Natural Selection its power compared with man’s selection its power
on characters of trifling importance its power at all ages and on
both sexes Sexual Selection On the generality of intercrosses
between individuals of the same species Circumstances favourable and
unfavourable to the results of Natural Selection, namely, intercrossing,
isolation, number of individuals Slow action Extinction caused by
Natural Selection Divergence of Character, related to the diversity of
inhabitants of any small area and to naturalisation Action of Natural
Selection, through Divergence of Character and Extinction, on the
descendants from a common parent Explains the Grouping of all organic
beings Advance in organisation Low forms preserved Convergence of
character Indefinite multiplication of species Summary.
How will the struggle for existence,
briefly discussed in the last chapter, act in regard
to variation? Can the principle of selection,
which we have seen is so potent in the hands of man,
apply under nature? I think we shall see that
it can act most efficiently. Let the endless
number of slight variations and individual differences
occurring in our domestic productions, and, in a lesser
degree, in those under nature, be borne in mind; as
well as the strength of the hereditary tendency.
Under domestication, it may truly be said that the
whole organisation becomes in some degree plastic.
But the variability, which we almost universally meet
with in our domestic productions is not directly produced,
as Hooker and Asa Gray have well remarked, by man;
he can neither originate varieties nor prevent their
occurrence; he can only preserve and accumulate such
as do occur. Unintentionally he exposes organic
beings to new and changing conditions of life, and
variability ensues; but similar changes of conditions
might and do occur under nature. Let it also
be borne in mind how infinitely complex and close-fitting
are the mutual relations of all organic beings to
each other and to their physical conditions of life;
and consequently what infinitely varied diversities
of structure might be of use to each being under changing
conditions of life. Can it then be thought improbable,
seeing that variations useful to man have undoubtedly
occurred, that other variations useful in some way
to each being in the great and complex battle of life,
should occur in the course of many successive generations?
If such do occur, can we doubt (remembering that many
more individuals are born than can possibly survive)
that individuals having any advantage, however slight,
over others, would have the best chance of surviving
and procreating their kind? On the other hand,
we may feel sure that any variation in the least degree
injurious would be rigidly destroyed. This preservation
of favourable individual differences and variations,
and the destruction of those which are injurious, I
have called Natural Selection, or the Survival of
the Fittest. Variations neither useful nor injurious
would not be affected by natural selection, and would
be left either a fluctuating element, as perhaps we
see in certain polymorphic species, or would ultimately
become fixed, owing to the nature of the organism
and the nature of the conditions.
Several writers have misapprehended
or objected to the term Natural Selection. Some
have even imagined that natural selection induces
variability, whereas it implies only the preservation
of such variations as arise and are beneficial to
the being under its conditions of life. No one
objects to agriculturists speaking of the potent effects
of man’s selection; and in this case the individual
differences given by nature, which man for some object
selects, must of necessity first occur. Others
have objected that the term selection implies conscious
choice in the animals which become modified; and it
has even been urged that, as plants have no volition,
natural selection is not applicable to them!
In the literal sense of the word, no doubt, natural
selection is a false term; but who ever objected to
chemists speaking of the elective affinities of the
various elements? and yet an acid cannot
strictly be said to elect the base with which it in
preference combines. It has been said that I
speak of natural selection as an active power or Deity;
but who objects to an author speaking of the attraction
of gravity as ruling the movements of the planets?
Every one knows what is meant and is implied by such
metaphorical expressions; and they are almost necessary
for brevity. So again it is difficult to avoid
personifying the word Nature; but I mean by nature,
only the aggregate action and product of many natural
laws, and by laws the sequence of events as ascertained
by us. With a little familiarity such superficial
objections will be forgotten.
We shall best understand the probable
course of natural selection by taking the case of
a country undergoing some slight physical change, for
instance, of climate. The proportional numbers
of its inhabitants will almost immediately undergo
a change, and some species will probably become extinct.
We may conclude, from what we have seen of the intimate
and complex manner in which the inhabitants of each
country are bound together, that any change in the
numerical proportions of the inhabitants, independently
of the change of climate itself, would seriously affect
the others. If the country were open on its borders,
new forms would certainly immigrate, and this would
likewise seriously disturb the relations of some of
the former inhabitants. Let it be remembered
how powerful the influence of a single introduced tree
or mammal has been shown to be. But in the case
of an island, or of a country partly surrounded by
barriers, into which new and better adapted forms
could not freely enter, we should then have places
in the economy of nature which would assuredly be
better filled up if some of the original inhabitants
were in some manner modified; for, had the area been
open to immigration, these same places would have been
seized on by intruders. In such cases, slight
modifications, which in any way favoured the individuals
of any species, by better adapting them to their altered
conditions, would tend to be preserved; and natural
selection would have free scope for the work of improvement.
We have good reason to believe, as
shown in the first chapter, that changes in the conditions
of life give a tendency to increased variability;
and in the foregoing cases the conditions the changed,
and this would manifestly be favourable to natural
selection, by affording a better chance of the occurrence
of profitable variations. Unless such occur,
natural selection can do nothing. Under the term
of “variations,” it must never be forgotten
that mere individual differences are included.
As man can produce a great result with his domestic
animals and plants by adding up in any given direction
individual differences, so could natural selection,
but far more easily from having incomparably longer
time for action. Nor do I believe that any great
physical change, as of climate, or any unusual degree
of isolation, to check immigration, is necessary in
order that new and unoccupied places should be left
for natural selection to fill up by improving some
of the varying inhabitants. For as all the inhabitants
of each country are struggling together with nicely
balanced forces, extremely slight modifications in
the structure or habits of one species would often
give it an advantage over others; and still further
modifications of the same kind would often still further
increase the advantage, as long as the species continued
under the same conditions of life and profited by similar
means of subsistence and defence. No country can
be named in which all the native inhabitants are now
so perfectly adapted to each other and to the physical
conditions under which they live, that none of them
could be still better adapted or improved; for in
all countries, the natives have been so far conquered
by naturalised productions that they have allowed
some foreigners to take firm possession of the land.
And as foreigners have thus in every country beaten
some of the natives, we may safely conclude that the
natives might have been modified with advantage, so
as to have better resisted the intruders.
As man can produce, and certainly
has produced, a great result by his methodical and
unconscious means of selection, what may not natural
selection effect? Man can act only on external
and visible characters: Nature, if I may be allowed
to personify the natural preservation or survival
of the fittest, cares nothing for appearances, except
in so far as they are useful to any being. She
can act on every internal organ, on every shade of
constitutional difference, on the whole machinery of
life. Man selects only for his own good; Nature
only for that of the being which she tends. Every
selected character is fully exercised by her, as is
implied by the fact of their selection. Man keeps
the natives of many climates in the same country.
He seldom exercises each selected character in some
peculiar and fitting manner; he feeds a long and a
short-beaked pigeon on the same food; he does not exercise
a long-backed or long-legged quadruped in any peculiar
manner; he exposes sheep with long and short wool
to the same climate; does not allow the most vigorous
males to struggle for the females; he does not rigidly
destroy all inferior animals, but protects during
each varying season, as far as lies in his power,
all his productions. He often begins his selection
by some half-monstrous form, or at least by some modification
prominent enough to catch the eye or to be plainly
useful to him. Under nature, the slightest differences
of structure or constitution may well turn the nicely-balanced
scale in the struggle for life, and so be preserved.
How fleeting are the wishes and efforts of man!
How short his time, and consequently how poor will
be his results, compared with those accumulated by
Nature during whole geological periods! Can we
wonder, then, that Nature’s productions should
be far “truer” in character than man’s
productions; that they should be infinitely better
adapted to the most complex conditions of life, and
should plainly bear the stamp of far higher workmanship?
It may metaphorically be said that
natural selection is daily and hourly scrutinising,
throughout the world, the slightest variations; rejecting
those that are bad, preserving and adding up all that
are good; silently and insensibly working, whenever
and wherever opportunity offers,
at the improvement of each organic being in relation
to its organic and inorganic conditions of life.
We see nothing of these slow changes in progress,
until the hand of time has marked the long lapse of
ages, and then so imperfect is our view into long-past
geological ages that we see only that the forms of
life are now different from what they formerly were.
In order that any great amount of
modification should be effected in a species, a variety,
when once formed must again, perhaps after a long
interval of time, vary or present individual differences
of the same favourable nature as before; and these
must again be preserved, and so onward, step by step.
Seeing that individual differences of the same kind
perpetually recur, this can hardly be considered as
an unwarrantable assumption. But whether it is
true, we can judge only by seeing how far the hypothesis
accords with and explains the general phenomena of
nature. On the other hand, the ordinary belief
that the amount of possible variation is a strictly
limited quantity, is likewise a simple assumption.
Although natural selection can act
only through and for the good of each being, yet characters
and structures, which we are apt to consider as of
very trifling importance, may thus be acted on.
When we see leaf-eating insects green, and bark-feeders
mottled-grey; the alpine ptarmigan white in winter,
the red-grouse the colour of heather, we must believe
that these tints are of service to these birds and
insects in preserving them from danger. Grouse,
if not destroyed at some period of their lives, would
increase in countless numbers; they are known to suffer
largely from birds of prey; and hawks are guided by
eyesight to their prey, so much so that
on parts of the continent persons are warned not to
keep white pigeons, as being the most liable to destruction.
Hence natural selection might be effective in giving
the proper colour to each kind of grouse, and in keeping
that colour, when once acquired, true and constant.
Nor ought we to think that the occasional destruction
of an animal of any particular colour would produce
little effect; we should remember how essential it
is in a flock of white sheep to destroy a lamb with
the faintest trace of black. We have seen how
the colour of hogs, which feed on the “paint-root”
in Virginia, determines whether they shall live or
die. In plants, the down on the fruit and the
colour of the flesh are considered by botanists as
characters of the most trifling importance; yet we
hear from an excellent horticulturist, Downing, that
in the United States smooth-skinned fruits suffer far
more from a beetle, a Curculio, than those with down;
that purple plums suffer far more from a certain disease
than yellow plums; whereas another disease attacks
yellow-fleshed peaches far more than those with other
coloured flesh. If, with all the aids of art,
these slight differences make a great difference in
cultivating the several varieties, assuredly, in a
state of nature, where the trees would have to struggle
with other trees and with a host of enemies, such
differences would effectually settle which variety,
whether a smooth or downy, a yellow or a purple-fleshed
fruit, should succeed.
In looking at many small points of
difference between species, which, as far as our ignorance
permits us to judge, seem quite unimportant, we must
not forget that climate, food, etc., have no doubt
produced some direct effect. It is also necessary
to bear in mind that, owing to the law of correlation,
when one part varies and the variations are accumulated
through natural selection, other modifications, often
of the most unexpected nature, will ensue.
