On the slow and successive appearance of new species On their different
rates of change Species once lost do not reappear Groups of species
follow the same general rules in their appearance and disappearance as
do single species On extinction On simultaneous changes in the forms
of life throughout the world On the affinities of extinct species to
each other and to living species On the state of development of
ancient forms On the succession of the same types within the same
areas Summary of preceding and present chapters.
Let us now see whether the several
facts and laws relating to the geological succession
of organic beings accord best with the common view
of the immutability of species, or with that of their
slow and gradual modification, through variation and
natural selection.
New species have appeared very slowly,
one after another, both on the land and in the waters.
Lyell has shown that it is hardly possible to resist
the evidence on this head in the case of the several
tertiary stages; and every year tends to fill up the
blanks between the stages, and to make the proportion
between the lost and existing forms more gradual.
In some of the most recent beds, though undoubtedly
of high antiquity if measured by years, only one or
two species are extinct, and only one or two are new,
having appeared there for the first time, either locally,
or, as far as we know, on the face of the earth.
The secondary formations are more broken; but, as
Bronn has remarked, neither the appearance nor disappearance
of the many species embedded in each formation has
been simultaneous.
Species belonging to different genera
and classes have not changed at the same rate, or
in the same degree. In the older tertiary beds
a few living shells may still be found in the midst
of a multitude of extinct forms. Falconer has
given a striking instance of a similar fact, for an
existing crocodile is associated with many lost mammals
and reptiles in the sub-Himalayan deposits. The
Silurian Lingula differs but little from the
living species of this genus; whereas most of the other
Silurian Molluscs and all the Crustaceans have changed
greatly. The productions of the land seem to
have changed at a quicker rate than those of the sea,
of which a striking instance has been observed in Switzerland.
There is some reason to believe that organisms high
in the scale, change more quickly than those that
are low: though there are exceptions to this
rule. The amount of organic change, as Pictet
has remarked, is not the same in each successive so-called
formation. Yet if we compare any but the most
closely related formations, all the species will be
found to have undergone some change. When a species
has once disappeared from the face of the earth, we
have no reason to believe that the same identical
form ever reappears. The strongest apparent exception
to this latter rule is that of the so-called “colonies”
of M. Barrande, which intrude for a period in the
midst of an older formation, and then allow the pre-existing
fauna to reappear; but Lyell’s explanation, namely,
that it is a case of temporary migration from a distinct
geographical province, seems satisfactory.
These several facts accord well with
our theory, which includes no fixed law of development,
causing all the inhabitants of an area to change abruptly,
or simultaneously, or to an equal degree. The
process of modification must be slow, and will generally
affect only a few species at the same time; for the
variability of each species is independent of that
of all others. Whether such variations or individual
differences as may arise will be accumulated through
natural selection in a greater or less degree, thus
causing a greater or less amount of permanent modification,
will depend on many complex contingencies on
the variations being of a beneficial nature, on the
freedom of intercrossing, on the slowly changing physical
conditions of the country, on the immigration of new
colonists, and on the nature of the other inhabitants
with which the varying species come into competition.
Hence it is by no means surprising that one species
should retain the same identical form much longer
than others; or, if changing, should change in a less
degree. We find similar relations between the
existing inhabitants of distinct countries; for instance,
the land-shells and coleopterous insects of Madeira
have come to differ considerably from their nearest
allies on the continent of Europe, whereas the marine
shells and birds have remained unaltered. We can
perhaps understand the apparently quicker rate of
change in terrestrial and in more highly organised
productions compared with marine and lower productions,
by the more complex relations of the higher beings
to their organic and inorganic conditions of life,
as explained in a former chapter. When many of
the inhabitants of any area have become modified and
improved, we can understand, on the principle of competition,
and from the all-important relations of organism to
organism in the struggle for life, that any form which
did not become in some degree modified and improved,
would be liable to extermination. Hence, we see
why all the species in the same region do at last,
if we look to long enough intervals of time, become
modified; for otherwise they would become extinct.
