Difficulties of the theory of descent with modification Absence
or rarity of transitional varieties Transitions in habits of
life Diversified habits in the same species Species with habits
widely different from those of their allies Organs of extreme
perfection Modes of transition Cases of difficulty Natura non facit
saltum Organs of small importance Organs not in all cases absolutely
perfect The law of Unity of Type and of the Conditions of Existence
embraced by the theory of Natural Selection.
Long before the reader has arrived
at this part of my work, a crowd of difficulties will
have occurred to him. Some of them are so serious
that to this day I can hardly reflect on them without
being in some degree staggered; but, to the best of
my judgment, the greater number are only apparent,
and those that are real are not, I think, fatal to
the theory.
These difficulties and objections
may be classed under the following heads: First,
why, if species have descended from other species by
fine gradations, do we not everywhere see innumerable
transitional forms? Why is not all nature in
confusion, instead of the species being, as we see
them, well defined?
Secondly, is it possible that an animal
having, for instance, the structure and habits of
a bat, could have been formed by the modification
of some other animal with widely different habits and
structure? Can we believe that natural selection
could produce, on the one hand, an organ of trifling
importance, such as the tail of a giraffe, which serves
as a fly-flapper, and, on the other hand, an organ
so wonderful as the eye?
Thirdly, can instincts be acquired
and modified through natural selection? What
shall we say to the instinct which leads the bee to
make cells, and which has practically anticipated
the discoveries of profound mathematicians?
Fourthly, how can we account for species,
when crossed, being sterile and producing sterile
offspring, whereas, when varieties are crossed, their
fertility is unimpaired?
The two first heads will be here discussed;
some miscellaneous objections in the following chapter;
Instinct and Hybridism in the two succeeding chapters.
On the absence or rarity
of transitional varieties.
As natural selection acts solely by
the preservation of profitable modifications, each
new form will tend in a fully-stocked country to take
the place of, and finally to exterminate, its own less
improved parent-form and other less-favoured forms
with which it comes into competition. Thus extinction
and natural selection go hand in hand. Hence,
if we look at each species as descended from some unknown
form, both the parent and all the transitional varieties
will generally have been exterminated by the very
process of the formation and perfection of the new
form.
But, as by this theory innumerable
transitional forms must have existed, why do we not
find them embedded in countless numbers in the crust
of the earth? It will be more convenient to discuss
this question in the chapter on the imperfection of
the geological record; and I will here only state
that I believe the answer mainly lies in the record
being incomparably less perfect than is generally
supposed. The crust of the earth is a vast museum;
but the natural collections have been imperfectly
made, and only at long intervals of time.
But it may be urged that when several
closely allied species inhabit the same territory,
we surely ought to find at the present time many transitional
forms. Let us take a simple case: in travelling
from north to south over a continent, we generally
meet at successive intervals with closely allied or
representative species, evidently filling nearly the
same place in the natural economy of the land.
These representative species often meet and interlock;
and as the one becomes rarer and rarer, the other
becomes more and more frequent, till the one replaces
the other. But if we compare these species where
they intermingle, they are generally as absolutely
distinct from each other in every detail of structure
as are specimens taken from the metropolis inhabited
by each. By my theory these allied species are
descended from a common parent; and during the process
of modification, each has become adapted to the conditions
of life of its own region, and has supplanted and
exterminated its original parent-form and all the transitional
varieties between its past and present states.
Hence we ought not to expect at the present time to
meet with numerous transitional varieties in each
region, though they must have existed there, and may
be embedded there in a fossil condition. But
in the intermediate region, having intermediate conditions
of life, why do we not now find closely-linking intermediate
varieties? This difficulty for a long time quite
confounded me. But I think it can be in large
part explained.
In the first place we should be extremely
cautious in inferring, because an area is now continuous,
that it has been continuous during a long period.
Geology would lead us to believe that most continents
have been broken up into islands even during the later
tertiary periods; and in such islands distinct species
might have been separately formed without the possibility
of intermediate varieties existing in the intermediate
zones. By changes in the form of the land and
of climate, marine areas now continuous must often
have existed within recent times in a far less continuous
and uniform condition than at present. But I will
pass over this way of escaping from the difficulty;
for I believe that many perfectly defined species
have been formed on strictly continuous areas; though
I do not doubt that the formerly broken condition of
areas now continuous, has played an important part
in the formation of new species, more especially with
freely-crossing and wandering animals.
In looking at species as they are
now distributed over a wide area, we generally find
them tolerably numerous over a large territory, then
becoming somewhat abruptly rarer and rarer on the confines,
and finally disappearing. Hence the neutral territory
between two representative species is generally narrow
in comparison with the territory proper to each.
We see the same fact in ascending mountains, and sometimes
it is quite remarkable how abruptly, as Alph.
De Candolle has observed, a common alpine species
disappears. The same fact has been noticed by
E. Forbes in sounding the depths of the sea with the
dredge. To those who look at climate and the
physical conditions of life as the all-important elements
of distribution, these facts ought to cause surprise,
as climate and height or depth graduate away insensibly.
But when we bear in mind that almost every species,
even in its metropolis, would increase immensely in
numbers, were it not for other competing species;
that nearly all either prey on or serve as prey for
others; in short, that each organic being is either
directly or indirectly related in the most important
manner to other organic beings we see that
the range of the inhabitants of any country by no
means exclusively depends on insensibly changing physical
conditions, but in large part on the presence of other
species, on which it lives, or by which it is destroyed,
or with which it comes into competition; and as these
species are already defined objects, not blending
one into another by insensible gradations, the range
of any one species, depending as it does on the range
of others, will tend to be sharply defined. Moreover,
each species on the confines of its range, where it
exists in lessened numbers, will, during fluctuations
in the number of its enemies or of its prey, or in
the nature of the seasons, be extremely liable to utter
extermination; and thus its geographical range will
come to be still more sharply defined.
As allied or representative species,
when inhabiting a continuous area, are generally distributed
in such a manner that each has a wide range, with
a comparatively narrow neutral territory between them,
in which they become rather suddenly rarer and rarer;
then, as varieties do not essentially differ from
species, the same rule will probably apply to both;
and if we take a varying species inhabiting a very
large area, we shall have to adapt two varieties to
two large areas, and a third variety to a narrow intermediate
zone. The intermediate variety, consequently,
will exist in lesser numbers from inhabiting a narrow
and lesser area; and practically, as far as I can
make out, this rule holds good with varieties in a
state of nature. I have met with striking instances
of the rule in the case of varieties intermediate between
well-marked varieties in the genus Balanus.
And it would appear from information given me by Mr.
Watson, Dr. Asa Gray, and Mr. Wollaston, that generally,
when varieties intermediate between two other forms
occur, they are much rarer numerically than the forms
which they connect. Now, if we may trust these
facts and inferences, and conclude that varieties
linking two other varieties together generally have
existed in lesser numbers than the forms which they
connect, then we can understand why intermediate varieties
should not endure for very long periods: why,
as a general rule, they should be exterminated and
disappear, sooner than the forms which they originally
linked together.
For any form existing in lesser numbers
would, as already remarked, run a greater chance of
being exterminated than one existing in large numbers;
and in this particular case the intermediate form would
be eminently liable to the inroads of closely allied
forms existing on both sides of it. But it is
a far more important consideration, that during the
process of further modification, by which two varieties
are supposed to be converted and perfected into two
distinct species, the two which exist in larger numbers,
from inhabiting larger areas, will have a great advantage
over the intermediate variety, which exists in smaller
numbers in a narrow and intermediate zone. For
forms existing in larger numbers will have a better
chance, within any given period, of presenting further
favourable variations for natural selection to seize
on, than will the rarer forms which exist in lesser
numbers. Hence, the more common forms, in the
race for life, will tend to beat and supplant the
less common forms, for these will be more slowly modified
and improved. It is the same principle which,
as I believe, accounts for the common species in each
country, as shown in the second chapter, presenting
on an average a greater number of well-marked varieties
than do the rarer species. I may illustrate what
I mean by supposing three varieties of sheep to be
kept, one adapted to an extensive mountainous region;
a second to a comparatively narrow, hilly tract; and
a third to the wide plains at the base; and that the
inhabitants are all trying with equal steadiness and
skill to improve their stocks by selection; the chances
in this case will be strongly in favour of the great
holders on the mountains or on the plains improving
their breeds more quickly than the small holders on
the intermediate narrow, hilly tract; and consequently
the improved mountain or plain breed will soon take
the place of the less improved hill breed; and thus
the two breeds, which originally existed in greater
numbers, will come into close contact with each other,
without the interposition of the supplanted, intermediate
hill variety.