As we see that those variations which,
under domestication, appear at any particular period
of life, tend to reappear in the offspring at the
same period; for instance, in the shape, size and flavour
of the seeds of the many varieties of our culinary
and agricultural plants; in the caterpillar and cocoon
stages of the varieties of the silkworm; in the eggs
of poultry, and in the colour of the down of their
chickens; in the horns of our sheep and cattle when
nearly adult; so in a state of nature natural selection
will be enabled to act on and modify organic beings
at any age, by the accumulation of variations profitable
at that age, and by their inheritance at a corresponding
age. If it profit a plant to have its seeds more
and more widely disseminated by the wind, I can see
no greater difficulty in this being effected through
natural selection, than in the cotton-planter increasing
and improving by selection the down in the pods on
his cotton-trees. Natural selection may modify
and adapt the larva of an insect to a score of contingencies,
wholly different from those which concern the mature
insect; and these modifications may affect, through
correlation, the structure of the adult. So,
conversely, modifications in the adult may affect the
structure of the larva; but in all cases natural selection
will ensure that they shall not be injurious:
for if they were so, the species would become extinct.
Natural selection will modify the
structure of the young in relation to the parent and
of the parent in relation to the young. In social
animals it will adapt the structure of each individual
for the benefit of the whole community; if the community
profits by the selected change. What natural
selection cannot do, is to modify the structure of
one species, without giving it any advantage, for
the good of another species; and though statements
to this effect may be found in works of natural history,
I cannot find one case which will bear investigation.
A structure used only once in an animal’s life,
if of high importance to it, might be modified to
any extent by natural selection; for instance, the
great jaws possessed by certain insects, used exclusively
for opening the cocoon or the hard tip
to the beak of unhatched birds, used for breaking
the eggs. It has been asserted, that of the best
short-beaked tumbler-pigeons a greater number perish
in the egg than are able to get out of it; so that
fanciers assist in the act of hatching. Now,
if nature had to make the beak of a full-grown pigeon
very short for the bird’s own advantage, the
process of modification would be very slow, and there
would be simultaneously the most rigorous selection
of all the young birds within the egg, which had the
most powerful and hardest beaks, for all with weak
beaks would inevitably perish: or, more delicate
and more easily broken shells might be selected, the
thickness of the shell being known to vary like every
other structure.
It may be well here to remark that
with all beings there must be much fortuitous destruction,
which can have little or no influence on the course
of natural selection. For instance, a vast number
of eggs or seeds are annually devoured, and these
could be modified through natural selection only if
they varied in some manner which protected them from
their enemies. Yet many of these eggs or seeds
would perhaps, if not destroyed, have yielded individuals
better adapted to their conditions of life than any
of those which happened to survive. So again a
vast number of mature animals and plants, whether
or not they be the best adapted to their conditions,
must be annually destroyed by accidental causes, which
would not be in the least degree mitigated by certain
changes of structure or constitution which would in
other ways be beneficial to the species. But
let the destruction of the adults be ever so heavy,
if the number which can exist in any district be not
wholly kept down by such causes or again
let the destruction of eggs or seeds be so great that
only a hundredth or a thousandth part are developed yet
of those which do survive, the best adapted individuals,
supposing that there is any variability in a favourable
direction, will tend to propagate their kind in larger
numbers than the less well adapted. If the numbers
be wholly kept down by the causes just indicated,
as will often have been the case, natural selection
will be powerless in certain beneficial directions;
but this is no valid objection to its efficiency at
other times and in other ways; for we are far from
having any reason to suppose that many species ever
undergo modification and improvement at the same time
in the same area.
Sexual selection.
Inasmuch as peculiarities often appear
under domestication in one sex and become hereditarily
attached to that sex, so no doubt it will be under
nature. Thus it is rendered possible for the two
sexes to be modified through natural selection in
relation to different habits of life, as is sometimes
the case; or for one sex to be modified in relation
to the other sex, as commonly occurs. This leads
me to say a few words on what I have called sexual
selection. This form of selection depends, not
on a struggle for existence in relation to other organic
beings or to external conditions, but on a struggle
between the individuals of one sex, generally the
males, for the possession of the other sex. The
result is not death to the unsuccessful competitor,
but few or no offspring. Sexual selection is,
therefore, less rigorous than natural selection.
Generally, the most vigorous males, those which are
best fitted for their places in nature, will leave
most progeny. But in many cases victory depends
not so much on general vigour, but on having special
weapons, confined to the male sex. A hornless
stag or spurless cock would have a poor chance of
leaving numerous offspring. Sexual selection,
by always allowing the victor to breed, might surely
give indomitable courage, length of spur, and strength
to the wing to strike in the spurred leg, in nearly
the same manner as does the brutal cockfighter by
the careful selection of his best cocks. How low
in the scale of nature the law of battle descends
I know not; male alligators have been described as
fighting, bellowing, and whirling round, like Indians
in a war-dance, for the possession of the females;
male salmons have been observed fighting all day long;
male stag-beetles sometimes bear wounds from the huge
mandibles of other males; the males of certain hymenopterous
insects have been frequently seen by that inimitable
observer M. Fabre, fighting for a particular female
who sits by, an apparently unconcerned beholder of
the struggle, and then retires with the conqueror.
The war is, perhaps, severest between the males of
polygamous animals, and these seem oftenest provided
with special weapons. The males of carnivorous
animals are already well armed; though to them and
to others, special means of defence may be given through
means of sexual selection, as the mane of the lion,
and the hooked jaw to the male salmon; for the shield
may be as important for victory as the sword or spear.
Among birds, the contest is often
of a more peaceful character. All those who have
attended to the subject, believe that there is the
severest rivalry between the males of many species
to attract, by singing, the females. The rock-thrush
of Guiana, birds of paradise, and some others, congregate,
and successive males display with the most elaborate
care, and show off in the best manner, their gorgeous
plumage; they likewise perform strange antics before
the females, which, standing by as spectators, at
last choose the most attractive partner. Those
who have closely attended to birds in confinement
well know that they often take individual preferences
and dislikes: thus Sir R. Heron has described
how a pied peacock was eminently attractive to all
his hen birds. I cannot here enter on the necessary
details; but if man can in a short time give beauty
and an elegant carriage to his bantams, according
to his standard of beauty, I can see no good reason
to doubt that female birds, by selecting, during thousands
of generations, the most melodious or beautiful males,
according to their standard of beauty, might produce
a marked effect. Some well-known laws, with respect
to the plumage of male and female birds, in comparison
with the plumage of the young, can partly be explained
through the action of sexual selection on variations
occurring at different ages, and transmitted to the
males alone or to both sexes at corresponding ages;
but I have not space here to enter on this subject.
Thus it is, as I believe, that when
the males and females of any animal have the same
general habits of life, but differ in structure, colour,
or ornament, such differences have been mainly caused
by sexual selection: that is, by individual males
having had, in successive generations, some slight
advantage over other males, in their weapons, means
of defence, or charms; which they have transmitted
to their male offspring alone. Yet, I would not
wish to attribute all sexual differences to this agency:
for we see in our domestic animals peculiarities arising
and becoming attached to the male sex, which apparently
have not been augmented through selection by man.
The tuft of hair on the breast of the wild turkey-cock
cannot be of any use, and it is doubtful whether it
can be ornamental in the eyes of the female bird;
indeed, had the tuft appeared under domestication it
would have been called a monstrosity.
Illustrations of the
action of natural selection, or
the survival of the fittest.
In order to make it clear how, as
I believe, natural selection acts, I must beg permission
to give one or two imaginary illustrations. Let
us take the case of a wolf, which preys on various
animals, securing some by craft, some by strength,
and some by fleetness; and let us suppose that the
fleetest prey, a deer for instance, had from any change
in the country increased in numbers, or that other
prey had decreased in numbers, during that season
of the year when the wolf was hardest pressed for
food. Under such circumstances the swiftest and
slimmest wolves have the best chance of surviving,
and so be preserved or selected, provided always that
they retained strength to master their prey at this
or some other period of the year, when they were compelled
to prey on other animals. I can see no more reason
to doubt that this would be the result, than that
man should be able to improve the fleetness of his
greyhounds by careful and methodical selection, or
by that kind of unconscious selection which follows
from each man trying to keep the best dogs without
any thought of modifying the breed. I may add
that, according to Mr. Pierce, there are two varieties
of the wolf inhabiting the Catskill Mountains, in
the United States, one with a light greyhound-like
form, which pursues deer, and the other more bulky,
with shorter legs, which more frequently attacks the
shepherd’s flocks.
Even without any change in the proportional
numbers of the animals on which our wolf preyed, a
cub might be born with an innate tendency to pursue
certain kinds of prey. Nor can this be thought
very improbable; for we often observe great differences
in the natural tendencies of our domestic animals;
one cat, for instance, taking to catch rats, another
mice; one cat, according to Mr. St. John, bringing
home winged game, another hares or rabbits, and another
hunting on marshy ground and almost nightly catching
woodcocks or snipes. The tendency to catch rats
rather than mice is known to be inherited. Now,
if any slight innate change of habit or of structure
benefited an individual wolf, it would have the best
chance of surviving and of leaving offspring.
Some of its young would probably inherit the same
habits or structure, and by the repetition of this
process, a new variety might be formed which would
either supplant or coexist with the parent-form of
wolf. Or, again, the wolves inhabiting a mountainous
district, and those frequenting the lowlands, would
naturally be forced to hunt different prey; and from
the continued preservation of the individuals best
fitted for the two sites, two varieties might slowly
be formed. These varieties would cross and blend
where they met; but to this subject of intercrossing
we shall soon have to return. I may add, that,
according to Mr. Pierce, there are two varieties of
the wolf inhabiting the Catskill Mountains in the United
States, one with a light greyhound-like form, which
pursues deer, and the other more bulky, with shorter
legs, which more frequently attacks the shepherd’s
flocks.
It should be observed that in the
above illustration, I speak of the slimmest individual
wolves, and not of any single strongly marked variation
having been preserved. In former editions of this
work I sometimes spoke as if this latter alternative
had frequently occurred. I saw the great importance
of individual differences, and this led me fully to
discuss the results of unconscious selection by man,
which depends on the preservation of all the more or
less valuable individuals, and on the destruction
of the worst. I saw, also, that the preservation
in a state of nature of any occasional deviation of
structure, such as a monstrosity, would be a rare event;
and that, if at first preserved, it would generally
be lost by subsequent intercrossing with ordinary
individuals. Nevertheless, until reading an able
and valuable article in the “North British Review”
(1867), I did not appreciate how rarely single variations,
whether slight or strongly marked, could be perpetuated.