In members of the same class the average
amount of change, during long and equal periods of
time, may, perhaps, be nearly the same; but as the
accumulation of enduring formations, rich in fossils,
depends on great masses of sediment being deposited
on subsiding areas, our formations have been almost
necessarily accumulated at wide and irregularly intermittent
intervals of time; consequently the amount of organic
change exhibited by the fossils embedded in consecutive
formations is not equal. Each formation, on this
view, does not mark a new and complete act of creation,
but only an occasional scene, taken almost at hazard,
in an ever slowly changing drama.
We can clearly understand why a species
when once lost should never reappear, even if the
very same conditions of life, organic and inorganic,
should recur. For though the offspring of one
species might be adapted (and no doubt this has occurred
in innumerable instances) to fill the place of another
species in the economy of nature, and thus supplant
it; yet the two forms the old and the new would
not be identically the same; for both would almost
certainly inherit different characters from their
distinct progenitors; and organisms already differing
would vary in a different manner. For instance,
it is possible, if all our fantail-pigeons were destroyed,
that fanciers might make a new breed hardly distinguishable
from the present breed; but if the parent rock-pigeon
were likewise destroyed, and under nature we have
every reason to believe that parent forms are generally
supplanted and exterminated by their improved offspring,
it is incredible that a fantail, identical with the
existing breed, could be raised from any other species
of pigeon, or even from any other well established
race of the domestic pigeon, for the successive variations
would almost certainly be in some degree different,
and the newly-formed variety would probably inherit
from its progenitor some characteristic differences.
Groups of species, that is, genera
and families, follow the same general rules in their
appearance and disappearance as do single species,
changing more or less quickly, and in a greater or
lesser degree. A group, when it has once disappeared,
never reappears; that is, its existence, as long as
it lasts, is continuous. I am aware that there
are some apparent exceptions to this rule, but the
exceptions are surprisingly few, so few that E. Forbes,
Pictet, and Woodward (though all strongly opposed
to such views as I maintain) admit its truth; and
the rule strictly accords with the theory. For
all the species of the same group, however long it
may have lasted, are the modified descendants one
from the other, and all from a common progenitor.
In the genus Lingula, for instance, the
species which have successively appeared at all ages
must have been connected by an unbroken series of
generations, from the lowest Silurian stratum to the
present day.
We have seen in the last chapter that
whole groups of species sometimes falsely appear to
have been abruptly developed; and I have attempted
to give an explanation of this fact, which if true
would be fatal to my views. But such cases are
certainly exceptional; the general rule being a gradual
increase in number, until the group reaches its maximum,
and then, sooner or later, a gradual decrease.
If the number of the species included within a genus,
or the number of the genera within a family, be represented
by a vertical line of varying thickness, ascending
through the successive geological formations, in which
the species are found, the line will sometimes falsely
appear to begin at its lower end, not in a sharp point,
but abruptly; it then gradually thickens upwards, often
keeping of equal thickness for a space, and ultimately
thins out in the upper beds, marking the decrease
and final extinction of the species. This gradual
increase in number of the species of a group is strictly
conformable with the theory; for the species of the
same genus, and the genera of the same family, can
increase only slowly and progressively; the process
of modification and the production of a number of allied
forms necessarily being a slow and gradual process,
one species first giving rise to two or three varieties,
these being slowly converted into species, which in
their turn produce by equally slow steps other varieties
and species, and so on, like the branching of a great
tree from a single stem, till the group becomes large.
On extinction.
We have as yet only spoken incidentally
of the disappearance of species and of groups of species.
On the theory of natural selection, the extinction
of old forms and the production of new and improved
forms are intimately connected together. The
old notion of all the inhabitants of the earth having
been swept away by catastrophes at successive periods
is very generally given up, even by those geologists,
as Elie de Beaumont, Murchison, Barrande, etc.,
whose general views would naturally lead them to this
conclusion. On the contrary, we have every reason
to believe, from the study of the tertiary formations,
that species and groups of species gradually disappear,
one after another, first from one spot, then from
another, and finally from the world. In some few
cases, however, as by the breaking of an isthmus and
the consequent irruption of a multitude of new inhabitants
into an adjoining sea, or by the final subsidence
of an island, the process of extinction may have been
rapid. Both single species and whole groups of
species last for very unequal periods; some groups,
as we have seen, have endured from the earliest known
dawn of life to the present day; some have disappeared
before the close of the palaeozoic period. No
fixed law seems to determine the length of time during
which any single species or any single genus endures.