To sum up, I believe that species
come to be tolerably well-defined objects, and do
not at any one period present an inextricable chaos
of varying and intermediate links: first, because
new varieties are very slowly formed, for variation
is a slow process, and natural selection can do nothing
until favourable individual differences or variations
occur, and until a place in the natural polity of the
country can be better filled by some modification
of some one or more of its inhabitants. And such
new places will depend on slow changes of climate,
or on the occasional immigration of new inhabitants,
and, probably, in a still more important degree, on
some of the old inhabitants becoming slowly modified,
with the new forms thus produced and the old ones
acting and reacting on each other. So that, in
any one region and at any one time, we ought to see
only a few species presenting slight modifications
of structure in some degree permanent; and this assuredly
we do see.
Secondly, areas now continuous must
often have existed within the recent period as isolated
portions, in which many forms, more especially among
the classes which unite for each birth and wander much,
may have separately been rendered sufficiently distinct
to rank as representative species. In this case,
intermediate varieties between the several representative
species and their common parent, must formerly have
existed within each isolated portion of the land, but
these links during the process of natural selection
will have been supplanted and exterminated, so that
they will no longer be found in a living state.
Thirdly, when two or more varieties
have been formed in different portions of a strictly
continuous area, intermediate varieties will, it is
probable, at first have been formed in the intermediate
zones, but they will generally have had a short duration.
For these intermediate varieties will, from reasons
already assigned (namely from what we know of the
actual distribution of closely allied or representative
species, and likewise of acknowledged varieties),
exist in the intermediate zones in lesser numbers
than the varieties which they tend to connect.
From this cause alone the intermediate varieties will
be liable to accidental extermination; and during
the process of further modification through natural
selection, they will almost certainly be beaten and
supplanted by the forms which they connect; for these,
from existing in greater numbers will, in the aggregate,
present more varieties, and thus be further improved
through natural selection and gain further advantages.
Lastly, looking not to any one time,
but at all time, if my theory be true, numberless
intermediate varieties, linking closely together all
the species of the same group, must assuredly have
existed; but the very process of natural selection
constantly tends, as has been so often remarked, to
exterminate the parent forms and the intermediate links.
Consequently evidence of their former existence could
be found only among fossil remains, which are preserved,
as we shall attempt to show in a future chapter, in
an extremely imperfect and intermittent record.
On the origin and
transition of organic beings with
peculiar habits and structure.
It has been asked by the opponents
of such views as I hold, how, for instance, could
a land carnivorous animal have been converted into
one with aquatic habits; for how could the animal
in its transitional state have subsisted? It
would be easy to show that there now exist carnivorous
animals presenting close intermediate grades from strictly
terrestrial to aquatic habits; and as each exists by
a struggle for life, it is clear that each must be
well adapted to its place in nature. Look at
the Mustela vison of North America, which
has webbed feet, and which resembles an otter in its
fur, short legs, and form of tail; during summer this
animal dives for and preys on fish, but during the
long winter it leaves the frozen waters, and preys,
like other polecats on mice and land animals.
If a different case had been taken, and it had been
asked how an insectivorous quadruped could possibly
have been converted into a flying bat, the question
would have been far more difficult to answer.
Yet I think such difficulties have little weight.
Here, as on other occasions, I lie
under a heavy disadvantage, for, out of the many striking
cases which I have collected, I can give only one
or two instances of transitional habits and structures
in allied species; and of diversified habits, either
constant or occasional, in the same species.
And it seems to me that nothing less than a long list
of such cases is sufficient to lessen the difficulty
in any particular case like that of the bat.
Look at the family of squirrels; here
we have the finest gradation from animals with their
tails only slightly flattened, and from others, as
Sir J. Richardson has remarked, with the posterior
part of their bodies rather wide and with the skin
on their flanks rather full, to the so-called flying
squirrels; and flying squirrels have their limbs and
even the base of the tail united by a broad expanse
of skin, which serves as a parachute and allows them
to glide through the air to an astonishing distance
from tree to tree. We cannot doubt that each
structure is of use to each kind of squirrel in its
own country, by enabling it to escape birds or beasts
of prey, or to collect food more quickly, or, as there
is reason to believe, to lessen the danger from occasional
falls. But it does not follow from this fact that
the structure of each squirrel is the best that it
is possible to conceive under all possible conditions.
Let the climate and vegetation change, let other competing
rodents or new beasts of prey immigrate, or old ones
become modified, and all analogy would lead us to believe
that some, at least, of the squirrels would decrease
in numbers or become exterminated, unless they also
become modified and improved in structure in a corresponding
manner. Therefore, I can see no difficulty, more
especially under changing conditions of life, in the
continued preservation of individuals with fuller
and fuller flank-membranes, each modification being
useful, each being propagated, until, by the accumulated
effects of this process of natural selection, a perfect
so-called flying squirrel was produced.
Now look at the Galeopithecus or so-called
flying lemur, which was formerly ranked among bats,
but is now believed to belong to the Insectivora.
An extremely wide flank-membrane stretches from the
corners of the jaw to the tail, and includes the limbs
with the elongated fingers. This flank-membrane
is furnished with an extensor muscle. Although
no graduated links of structure, fitted for gliding
through the air, now connect the Galeopithecus with
the other Insectivora, yet there is no difficulty
in supposing that such links formerly existed, and
that each was developed in the same manner as with
the less perfectly gliding squirrels; each grade of
structure having been useful to its possessor.
Nor can I see any insuperable difficulty in further
believing it possible that the membrane-connected
fingers and fore-arm of the Galeopithecus might have
been greatly lengthened by natural selection; and
this, as far as the organs of flight are concerned,
would have converted the animal into a bat. In
certain bats in which the wing-membrane extends from
the top of the shoulder to the tail and includes the
hind-legs, we perhaps see traces of an apparatus originally
fitted for gliding through the air rather than for
flight.
If about a dozen genera of birds were
to become extinct, who would have ventured to surmise
that birds might have existed which used their wings
solely as flappers, like the logger headed duck (Micropterus
of Eyton); as fins in the water and as front legs
on the land, like the penguin; as sails, like the
ostrich; and functionally for no purpose, like the
apteryx? Yet the structure of each of these birds
is good for it, under the conditions of life to which
it is exposed, for each has to live by a struggle:
but it is not necessarily the best possible under all
possible conditions. It must not be inferred
from these remarks that any of the grades of wing-structure
here alluded to, which perhaps may all be the result
of disuse, indicate the steps by which birds actually
acquired their perfect power of flight; but they serve
to show what diversified means of transition are at
least possible.
Seeing that a few members of such
water-breathing classes as the Crustacea and Mollusca
are adapted to live on the land; and seeing that we
have flying birds and mammals, flying insects of the
most diversified types, and formerly had flying reptiles,
it is conceivable that flying-fish, which now glide
far through the air, slightly rising and turning by
the aid of their fluttering fins, might have been modified
into perfectly winged animals. If this had been
effected, who would have ever imagined that in an
early transitional state they had been inhabitants
of the open ocean, and had used their incipient organs
of flight exclusively, so far as we know, to escape
being devoured by other fish?
When we see any structure highly perfected
for any particular habit, as the wings of a bird for
flight, we should bear in mind that animals displaying
early transitional grades of the structure will seldom
have survived to the present day, for they will have
been supplanted by their successors, which were gradually
rendered more perfect through natural selection.
Furthermore, we may conclude that transitional states
between structures fitted for very different habits
of life will rarely have been developed at an early
period in great numbers and under many subordinate
forms. Thus, to return to our imaginary illustration
of the flying-fish, it does not seem probable that
fishes capable of true flight would have been developed
under many subordinate forms, for taking prey of many
kinds in many ways, on the land and in the water,
until their organs of flight had come to a high stage
of perfection, so as to have given them a decided
advantage over other animals in the battle for life.
Hence the chance of discovering species with transitional
grades of structure in a fossil condition will always
be less, from their having existed in lesser numbers,
than in the case of species with fully developed structures.
I will now give two or three instances,
both of diversified and of changed habits, in the
individuals of the same species. In either case
it would be easy for natural selection to adapt the
structure of the animal to its changed habits, or
exclusively to one of its several habits. It
is, however, difficult to decide and immaterial for
us, whether habits generally change first and structure
afterwards; or whether slight modifications of structure
lead to changed habits; both probably often occurring
almost simultaneously. Of cases of changed habits
it will suffice merely to allude to that of the many
British insects which now feed on exotic plants, or
exclusively on artificial substances. Of diversified
habits innumerable instances could be given:
I have often watched a tyrant flycatcher (Saurophagus
sulphuratus) in South America, hovering over one spot
and then proceeding to another, like a kestrel, and
at other times standing stationary on the margin of
water, and then dashing into it like a kingfisher at
a fish. In our own country the larger titmouse
(Parus major) may be seen climbing branches,
almost like a creeper; it sometimes, like a shrike,
kills small birds by blows on the head; and I have
many times seen and heard it hammering the seeds of
the yew on a branch, and thus breaking them like a
nuthatch. In North America the black bear was
seen by Hearne swimming for hours with widely open
mouth, thus catching, almost like a whale, insects
in the water.