The author takes the case of a pair of animals, producing
during their lifetime two hundred offspring, of which,
from various causes of destruction, only two on an
average survive to pro-create their kind. This
is rather an extreme estimate for most of the higher
animals, but by no means so for many of the lower
organisms. He then shows that if a single individual
were born, which varied in some manner, giving it
twice as good a chance of life as that of the other
individuals, yet the chances would be strongly against
its survival. Supposing it to survive and to
breed, and that half its young inherited the favourable
variation; still, as the Reviewer goes onto show,
the young would have only a slightly better chance
of surviving and breeding; and this chance would go
on decreasing in the succeeding generations.
The justice of these remarks cannot, I think, be disputed.
If, for instance, a bird of some kind could procure
its food more easily by having its beak curved, and
if one were born with its beak strongly curved, and
which consequently flourished, nevertheless there would
be a very poor chance of this one individual perpetuating
its kind to the exclusion of the common form; but
there can hardly be a doubt, judging by what we see
taking place under domestication, that this result
would follow from the preservation during many generations
of a large number of individuals with more or less
strongly curved beaks, and from the destruction of
a still larger number with the straightest beaks.
It should not, however, be overlooked
that certain rather strongly marked variations, which
no one would rank as mere individual differences,
frequently recur owing to a similar organisation being
similarly acted on of which fact numerous
instances could be given with our domestic productions.
In such cases, if the varying individual did not actually
transmit to its offspring its newly-acquired character,
it would undoubtedly transmit to them, as long as
the existing conditions remained the same, a still
stronger tendency to vary in the same manner.
There can also be little doubt that the tendency to
vary in the same manner has often been so strong that
all the individuals of the same species have been
similarly modified without the aid of any form of
selection. Or only a third, fifth, or tenth part
of the individuals may have been thus affected, of
which fact several instances could be given.
Thus Graba estimates that about one-fifth of the guillemots
in the Faroe Islands consist of a variety so well
marked, that it was formerly ranked as a distinct
species under the name of Uria lacrymans. In cases
of this kind, if the variation were of a beneficial
nature, the original form would soon be supplanted
by the modified form, through the survival of the
fittest.
To the effects of intercrossing in
eliminating variations of all kinds, I shall have
to recur; but it may be here remarked that most animals
and plants keep to their proper homes, and do not
needlessly wander about; we see this even with migratory
birds, which almost always return to the same spot.
Consequently each newly-formed variety would generally
be at first local, as seems to be the common rule
with varieties in a state of nature; so that similarly
modified individuals would soon exist in a small body
together, and would often breed together. If the
new variety were successful in its battle for life,
it would slowly spread from a central district, competing
with and conquering the unchanged individuals on the
margins of an ever-increasing circle.
It may be worth while to give another
and more complex illustration of the action of natural
selection. Certain plants excrete sweet juice,
apparently for the sake of eliminating something injurious
from the sap: this is effected, for instance,
by glands at the base of the stipules in some Leguminosae,
and at the backs of the leaves of the common laurel.
This juice, though small in quantity, is greedily sought
by insects; but their visits do not in any way benefit
the plant. Now, let us suppose that the juice
or nectar was excreted from the inside of the flowers
of a certain number of plants of any species.
Insects in seeking the nectar would get dusted with
pollen, and would often transport it from one flower
to another. The flowers of two distinct individuals
of the same species would thus get crossed; and the
act of crossing, as can be fully proved, gives rise
to vigorous seedlings, which consequently would have
the best chance of flourishing and surviving.
The plants which produced flowers with the largest
glands or nectaries, excreting most nectar, would
oftenest be visited by insects, and would oftenest
be crossed; and so in the long-run would gain the
upper hand and form a local variety. The flowers,
also, which had their stamens and pistils placed, in
relation to the size and habits of the particular insect
which visited them, so as to favour in any degree
the transportal of the pollen, would likewise be favoured.
We might have taken the case of insects visiting flowers
for the sake of collecting pollen instead of nectar;
and as pollen is formed for the sole purpose of fertilisation,
its destruction appears to be a simple loss to the
plant; yet if a little pollen were carried, at first
occasionally and then habitually, by the pollen-devouring
insects from flower to flower, and a cross thus effected,
although nine-tenths of the pollen were destroyed it
might still be a great gain to the plant to be thus
robbed; and the individuals which produced more and
more pollen, and had larger anthers, would be selected.
When our plant, by the above process
long continued, had been rendered highly attractive
to insects, they would, unintentionally on their part,
regularly carry pollen from flower to flower; and that
they do this effectually I could easily show by many
striking facts. I will give only one, as likewise
illustrating one step in the separation of the sexes
of plants. Some holly-trees bear only male flowers,
which have four stamens producing a rather small quantity
of pollen, and a rudimentary pistil; other holly-trees
bear only female flowers; these have a full-sized
pistil, and four stamens with shrivelled anthers, in
which not a grain of pollen can be detected.
Having found a female tree exactly sixty yards from
a male tree, I put the stigmas of twenty flowers, taken
from different branches, under the microscope, and
on all, without exception, there were a few pollen-grains,
and on some a profusion. As the wind had set
for several days from the female to the male tree,
the pollen could not thus have been carried.
The weather had been cold and boisterous and therefore
not favourable to bees, nevertheless every female flower
which I examined had been effectually fertilised by
the bees, which had flown from tree to tree in search
of nectar. But to return to our imaginary case;
as soon as the plant had been rendered so highly attractive
to insects that pollen was regularly carried from
flower to flower, another process might commence.
No naturalist doubts the advantage of what has been
called the “physiological division of labour;”
hence we may believe that it would be advantageous
to a plant to produce stamens alone in one flower
or on one whole plant, and pistils alone in another
flower or on another plant. In plants under culture
and placed under new conditions of life, sometimes
the male organs and sometimes the female organs become
more or less impotent; now if we suppose this to occur
in ever so slight a degree under nature, then, as
pollen is already carried regularly from flower to
flower, and as a more complete separation of the sexes
of our plant would be advantageous on the principle
of the division of labour, individuals with this tendency
more and more increased, would be continually favoured
or selected, until at last a complete separation of
the sexes might be effected. It would take up
too much space to show the various steps, through dimorphism
and other means, by which the separation of the sexes
in plants of various kinds is apparently now in progress;
but I may add that some of the species of holly in
North America are, according to Asa Gray, in an exactly
intermediate condition, or, as he expresses it, are
more or less dioeciously polygamous.
Let us now turn to the nectar-feeding
insects; we may suppose the plant of which we have
been slowly increasing the nectar by continued selection,
to be a common plant; and that certain insects depended
in main part on its nectar for food. I could
give many facts showing how anxious bees are to save
time: for instance, their habit of cutting holes
and sucking the nectar at the bases of certain flowers,
which with a very little more trouble they can enter
by the mouth. Bearing such facts in mind, it
may be believed that under certain circumstances individual
differences in the curvature or length of the proboscis,
etc., too slight to be appreciated by us, might
profit a bee or other insect, so that certain individuals
would be able to obtain their food more quickly than
others; and thus the communities to which they belonged
would flourish and throw off many swarms inheriting
the same peculiarities. The tubes of the corolla
of the common red or incarnate clovers (Trifolium
pratense and incarnatum) do not on a hasty
glance appear to differ in length; yet the hive-bee
can easily suck the nectar out of the incarnate clover,
but not out of the common red clover, which is visited
by humble-bees alone; so that whole fields of the red
clover offer in vain an abundant supply of precious
nectar to the hive-bee. That this nectar is much
liked by the hive-bee is certain; for I have repeatedly
seen, but only in the autumn, many hive-bees sucking
the flowers through holes bitten in the base of the
tube by humble bees. The difference in the length
of the corolla in the two kinds of clover, which determines
the visits of the hive-bee, must be very trifling;
for I have been assured that when red clover has been
mown, the flowers of the second crop are somewhat
smaller, and that these are visited by many hive-bees.
I do not know whether this statement is accurate; nor
whether another published statement can be trusted,
namely, that the Ligurian bee, which is generally
considered a mere variety of the common hive-bee,
and which freely crosses with it, is able to reach
and suck the nectar of the red clover. Thus,
in a country where this kind of clover abounded, it
might be a great advantage to the hive-bee to have
a slightly longer or differently constructed proboscis.
On the other hand, as the fertility of this clover
absolutely depends on bees visiting the flowers, if
humble-bees were to become rare in any country, it
might be a great advantage to the plant to have a
shorter or more deeply divided corolla, so that the
hive-bees should be enabled to suck its flowers.
Thus I can understand how a flower and a bee might
slowly become, either simultaneously or one after
the other, modified and adapted to each other in the
most perfect manner, by the continued preservation
of all the individuals which presented slight deviations
of structure mutually favourable to each other.
I am well aware that this doctrine
of natural selection, exemplified in the above imaginary
instances, is open to the same objections which were
first urged against Sir Charles Lyell’s noble
views on “the modern changes of the earth, as
illustrative of geology;” but we now seldom
hear the agencies which we see still at work, spoken
of as trifling and insignificant, when used in explaining
the excavation of the deepest valleys or the formation
of long lines of inland cliffs. Natural selection
acts only by the preservation and accumulation of small
inherited modifications, each profitable to the preserved
being; and as modern geology has almost banished such
views as the excavation of a great valley by a single
diluvial wave, so will natural selection banish the
belief of the continued creation of new organic beings,
or of any great and sudden modification in their structure.
On the intercrossing of individuals.
I must here introduce a short digression.
In the case of animals and plants with separated sexes,
it is of course obvious that two individuals must
always (with the exception of the curious and not well
understood cases of parthenogenesis) unite for each
birth; but in the case of hermaphrodites this is far
from obvious. Nevertheless there is reason to
believe that with all hermaphrodites two individuals,
either occasionally or habitually, concur for the
reproduction of their kind. This view was long
ago doubtfully suggested by Sprengel, Knight and
Kolreuter. We shall presently see its importance;
but I must here treat the subject with extreme brevity,
though I have the materials prepared for an ample
discussion. All vertebrate animals, all insects
and some other large groups of animals, pair for each
birth. Modern research has much diminished the
number of supposed hermaphrodites and of real hermaphrodites
a large number pair; that is, two individuals regularly
unite for reproduction, which is all that concerns
us. But still there are many hermaphrodite animals
which certainly do not habitually pair, and a vast
majority of plants are hermaphrodites. What reason,
it may be asked, is there for supposing in these cases
that two individuals ever concur in reproduction?