There is reason to believe that the extinction of a
whole group of species is generally a slower process
than their production: if their appearance and
disappearance be represented, as before, by a vertical
line of varying thickness the line is found to taper
more gradually at its upper end, which marks the progress
of extermination, than at its lower end, which marks
the first appearance and the early increase in number
of the species. In some cases, however, the extermination
of whole groups, as of ammonites, towards the close
of the secondary period, has been wonderfully sudden.
The extinction of species has been
involved in the most gratuitous mystery. Some
authors have even supposed that, as the individual
has a definite length of life, so have species a definite
duration. No one can have marvelled more than
I have done at the extinction of species. When
I found in La Plata the tooth of a horse embedded with
the remains of Mastodon, Mégathérium, Toxodon
and other extinct monsters, which all co-existed with
still living shells at a very late geological period,
I was filled with astonishment; for, seeing that the
horse, since its introduction by the Spaniards into
South America, has run wild over the whole country
and has increased in numbers at an unparalleled rate,
I asked myself what could so recently have exterminated
the former horse under conditions of life apparently
so favourable. But my astonishment was groundless.
Professor Owen soon perceived that the tooth, though
so like that of the existing horse, belonged to an
extinct species. Had this horse been still living,
but in some degree rare, no naturalist would have
felt the least surprise at its rarity; for rarity is
the attribute of a vast number of species of all classes,
in all countries. If we ask ourselves why this
or that species is rare, we answer that something
is unfavourable in its conditions of life; but what
that something is, we can hardly ever tell. On
the supposition of the fossil horse still existing
as a rare species, we might have felt certain, from
the analogy of all other mammals, even of the slow-breeding
elephant, and from the history of the naturalisation
of the domestic horse in South America, that under
more favourable conditions it would in a very few
years have stocked the whole continent. But we
could not have told what the unfavourable conditions
were which checked its increase, whether some one
or several contingencies, and at what period of the
horse’s life, and in what degree they severally
acted. If the conditions had gone on, however
slowly, becoming less and less favourable, we assuredly
should not have perceived the fact, yet the fossil
horse would certainly have become rarer and rarer,
and finally extinct its place being seized
on by some more successful competitor.
It is most difficult always to remember
that the increase of every living creature is constantly
being checked by unperceived hostile agencies; and
that these same unperceived agencies are amply sufficient
to cause rarity, and finally extinction. So little
is this subject understood, that I have heard surprise
repeatedly expressed at such great monsters as the
Mastodon and the more ancient Dinosaurians having
become extinct; as if mere bodily strength gave victory
in the battle of life. Mere size, on the contrary,
would in some cases determine, as has been remarked
by Owen, quicker extermination, from the greater amount
of requisite food. Before man inhabited India
or Africa, some cause must have checked the continued
increase of the existing elephant. A highly capable
judge, Dr. Falconer, believes that it is chiefly insects
which, from incessantly harassing and weakening the
elephant in India, check its increase; and this was
Bruce’s conclusion with respect to the African
elephant in Abyssinia. It is certain that insects
and blood-sucking bats determine the existence of
the larger naturalised quadrupeds in several parts
of South America.
We see in many cases in the more recent
tertiary formations that rarity precedes extinction;
and we know that this has been the progress of events
with those animals which have been exterminated, either
locally or wholly, through man’s agency.
I may repeat what I published in 1845, namely, that
to admit that species generally become rare before
they become extinct to feel no surprise
at the rarity of a species, and yet to marvel greatly
when the species ceases to exist, is much the same
as to admit that sickness in the individual is the
forerunner of death to feel no surprise
at sickness, but, when the sick man dies, to wonder
and to suspect that he died by some deed of violence.