As we sometimes see individuals following
habits different from those proper to their species
and to the other species of the same genus, we might
expect that such individuals would occasionally give
rise to new species, having anomalous habits, and
with their structure either slightly or considerably
modified from that of their type. And such instances
occur in nature. Can a more striking instance
of adaptation be given than that of a woodpecker for
climbing trees and seizing insects in the chinks of
the bark? Yet in North America there are woodpeckers
which feed largely on fruit, and others with elongated
wings which chase insects on the wing. On the
plains of La Plata, where hardly a tree grows, there
is a woodpecker (Colaptes campestris) which has
two toes before and two behind, a long-pointed tongue,
pointed tail-feathers, sufficiently stiff to support
the bird in a vertical position on a post, but not
so stiff as in the typical wood-peckers, and a straight,
strong beak. The beak, however, is not so straight
or so strong as in the typical woodpeckers but it
is strong enough to bore into wood. Hence this
Colaptes, in all the essential parts of its structure,
is a woodpecker. Even in such trifling characters
as the colouring, the harsh tone of the voice, and
undulatory flight, its close blood-relationship to
our common woodpecker is plainly declared; yet, as
I can assert, not only from my own observations, but
from those of the accurate Azara, in certain large
districts it does not climb trees, and it makes its
nest in holes in banks! In certain other districts,
however, this same woodpecker, as Mr. Hudson states,
frequents trees, and bores holes in the trunk for
its nest. I may mention as another illustration
of the varied habits of this genus, that a Mexican
Colaptes has been described by De Saussure as boring
holes into hard wood in order to lay up a store of
acorns.
Pétrels are the most aerial and
oceanic of birds, but, in the quiet sounds of Tierra
del Fuego, the Puffinuria berardi, in its
general habits, in its astonishing power of diving,
in its manner of swimming and of flying when made
to take flight, would be mistaken by any one for an
auk or a grebe; nevertheless, it is essentially a petrel,
but with many parts of its organisation profoundly
modified in relation to its new habits of life; whereas
the woodpecker of La Plata has had its structure only
slightly modified. In the case of the water-ouzel,
the acutest observer, by examining its dead body,
would never have suspected its sub-aquatic habits;
yet this bird, which is allied to the thrush family,
subsists by diving, using its wings under
water and grasping stones with its feet. All
the members of the great order of Hymenopterous insects
are terrestrial, excepting the genus Proctotrupes,
which Sir John Lubbock has discovered to be aquatic
in its habits; it often enters the water and dives
about by the use not of its legs but of its wings,
and remains as long as four hours beneath the surface;
yet it exhibits no modification in structure in accordance
with its abnormal habits.
He who believes that each being has
been created as we now see it, must occasionally have
felt surprise when he has met with an animal having
habits and structure not in agreement. What can
be plainer than that the webbed feet of ducks and
geese are formed for swimming? Yet there are
upland geese with webbed feet which rarely go near
the water; and no one except Audubon, has seen the
frigate-bird, which has all its four toes webbed,
alight on the surface of the ocean. On the other
hand, grèbes and coots are eminently aquatic,
although their toes are only bordered by membrane.
What seems plainer than that the long toes, not furnished
with membrane, of the Grallatores, are formed for walking
over swamps and floating plants. The water-hen
and landrail are members of this order, yet the first
is nearly as aquatic as the coot, and the second is
nearly as terrestrial as the quail or partridge.
In such cases, and many others could be given, habits
have changed without a corresponding change of structure.
The webbed feet of the upland goose may be said to
have become almost rudimentary in function, though
not in structure. In the frigate-bird, the deeply
scooped membrane between the toes shows that structure
has begun to change.
He who believes in separate and innumerable
acts of creation may say, that in these cases it has
pleased the Creator to cause a being of one type to
take the place of one belonging to another type; but
this seems to me only restating the fact in dignified
language. He who believes in the struggle for
existence and in the principle of natural selection,
will acknowledge that every organic being is constantly
endeavouring to increase in numbers; and that if any
one being varies ever so little, either in habits
or structure, and thus gains an advantage over some
other inhabitant of the same country, it will seize
on the place of that inhabitant, however different
that may be from its own place. Hence it will
cause him no surprise that there should be geese and
frigate-birds with webbed feet, living on the dry
land and rarely alighting on the water, that there
should be long-toed corncrakes, living in meadows
instead of in swamps; that there should be woodpeckers
where hardly a tree grows; that there should be diving
thrushes and diving Hymenoptera, and pétrels
with the habits of auks.
Organs of extreme perfection and
complication.
To suppose that the eye with all its
inimitable contrivances for adjusting the focus to
different distances, for admitting different amounts
of light, and for the correction of spherical and chromatic
aberration, could have been formed by natural selection,
seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest degree.
When it was first said that the sun stood still and
the world turned round, the common sense of mankind
declared the doctrine false; but the old saying of
Vox populi, vox Dei, as every
philosopher knows, cannot be trusted in science.
Reason tells me, that if numerous gradations from
a simple and imperfect eye to one complex and perfect
can be shown to exist, each grade being useful to
its possessor, as is certainly the case; if further,
the eye ever varies and the variations be inherited,
as is likewise certainly the case; and if such variations
should be useful to any animal under changing conditions
of life, then the difficulty of believing that a perfect
and complex eye could be formed by natural selection,
though insuperable by our imagination, should not
be considered as subversive of the theory. How
a nerve comes to be sensitive to light, hardly concerns
us more than how life itself originated; but I may
remark that, as some of the lowest organisms in which
nerves cannot be detected, are capable of perceiving
light, it does not seem impossible that certain sensitive
elements in their sarcode should become aggregated
and developed into nerves, endowed with this special
sensibility.
In searching for the gradations through
which an organ in any species has been perfected,
we ought to look exclusively to its lineal progenitors;
but this is scarcely ever possible, and we are forced
to look to other species and genera of the same group,
that is to the collateral descendants from the same
parent-form, in order to see what gradations are possible,
and for the chance of some gradations having been
transmitted in an unaltered or little altered condition.
But the state of the same organ in distinct classes
may incidentally throw light on the steps by which
it has been perfected.
The simplest organ which can be called
an eye consists of an optic nerve, surrounded by pigment-cells
and covered by translucent skin, but without any lens
or other refractive body. We may, however, according
to M. Jourdain, descend even a step lower and find
aggregates of pigment-cells, apparently serving as
organs of vision, without any nerves, and resting
merely on sarcodic tissue. Eyes of the above simple
nature are not capable of distinct vision, and serve
only to distinguish light from darkness. In certain
star-fishes, small depressions in the layer of pigment
which surrounds the nerve are filled, as described
by the author just quoted, with transparent gelatinous
matter, projecting with a convex surface, like the
cornea in the higher animals. He suggests that
this serves not to form an image, but only to concentrate
the luminous rays and render their perception more
easy. In this concentration of the rays we gain
the first and by far the most important step towards
the formation of a true, picture-forming eye; for
we have only to place the naked extremity of the optic
nerve, which in some of the lower animals lies deeply
buried in the body, and in some near the surface,
at the right distance from the concentrating apparatus,
and an image will be formed on it.
In the great class of the Articulata,
we may start from an optic nerve simply coated with
pigment, the latter sometimes forming a sort of pupil,
but destitute of lens or other optical contrivance.
With insects it is now known that the numerous facets
on the cornea of their great compound eyes form true
lenses, and that the cones include curiously modified
nervous filaments. But these organs in the Articulata
are so much diversified that Muller formerly made
three main classes with seven subdivisions, besides
a fourth main class of aggregated simple eyes.
When we reflect on these facts, here
given much too briefly, with respect to the wide,
diversified, and graduated range of structure in the
eyes of the lower animals; and when we bear in mind
how small the number of all living forms must be in
comparison with those which have become extinct, the
difficulty ceases to be very great in believing that
natural selection may have converted the simple apparatus
of an optic nerve, coated with pigment and invested
by transparent membrane, into an optical instrument
as perfect as is possessed by any member of the Articulata
class.
He who will go thus far, ought not
to hesitate to go one step further, if he finds on
finishing this volume that large bodies of facts,
otherwise inexplicable, can be explained by the theory
of modification through natural selection; he ought
to admit that a structure even as perfect as an eagle’s
eye might thus be formed, although in this case he
does not know the transitional states. It has
been objected that in order to modify the eye and
still preserve it as a perfect instrument, many changes
would have to be effected simultaneously, which, it
is assumed, could not be done through natural selection;
but as I have attempted to show in my work on the
variation of domestic animals, it is not necessary
to suppose that the modifications were all simultaneous,
if they were extremely slight and gradual. Different
kinds of modification would, also, serve for the same
general purpose: as Mr. Wallace has remarked,
“If a lens has too short or too long a focus,
it may be amended either by an alteration of curvature,
or an alteration of density; if the curvature be irregular,
and the rays do not converge to a point, then any
increased regularity of curvature will be an improvement.