As it is impossible here to enter on details, I must
trust to some general considerations alone.
In the first place, I have collected
so large a body of facts, and made so many experiments,
showing, in accordance with the almost universal belief
of breeders, that with animals and plants a cross between
different varieties, or between individuals of the
same variety but of another strain, gives vigour and
fertility to the offspring; and on the other hand,
that close interbreeding diminishes vigour and
fertility; that these facts alone incline me to believe
that it is a general law of nature that no organic
being fertilises itself for a perpetuity of generations;
but that a cross with another individual is occasionally perhaps
at long intervals of time indispensable.
On the belief that this is a law of
nature, we can, I think, understand several large
classes of facts, such as the following, which on any
other view are inexplicable. Every hybridizer
knows how unfavourable exposure to wet is to the fertilisation
of a flower, yet what a multitude of flowers have
their anthers and stigmas fully exposed to the weather!
If an occasional cross be indispensable, notwithstanding
that the plant’s own anthers and pistil stand
so near each other as almost to ensure self-fertilisation,
the fullest freedom for the entrance of pollen from
another individual will explain the above state of
exposure of the organs. Many flowers, on the
other hand, have their organs of fructification closely
enclosed, as in the great papilionaceous or pea-family;
but these almost invariably present beautiful and curious
adaptations in relation to the visits of insects.
So necessary are the visits of bees to many papilionaceous
flowers, that their fertility is greatly diminished
if these visits be prevented. Now, it is scarcely
possible for insects to fly from flower to flower,
and not to carry pollen from one to the other, to
the great good of the plant. Insects act like
a camel-hair pencil, and it is sufficient, to ensure
fertilisation, just to touch with the same brush the
anthers of one flower and then the stigma of another;
but it must not be supposed that bees would thus produce
a multitude of hybrids between distinct species; for
if a plant’s own pollen and that from another
species are placed on the same stigma, the former
is so prepotent that it invariably and completely
destroys, as has been shown by Gartner, the influence
of the foreign pollen.
When the stamens of a flower suddenly
spring towards the pistil, or slowly move one after
the other towards it, the contrivance seems adapted
solely to ensure self-fertilisation; and no doubt it
is useful for this end: but the agency of insects
is often required to cause the stamens to spring forward,
as Kolreuter has shown to be the case with the barberry;
and in this very genus, which seems to have a special
contrivance for self-fertilisation, it is well known
that, if closely-allied forms or varieties are planted
near each other, it is hardly possible to raise pure
seedlings, so largely do they naturally cross.
In numerous other cases, far from self-fertilisation
being favoured, there are special contrivances which
effectually prevent the stigma receiving pollen from
its own flower, as I could show from the works of
Sprengel and others, as well as from my own observations:
for instance, in Lobelia fulgens, there is a
really beautiful and elaborate contrivance by which
all the infinitely numerous pollen-granules are swept
out of the conjoined anthers of each flower, before
the stigma of that individual flower is ready to receive
them; and as this flower is never visited, at least
in my garden, by insects, it never sets a seed, though
by placing pollen from one flower on the stigma of
another, I raise plenty of seedlings. Another
species of Lobelia, which is visited by bees, seeds
freely in my garden. In very many other cases,
though there is no special mechanical contrivance
to prevent the stigma receiving pollen from the same
flower, yet, as Sprengel, and more recently Hildebrand
and others have shown, and as I can confirm, either
the anthers burst before the stigma is ready for fertilisation,
or the stigma is ready before the pollen of that flower
is ready, so that these so-named dichogamous plants
have in fact separated sexes, and must habitually
be crossed. So it is with the reciprocally dimorphic
and trimorphic plants previously alluded to.
How strange are these facts! How strange that
the pollen and stigmatic surface of the same flower,
though placed so close together, as if for the very
purpose of self-fertilisation, should be in so many
cases mutually useless to each other! How simply
are these facts explained on the view of an occasional
cross with a distinct individual being advantageous
or indispensable!
If several varieties of the cabbage,
radish, onion, and of some other plants, be allowed
to seed near each other, a large majority of the seedlings
thus raised turn out, as I found, mongrels: for
instance, I raised 233 seedling cabbages from some
plants of different varieties growing near each other,
and of these only 78 were true to their kind, and
some even of these were not perfectly true. Yet
the pistil of each cabbage-flower is surrounded not
only by its own six stamens but by those of the many
other flowers on the same plant; and the pollen of
each flower readily gets on its stigma without insect
agency; for I have found that plants carefully protected
from insects produce the full number of pods.
How, then, comes it that such a vast number of the
seedlings are mongrelized? It must arise from
the pollen of a distinct variety having a prepotent
effect over the flower’s own pollen; and that
this is part of the general law of good being derived
from the intercrossing of distinct individuals of
the same species. When distinct species
are crossed the case is reversed, for a plant’s
own pollen is always prepotent over foreign pollen;
but to this subject we shall return in a future chapter.
In the case of a large tree covered
with innumerable flowers, it may be objected that
pollen could seldom be carried from tree to tree, and
at most only from flower to flower on the same tree;
and flowers on the same tree can be considered as
distinct individuals only in a limited sense.
I believe this objection to be valid, but that nature
has largely provided against it by giving to trees
a strong tendency to bear flowers with separated sexes.
When the sexes are separated, although the male and
female flowers may be produced on the same tree, pollen
must be regularly carried from flower to flower; and
this will give a better chance of pollen being occasionally
carried from tree to tree. That trees belonging
to all orders have their sexes more often separated
than other plants, I find to be the case in this country;
and at my request Dr. Hooker tabulated the trees of
New Zealand, and Dr. Asa Gray those of the United
States, and the result was as I anticipated. On
the other hand, Dr. Hooker informs me that the rule
does not hold good in Australia: but if most
of the Australian trees are dichogamous, the same
result would follow as if they bore flowers with separated
sexes. I have made these few remarks on trees
simply to call attention to the subject.
Turning for a brief space to animals:
various terrestrial species are hermaphrodites, such
as the land-mollusca and earth-worms; but these all
pair. As yet I have not found a single terrestrial
animal which can fertilise itself. This remarkable
fact, which offers so strong a contrast with terrestrial
plants, is intelligible on the view of an occasional
cross being indispensable; for owing to the nature
of the fertilising element there are no means, analogous
to the action of insects and of the wind with plants,
by which an occasional cross could be effected with
terrestrial animals without the concurrence of two
individuals. Of aquatic animals, there are many
self-fertilising hermaphrodites; but here the currents
of water offer an obvious means for an occasional
cross. As in the case of flowers, I have as yet
failed, after consultation with one of the highest
authorities, namely, Professor Huxley, to discover
a single hermaphrodite animal with the organs of reproduction
so perfectly enclosed that access from without, and
the occasional influence of a distinct individual,
can be shown to be physically impossible. Cirripedes
long appeared to me to present, under this point of
view, a case of great difficulty; but I have been
enabled, by a fortunate chance, to prove that two individuals,
though both are self-fertilising hermaphrodites, do
sometimes cross.
It must have struck most naturalists
as a strange anomaly that, both with animals and plants,
some species of the same family and even of the same
genus, though agreeing closely with each other in their
whole organisation, are hermaphrodites, and some unisexual.
But if, in fact, all hermaphrodites do occasionally
intercross, the difference between them and unisexual
species is, as far as function is concerned, very
small.
From these several considerations
and from the many special facts which I have collected,
but which I am unable here to give, it appears that
with animals and plants an occasional intercross between
distinct individuals is a very general, if not universal,
law of nature.
Circumstances favourable
for the production of new
forms through natural selection.
This is an extremely intricate subject.
A great amount of variability, under which term individual
differences are always included, will evidently be
favourable. A large number of individuals, by
giving a better chance within any given period for
the appearance of profitable variations, will compensate
for a lesser amount of variability in each individual,
and is, I believe, a highly important element of success.
Though nature grants long periods of time for the work
of natural selection, she does not grant an indefinite
period; for as all organic beings are striving to
seize on each place in the economy of nature, if any
one species does not become modified and improved in
a corresponding degree with its competitors it will
be exterminated. Unless favourable variations
be inherited by some at least of the offspring, nothing
can be effected by natural selection. The tendency
to reversion may often check or prevent the work;
but as this tendency has not prevented man from forming
by selection numerous domestic races, why should it
prevail against natural selection?
In the case of methodical selection,
a breeder selects for some definite object, and if
the individuals be allowed freely to intercross, his
work will completely fail. But when many men,
without intending to alter the breed, have a nearly
common standard of perfection, and all try to procure
and breed from the best animals, improvement surely
but slowly follows from this unconscious process of
selection, notwithstanding that there is no separation
of selected individuals. Thus it will be under
nature; for within a confined area, with some place
in the natural polity not perfectly occupied, all
the individuals varying in the right direction, though
in different degrees, will tend to be preserved.
But if the area be large, its several districts will
almost certainly present different conditions of life;
and then, if the same species undergoes modification
in different districts, the newly formed varieties
will intercross on the confines of each. But we
shall see in the sixth chapter that intermediate varieties,
inhabiting intermediate districts, will in the long
run generally be supplanted by one of the adjoining
varieties. Intercrossing will chiefly affect those
animals which unite for each birth and wander much,
and which do not breed at a very quick rate.
Hence with animals of this nature, for instance birds,
varieties will generally be confined to separated countries;
and this I find to be the case. With hermaphrodite
organisms which cross only occasionally, and likewise
with animals which unite for each birth, but which
wander little and can increase at a rapid rate, a new
and improved variety might be quickly formed on any
one spot, and might there maintain itself in a body
and afterward spread, so that the individuals of the
new variety would chiefly cross together. On this
principle nurserymen always prefer saving seed from
a large body of plants, as the chance of intercrossing
is thus lessened.
Even with animals which unite for
each birth, and which do not propagate rapidly, we
must not assume that free intercrossing would always
eliminate the effects of natural selection; for I can
bring forward a considerable body of facts showing
that within the same area two varieties of the same
animal may long remain distinct, from haunting different
stations, from breeding at slightly different seasons,
or from the individuals of each variety preferring
to pair together.
Intercrossing plays a very important
part in nature by keeping the individuals of the same
species, or of the same variety, true and uniform
in character. It will obviously thus act far more
efficiently with those animals which unite for each
birth; but, as already stated, we have reason to believe
that occasional intercrosses take place with all animals
and plants. Even if these take place only at long
intervals of time, the young thus produced will gain
so much in vigour and fertility over the offspring
from long-continued self-fertilisation, that they
will have a better chance of surviving and propagating
their kind; and thus in the long run the influence
of crosses, even at rare intervals, will be great.