The theory of natural selection is
grounded on the belief that each new variety and ultimately
each new species, is produced and maintained by having
some advantage over those with which it comes into
competition; and the consequent extinction of less-favoured
forms almost inevitably follows. It is the same
with our domestic productions: when a new and
slightly improved variety has been raised, it at first
supplants the less improved varieties in the same
neighbourhood; when much improved it is transported
far and near, like our short-horn cattle, and takes
the place of other breeds in other countries.
Thus the appearance of new forms and the disappearance
of old forms, both those naturally and artificially
produced, are bound together. In flourishing groups,
the number of new specific forms which have been produced
within a given time has at some periods probably been
greater than the number of the old specific forms
which have been exterminated; but we know that species
have not gone on indefinitely increasing, at least
during the later geological epochs, so that, looking
to later times, we may believe that the production
of new forms has caused the extinction of about the
same number of old forms.
The competition will generally be
most severe, as formerly explained and illustrated
by examples, between the forms which are most like
each other in all respects. Hence the improved
and modified descendants of a species will generally
cause the extermination of the parent-species; and
if many new forms have been developed from any one
species, the nearest allies of that species, i.e.
the species of the same genus, will be the most liable
to extermination. Thus, as I believe, a number
of new species descended from one species, that is
a new genus, comes to supplant an old genus, belonging
to the same family. But it must often have happened
that a new species belonging to some one group has
seized on the place occupied by a species belonging
to a distinct group, and thus have caused its extermination.
If many allied forms be developed from the successful
intruder, many will have to yield their places; and
it will generally be the allied forms, which will suffer
from some inherited inferiority in common. But
whether it be species belonging to the same or to
a distinct class, which have yielded their places to
other modified and improved species, a few of the sufferers
may often be preserved for a long time, from being
fitted to some peculiar line of life, or from inhabiting
some distant and isolated station, where they will
have escaped severe competition. For instance,
some species of Trigonia, a great genus of shells
in the secondary formations, survive in the Australian
seas; and a few members of the great and almost extinct
group of Ganoid fishes still inhabit our fresh waters.
Therefore, the utter extinction of a group is generally,
as we have seen, a slower process than its production.
With respect to the apparently sudden
extermination of whole families or orders, as of Trilobites
at the close of the palaeozoic period, and of Ammonites
at the close of the secondary period, we must remember
what has been already said on the probable wide intervals
of time between our consecutive formations; and in
these intervals there may have been much slow extermination.
Moreover, when, by sudden immigration or by unusually
rapid development, many species of a new group have
taken possession of an area, many of the older species
will have been exterminated in a correspondingly rapid
manner; and the forms which thus yield their places
will commonly be allied, for they will partake of the
same inferiority in common.
Thus, as it seems to me, the manner
in which single species and whole groups of species
become extinct accords well with the theory of natural
selection. We need not marvel at extinction; if
we must marvel, let it be at our presumption in imagining
for a moment that we understand the many complex contingencies
on which the existence of each species depends.
If we forget for an instant that each species tends
to increase inordinately, and that some check is always
in action, yet seldom perceived by us, the whole economy
of nature will be utterly obscured. Whenever
we can precisely say why this species is more abundant
in individuals than that; why this species and not
another can be naturalised in a given country; then,
and not until then, we may justly feel surprise why
we cannot account for the extinction of any particular
species or group of species.
On the forms of
life changing almost simultaneously
throughout the world.
Scarcely any palaeontological discovery
is more striking than the fact that the forms of life
change almost simultaneously throughout the world.
Thus our European Chalk formation can be recognised
in many distant regions, under the most different
climates, where not a fragment of the mineral chalk
itself can be found; namely, in North America, in
equatorial South America, in Tierra del Fuego,
at the Cape of Good Hope, and in the peninsula of
India. For at these distant points, the organic
remains in certain beds present an unmistakable resemblance
to those of the Chalk. It is not that the same
species are met with; for in some cases not one species
is identically the same, but they belong to the same
families, genera, and sections of genera, and sometimes
are similarly characterised in such trifling points
as mere superficial sculpture. Moreover, other
forms, which are not found in the Chalk of Europe,
but which occur in the formations either above or below,
occur in the same order at these distant points of
the world. In the several successive palaeozoic
formations of Russia, Western Europe and North America,
a similar parallelism in the forms of life has been
observed by several authors; so it is, according to
Lyell, with the European and North American tertiary
deposits. Even if the few fossil species which
are common to the Old and New Worlds were kept wholly
out of view, the general parallelism in the successive
forms of life, in the palaeozoic and tertiary stages,
would still be manifest, and the several formations
could be easily correlated.