So the contraction of the iris and the muscular movements
of the eye are neither of them essential to vision,
but only improvements which might have been added
and perfected at any stage of the construction of
the instrument.” Within the highest division
of the animal kingdom, namely, the Vertebrata, we
can start from an eye so simple, that it consists,
as in the lancelet, of a little sack of transparent
skin, furnished with a nerve and lined with pigment,
but destitute of any other apparatus. In fishes
and reptiles, as Owen has remarked, “The range
of gradation of dioptric structures is very great.”
It is a significant fact that even in man, according
to the high authority of Virchow, the beautiful crystalline
lens is formed in the embryo by an accumulation of
epidermic cells, lying in a sack-like fold of the
skin; and the vitreous body is formed from embryonic
subcutaneous tissue. To arrive, however, at a
just conclusion regarding the formation of the eye,
with all its marvellous yet not absolutely perfect
characters, it is indispensable that the reason should
conquer the imagination; but I have felt the difficulty
far to keenly to be surprised at others hesitating
to extend the principle of natural selection to so
startling a length.
It is scarcely possible to avoid comparing
the eye with a telescope. We know that this instrument
has been perfected by the long-continued efforts of
the highest human intellects; and we naturally infer
that the eye has been formed by a somewhat analogous
process. But may not this inference be presumptuous?
Have we any right to assume that the Creator works
by intellectual powers like those of man? If we
must compare the eye to an optical instrument, we
ought in imagination to take a thick layer of transparent
tissue, with spaces filled with fluid, and with a
nerve sensitive to light beneath, and then suppose
every part of this layer to be continually changing
slowly in density, so as to separate into layers of
different densities and thicknesses, placed at different
distances from each other, and with the surfaces of
each layer slowly changing in form. Further we
must suppose that there is a power, represented by
natural selection or the survival of the fittest, always
intently watching each slight alteration in the transparent
layers; and carefully preserving each which, under
varied circumstances, in any way or degree, tends
to produce a distincter image. We must suppose
each new state of the instrument to be multiplied
by the million; each to be preserved until a better
is produced, and then the old ones to be all destroyed.
In living bodies, variation will cause the slight alteration,
generation will multiply them almost infinitely, and
natural selection will pick out with unerring skill
each improvement. Let this process go on for
millions of years; and during each year on millions
of individuals of many kinds; and may we not believe
that a living optical instrument might thus be formed
as superior to one of glass, as the works of the Creator
are to those of man?
Modes Of transition.
If it could be demonstrated that any
complex organ existed, which could not possibly have
been formed by numerous, successive, slight modifications,
my theory would absolutely break down. But I can
find out no such case. No doubt many organs exist
of which we do not know the transitional grades, more
especially if we look to much-isolated species, around
which, according to the theory, there has been much
extinction. Or again, if we take an organ common
to all the members of a class, for in this latter
case the organ must have been originally formed at
a remote period, since which all the many members of
the class have been developed; and in order to discover
the early transitional grades through which the organ
has passed, we should have to look to very ancient
ancestral forms, long since become extinct.
We should be extremely cautious in
concluding that an organ could not have been formed
by transitional gradations of some kind. Numerous
cases could be given among the lower animals of the
same organ performing at the same time wholly distinct
functions; thus in the larva of the dragon-fly and
in the fish Cobites the alimentary canal respires,
digests, and excretes. In the Hydra, the animal
may be turned inside out, and the exterior surface
will then digest and the stomach respire. In
such cases natural selection might specialise, if any
advantage were thus gained, the whole or part of an
organ, which had previously performed two functions,
for one function alone, and thus by insensible steps
greatly change its nature. Many plants are known
which regularly produce at the same time differently
constructed flowers; and if such plants were to produce
one kind alone, a great change would be effected with
comparative suddenness in the character of the species.
It is, however, probable that the two sorts of flowers
borne by the same plant were originally differentiated
by finely graduated steps, which may still be followed
in some few cases.
Again, two distinct organs, or the
same organ under two very different forms, may simultaneously
perform in the same individual the same function,
and this is an extremely important means of transition:
to give one instance there are fish with
gills or branchiae that breathe the air dissolved
in the water, at the same time that they breathe free
air in their swim-bladders, this latter organ being
divided by highly vascular partitions and having a
ductus pneumaticus for the supply of air.
To give another instance from the vegetable kingdom:
plants climb by three distinct means, by spirally
twining, by clasping a support with their sensitive
tendrils, and by the emission of aerial rootlets; these
three means are usually found in distinct groups, but
some few species exhibit two of the means, or even
all three, combined in the same individual. In
all such cases one of the two organs might readily
be modified and perfected so as to perform all the
work, being aided during the progress of modification
by the other organ; and then this other organ might
be modified for some other and quite distinct purpose,
or be wholly obliterated.
The illustration of the swim-bladder
in fishes is a good one, because it shows us clearly
the highly important fact that an organ originally
constructed for one purpose, namely flotation, may
be converted into one for a widely different purpose,
namely respiration. The swim-bladder has, also,
been worked in as an accessory to the auditory organs
of certain fishes. All physiologists admit that
the swim-bladder is homologous, or “ideally
similar” in position and structure with the
lungs of the higher vertebrate animals: hence
there is no reason to doubt that the swim-bladder
has actually been converted into lungs, or an organ
used exclusively for respiration.
According to this view it may be inferred
that all vertebrate animals with true lungs are descended
by ordinary generation from an ancient and unknown
prototype which was furnished with a floating apparatus
or swim-bladder. We can thus, as I infer from
Professor Owen’s interesting description of
these parts, understand the strange fact that every
particle of food and drink which we swallow has to
pass over the orifice of the trachea, with some risk
of falling into the lungs, notwithstanding the beautiful
contrivance by which the glottis is closed. In
the higher Vertebrata the branchiae have wholly
disappeared but in the embryo the slits
on the sides of the neck and the loop-like course
of the arteries still mark their former position.
But it is conceivable that the now utterly lost branchiae
might have been gradually worked in by natural selection
for some distinct purpose: for instance, Landois
has shown that the wings of insects are developed
from the trachea; it is therefore highly probable that
in this great class organs which once served for respiration
have been actually converted into organs for flight.
In considering transitions of organs,
it is so important to bear in mind the probability
of conversion from one function to another, that I
will give another instance. Pedunculated cirripedes
have two minute folds of skin, called by me the ovigerous
frena, which serve, through the means of a sticky
secretion, to retain the eggs until they are hatched
within the sack. These cirripedes have no branchiae,
the whole surface of the body and of the sack, together
with the small frena, serving for respiration.
The Balanidae or sessile cirripedes, on the other hand,
have no ovigerous frena, the eggs lying loose
at the bottom of the sack, within the well-enclosed
shell; but they have, in the same relative position
with the frena, large, much-folded membranes,
which freely communicate with the circulatory lacunae
of the sack and body, and which have been considered
by all naturalists to act as branchiae. Now
I think no one will dispute that the ovigerous frena
in the one family are strictly homologous with the
branchiae of the other family; indeed, they graduate
into each other. Therefore it need not be doubted
that the two little folds of skin, which originally
served as ovigerous frena, but which, likewise,
very slightly aided in the act of respiration, have
been gradually converted by natural selection into
branchiae, simply through an increase in their
size and the obliteration of their adhesive glands.
If all pedunculated cirripedes had become extinct,
and they have suffered far more extinction than have
sessile cirripedes, who would ever have imagined that
the branchiae in this latter family had originally
existed as organs for preventing the ova from being
washed out of the sack?
There is another possible mode of
transition, namely, through the acceleration or retardation
of the period of reproduction. This has lately
been insisted on by Professor Cope and others in the
United States. It is now known that some animals
are capable of reproduction at a very early age, before
they have acquired their perfect characters; and if
this power became thoroughly well developed in a species,
it seems probable that the adult stage of development
would sooner or later be lost; and in this case, especially
if the larva differed much from the mature form, the
character of the species would be greatly changed
and degraded. Again, not a few animals, after
arriving at maturity, go on changing in character
during nearly their whole lives. With mammals,
for instance, the form of the skull is often much altered
with age, of which Dr. Murie has given some striking
instances with seals. Every one knows how the
horns of stags become more and more branched, and the
plumes of some birds become more finely developed,
as they grow older. Professor Cope states that
the teeth of certain lizards change much in shape
with advancing years. With crustaceans not only
many trivial, but some important parts assume a new
character, as recorded by Fritz Muller, after maturity.
In all such cases and many could be given if
the age for reproduction were retarded, the character
of the species, at least in its adult state, would
be modified; nor is it improbable that the previous
and earlier stages of development would in some cases
be hurried through and finally lost. Whether
species have often or ever been modified through this
comparatively sudden mode of transition, I can form
no opinion; but if this has occurred, it is probable
that the differences between the young and the mature,
and between the mature and the old, were primordially
acquired by graduated steps.
Special difficulties of the theory
of natural selection.
Although we must be extremely cautious
in concluding that any organ could not have been produced
by successive, small, transitional gradations, yet
undoubtedly serious cases of difficulty occur.