With respect to organic beings extremely low in the
scale, which do not propagate sexually, nor conjugate,
and which cannot possibly intercross, uniformity of
character can be retained by them under the same conditions
of life, only through the principle of inheritance,
and through natural selection which will destroy any
individuals departing from the proper type. If
the conditions of life change and the form undergoes
modification, uniformity of character can be given
to the modified offspring, solely by natural selection
preserving similar favourable variations.
Isolation also is an important element
in the modification of species through natural selection.
In a confined or isolated area, if not very large,
the organic and inorganic conditions of life will generally
be almost uniform; so that natural selection will
tend to modify all the varying individuals of the
same species in the same manner. Intercrossing
with the inhabitants of the surrounding districts,
will also be thus prevented. Moritz Wagner has
lately published an interesting essay on this subject,
and has shown that the service rendered by isolation
in preventing crosses between newly-formed varieties
is probably greater even than I supposed. But
from reasons already assigned I can by no means agree
with this naturalist, that migration and isolation
are necessary elements for the formation of new species.
The importance of isolation is likewise great in preventing,
after any physical change in the conditions, such as
of climate, elevation of the land, etc., the
immigration of better adapted organisms; and thus
new places in the natural economy of the district
will be left open to be filled up by the modification
of the old inhabitants. Lastly, isolation will
give time for a new variety to be improved at a slow
rate; and this may sometimes be of much importance.
If, however, an isolated area be very small, either
from being surrounded by barriers, or from having
very peculiar physical conditions, the total number
of the inhabitants will be small; and this will retard
the production of new species through natural selection,
by decreasing the chances of favourable variations
arising.
The mere lapse of time by itself does
nothing, either for or against natural selection.
I state this because it has been erroneously asserted
that the element of time has been assumed by me to
play an all-important part in modifying species, as
if all the forms of life were necessarily undergoing
change through some innate law. Lapse of time
is only so far important, and its importance in this
respect is great, that it gives a better chance of
beneficial variations arising and of their being selected,
accumulated, and fixed. It likewise tends to increase
the direct action of the physical conditions of life,
in relation to the constitution of each organism.
If we turn to nature to test the truth
of these remarks, and look at any small isolated area,
such as an oceanic island, although the number of
the species inhabiting it is small, as we shall see
in our chapter on Geographical Distribution; yet of
these species a very large proportion are endemic, that
is, have been produced there and nowhere else in the
world. Hence an oceanic island at first sight
seems to have been highly favourable for the production
of new species. But we may thus deceive ourselves,
for to ascertain whether a small isolated area, or
a large open area like a continent, has been most
favourable for the production of new organic forms,
we ought to make the comparison within equal times;
and this we are incapable of doing.
Although isolation is of great importance
in the production of new species, on the whole I am
inclined to believe that largeness of area is still
more important, especially for the production of species
which shall prove capable of enduring for a long period,
and of spreading widely. Throughout a great and
open area, not only will there be a better chance
of favourable variations, arising from the large number
of individuals of the same species there supported,
but the conditions of life are much more complex from
the large number of already existing species; and
if some of these many species become modified and improved,
others will have to be improved in a corresponding
degree, or they will be exterminated. Each new
form, also, as soon as it has been much improved,
will be able to spread over the open and continuous
area, and will thus come into competition with many
other forms. Moreover, great areas, though now
continuous, will often, owing to former oscillations
of level, have existed in a broken condition, so that
the good effects of isolation will generally, to a
certain extent, have concurred. Finally, I conclude
that, although small isolated areas have been in some
respects highly favourable for the production of new
species, yet that the course of modification will
generally have been more rapid on large areas; and
what is more important, that the new forms produced
on large areas, which already have been victorious
over many competitors, will be those that will spread
most widely, and will give rise to the greatest number
of new varieties and species. They will thus play
a more important part in the changing history of the
organic world.
In accordance with this view, we can,
perhaps, understand some facts which will be again
alluded to in our chapter on Geographical Distribution;
for instance, the fact of the productions of the smaller
continent of Australia now yielding before those of
the larger Europaeo-Asiatic area. Thus, also,
it is that continental productions have everywhere
become so largely naturalised on islands. On a
small island, the race for life will have been less
severe, and there will have been less modification
and less extermination. Hence, we can understand
how it is that the flora of Madeira, according to Oswald
Heer, resembles to a certain extent the extinct tertiary
flora of Europe. All fresh water basins, taken
together, make a small area compared with that of
the sea or of the land. Consequently, the competition
between fresh water productions will have been less
severe than elsewhere; new forms will have been more
slowly produced, and old forms more slowly exterminated.
And it is in fresh water basins that we find seven
genera of Ganoid fishes, remnants of a once preponderant
order: and in fresh water we find some of the
most anomalous forms now known in the world, as the
Ornithorhynchus and Lepidosiren, which, like fossils,
connect to a certain extent orders at present widely
separated in the natural scale. These anomalous
forms may be called living fossils; they have endured
to the present day, from having inhabited a confined
area, and from having been exposed to less varied,
and therefore less severe, competition.
To sum up, as far as the extreme intricacy
of the subject permits, the circumstances favourable
and unfavourable for the production of new species
through natural selection. I conclude that for
terrestrial productions a large continental area,
which has undergone many oscillations of level, will
have been the most favourable for the production of
many new forms of life, fitted to endure for a long
time and to spread widely. While the area existed
as a continent the inhabitants will have been numerous
in individuals and kinds, and will have been subjected
to severe competition. When converted by subsidence
into large separate islands there will still have existed
many individuals of the same species on each island:
intercrossing on the confines of the range of each
new species will have been checked: after physical
changes of any kind immigration will have been prevented,
so that new places in the polity of each island will
have had to be filled up by the modification of the
old inhabitants; and time will have been allowed for
the varieties in each to become well modified and perfected.
When, by renewed elevation, the islands were reconverted
into a continental area, there will again have been
very severe competition; the most favoured or improved
varieties will have been enabled to spread; there
will have been much extinction of the less improved
forms, and the relative proportional numbers of the
various inhabitants of the reunited continent will
again have been changed; and again there will have
been a fair field for natural selection to improve
still further the inhabitants, and thus to produce
new species.
That natural selection generally act
with extreme slowness I fully admit. It can act
only when there are places in the natural polity of
a district which can be better occupied by the modification
of some of its existing inhabitants. The occurrence
of such places will often depend on physical changes,
which generally take place very slowly, and on the
immigration of better adapted forms being prevented.
As some few of the old inhabitants become modified
the mutual relations of others will often be disturbed;
and this will create new places, ready to be filled
up by better adapted forms; but all this will take
place very slowly. Although all the individuals
of the same species differ in some slight degree from
each other, it would often be long before differences
of the right nature in various parts of the organisation
might occur. The result would often be greatly
retarded by free intercrossing. Many will exclaim
that these several causes are amply sufficient to neutralise
the power of natural selection. I do not believe
so. But I do believe that natural selection will
generally act very slowly, only at long intervals
of time, and only on a few of the inhabitants of the
same region. I further believe that these slow,
intermittent results accord well with what geology
tells us of the rate and manner at which the inhabitants
of the world have changed.
Slow though the process of selection
may be, if feeble man can do much by artificial selection,
I can see no limit to the amount of change, to the
beauty and complexity of the coadaptations between
all organic beings, one with another and with their
physical conditions of life, which may have been effected
in the long course of time through nature’s
power of selection, that is by the survival of the
fittest.
Extinction caused by natural selection.
This subject will be more fully discussed
in our chapter on Geology; but it must here be alluded
to from being intimately connected with natural selection.
Natural selection acts solely through the preservation
of variations in some way advantageous, which consequently
endure. Owing to the high geometrical rate of
increase of all organic beings, each area is already
fully stocked with inhabitants, and it follows from
this, that as the favoured forms increase in number,
so, generally, will the less favoured decrease and
become rare. Rarity, as geology tells us, is
the precursor to extinction. We can see that any
form which is represented by few individuals will
run a good chance of utter extinction, during great
fluctuations in the nature or the seasons, or from
a temporary increase in the number of its enemies.
But we may go further than this; for as new forms
are produced, unless we admit that specific forms
can go on indefinitely increasing in number, many old
forms must become extinct. That the number of
specific forms has not indefinitely increased, geology
plainly tells us; and we shall presently attempt to
show why it is that the number of species throughout
the world has not become immeasurably great.
We have seen that the species which
are most numerous in individuals have the best chance
of producing favourable variations within any given
period. We have evidence of this, in the facts
stated in the second chapter, showing that it is the
common and diffused or dominant species which offer
the greatest number of recorded varieties. Hence,
rare species will be less quickly modified or improved
within any given period; they will consequently be
beaten in the race for life by the modified and improved
descendants of the commoner species.
From these several considerations
I think it inevitably follows, that as new species
in the course of time are formed through natural selection,
others will become rarer and rarer, and finally extinct.
The forms which stand in closest competition with those
undergoing modification and improvement, will naturally
suffer most. And we have seen in the chapter
on the Struggle for Existence that it is the most
closely-allied forms, varieties of the same
species, and species of the same genus or related
genera, which, from having nearly the same
structure, constitution and habits, generally come
into the severest competition with each other.
Consequently, each new variety or species, during
the progress of its formation, will generally press
hardest on its nearest kindred, and tend to exterminate
them. We see the same process of extermination
among our domesticated productions, through the selection
of improved forms by man. Many curious instances
could be given showing how quickly new breeds of cattle,
sheep and other animals, and varieties of flowers,
take the place of older and inferior kinds. In
Yorkshire, it is historically known that the ancient
black cattle were displaced by the long-horns, and
that these “were swept away by the short-horns”
(I quote the words of an agricultural writer) “as
if by some murderous pestilence.”
Divergence of character.
The principle, which I have designated
by this term, is of high importance, and explains,
as I believe, several important facts. In the
first place, varieties, even strongly-marked ones,
though having somewhat of the character of species as
is shown by the hopeless doubts in many cases how
to rank them yet certainly differ far less
from each other than do good and distinct species.
Nevertheless according to my view, varieties are species
in the process of formation, or are, as I have called
them, incipient species. How, then, does the lesser
difference between varieties become augmented into
the greater difference between species? That
this does habitually happen, we must infer from most
of the innumerable species throughout nature presenting
well-marked differences; whereas varieties, the supposed
prototypes and parents of future well-marked species,
present slight and ill-defined differences. Mere
chance, as we may call it, might cause one variety
to differ in some character from its parents, and the
offspring of this variety again to differ from its
parent in the very same character and in a greater
degree; but this alone would never account for so habitual
and large a degree of difference as that between the
species of the same genus.