These observations, however, relate
to the marine inhabitants of the world: we have
not sufficient data to judge whether the productions
of the land and of fresh water at distant points change
in the same parallel manner. We may doubt whether
they have thus changed: if the Mégathérium,
Mylodon, Macrauchenia, and Toxodon had been brought
to Europe from La Plata, without any information in
regard to their geological position, no one would
have suspected that they had co-existed with sea-shells
all still living; but as these anomalous monsters
co-existed with the Mastodon and Horse, it might at
least have been inferred that they had lived during
one of the later tertiary stages.
When the marine forms of life are
spoken of as having changed simultaneously throughout
the world, it must not be supposed that this expression
relates to the same year, or even to the same century,
or even that it has a very strict geological sense;
for if all the marine animals now living in Europe,
and all those that lived in Europe during the pléistocène
period (a very remote period as measured by years,
including the whole glacial epoch) were compared with
those now existing in South America or in Australia,
the most skilful naturalist would hardly be able to
say whether the present or the pléistocène inhabitants
of Europe resembled most closely those of the southern
hemisphere. So, again, several highly competent
observers maintain that the existing productions of
the United States are more closely related to those
which lived in Europe during certain late tertiary
stages, than to the present inhabitants of Europe;
and if this be so, it is evident that fossiliferous
beds now deposited on the shores of North America would
hereafter be liable to be classed with somewhat older
European beds. Nevertheless, looking to a remotely
future epoch, there can be little doubt that all the
more modern marine formations, namely, the upper
pliocène, the pléistocène and strictly modern
beds of Europe, North and South America, and Australia,
from containing fossil remains in some degree allied,
and from not including those forms which are found
only in the older underlying deposits, would be correctly
ranked as simultaneous in a geological sense.
The fact of the forms of life changing
simultaneously in the above large sense, at distant
parts of the world, has greatly struck those admirable
observers, mm. de Verneuil and d’Archiac.
After referring to the parallelism of the palaeozoic
forms of life in various parts of Europe, they add,
“If struck by this strange sequence, we turn
our attention to North America, and there discover
a series of analogous phenomena, it will appear certain
that all these modifications of species, their extinction,
and the introduction of new ones, cannot be owing to
mere changes in marine currents or other causes more
or less local and temporary, but depend on general
laws which govern the whole animal kingdom.”
M. Barrande has made forcible remarks to precisely
the same effect. It is, indeed, quite futile
to look to changes of currents, climate, or other
physical conditions, as the cause of these great mutations
in the forms of life throughout the world, under the
most different climates. We must, as Barrande
has remarked, look to some special law. We shall
see this more clearly when we treat of the present
distribution of organic beings, and find how slight
is the relation between the physical conditions of
various countries and the nature of their inhabitants.
This great fact of the parallel succession
of the forms of life throughout the world, is explicable
on the theory of natural selection. New species
are formed by having some advantage over older forms;
and the forms, which are already dominant, or have
some advantage over the other forms in their own country,
give birth to the greatest number of new varieties
or incipient species. We have distinct evidence
on this head, in the plants which are dominant, that
is, which are commonest and most widely diffused,
producing the greatest number of new varieties.
It is also natural that the dominant, varying and far-spreading
species, which have already invaded, to a certain
extent, the territories of other species, should be
those which would have the best chance of spreading
still further, and of giving rise in new countries
to other new varieties and species. The process
of diffusion would often be very slow, depending on
climatal and geographical changes, on strange accidents,
and on the gradual acclimatization of new species to
the various climates through which they might have
to pass, but in the course of time the dominant forms
would generally succeed in spreading and would ultimately
prevail. The diffusion would, it is probable,
be slower with the terrestrial inhabitants of distinct
continents than with the marine inhabitants of the
continuous sea. We might therefore expect to
find, as we do find, a less strict degree of parallelism
in the succession of the productions of the land than
with those of the sea.