One of the most serious is that of
neuter insects, which are often differently constructed
from either the males or fertile females; but this
case will be treated of in the next chapter. The
electric organs of fishes offer another case of special
difficulty; for it is impossible to conceive by what
steps these wondrous organs have been produced.
But this is not surprising, for we do not even know
of what use they are. In the gymnotus and torpedo
they no doubt serve as powerful means of defence,
and perhaps for securing prey; yet in the ray, as observed
by Matteucci, an analogous organ in the tail manifests
but little electricity, even when the animal is greatly
irritated; so little that it can hardly be of any
use for the above purposes. Moreover, in the
ray, besides the organ just referred to, there is,
as Dr. R. McDonnell has shown, another organ near
the head, not known to be electrical, but which appears
to be the real homologue of the electric battery in
the torpedo. It is generally admitted that there
exists between these organs and ordinary muscle a
close analogy, in intimate structure, in the distribution
of the nerves, and in the manner in which they are
acted on by various reagents. It should, also,
be especially observed that muscular contraction is
accompanied by an electrical discharge; and, as Dr.
Radcliffe insists, “in the electrical apparatus
of the torpedo during rest, there would seem to be
a charge in every respect like that which is met with
in muscle and nerve during the rest, and the discharge
of the torpedo, instead of being peculiar, may be only
another form of the discharge which attends upon the
action of muscle and motor nerve.” Beyond
this we cannot at present go in the way of explanation;
but as we know so little about the uses of these organs,
and as we know nothing about the habits and structure
of the progenitors of the existing electric fishes,
it would be extremely bold to maintain that no serviceable
transitions are possible by which these organs might
have been gradually developed.
These organs appear at first to offer
another and far more serious difficulty; for they
occur in about a dozen kinds of fish, of which several
are widely remote in their affinities. When the
same organ is found in several members of the same
class, especially if in members having very different
habits of life, we may generally attribute its presence
to inheritance from a common ancestor; and its absence
in some of the members to loss through disuse or natural
selection. So that, if the electric organs had
been inherited from some one ancient progenitor, we
might have expected that all electric fishes would
have been specially related to each other; but this
is far from the case. Nor does geology at all
lead to the belief that most fishes formerly possessed
electric organs, which their modified descendants have
now lost. But when we look at the subject more
closely, we find in the several fishes provided with
electric organs, that these are situated in different
parts of the body, that they differ in construction,
as in the arrangement of the plates, and, according
to Pacini, in the process or means by which the electricity
is excited and lastly, in being supplied
with nerves proceeding from different sources, and
this is perhaps the most important of all the differences.
Hence in the several fishes furnished with electric
organs, these cannot be considered as homologous,
but only as analogous in function. Consequently
there is no reason to suppose that they have been
inherited from a common progenitor; for had this been
the case they would have closely resembled each other
in all respects. Thus the difficulty of an organ,
apparently the same, arising in several remotely allied
species, disappears, leaving only the lesser yet still
great difficulty: namely, by what graduated steps
these organs have been developed in each separate group
of fishes.
The luminous organs which occur in
a few insects, belonging to widely different families,
and which are situated in different parts of the body,
offer, under our present state of ignorance, a difficulty
almost exactly parallel with that of the electric
organs. Other similar cases could be given; for
instance in plants, the very curious contrivance of
a mass of pollen-grains, borne on a foot-stalk with
an adhesive gland, is apparently the same in Orchis
and Asclepias, genera almost as remote as is
possible among flowering plants; but here again the
parts are not homologous. In all cases of beings,
far removed from each other in the scale of organisation,
which are furnished with similar and peculiar organs,
it will be found that although the general appearance
and function of the organs may be the same, yet fundamental
differences between them can always be detected.
For instance, the eyes of Cephalopods or cuttle-fish
and of vertebrate animals appear wonderfully alike;
and in such widely sundered groups no part of this
resemblance can be due to inheritance from a common
progenitor. Mr. Mivart has advanced this case
as one of special difficulty, but I am unable to see
the force of his argument. An organ for vision
must be formed of transparent tissue, and must include
some sort of lens for throwing an image at the back
of a darkened chamber. Beyond this superficial
resemblance, there is hardly any real similarity between
the eyes of cuttle-fish and vertebrates, as may be
seen by consulting Hensen’s admirable memoir
on these organs in the Cephalopoda. It is impossible
for me here to enter on details, but I may specify
a few of the points of difference. The crystalline
lens in the higher cuttle-fish consists of two parts,
placed one behind the other like two lenses, both having
a very different structure and disposition to what
occurs in the vertebrata. The retina is wholly
different, with an actual inversion of the elemental
parts, and with a large nervous ganglion included within
the membranes of the eye. The relations of the
muscles are as different as it is possible to conceive,
and so in other points. Hence it is not a little
difficult to decide how far even the same terms ought
to be employed in describing the eyes of the Cephalopoda
and Vertebrata. It is, of course, open to any
one to deny that the eye in either case could have
been developed through the natural selection of successive
slight variations; but if this be admitted in the
one case it is clearly possible in the other; and
fundamental differences of structure in the visual
organs of two groups might have been anticipated, in
accordance with this view of their manner of formation.
As two men have sometimes independently hit on the
same invention, so in the several foregoing cases
it appears that natural selection, working for the
good of each being, and taking advantage of all favourable
variations, has produced similar organs, as far as
function is concerned, in distinct organic beings,
which owe none of their structure in common to inheritance
from a common progenitor.
Fritz Muller, in order to test the
conclusions arrived at in this volume, has followed
out with much care a nearly similar line of argument.
Several families of crustaceans include a few species,
possessing an air-breathing apparatus and fitted to
live out of the water. In two of these families,
which were more especially examined by Muller, and
which are nearly related to each other, the species
agree most closely in all important characters:
namely in their sense organs, circulating systems,
in the position of the tufts of hair within their
complex stomachs, and lastly in the whole structure
of the water-breathing branchiae, even to the
microscopical hooks by which they are cleansed.
Hence it might have been expected that in the few species
belonging to both families which live on the land,
the equally important air-breathing apparatus would
have been the same; for why should this one apparatus,
given for the same purpose, have been made to differ,
while all the other important organs were closely similar,
or rather, identical.
Fritz Muller argues that this close
similarity in so many points of structure must, in
accordance with the views advanced by me, be accounted
for by inheritance from a common progenitor. But
as the vast majority of the species in the above two
families, as well as most other crustaceans, are aquatic
in their habits, it is improbable in the highest degree
that their common progenitor should have been adapted
for breathing air. Muller was thus led carefully
to examine the apparatus in the air-breathing species;
and he found it to differ in each in several important
points, as in the position of the orifices, in the
manner in which they are opened and closed, and in
some accessory details. Now such differences
are intelligible, and might even have been expected,
on the supposition that species belonging to distinct
families had slowly become adapted to live more and
more out of water, and to breathe the air. For
these species, from belonging to distinct families,
would have differed to a certain extent, and in accordance
with the principle that the nature of each variation
depends on two factors, viz., the nature of the
organism and that of the surrounding conditions, their
variability assuredly would not have been exactly
the same. Consequently natural selection would
have had different materials or variations to work
on, in order to arrive at the same functional result;
and the structures thus acquired would almost necessarily
have differed. On the hypothesis of separate
acts of creation the whole case remains unintelligible.
This line of argument seems to have had great weight
in leading Fritz Muller to accept the views maintained
by me in this volume.
Another distinguished zoologist, the
late Professor Claparede, has argued in the same manner,
and has arrived at the same result. He shows
that there are parasitic mites (Acaridae), belonging
to distinct sub-families and families, which are furnished
with hair-claspers. These organs must have been
independently developed, as they could not have been
inherited from a common progenitor; and in the several
groups they are formed by the modification of the
fore legs, of the hind legs, of the maxillae or lips,
and of appendages on the under side of the hind part
of the body.
In the foregoing cases, we see the
same end gained and the same function performed, in
beings not at all or only remotely allied, by organs
in appearance, though not in development, closely
similar. On the other hand, it is a common rule
throughout nature that the same end should be gained,
even sometimes in the case of closely related beings,
by the most diversified means. How differently
constructed is the feathered wing of a bird and the
membrane-covered wing of a bat; and still more so
the four wings of a butterfly, the two wings of a fly,
and the two wings with the elytra of a beetle.
Bivalve shells are made to open and shut, but on what
a number of patterns is the hinge constructed, from
the long row of neatly interlocking teeth in a Nucula
to the simple ligament of a Mussel! Seeds are
disseminated by their minuteness, by their capsule
being converted into a light balloon-like envelope,
by being embedded in pulp or flesh, formed of the
most diverse parts, and rendered nutritious, as well
as conspicuously coloured, so as to attract and be
devoured by birds, by having hooks and grapnels of
many kinds and serrated awns, so as to adhere to the
fur of quadrupeds, and by being furnished with wings
and plumes, as different in shape as they are elegant
in structure, so as to be wafted by every breeze.