As has always been my practice, I
have sought light on this head from our domestic productions.
We shall here find something analogous. It will
be admitted that the production of races so different
as short-horn and Hereford cattle, race and cart horses,
the several breeds of pigeons, etc., could never
have been effected by the mere chance accumulation
of similar variations during many successive generations.
In practice, a fancier is, for instance, struck by
a pigeon having a slightly shorter beak; another fancier
is struck by a pigeon having a rather longer beak;
and on the acknowledged principle that “fanciers
do not and will not admire a medium standard, but
like extremes,” they both go on (as has actually
occurred with the sub-breeds of the tumbler-pigeon)
choosing and breeding from birds with longer and longer
beaks, or with shorter and shorter beaks. Again,
we may suppose that at an early period of history,
the men of one nation or district required swifter
horses, while those of another required stronger and
bulkier horses. The early differences would be
very slight; but, in the course of time, from the
continued selection of swifter horses in the one case,
and of stronger ones in the other, the differences
would become greater, and would be noted as forming
two sub-breeds. Ultimately after the lapse of
centuries, these sub-breeds would become converted
into two well-established and distinct breeds.
As the differences became greater, the inferior animals
with intermediate characters, being neither very swift
nor very strong, would not have been used for breeding,
and will thus have tended to disappear. Here,
then, we see in man’s productions the action
of what may be called the principle of divergence,
causing differences, at first barely appreciable,
steadily to increase, and the breeds to diverge in
character, both from each other and from their common
parent.
But how, it may be asked, can any
analogous principle apply in nature? I believe
it can and does apply most efficiently (though it was
a long time before I saw how), from the simple circumstance
that the more diversified the descendants from any
one species become in structure, constitution, and
habits, by so much will they be better enabled to
seize on many and widely diversified places in the
polity of nature, and so be enabled to increase in
numbers.
We can clearly discern this in the
case of animals with simple habits. Take the
case of a carnivorous quadruped, of which the number
that can be supported in any country has long ago
arrived at its full average. If its natural power
of increase be allowed to act, it can succeed in increasing
(the country not undergoing any change in conditions)
only by its varying descendants seizing on places
at present occupied by other animals: some of
them, for instance, being enabled to feed on new kinds
of prey, either dead or alive; some inhabiting new
stations, climbing trees, frequenting water, and some
perhaps becoming less carnivorous. The more diversified
in habits and structure the descendants of our carnivorous
animals become, the more places they will be enabled
to occupy. What applies to one animal will apply
throughout all time to all animals that
is, if they vary for otherwise natural selection
can effect nothing. So it will be with plants.
It has been experimentally proved, that if a plot
of ground be sown with one species of grass, and a
similar plot be sown with several distinct genera of
grasses, a greater number of plants and a greater
weight of dry herbage can be raised in the latter
than in the former case. The same has been found
to hold good when one variety and several mixed varieties
of wheat have been sown on equal spaces of ground.
Hence, if any one species of grass were to go on varying,
and the varieties were continually selected which
differed from each other in the same manner, though
in a very slight degree, as do the distinct species
and genera of grasses, a greater number of individual
plants of this species, including its modified descendants,
would succeed in living on the same piece of ground.
And we know that each species and each variety of
grass is annually sowing almost countless seeds; and
is thus striving, as it may be said, to the utmost
to increase in number. Consequently, in the course
of many thousand generations, the most distinct varieties
of any one species of grass would have the best chance
of succeeding and of increasing in numbers, and thus
of supplanting the less distinct varieties; and varieties,
when rendered very distinct from each other, take the
rank of species.
The truth of the principle that the
greatest amount of life can be supported by great
diversification of structure, is seen under many natural
circumstances. In an extremely small area, especially
if freely open to immigration, and where the contest
between individual and individual must be very severe,
we always find great diversity in its inhabitants.
For instance, I found that a piece of turf, three feet
by four in size, which had been exposed for many years
to exactly the same conditions, supported twenty species
of plants, and these belonged to eighteen genera and
to eight orders, which shows how much these plants
differed from each other. So it is with the plants
and insects on small and uniform islets: also
in small ponds of fresh water. Farmers find that
they can raise more food by a rotation of plants belonging
to the most different orders: nature follows
what may be called a simultaneous rotation. Most
of the animals and plants which live close round any
small piece of ground, could live on it (supposing
its nature not to be in any way peculiar), and may
be said to be striving to the utmost to live there;
but, it is seen, that where they come into the closest
competition, the advantages of diversification of structure,
with the accompanying differences of habit and constitution,
determine that the inhabitants, which thus jostle
each other most closely, shall, as a general rule,
belong to what we call different genera and orders.
The same principle is seen in the
naturalisation of plants through man’s agency
in foreign lands. It might have been expected
that the plants which would succeed in becoming naturalised
in any land would generally have been closely allied
to the indigenes; for these are commonly looked at
as specially created and adapted for their own country.
It might also, perhaps, have been expected that naturalised
plants would have belonged to a few groups more especially
adapted to certain stations in their new homes.
But the case is very different; and Alph. de Candolle
has well remarked, in his great and admirable work,
that floras gain by naturalisation, proportionally
with the number of the native genera and species,
far more in new genera than in new species. To
give a single instance: in the last edition of
Dr. Asa Gray’s “Manual of the Flora of
the Northern United States,” 260 naturalised
plants are enumerated, and these belong to 162 genera.
We thus see that these naturalised plants are of a
highly diversified nature. They differ, moreover,
to a large extent, from the indigenes, for out of
the 162 naturalised genera, no less than 100 genera
are not there indigenous, and thus a large proportional
addition is made to the genera now living in the United
States.
By considering the nature of the plants
or animals which have in any country struggled successfully
with the indigenes, and have there become naturalised,
we may gain some crude idea in what manner some of
the natives would have had to be modified in order
to gain an advantage over their compatriots; and we
may at least infer that diversification of structure,
amounting to new generic differences, would be profitable
to them.
The advantage of diversification of
structure in the inhabitants of the same region is,
in fact, the same as that of the physiological division
of labour in the organs of the same individual body a
subject so well elucidated by Milne Edwards.
No physiologist doubts that a stomach by being adapted
to digest vegetable matter alone, or flesh alone, draws
most nutriment from these substances. So in the
general economy of any land, the more widely and perfectly
the animals and plants are diversified for different
habits of life, so will a greater number of individuals
be capable of there supporting themselves. A set
of animals, with their organisation but little diversified,
could hardly compete with a set more perfectly diversified
in structure. It may be doubted, for instance,
whether the Australian marsupials, which are divided
into groups differing but little from each other,
and feebly representing, as Mr. Waterhouse and others
have remarked, our carnivorous, ruminant, and rodent
mammals, could successfully compete with these well-developed
orders. In the Australian mammals, we see the
process of diversification in an early and incomplete
stage of development.
The probable effects
of the action of natural selection
through divergence of character
and extinction, on the descendants
of A common ancestor.
After the foregoing discussion, which
has been much compressed, we may assume that the modified
descendants of any one species will succeed so much
the better as they become more diversified in structure,
and are thus enabled to encroach on places occupied
by other beings. Now let us see how this principle
of benefit being derived from divergence of character,
combined with the principles of natural selection and
of extinction, tends to act.
The accompanying diagram will aid
us in understanding this rather perplexing subject.
Let A to L represent the species of a genus large
in its own country; these species are supposed to resemble
each other in unequal degrees, as is so generally
the case in nature, and as is represented in the diagram
by the letters standing at unequal distances.
I have said a large genus, because as we saw in the
second chapter, on an average more species vary in
large genera than in small genera; and the varying
species of the large genera present a greater number
of varieties. We have, also, seen that the species,
which are the commonest and most widely-diffused,
vary more than do the rare and restricted species.
Let (A) be a common, widely-diffused, and varying species,
belonging to a genus large in its own country.
The branching and diverging dotted lines of unequal
lengths proceeding from (A), may represent its varying
offspring. The variations are supposed to be
extremely slight, but of the most diversified nature;
they are not supposed all to appear simultaneously,
but often after long intervals of time; nor are they
all supposed to endure for equal periods. Only
those variations which are in some way profitable will
be preserved or naturally selected. And here
the importance of the principle of benefit derived
from divergence of character comes in; for this will
generally lead to the most different or divergent
variations (represented by the outer dotted lines)
being preserved and accumulated by natural selection.
When a dotted line reaches one of the horizontal lines,
and is there marked by a small numbered letter, a sufficient
amount of variation is supposed to have been accumulated
to form it into a fairly well-marked variety, such
as would be thought worthy of record in a systematic
work.
The intervals between the horizontal
lines in the diagram, may represent each a thousand
or more generations. After a thousand generations,
species (A) is supposed to have produced two fairly
well-marked varieties, namely a1 and m1. These
two varieties will generally still be exposed to the
same conditions which made their parents variable,
and the tendency to variability is in itself hereditary;
consequently they will likewise tend to vary, and
commonly in nearly the same manner as did their parents.
Moreover, these two varieties, being only slightly
modified forms, will tend to inherit those advantages
which made their parent (A) more numerous than most
of the other inhabitants of the same country; they
will also partake of those more general advantages
which made the genus to which the parent-species belonged,
a large genus in its own country. And all these
circumstances are favourable to the production of
new varieties.
If, then, these two varieties be variable,
the most divergent of their variations will generally
be preserved during the next thousand generations.
And after this interval, variety a1 is supposed in
the diagram to have produced variety a2, which will,
owing to the principle of divergence, differ more
from (A) than did variety a1. Variety m1 is supposed
to have produced two varieties, namely m2 and s2, differing
from each other, and more considerably from their common
parent (A). We may continue the process by similar
steps for any length of time; some of the varieties,
after each thousand generations, producing only a
single variety, but in a more and more modified condition,
some producing two or three varieties, and some failing
to produce any. Thus the varieties or modified
descendants of the common parent (A), will generally
go on increasing in number and diverging in character.
In the diagram the process is represented up to the
ten-thousandth generation, and under a condensed and
simplified form up to the fourteen-thousandth generation.
But I must here remark that I do not
suppose that the process ever goes on so regularly
as is represented in the diagram, though in itself
made somewhat irregular, nor that it goes on continuously;
it is far more probable that each form remains for
long periods unaltered, and then again undergoes modification.
