s crowded column with his own front,
which fought under cover of his first abattis,
he wheeled the rest of his men into line to the left
and thus took Purdy in flank. Macdonell was out
of range behind the rear ford; but he played his part
by making his buglers sound the advance from several
different quarters, while his men, joined by de Salaberry’s
militiamen and by the Indians in the bush, cheered
vociferously and raised the war-whoop. This was
too much for Purdy’s fifteen hundred. They
broke in confusion, ran away from the river into the
woods under a storm of bullets, fired into each other,
and finally disappeared. Hampton’s attack
on de Salaberry’s first abattis then came
to a full stop; after which the whole American army
retired beaten from the field.
Ten days after Chateauguay dilatory
Wilkinson, tired of waiting for defeated Hampton,
left the original rendezvous at French Creek, fifty
miles below Sackett’s Harbour. Like Dearborn
in 1812, he began his campaign just as the season
was closing. But, again like Dearborn, he had
the excuse of being obliged to organize his army in
the middle of the war. Four days later again,
on November 9, Brown, the successful defender of Sackett’s
Harbour against Prevost’s attack in May, was
landed at Williamsburg, on the Canadian side, with
two thousand men, to clear the twenty miles down to
Cornwall, opposite the rendezvous at St Regis, where
Wilkinson expected to find Hampton ready to join him
for the combined attack on Montreal. But Brown
had to reckon with Dennis, the first defender of Queenston,
who now commanded the little garrison of Cornwall,
and who disputed every inch of the way by breaking
the bridges and resisting each successive advance
till Brown was compelled to deploy for attack.
Two days were taken up with these harassing manoeuvres,
during which another two thousand Americans were landed
at Williamsburg under Boyd, who immediately found
himself still more harassed in rear than Brown had
been in front.
This new British force in Boyd’s
rear was only a thousand strong; but, as it included
every human element engaged in the defence of Canada,
it has a quite peculiar interest of its own.
Afloat, it included bluejackets of the Royal Navy,
men of the Provincial Marine, French-Canadian voyageurs,
and Anglo-Canadian boatmen from the trading-posts,
all under a first-rate fighting seaman, Captain Mulcaster,
R.N. Ashore, under a good regimental leader,
Colonel Morrison whose chief staff officer
was Harvey, of Stoney Creek renown it included
Imperial regulars, Canadian regulars of both races,
French-Canadian and Anglo-Canadian militiamen, and
a party of Indians.
Early on the 11th Brown had arrived
at Cornwall with his two thousand Americans; Wilkinson
was starting down from Williamsburg in boats with
three thousand more, and Boyd was starting down ashore
with eighteen hundred. But Mulcaster’s
vessels pressed in on Wilkinson’s rear, while
Morrison pressed in on Boyd’s. Wilkinson
then ordered Boyd to turn about and drive off Morrison,
while he hurried his own men out of reach of Mulcaster,
whose armed vessels could not follow down the rapids.
Boyd thereupon attacked Morrison, and a stubborn fight
ensued at Chrystler’s Farm. The field was
of the usual type: woods on one flank, water
on the other, and a more or less flat clearing in
the centre. Boyd tried hard to drive his wedge
in between the British and the river. But Morrison
foiled him in manoeuvre; and the eight hundred British
stood fast against their eighteen hundred enemies
all along the line. Boyd then withdrew, having
lost four hundred men; and Morrison’s remaining
six hundred effectives slept on their hard-won ground.
Next morning the energetic Morrison
resumed his pursuit. But the campaign against
Montreal was already over. Wilkinson had found
that Hampton had started back for Lake Champlain while
the battle was in progress; so he landed at St Regis,
just inside his own country, and went into winter
quarters at French Mills on the Salmon river.
In December the scene of strife changed
back again to the Niagara, where the American commander,
McClure, decided to evacuate Fort George. At
dusk on the 10th he ordered four hundred women and
children to be turned out of their homes at Newark
into the biting midwinter cold, and then burnt the
whole settlement down to the ground. If he had
intended to hold the position he might have been justified
in burning Newark, under more humane conditions, because
this village undoubtedly interfered with the defensive
fire of Fort George. But, as he was giving up
Fort George, his act was an entirely wanton deed of
shame.
Meanwhile the new British general,
Gordon Drummond, second in ability to Brock alone,
was hurrying to the Niagara frontier. He was
preceded by Colonel Murray, who took possession of
Fort George on the 12th, the day McClure crossed the
Niagara river. Murray at once made a plan to
take the American Fort Niagara opposite; and Drummond
at once approved it for immediate execution.
On the night of the 18th six hundred men were landed
on the American side three miles up the river.
At four the next morning Murray led them down to the
fort, rushing the sentries and pickets by the way
with the bayonet in dead silence. He then told
off two hundred men to take a bastion at the same
time that he was to lead the other four hundred straight
through the main gate, which he knew would soon be
opened to let the reliefs pass out. Everything
worked to perfection. When the reliefs came out
they were immediately charged and bayoneted, as were
the first astonished men off duty who ran out of their
quarters to see what the matter was. A stiff
hand-to-hand fight followed. But every American
attempt to form was instantly broken up; and presently
the whole place surrendered. Drummond, who was
delighted with such an excellent beginning, took care
to underline the four significant words referring
to the enemy’s killed and wounded all
with the bayonet. This was done in no mere
vulgar spirit of bravado, still less in abominable
bloody-mindedness. It was the soldierly recognition
of a particularly gallant feat of arms, carried out
with such conspicuously good discipline that its memory
is cherished, even to the present day, by the 100th,
afterwards raised again as the Royal Canadians, and
now known as the Prince of Wales’s Leinster
regiment. A facsimile of Drummond’s underlined
order is one of the most highly honoured souvenirs
in the officers’ mess.
Not a moment was lost in following
up this splendid feat of arms. The Indians drove
the American militia out of Lewiston, which the advancing
redcoats burnt to the ground. Fort Schlosser
fell next, then Black Rock, and finally Buffalo.
Each was laid in ashes. Thus, before 1813 ended,
the whole American side of the Niagara was nothing
but one long, bare line of blackened desolation, with
the sole exception of Fort Niagara, which remained
secure in British hands until the war was over.