I will give one other instance: for this subject
of the same end being gained by the most diversified
means well deserves attention. Some authors maintain
that organic beings have been formed in many ways for
the sake of mere variety, almost like toys in a shop,
but such a view of nature is incredible. With
plants having separated sexes, and with those in which,
though hermaphrodites, the pollen does not spontaneously
fall on the stigma, some aid is necessary for their
fertilisation. With several kinds this is effected
by the pollen-grains, which are light and incoherent,
being blown by the wind through mere chance on to the
stigma; and this is the simplest plan which can well
be conceived. An almost equally simple, though
very different plan occurs in many plants in which
a symmetrical flower secretes a few drops of nectar,
and is consequently visited by insects; and these
carry the pollen from the anthers to the stigma.
From this simple stage we may pass
through an inexhaustible number of contrivances, all
for the same purpose and effected in essentially the
same manner, but entailing changes in every part of
the flower. The nectar may be stored in variously
shaped receptacles, with the stamens and pistils modified
in many ways, sometimes forming trap-like contrivances,
and sometimes capable of neatly adapted movements through
irritability or elasticity. From such structures
we may advance till we come to such a case of extraordinary
adaptation as that lately described by Dr. Cruger
in the Coryanthes. This orchid has part of its
labellum or lower lip hollowed out into a great bucket,
into which drops of almost pure water continually
fall from two secreting horns which stand above it;
and when the bucket is half-full, the water overflows
by a spout on one side. The basal part of the
labellum stands over the bucket, and is itself hollowed
out into a sort of chamber with two lateral entrances;
within this chamber there are curious fleshy ridges.
The most ingenious man, if he had not witnessed what
takes place, could never have imagined what purpose
all these parts serve. But Dr. Cruger saw crowds
of large humble-bees visiting the gigantic flowers
of this orchid, not in order to suck nectar, but to
gnaw off the ridges within the chamber above the bucket;
in doing this they frequently pushed each other into
the bucket, and their wings being thus wetted they
could not fly away, but were compelled to crawl out
through the passage formed by the spout or overflow.
Dr. Cruger saw a “continual procession”
of bees thus crawling out of their involuntary bath.
The passage is narrow, and is roofed over by the column,
so that a bee, in forcing its way out, first rubs its
back against the viscid stigma and then against the
viscid glands of the pollen-masses. The pollen-masses
are thus glued to the back of the bee which first
happens to crawl out through the passage of a lately
expanded flower, and are thus carried away. Dr.
Cruger sent me a flower in spirits of wine, with a
bee which he had killed before it had quite crawled
out, with a pollen-mass still fastened to its back.
When the bee, thus provided, flies to another flower,
or to the same flower a second time, and is pushed
by its comrades into the bucket and then crawls out
by the passage, the pollen-mass necessarily comes first
into contact with the viscid stigma, and adheres to
it, and the flower is fertilised. Now at last
we see the full use of every part of the flower, of
the water-secreting horns of the bucket half-full of
water, which prevents the bees from flying away, and
forces them to crawl out through the spout, and rub
against the properly placed viscid pollen-masses and
the viscid stigma.
The construction of the flower in
another closely allied orchid, namely, the Catasetum,
is widely different, though serving the same end; and
is equally curious. Bees visit these flowers,
like those of the Coryanthes, in order to gnaw the
labellum; in doing this they inevitably touch a long,
tapering, sensitive projection, or, as I have called
it, the antenna. This antenna, when touched,
transmits a sensation or vibration to a certain membrane
which is instantly ruptured; this sets free a spring
by which the pollen-mass is shot forth, like an arrow,
in the right direction, and adheres by its viscid
extremity to the back of the bee. The pollen-mass
of the male plant (for the sexes are separate in this
orchid) is thus carried to the flower of the female
plant, where it is brought into contact with the stigma,
which is viscid enough to break certain elastic threads,
and retain the pollen, thus effecting fertilisation.
How, it may be asked, in the foregoing
and in innumerable other instances, can we understand
the graduated scale of complexity and the multifarious
means for gaining the same end. The answer no
doubt is, as already remarked, that when two forms
vary, which already differ from each other in some
slight degree, the variability will not be of the
same exact nature, and consequently the results obtained
through natural selection for the same general purpose
will not be the same. We should also bear in
mind that every highly developed organism has passed
through many changes; and that each modified structure
tends to be inherited, so that each modification will
not readily be quite lost, but may be again and again
further altered. Hence, the structure of each
part of each species, for whatever purpose it may serve,
is the sum of many inherited changes, through which
the species has passed during its successive adaptations
to changed habits and conditions of life.
Finally, then, although in many cases
it is most difficult even to conjecture by what transitions
organs could have arrived at their present state;
yet, considering how small the proportion of living
and known forms is to the extinct and unknown, I have
been astonished how rarely an organ can be named,
towards which no transitional grade is known to lead.
It is certainly true, that new organs appearing as
if created for some special purpose rarely or never
appear in any being; as indeed is shown by that old,
but somewhat exaggerated, canon in natural history
of “Natura non facit saltum.” We meet
with this admission in the writings of almost every
experienced naturalist; or, as Milne Edwards has well
expressed it, “Nature is prodigal in variety,
but niggard in innovation.” Why, on the
theory of Creation, should there be so much variety
and so little real novelty? Why should all the
parts and organs of many independent beings, each
supposed to have been separately created for its own
proper place in nature, be so commonly linked together
by graduated steps? Why should not Nature take
a sudden leap from structure to structure? On
the theory of natural selection, we can clearly understand
why she should not; for natural selection acts only
by taking advantage of slight successive variations;
she can never take a great and sudden leap, but must
advance by the short and sure, though slow steps.
Organs of little apparent
importance, as affected by natural
selection.
As natural selection acts by life
and death, by the survival of the fittest, and by
the destruction of the less well-fitted individuals,
I have sometimes felt great difficulty in understanding
the origin or formation of parts of little importance;
almost as great, though of a very different kind,
as in the case of the most perfect and complex organs.
In the first place, we are much too
ignorant in regard to the whole economy of any one
organic being to say what slight modifications would
be of importance or not. In a former chapter I
have given instances of very trifling characters,
such as the down on fruit and the colour of its flesh,
the colour of the skin and hair of quadrupeds, which,
from being correlated with constitutional differences,
or from determining the attacks of insects, might
assuredly be acted on by natural selection. The
tail of the giraffe looks like an artificially constructed
fly-flapper; and it seems at first incredible that
this could have been adapted for its present purpose
by successive slight modifications, each better and
better fitted, for so trifling an object as to drive
away flies; yet we should pause before being too positive
even in this case, for we know that the distribution
and existence of cattle and other animals in South
America absolutely depend on their power of resisting
the attacks of insects: so that individuals which
could by any means defend themselves from these small
enemies, would be able to range into new pastures
and thus gain a great advantage. It is not that
the larger quadrupeds are actually destroyed (except
in some rare cases) by flies, but they are incessantly
harassed and their strength reduced, so that they
are more subject to disease, or not so well enabled
in a coming dearth to search for food, or to escape
from beasts of prey.
Organs now of trifling importance
have probably in some cases been of high importance
to an early progenitor, and, after having been slowly
perfected at a former period, have been transmitted
to existing species in nearly the same state, although
now of very slight use; but any actually injurious
deviations in their structure would of course have
been checked by natural selection. Seeing how
important an organ of locomotion the tail is in most
aquatic animals, its general presence and use for
many purposes in so many land animals, which in their
lungs or modified swim-bladders betray their aquatic
origin, may perhaps be thus accounted for. A
well-developed tail having been formed in an aquatic
animal, it might subsequently come to be worked in
for all sorts of purposes, as a fly-flapper, an organ
of prehension, or as an aid in turning, as in the
case of the dog, though the aid in this latter respect
must be slight, for the hare, with hardly any tail,
can double still more quickly.
In the second place, we may easily
err in attributing importance to characters, and in
believing that they have been developed through natural
selection. We must by no means overlook the effects
of the definite action of changed conditions of life,
of so-called spontaneous variations, which seem to
depend in a quite subordinate degree on the nature
of the conditions, of the tendency to reversion to
long-lost characters, of the complex laws of growth,
such as of correlation, comprehension, of the pressure
of one part on another, etc., and finally of
sexual selection, by which characters of use to one
sex are often gained and then transmitted more or
less perfectly to the other sex, though of no use
to the sex. But structures thus indirectly gained,
although at first of no advantage to a species, may
subsequently have been taken advantage of by its modified
descendants, under new conditions of life and newly
acquired habits.