Thus, as it seems to me, the parallel,
and, taken in a large sense, simultaneous, succession
of the same forms of life throughout the world, accords
well with the principle of new species having been
formed by dominant species spreading widely and varying;
the new species thus produced being themselves dominant,
owing to their having had some advantage over their
already dominant parents, as well as over other species;
and again spreading, varying, and producing new forms.
The old forms which are beaten and which yield their
places to the new and victorious forms, will generally
be allied in groups, from inheriting some inferiority
in common; and, therefore, as new and improved groups
spread throughout the world, old groups disappear from
the world; and the succession of forms everywhere
tends to correspond both in their first appearance
and final disappearance.
There is one other remark connected
with this subject worth making. I have given
my reasons for believing that most of our great formations,
rich in fossils, were deposited during periods of subsidence;
and that blank intervals of vast duration, as far
as fossils are concerned, occurred during the periods
when the bed of the sea was either stationary or rising,
and likewise when sediment was not thrown down quickly
enough to embed and preserve organic remains.
During these long and blank intervals I suppose that
the inhabitants of each region underwent a considerable
amount of modification and extinction, and that there
was much migration from other parts of the world.
As we have reason to believe that large areas are
affected by the same movement, it is probable that
strictly contemporaneous formations have often been
accumulated over very wide spaces in the same quarter
of the world; but we are very far from having any
right to conclude that this has invariably been the
case, and that large areas have invariably been affected
by the same movements. When two formations have
been deposited in two regions during nearly, but not
exactly, the same period, we should find in both,
from the causes explained in the foregoing paragraphs,
the same general succession in the forms of life; but
the species would not exactly correspond; for there
will have been a little more time in the one region
than in the other for modification, extinction, and
immigration.
I suspect that cases of this nature
occur in Europe. Mr. Prestwich, in his admirable
Memoirs on the éocène deposits of England and
France, is able to draw a close general parallelism
between the successive stages in the two countries;
but when he compares certain stages in England with
those in France, although he finds in both a curious
accordance in the numbers of the species belonging
to the same genera, yet the species themselves differ
in a manner very difficult to account for considering
the proximity of the two areas, unless, indeed, it
be assumed that an isthmus separated two seas inhabited
by distinct, but contemporaneous faunas.
Lyell has made similar observations on some of the
later tertiary formations. Barrande, also, shows
that there is a striking general parallelism in the
successive Silurian deposits of Bohemia and Scandinavia;
nevertheless he finds a surprising amount of difference
in the species. If the several formations in
these regions have not been deposited during the same
exact periods a formation in one region
often corresponding with a blank interval in the other and
if in both regions the species have gone on slowly
changing during the accumulation of the several formations
and during the long intervals of time between them;
in this case the several formations in the two regions
could be arranged in the same order, in accordance
with the general succession of the forms of life,
and the order would falsely appear to be strictly
parallel; nevertheless the species would not all be
the same in the apparently corresponding stages in
the two regions.
On the affinities of
extinct species to each other,
and to living forms.
Let us now look to the mutual affinities
of extinct and living species. All fall into
a few grand classes; and this fact is at once explained
on the principle of descent. The more ancient
any form is, the more, as a general rule, it differs
from living forms. But, as Buckland long ago
remarked, extinct species can all be classed either
in still existing groups, or between them. That
the extinct forms of life help to fill up the intervals
between existing genera, families, and orders, is
certainly true; but as this statement has often been
ignored or even denied, it may be well to make some
remarks on this subject, and to give some instances.