Nor do I suppose that the most divergent varieties
are invariably preserved: a medium form may often
long endure, and may or may not produce more than
one modified descendant; for natural selection will
always act according to the nature of the places which
are either unoccupied or not perfectly occupied by
other beings; and this will depend on infinitely complex
relations. But as a general rule, the more diversified
in structure the descendants from any one species
can be rendered, the more places they will be enabled
to seize on, and the more their modified progeny will
increase. In our diagram the line of succession
is broken at regular intervals by small numbered letters
marking the successive forms which have become sufficiently
distinct to be recorded as varieties. But these
breaks are imaginary, and might have been inserted
anywhere, after intervals long enough to allow the
accumulation of a considerable amount of divergent
variation.
As all the modified descendants from
a common and widely-diffused species, belonging to
a large genus, will tend to partake of the same advantages
which made their parent successful in life, they will
generally go on multiplying in number as well as diverging
in character: this is represented in the diagram
by the several divergent branches proceeding from
(A). The modified offspring from the later and
more highly improved branches in the lines of descent,
will, it is probable, often take the place of, and
so destroy, the earlier and less improved branches:
this is represented in the diagram by some of the lower
branches not reaching to the upper horizontal lines.
In some cases no doubt the process of modification
will be confined to a single line of descent, and
the number of modified descendants will not be increased;
although the amount of divergent modification may have
been augmented. This case would be represented
in the diagram, if all the lines proceeding from (A)
were removed, excepting that from a1 to a10. In
the same way the English racehorse and English pointer
have apparently both gone on slowly diverging in character
from their original stocks, without either having
given off any fresh branches or races.
After ten thousand generations, species
(A) is supposed to have produced three forms, a10,
f10, and m10, which, from having diverged in character
during the successive generations, will have come to
differ largely, but perhaps unequally, from each other
and from their common parent. If we suppose the
amount of change between each horizontal line in our
diagram to be excessively small, these three forms
may still be only well-marked varieties; but we have
only to suppose the steps in the process of modification
to be more numerous or greater in amount, to convert
these three forms into doubtful or at least into well-defined
species: thus the diagram illustrates the steps
by which the small differences distinguishing varieties
are increased into the larger differences distinguishing
species. By continuing the same process for a
greater number of generations (as shown in the diagram
in a condensed and simplified manner), we get eight
species, marked by the letters between a14 and m14,
all descended from (A). Thus, as I believe, species
are multiplied and genera are formed.
In a large genus it is probable that
more than one species would vary. In the diagram
I have assumed that a second species (I) has produced,
by analogous steps, after ten thousand generations,
either two well-marked varieties (w10 and z10) or
two species, according to the amount of change supposed
to be represented between the horizontal lines.
After fourteen thousand generations, six new species,
marked by the letters n14 to z14, are supposed to
have been produced. In any genus, the species
which are already very different in character from
each other, will generally tend to produce the greatest
number of modified descendants; for these will have
the best chance of seizing on new and widely different
places in the polity of nature: hence in the diagram
I have chosen the extreme species (A), and the nearly
extreme species (I), as those which have largely varied,
and have given rise to new varieties and species.
The other nine species (marked by capital letters)
of our original genus, may for long but unequal periods
continue to transmit unaltered descendants; and this
is shown in the diagram by the dotted lines unequally
prolonged upwards.
But during the process of modification,
represented in the diagram, another of our principles,
namely that of extinction, will have played an important
part. As in each fully stocked country natural
selection necessarily acts by the selected form having
some advantage in the struggle for life over other
forms, there will be a constant tendency in the improved
descendants of any one species to supplant and exterminate
in each stage of descent their predecessors and their
original progenitor. For it should be remembered
that the competition will generally be most severe
between those forms which are most nearly related
to each other in habits, constitution and structure.
Hence all the intermediate forms between the earlier
and later states, that is between the less and more
improved states of a the same species, as well as
the original parent-species itself, will generally
tend to become extinct. So it probably will be
with many whole collateral lines of descent, which
will be conquered by later and improved lines.
If, however, the modified offspring of a species get
into some distinct country, or become quickly adapted
to some quite new station, in which offspring and
progenitor do not come into competition, both may continue
to exist.
If, then, our diagram be assumed to
represent a considerable amount of modification, species
(A) and all the earlier varieties will have become
extinct, being replaced by eight new species (a14 to
m14); and species (I) will be replaced by six (n14
to z14) new species.
But we may go further than this.
The original species of our genus were supposed to
resemble each other in unequal degrees, as is so generally
the case in nature; species (A) being more nearly related
to B, C, and D than to the other species; and species
(I) more to G, H, K, L, than to the others. These
two species (A and I), were also supposed to be very
common and widely diffused species, so that they must
originally have had some advantage over most of the
other species of the genus. Their modified descendants,
fourteen in number at the fourteen-thousandth generation,
will probably have inherited some of the same advantages:
they have also been modified and improved in a diversified
manner at each stage of descent, so as to have become
adapted to many related places in the natural economy
of their country. It seems, therefore, extremely
probable that they will have taken the places of, and
thus exterminated, not only their parents (A) and
(I), but likewise some of the original species which
were most nearly related to their parents. Hence
very few of the original species will have transmitted
offspring to the fourteen-thousandth generation.
We may suppose that only one (F) of the two species
(E and F) which were least closely related to the
other nine original species, has transmitted descendants
to this late stage of descent.
The new species in our diagram, descended
from the original eleven species, will now be fifteen
in number. Owing to the divergent tendency of
natural selection, the extreme amount of difference
in character between species a14 and z14 will be much
greater than that between the most distinct of the
original eleven species. The new species, moreover,
will be allied to each other in a widely different
manner. Of the eight descendants from (A) the
three marked a14, q14, p14, will be nearly related
from having recently branched off from a10; b14 and
f14, from having diverged at an earlier period from
a5, will be in some degree distinct from the three
first-named species; and lastly, o14, e14, and m14,
will be nearly related one to the other, but, from
having diverged at the first commencement of the process
of modification, will be widely different from the
other five species, and may constitute a sub-genus
or a distinct genus.
The six descendants from (I) will
form two sub-genera or genera. But as the original
species (I) differed largely from (A), standing nearly
at the extreme end of the original genus, the six descendants
from (I) will, owing to inheritance alone, differ
considerably from the eight descendants from (A);
the two groups, moreover, are supposed to have gone
on diverging in different directions. The intermediate
species, also (and this is a very important consideration),
which connected the original species (A) and (I),
have all become, except (F), extinct, and have left
no descendants. Hence the six new species descended
from (I), and the eight descendants from (A), will
have to be ranked as very distinct genera, or even
as distinct sub-families.
Thus it is, as I believe, that two
or more genera are produced by descent with modification,
from two or more species of the same genus. And
the two or more parent-species are supposed to be descended
from some one species of an earlier genus. In
our diagram this is indicated by the broken lines
beneath the capital letters, converging in sub-branches
downwards towards a single point; this point represents
a species, the supposed progenitor of our several new
sub-genera and genera.
It is worth while to reflect for a
moment on the character of the new species F14, which
is supposed not to have diverged much in character,
but to have retained the form of (F), either unaltered
or altered only in a slight degree. In this case
its affinities to the other fourteen new species will
be of a curious and circuitous nature. Being descended
from a form that stood between the parent-species (A)
and (I), now supposed to be extinct and unknown, it
will be in some degree intermediate in character between
the two groups descended from these two species.
But as these two groups have gone on diverging in character
from the type of their parents, the new species (F14)
will not be directly intermediate between them, but
rather between types of the two groups; and every
naturalist will be able to call such cases before his
mind.
In the diagram each horizontal line
has hitherto been supposed to represent a thousand
generations, but each may represent a million or more
generations; it may also represent a section of the
successive strata of the earth’s crust including
extinct remains. We shall, when we come to our
chapter on geology, have to refer again to this subject,
and I think we shall then see that the diagram throws
light on the affinities of extinct beings, which,
though generally belonging to the same orders, families,
or genera, with those now living, yet are often, in
some degree, intermediate in character between existing
groups; and we can understand this fact, for the extinct
species lived at various remote epochs when the branching
lines of descent had diverged less.
I see no reason to limit the process
of modification, as now explained, to the formation
of genera alone. If, in the diagram, we suppose
the amount of change represented by each successive
group of diverging dotted lines to be great, the forms
marked a14 to p14, those marked b14 and f14, and those
marked o14 to m14, will form three very distinct genera.
We shall also have two very distinct genera descended
from (I), differing widely from the descendants of
(A). These two groups of genera will thus form
two distinct families, or orders, according to the
amount of divergent modification supposed to be represented
in the diagram. And the two new families, or
orders, are descended from two species of the original
genus; and these are supposed to be descended from
some still more ancient and unknown form.
We have seen that in each country
it is the species belonging to the larger genera which
oftenest present varieties or incipient species.
This, indeed, might have been expected; for as natural
selection acts through one form having some advantage
over other forms in the struggle for existence, it
will chiefly act on those which already have some
advantage; and the largeness of any group shows that
its species have inherited from a common ancestor
some advantage in common. Hence, the struggle
for the production of new and modified descendants
will mainly lie between the larger groups, which are
all trying to increase in number. One large group
will slowly conquer another large group, reduce its
number, and thus lessen its chance of further variation
and improvement. Within the same large group,
the later and more highly perfected sub-groups, from
branching out and seizing on many new places in the
polity of nature, will constantly tend to supplant
and destroy the earlier and less improved sub-groups.
Small and broken groups and sub-groups will finally
disappear. Looking to the future, we can predict
that the groups of organic beings which are now large
and triumphant, and which are least broken up, that
is, which have as yet suffered least extinction, will,
for a long period, continue to increase. But which
groups will ultimately prevail, no man can predict;
for we know that many groups, formerly most extensively
developed, have now become extinct. Looking still
more remotely to the future, we may predict that,
owing to the continued and steady increase of the larger
groups, a multitude of smaller groups will become
utterly extinct, and leave no modified descendants;
and consequently that, of the species living at any
one period, extremely few will transmit descendants
to a remote futurity. I shall have to return
to this subject in the chapter on classification,
but I may add that as, according to this view, extremely
few of the more ancient species have transmitted descendants
to the present day, and, as all the descendants of
the same species form a class, we can understand how
it is that there exist so few classes in each main
division of the animal and vegetable kingdoms.
Although few of the most ancient species have left
modified descendants, yet, at remote geological periods,
the earth may have been almost as well peopled with
species of many genera, families, orders and classes,
as at the present day.
On the degree to which organisation
tends to advance.