If green woodpeckers alone had existed,
and we did not know that there were many black and
pied kinds, I dare say that we should have thought
that the green colour was a beautiful adaptation to
conceal this tree-frequenting bird from its enemies;
and consequently that it was a character of importance,
and had been acquired through natural selection; as
it is, the colour is probably in chief part due to
sexual selection. A trailing palm in the Malay
Archipelago climbs the loftiest trees by the aid of
exquisitely constructed hooks clustered around the
ends of the branches, and this contrivance, no doubt,
is of the highest service to the plant; but as we
see nearly similar hooks on many trees which are not
climbers, and which, as there is reason to believe
from the distribution of the thorn-bearing species
in Africa and South America, serve as a defence against
browsing quadrupeds, so the spikes on the palm may
at first have been developed for this object, and
subsequently have been improved and taken advantage
of by the plant, as it underwent further modification
and became a climber. The naked skin on the head
of a vulture is generally considered as a direct adaptation
for wallowing in putridity; and so it may be, or it
may possibly be due to the direct action of putrid
matter; but we should be very cautious in drawing
any such inference, when we see that the skin on the
head of the clean-feeding male turkey is likewise
naked. The sutures in the skulls of young mammals
have been advanced as a beautiful adaptation for aiding
parturition, and no doubt they facilitate, or may be
indispensable for this act; but as sutures occur in
the skulls of young birds and reptiles, which have
only to escape from a broken egg, we may infer that
this structure has arisen from the laws of growth,
and has been taken advantage of in the parturition
of the higher animals.
We are profoundly ignorant of the
cause of each slight variation or individual difference;
and we are immediately made conscious of this by reflecting
on the differences between the breeds of our domesticated
animals in different countries, more especially in
the less civilized countries, where there has been
but little methodical selection. Animals kept
by savages in different countries often have to struggle
for their own subsistence, and are exposed to a certain
extent to natural selection, and individuals with
slightly different constitutions would succeed best
under different climates. With cattle susceptibility
to the attacks of flies is correlated with colour,
as is the liability to be poisoned by certain plants;
so that even colour would be thus subjected to the
action of natural selection. Some observers are
convinced that a damp climate affects the growth of
the hair, and that with the hair the horns are correlated.
Mountain breeds always differ from lowland breeds;
and a mountainous country would probably affect the
hind limbs from exercising them more, and possibly
even the form of the pelvis; and then by the law of
homologous variation, the front limbs and the head
would probably be affected. The shape, also,
of the pelvis might affect by pressure the shape of
certain parts of the young in the womb. The laborious
breathing necessary in high regions tends, as we have
good reason to believe, to increase the size of the
chest; and again correlation would come into play.
The effects of lessened exercise, together with abundant
food, on the whole organisation is probably still
more important, and this, as H. von Nathusius has lately
shown in his excellent Treatise, is apparently one
chief cause of the great modification which the breeds
of swine have undergone. But we are far too ignorant
to speculate on the relative importance of the several
known and unknown causes of variation; and I have made
these remarks only to show that, if we are unable
to account for the characteristic differences of our
several domestic breeds, which nevertheless are generally
admitted to have arisen through ordinary generation
from one or a few parent-stocks, we ought not to lay
too much stress on our ignorance of the precise cause
of the slight analogous differences between true species.
Utilitarian doctrine, how far
true: Beauty, how acquired.
The foregoing remarks lead me to say
a few words on the protest lately made by some naturalists
against the utilitarian doctrine that every detail
of structure has been produced for the good of its
possessor. They believe that many structures
have been created for the sake of beauty, to delight
man or the Creator (but this latter point is beyond
the scope of scientific discussion), or for the sake
of mere variety, a view already discussed. Such
doctrines, if true, would be absolutely fatal to my
theory. I fully admit that many structures are
now of no direct use to their possessors, and may
never have been of any use to their progenitors; but
this does not prove that they were formed solely for
beauty or variety. No doubt the definite action
of changed conditions, and the various causes of modifications,
lately specified, have all produced an effect, probably
a great effect, independently of any advantage thus
gained. But a still more important consideration
is that the chief part of the organisation of every
living creature is due to inheritance; and consequently,
though each being assuredly is well fitted for its
place in nature, many structures have now no very close
and direct relation to present habits of life.
Thus, we can hardly believe that the webbed feet of
the upland goose, or of the frigate-bird, are of special
use to these birds; we cannot believe that the similar
bones in the arm of the monkey, in the fore leg of
the horse, in the wing of the bat, and in the flipper
of the seal, are of special use to these animals.
We may safely attribute these structures to inheritance.
But webbed feet no doubt were as useful to the progenitor
of the upland goose and of the frigate-bird, as they
now are to the most aquatic of living birds.
So we may believe that the progenitor of the seal
did not possess a flipper, but a foot with five toes
fitted for walking or grasping; and we may further
venture to believe that the several bones in the limbs
of the monkey, horse and bat, were originally developed,
on the principle of utility, probably through the
reduction of more numerous bones in the fin of some
ancient fish-like progenitor of the whole class.
It is scarcely possible to decide how much allowance
ought to be made for such causes of change, as the
definite action of external conditions, so-called spontaneous
variations, and the complex laws of growth; but with
these important exceptions, we may conclude that the
structure of every living creature either now is,
or was formerly, of some direct or indirect use to
its possessor.
With respect to the belief that organic
beings have been created beautiful for the delight
of man a belief which it has been pronounced
is subversive of my whole theory I may first
remark that the sense of beauty obviously depends
on the nature of the mind, irrespective of any real
quality in the admired object; and that the idea of
what is beautiful, is not innate or unalterable.
We see this, for instance, in the men of different
races admiring an entirely different standard of beauty
in their women. If beautiful objects had been
created solely for man’s gratification, it ought
to be shown that before man appeared there was less
beauty on the face of the earth than since he came
on the stage. Were the beautiful volute and cone
shells of the Eocene epoch, and the gracefully sculptured
ammonites of the Secondary period, created that man
might ages afterwards admire them in his cabinet?
Few objects are more beautiful than the minute siliceous
cases of the diatomaceae: were these created
that they might be examined and admired under the
higher powers of the microscope? The beauty in
this latter case, and in many others, is apparently
wholly due to symmetry of growth. Flowers rank
among the most beautiful productions of nature; but
they have been rendered conspicuous in contrast with
the green leaves, and in consequence at the same time
beautiful, so that they may be easily observed by
insects. I have come to this conclusion from finding
it an invariable rule that when a flower is fertilised
by the wind it never has a gaily-coloured corolla.
Several plants habitually produce two kinds of flowers;
one kind open and coloured so as to attract insects;
the other closed, not coloured, destitute of nectar,
and never visited by insects. Hence, we may conclude
that, if insects had not been developed on the face
of the earth, our plants would not have been decked
with beautiful flowers, but would have produced only
such poor flowers as we see on our fir, oak, nut and
ash trees, on grasses, spinach, docks and nettles,
which are all fertilised through the agency of the
wind. A similar line of argument holds good with
fruits; that a ripe strawberry or cherry is as pleasing
to the eye as to the palate that the gaily-coloured
fruit of the spindle-wood tree and the scarlet berries
of the holly are beautiful objects will
be admitted by everyone. But this beauty serves
merely as a guide to birds and beasts, in order that
the fruit may be devoured and the matured seeds disseminated.
I infer that this is the case from having as yet found
no exception to the rule that seeds are always thus
disseminated when embedded within a fruit of any kind
(that is within a fleshy or pulpy envelope), if it
be coloured of any brilliant tint, or rendered conspicuous
by being white or black.
On the other hand, I willingly admit
that a great number of male animals, as all our most
gorgeous birds, some fishes, reptiles, and mammals,
and a host of magnificently coloured butterflies, have
been rendered beautiful for beauty’s sake.
But this has been effected through sexual selection,
that is, by the more beautiful males having been continually
preferred by the females, and not for the delight of
man. So it is with the music of birds. We
may infer from all this that a nearly similar taste
for beautiful colours and for musical sounds runs through
a large part of the animal kingdom. When the female
is as beautifully coloured as the male, which is not
rarely the case with birds and butterflies, the cause
apparently lies in the colours acquired through sexual
selection having been transmitted to both sexes, instead
of to the males alone. How the sense of beauty
in its simplest form that is, the reception
of a peculiar kind of pleasure from certain colours,
forms and sounds was first developed in
the mind of man and of the lower animals, is a very
obscure subject. The same sort of difficulty is
presented if we enquire how it is that certain flavours
and odours give pleasure, and others displeasure.
Habit in all these cases appears to have come to a
certain extent into play; but there must be some fundamental
cause in the constitution of the nervous system in
each species.
Natural selection cannot possibly
produce any modification in a species exclusively
for the good of another species; though throughout
nature one species incessantly takes advantage of,
and profits by the structures of others. But
natural selection can and does often produce structures
for the direct injury of other animals, as we see in
the fang of the adder, and in the ovipositor of the
ichneumon, by which its eggs are deposited in the
living bodies of other insects. If it could be
proved that any part of the structure of any one species
had been formed for the exclusive good of another
species, it would annihilate my theory, for such could
not have been produced through natural selection.
Although many statements may be found in works on natural
history to this effect, I cannot find even one which
seems to me of any weight. It is admitted that
the rattlesnake has a poison-fang for its own defence
and for the destruction of its prey; but some authors
suppose that at the same time it is furnished with
a rattle for its own injury, namely, to warn its prey.