If we confine our attention either to the living or
to the extinct species of the same class, the series
is far less perfect than if we combine both into one
general system. In the writings of Professor
Owen we continually meet with the expression of generalised
forms, as applied to extinct animals; and in the writings
of Agassiz, of prophetic or synthetic types; and these
terms imply that such forms are, in fact, intermediate
or connecting links. Another distinguished palaeontologist,
M. Gaudry, has shown in the most striking manner that
many of the fossil mammals discovered by him in Attica
serve to break down the intervals between existing
genera. Cuvier ranked the Ruminants and Pachyderms
as two of the most distinct orders of mammals; but
so many fossil links have been disentombed that Owen
has had to alter the whole classification, and has
placed certain Pachyderms in the same sub-order with
ruminants; for example, he dissolves by gradations
the apparently wide interval between the pig and the
camel. The Ungulata or hoofed quadrupeds are
now divided into the even-toed or odd-toed divisions;
but the Macrauchenia of South America connects to a
certain extent these two grand divisions. No
one will deny that the Hipparion is intermediate
between the existing horse and certain other ungulate
forms. What a wonderful connecting link in the
chain of mammals is the Typotherium from South America,
as the name given to it by Professor Gervais expresses,
and which cannot be placed in any existing order.
The Sirenia form a very distinct group of the
mammals, and one of the most remarkable peculiarities
in existing dugong and lamentin is the entire absence
of hind limbs, without even a rudiment being left;
but the extinct Halitherium had, according to Professor
Flower, an ossified thigh-bone “articulated
to a well-defined acetabulum in the pelvis,”
and it thus makes some approach to ordinary hoofed
quadrupeds, to which the Sirenia are in other
respects allied. The cetaceans or whales are
widely different from all other mammals, but the tertiary
Zeuglodon and Squalodon, which have been placed by
some naturalists in an order by themselves, are considered
by Professor Huxley to be undoubtedly cetaceans, “and
to constitute connecting links with the aquatic carnivora.”
Even the wide interval between birds
and reptiles has been shown by the naturalist just
quoted to be partially bridged over in the most unexpected
manner, on the one hand, by the ostrich and extinct
Archéoptéryx, and on the other hand by the Compsognathus,
one of the Dinosaurians that group which
includes the most gigantic of all terrestrial reptiles.
Turning to the Invertebrata, Barrande asserts, a higher
authority could not be named, that he is every day
taught that, although palaeozoic animals can certainly
be classed under existing groups, yet that at this
ancient period the groups were not so distinctly separated
from each other as they now are.
Some writers have objected to any
extinct species, or group of species, being considered
as intermediate between any two living species, or
groups of species. If by this term it is meant
that an extinct form is directly intermediate in all
its characters between two living forms or groups,
the objection is probably valid. But in a natural
classification many fossil species certainly stand
between living species, and some extinct genera between
living genera, even between genera belonging to distinct
families. The most common case, especially with
respect to very distinct groups, such as fish and
reptiles, seems to be that, supposing them to be distinguished
at the present day by a score of characters, the ancient
members are separated by a somewhat lesser number of
characters, so that the two groups formerly made a
somewhat nearer approach to each other than they now
do.
It is a common belief that the more
ancient a form is, by so much the more it tends to
connect by some of its characters groups now widely
separated from each other. This remark no doubt
must be restricted to those groups which have undergone
much change in the course of geological ages; and
it would be difficult to prove the truth of the proposition,
for every now and then even a living animal, as the
Lepidosiren, is discovered having affinities directed
towards very distinct groups. Yet if we compare
the older Reptiles and Batrachians, the older Fish,
the older Cephalopods, and the éocène Mammals,
with the recent members of the same classes, we must
admit that there is truth in the remark.
Let us see how far these several facts
and inferences accord with the theory of descent with
modification. As the subject is somewhat complex,
I must request the reader to turn to the diagram in
the fourth chapter. We may suppose that the numbered
letters in italics represent genera, and the dotted
lines diverging from them the species in each genus.
The diagram is much too simple, too few genera and
too few species being given, but this is unimportant
for us. The horizontal lines may represent successive
geological formations, and all the forms beneath the
uppermost line may be considered as extinct. The
three existing genera, a14, q14, p14, will form a
small family; b14 and f14, a closely allied family
or subfamily; and o14, i14, m14, a third family.