Natural selection acts exclusively
by the preservation and accumulation of variations,
which are beneficial under the organic and inorganic
conditions to which each creature is exposed at all
periods of life. The ultimate result is that
each creature tends to become more and more improved
in relation to its conditions. This improvement
inevitably leads to the gradual advancement of the
organisation of the greater number of living beings
throughout the world. But here we enter on a
very intricate subject, for naturalists have not defined
to each other’s satisfaction what is meant by
an advance in organisation. Among the vertebrata
the degree of intellect and an approach in structure
to man clearly come into play. It might be thought
that the amount of change which the various parts
and organs pass through in their development from
embryo to maturity would suffice as a standard of comparison;
but there are cases, as with certain parasitic crustaceans,
in which several parts of the structure become less
perfect, so that the mature animal cannot be called
higher than its larva. Von Baer’s standard
seems the most widely applicable and the best, namely,
the amount of differentiation of the parts of the
same organic being, in the adult state, as I should
be inclined to add, and their specialisation for different
functions; or, as Milne Edwards would express it, the
completeness of the division of physiological labour.
But we shall see how obscure this subject is if we
look, for instance, to fishes, among which some naturalists
rank those as highest which, like the sharks, approach
nearest to amphibians; while other naturalists rank
the common bony or teleostean fishes as the highest,
inasmuch as they are most strictly fish-like, and
differ most from the other vertebrate classes.
We see still more plainly the obscurity of the subject
by turning to plants, among which the standard of
intellect is of course quite excluded; and here some
botanists rank those plants as highest which have
every organ, as sepals, petals, stamens and pistils,
fully developed in each flower; whereas other botanists,
probably with more truth, look at the plants which
have their several organs much modified and reduced
in number as the highest.
If we take as the standard of high
organisation, the amount of differentiation and specialisation
of the several organs in each being when adult (and
this will include the advancement of the brain for
intellectual purposes), natural selection clearly leads
towards this standard: for all physiologists
admit that the specialisation of organs, inasmuch
as in this state they perform their functions better,
is an advantage to each being; and hence the accumulation
of variations tending towards specialisation is within
the scope of natural selection. On the other
hand, we can see, bearing in mind that all organic
beings are striving to increase at a high ratio and
to seize on every unoccupied or less well occupied
place in the economy of nature, that it is quite possible
for natural selection gradually to fit a being to
a situation in which several organs would be superfluous
or useless: in such cases there would be retrogression
in the scale of organisation. Whether organisation
on the whole has actually advanced from the remotest
geological periods to the present day will be more
conveniently discussed in our chapter on Geological
Succession.
But it may be objected that if all
organic beings thus tend to rise in the scale, how
is it that throughout the world a multitude of the
lowest forms still exist; and how is it that in each
great class some forms are far more highly developed
than others? Why have not the more highly developed
forms every where supplanted and exterminated the lower?
Lamarck, who believed in an innate and inevitable tendency
towards perfection in all organic beings, seems to
have felt this difficulty so strongly that he was
led to suppose that new and simple forms are continually
being produced by spontaneous generation. Science
has not as yet proved the truth of this belief, whatever
the future may reveal. On our theory the continued
existence of lowly organisms offers no difficulty;
for natural selection, or the survival of the fittest,
does not necessarily include progressive development it
only takes advantage of such variations as arise and
are beneficial to each creature under its complex
relations of life. And it may be asked what advantage,
as far as we can see, would it be to an infusorian
animalcule to an intestinal worm or
even to an earth-worm, to be highly organised.
If it were no advantage, these forms would be left,
by natural selection, unimproved or but little improved,
and might remain for indefinite ages in their present
lowly condition. And geology tells us that some
of the lowest forms, as the infusoria and rhizopods,
have remained for an enormous period in nearly their
present state. But to suppose that most of the
many now existing low forms have not in the least advanced
since the first dawn of life would be extremely rash;
for every naturalist who has dissected some of the
beings now ranked as very low in the scale, must have
been struck with their really wondrous and beautiful
organisation.
Nearly the same remarks are applicable,
if we look to the different grades of organisation
within the same great group; for instance, in the
vertebrata, to the co-existence of mammals and fish among
mammalia, to the co-existence of man and the ornithorhynchus among
fishes, to the co-existence of the shark and the lancelet
(Amphioxus), which latter fish in the extreme simplicity
of its structure approaches the invertebrate classes.
But mammals and fish hardly come into competition
with each other; the advancement of the whole class
of mammals, or of certain members in this class, to
the highest grade would not lead to their taking the
place of fishes. Physiologists believe that the
brain must be bathed by warm blood to be highly active,
and this requires aerial respiration; so that warm-blooded
mammals when inhabiting the water lie under a disadvantage
in having to come continually to the surface to breathe.
With fishes, members of the shark family would not
tend to supplant the lancelet; for the lancelet, as
I hear from Fritz Muller, has as sole companion and
competitor on the barren sandy shore of South Brazil,
an anomalous annelid. The three lowest orders
of mammals, namely, marsupials, edentata, and rodents,
co-exist in South America in the same region with
numerous monkeys, and probably interfere little with
each other. Although organisation, on the whole,
may have advanced and be still advancing throughout
the world, yet the scale will always present many
degrees of perfection; for the high advancement of
certain whole classes, or of certain members of each
class, does not at all necessarily lead to the extinction
of those groups with which they do not enter into
close competition. In some cases, as we shall
hereafter see, lowly organised forms appear to have
been preserved to the present day, from inhabiting
confined or peculiar stations, where they have been
subjected to less severe competition, and where their
scanty numbers have retarded the chance of favourable
variations arising.
Finally, I believe that many lowly
organised forms now exist throughout the world, from
various causes. In some cases variations or individual
differences of a favourable nature may never have arisen
for natural selection to act on and accumulate.
In no case, probably, has time sufficed for the utmost
possible amount of development. In some few cases
there has been what we must call retrogression or organisation.
But the main cause lies in the fact that under very
simple conditions of life a high organisation would
be of no service possibly would be of actual
disservice, as being of a more delicate nature, and
more liable to be put out of order and injured.
Looking to the first dawn of life,
when all organic beings, as we may believe, presented
the simplest structure, how, it has been asked, could
the first step in the advancement or differentiation
of parts have arisen? Mr. Herbert Spencer would
probably answer that, as soon as simple unicellular
organisms came by growth or division to be compounded
of several cells, or became attached to any supporting
surface, his law “that homologous units of any
order become differentiated in proportion as their
relations to incident forces become different”
would come into action. But as we have no facts
to guide us, speculation on the subject is almost
useless. It is, however, an error to suppose that
there would be no struggle for existence, and, consequently,
no natural selection, until many forms had been produced:
variations in a single species inhabiting an isolated
station might be beneficial, and thus the whole mass
of individuals might be modified, or two distinct forms
might arise. But, as I remarked towards the close
of the introduction, no one ought to feel surprise
at much remaining as yet unexplained on the origin
of species, if we make due allowance for our profound
ignorance on the mutual relations of the inhabitants
of the world at the present time, and still more so
during past ages.
Convergence of character.
Mr. H.C. Watson thinks that I
have overrated the importance of divergence of character
(in which, however, he apparently believes), and that
convergence, as it may be called, has likewise played
a part. If two species belonging to two distinct
though allied genera, had both produced a large number
of new and divergent forms, it is conceivable that
these might approach each other so closely that they
would have all to be classed under the same genus;
and thus the descendants of two distinct genera would
converge into one. But it would in most cases
be extremely rash to attribute to convergence a close
and general similarity of structure in the modified
descendants of widely distinct forms. The shape
of a crystal is determined solely by the molecular
forces, and it is not surprising that dissimilar substances
should sometimes assume the same form; but with organic
beings we should bear in mind that the form of each
depends on an infinitude of complex relations, namely
on the variations which have arisen, these being due
to causes far too intricate to be followed out on
the nature of the variations which have been preserved
or selected, and this depends on the surrounding physical
conditions, and in a still higher degree on the surrounding
organisms with which each being has come into competition and
lastly, on inheritance (in itself a fluctuating element)
from innumerable progenitors, all of which have had
their forms determined through equally complex relations.
It is incredible that the descendants of two organisms,
which had originally differed in a marked manner,
should ever afterwards converge so closely as to lead
to a near approach to identity throughout their whole
organisation. If this had occurred, we should
meet with the same form, independently of genetic
connection, recurring in widely separated geological
formations; and the balance of evidence is opposed
to any such an admission.
Mr. Watson has also objected that
the continued action of natural selection, together
with divergence of character, would tend to make an
indefinite number of specific forms. As far as
mere inorganic conditions are concerned, it seems
probable that a sufficient number of species would
soon become adapted to all considerable diversities
of heat, moisture, etc.; but I fully admit that
the mutual relations of organic beings are more important;
and as the number of species in any country goes on
increasing, the organic conditions of life must become
more and more complex. Consequently there seems
at first no limit to the amount of profitable diversification
of structure, and therefore no limit to the number
of species which might be produced. We do not
know that even the most prolific area is fully stocked
with specific forms: at the Cape of Good Hope
and in Australia, which support such an astonishing
number of species, many European plants have become
naturalised. But geology shows us, that from
an early part of the tertiary period the number of
species of shells, and that from the middle part of
this same period, the number of mammals has not greatly
or at all increased. What then checks an indefinite
increase in the number of species? The amount
of life (I do not mean the number of specific forms)
supported on an area must have a limit, depending
so largely as it does on physical conditions; therefore,
if an area be inhabited by very many species, each
or nearly each species will be represented by few individuals;
and such species will be liable to extermination from
accidental fluctuations in the nature of the seasons
or in the number of their enemies. The process
of extermination in such cases would be rapid, whereas
the production of new species must always be slow.
Imagine the extreme case of as many species as individuals
in England, and the first severe winter or very dry
summer would exterminate thousands on thousands of
species. Rare species, and each species will become
rare if the number of species in any country becomes
indefinitely increased, will, on the principal often
explained, present within a given period few favourable
variations; consequently, the process of giving birth
to new specific forms would thus be retarded.
When any species becomes very rare, close interbreeding
will help to exterminate it; authors have thought
that this comes into play in accounting for the deterioration
of the aurochs in Lithuania, of red deer in Scotland
and of bears in Norway, etc. Lastly, and
this I am inclined to think is the most important
element, a dominant species, which has already beaten
many competitors in its own home, will tend to spread
and supplant many others. Alph. de Candolle has
shown that those species which spread widely tend
generally to spread very widely, consequently
they will tend to supplant and exterminate several
species in several areas, and thus check the inordinate
increase of specific forms throughout the world.
Dr. Hooker has recently shown that in the southeast
corner of Australia, where, apparently, there are
many invaders from different quarters of the globe,
the endemic Australian species have been greatly reduced
in number. How much weight to attribute to these
several considerations I will not pretend to say;
but conjointly they must limit in each country the
tendency to an indefinite augmentation of specific
forms.