I would almost as soon believe that the cat curls the
end of its tail when preparing to spring, in order
to warn the doomed mouse. It is a much more probable
view that the rattlesnake uses its rattle, the cobra
expands its frill and the puff-adder swells while
hissing so loudly and harshly, in order to alarm the
many birds and beasts which are known to attack even
the most venomous species. Snakes act on the
same principle which makes the hen ruffle her feathers
and expand her wings when a dog approaches her chickens.
But I have not space here to enlarge on the many ways
by which animals endeavour to frighten away their
enemies.
Natural selection will never produce
in a being any structure more injurious than beneficial
to that being, for natural selection acts solely by
and for the good of each. No organ will be formed,
as Paley has remarked, for the purpose of causing
pain or for doing an injury to its possessor.
If a fair balance be struck between the good and evil
caused by each part, each will be found on the whole
advantageous. After the lapse of time, under
changing conditions of life, if any part comes to
be injurious, it will be modified; or if it be not
so, the being will become extinct, as myriads have
become extinct.
Natural selection tends only to make
each organic being as perfect as, or slightly more
perfect than the other inhabitants of the same country
with which it comes into competition. And we see
that this is the standard of perfection attained under
nature. The endemic productions of New Zealand,
for instance, are perfect, one compared with another;
but they are now rapidly yielding before the advancing
legions of plants and animals introduced from Europe.
Natural selection will not produce absolute perfection,
nor do we always meet, as far as we can judge, with
this high standard under nature. The correction
for the aberration of light is said by Muller not
to be perfect even in that most perfect organ, the
human eye. Helmholtz, whose judgment no one will
dispute, after describing in the strongest terms the
wonderful powers of the human eye, adds these remarkable
words: “That which we have discovered in
the way of inexactness and imperfection in the optical
machine and in the image on the retina, is as nothing
in comparison with the incongruities which we have
just come across in the domain of the sensations.
One might say that nature has taken delight in accumulating
contradictions in order to remove all foundation from
the theory of a pre-existing harmony between the external
and internal worlds.” If our reason leads
us to admire with enthusiasm a multitude of inimitable
contrivances in nature, this same reason tells us,
though we may easily err on both sides, that some
other contrivances are less perfect. Can we consider
the sting of the bee as perfect, which, when used against
many kinds of enemies, cannot be withdrawn, owing
to the backward serratures, and thus inevitably causes
the death of the insect by tearing out its viscera?
If we look at the sting of the bee,
as having existed in a remote progenitor, as a boring
and serrated instrument, like that in so many members
of the same great order, and that it has since been
modified but not perfected for its present purpose,
with the poison originally adapted for some other
object, such as to produce galls, since intensified,
we can perhaps understand how it is that the use of
the sting should so often cause the insect’s
own death: for if on the whole the power of stinging
be useful to the social community, it will fulfil
all the requirements of natural selection, though it
may cause the death of some few members. If we
admire the truly wonderful power of scent by which
the males of many insects find their females, can we
admire the production for this single purpose of thousands
of drones, which are utterly useless to the community
for any other purpose, and which are ultimately slaughtered
by their industrious and sterile sisters? It may
be difficult, but we ought to admire the savage instinctive
hatred of the queen-bee, which urges her to destroy
the young queens, her daughters, as soon as they are
born, or to perish herself in the combat; for undoubtedly
this is for the good of the community; and maternal
love or maternal hatred, though the latter fortunately
is most rare, is all the same to the inexorable principles
of natural selection. If we admire the several
ingenious contrivances by which orchids and many other
plants are fertilised through insect agency, can we
consider as equally perfect the elaboration of dense
clouds of pollen by our fir-trees, so that a few granules
may be wafted by chance on to the ovules?
Summary: The law
of unity of type and of
the conditions of existence embraced
by the theory of natural selection.
We have in this chapter discussed
some of the difficulties and objections which may
be urged against the theory. Many of them are
serious; but I think that in the discussion light has
been thrown on several facts, which on the belief
of independent acts of creation are utterly obscure.
We have seen that species at any one period are not
indefinitely variable, and are not linked together
by a multitude of intermediate gradations, partly
because the process of natural selection is always
very slow, and at any one time acts only on a few forms;
and partly because the very process of natural selection
implies the continual supplanting and extinction of
preceding and intermediate gradations. Closely
allied species, now living on a continuous area, must
often have been formed when the area was not continuous,
and when the conditions of life did not insensibly
graduate away from one part to another. When
two varieties are formed in two districts of a continuous
area, an intermediate variety will often be formed,
fitted for an intermediate zone; but from reasons
assigned, the intermediate variety will usually exist
in lesser numbers than the two forms which it connects;
consequently the two latter, during the course of further
modification, from existing in greater numbers, will
have a great advantage over the less numerous intermediate
variety, and will thus generally succeed in supplanting
and exterminating it.
We have seen in this chapter how cautious
we should be in concluding that the most different
habits of life could not graduate into each other;
that a bat, for instance, could not have been formed
by natural selection from an animal which at first
only glided through the air.
We have seen that a species under
new conditions of life may change its habits, or it
may have diversified habits, with some very unlike
those of its nearest congeners. Hence we can
understand, bearing in mind that each organic being
is trying to live wherever it can live, how it has
arisen that there are upland geese with webbed feet,
ground woodpeckers, diving thrushes, and pétrels
with the habits of auks.
Although the belief that an organ
so perfect as the eye could have been formed by natural
selection, is enough to stagger any one; yet in the
case of any organ, if we know of a long series of gradations
in complexity, each good for its possessor, then under
changing conditions of life, there is no logical impossibility
in the acquirement of any conceivable degree of perfection
through natural selection. In the cases in which
we know of no intermediate or transitional states,
we should be extremely cautious in concluding that
none can have existed, for the metamorphoses of many
organs show what wonderful changes in function are
at least possible. For instance, a swim-bladder
has apparently been converted into an air-breathing
lung. The same organ having performed simultaneously
very different functions, and then having been in part
or in whole specialised for one function; and two distinct
organs having performed at the same time the same
function, the one having been perfected whilst aided
by the other, must often have largely facilitated
transitions.
We have seen that in two beings widely
remote from each other in the natural scale, organs
serving for the same purpose and in external appearance
closely similar may have been separately and independently
formed; but when such organs are closely examined,
essential differences in their structure can almost
always be detected; and this naturally follows from
the principle of natural selection. On the other
hand, the common rule throughout nature is infinite
diversity of structure for gaining the same end; and
this again naturally follows from the same great principle.
In many cases we are far too ignorant
to be enabled to assert that a part or organ is so
unimportant for the welfare of a species, that modifications
in its structure could not have been slowly accumulated
by means of natural selection. In many other cases,
modifications are probably the direct result of the
laws of variation or of growth, independently of any
good having been thus gained. But even such structures
have often, as we may feel assured, been subsequently
taken advantage of, and still further modified, for
the good of species under new conditions of life.
We may, also, believe that a part formerly of high
importance has frequently been retained (as the tail
of an aquatic animal by its terrestrial descendants),
though it has become of such small importance that
it could not, in its present state, have been acquired
by means of natural selection.
Natural selection can produce nothing
in one species for the exclusive good or injury of
another; though it may well produce parts, organs,
and excretions highly useful or even indispensable,
or highly injurious to another species, but in all
cases at the same time useful to the possessor.
In each well-stocked country natural selection acts
through the competition of the inhabitants and consequently
leads to success in the battle for life, only in accordance
with the standard of that particular country.
Hence the inhabitants of one country, generally the
smaller one, often yield to the inhabitants of another
and generally the larger country. For in the
larger country there will have existed more individuals,
and more diversified forms, and the competition will
have been severer, and thus the standard of perfection
will have been rendered higher. Natural selection
will not necessarily lead to absolute perfection;
nor, as far as we can judge by our limited faculties,
can absolute perfection be everywhere predicated.
On the theory of natural selection
we can clearly understand the full meaning of that
old canon in natural history, “Natura non facit
saltum.” This canon, if we look to the
present inhabitants alone of the world, is not strictly
correct; but if we include all those of past times,
whether known or unknown, it must on this theory be
strictly true.
It is generally acknowledged that
all organic beings have been formed on two great laws Unity
of Type, and the Conditions of Existence. By unity
of type is meant that fundamental agreement in structure
which we see in organic beings of the same class,
and which is quite independent of their habits of
life. On my theory, unity of type is explained
by unity of descent. The expression of conditions
of existence, so often insisted on by the illustrious
Cuvier, is fully embraced by the principle of natural
selection. For natural selection acts by either
now adapting the varying parts of each being to its
organic and inorganic conditions of life; or by having
adapted them during past periods of time: the
adaptations being aided in many cases by the increased
use or disuse of parts, being affected by the direct
action of external conditions of life, and subjected
in all cases to the several laws of growth and variation.
Hence, in fact, the law of the Conditions of Existence
is the higher law; as it includes, through the inheritance
of former variations and adaptations, that of Unity
of Type.