These three families, together with the many extinct
genera on the several lines of descent diverging from
the parent form (A) will form an order; for all will
have inherited something in common from their ancient
progenitor. On the principle of the continued
tendency to divergence of character, which was formerly
illustrated by this diagram, the more recent any form
is the more it will generally differ from its ancient
progenitor. Hence, we can understand the rule
that the most ancient fossils differ most from existing
forms. We must not, however, assume that divergence
of character is a necessary contingency; it depends
solely on the descendants from a species being thus
enabled to seize on many and different places in the
economy of nature. Therefore it is quite possible,
as we have seen in the case of some Silurian forms,
that a species might go on being slightly modified
in relation to its slightly altered conditions of
life, and yet retain throughout a vast period the
same general characteristics. This is represented
in the diagram by the letter F14.
All the many forms, extinct and recent,
descended from (A), make, as before remarked, one
order; and this order, from the continued effects
of extinction and divergence of character, has become
divided into several sub-families and families, some
of which are supposed to have perished at different
periods, and some to have endured to the present day.
By looking at the diagram we can see
that if many of the extinct forms supposed to be embedded
in the successive formations, were discovered at several
points low down in the series, the three existing families
on the uppermost line would be rendered less distinct
from each other. If, for instance, the genera
a1, a5, a10, f8, m3, m6, m9, were disinterred, these
three families would be so closely linked together
that they probably would have to be united into one
great family, in nearly the same manner as has occurred
with ruminants and certain pachyderms. Yet he
who objected to consider as intermediate the extinct
genera, which thus link together the living genera
of three families, would be partly justified, for
they are intermediate, not directly, but only by a
long and circuitous course through many widely different
forms. If many extinct forms were to be discovered
above one of the middle horizontal lines or geological
formations for instance, above No.
VI. but none from beneath this line, then
only two of the families (those on the left hand a14,
etc., and b14, etc.) would have to be united
into one; and there would remain two families which
would be less distinct from each other than they were
before the discovery of the fossils. So again,
if the three families formed of eight genera (a14
to m14), on the uppermost line, be supposed to differ
from each other by half-a-dozen important characters,
then the families which existed at a period marked
VI would certainly have differed from each other by
a less number of characters; for they would at this
early stage of descent have diverged in a less degree
from their common progenitor. Thus it comes that
ancient and extinct genera are often in a greater
or less degree intermediate in character between their
modified descendants, or between their collateral
relations.
Under nature the process will be far
more complicated than is represented in the diagram;
for the groups will have been more numerous; they
will have endured for extremely unequal lengths of
time, and will have been modified in various degrees.
As we possess only the last volume of the geological
record, and that in a very broken condition, we have
no right to expect, except in rare cases, to fill up
the wide intervals in the natural system, and thus
to unite distinct families or orders. All that
we have a right to expect is, that those groups which
have, within known geological periods, undergone much
modification, should in the older formations make
some slight approach to each other; so that the older
members should differ less from each other in some
of their characters than do the existing members of
the same groups; and this by the concurrent evidence
of our best palaeontologists is frequently the case.
Thus, on the theory of descent with
modification, the main facts with respect to the mutual
affinities of the extinct forms of life to each other
and to living forms, are explained in a satisfactory
manner. And they are wholly inexplicable on any
other view.
On this same theory, it is evident
that the fauna during any one great period in the
earth’s history will be intermediate in general
character between that which preceded and that which
succeeded it. Thus the species which lived at
the sixth great stage of descent in the diagram are
the modified offspring of those which lived at the
fifth stage, and are the parents of those which became
still more modified at the seventh stage; hence they
could hardly fail to be nearly intermediate in character
between the forms of life above and below. We
must, however, allow for the entire extinction of
some preceding forms, and in any one region for the
immigration of new forms from other regions, and for
a large amount of modification during the long and
blank intervals between the successive formations.
Subject to these allowances, the fauna of each geological
period undoubtedly is intermediate in character, between
the preceding and succeeding faunas. I need
give only one instance, namely, the manner in which
the fossils of the Devonian system, when this system
was first discovered, were at once recognised by palaeontologists
as intermediate in character between those of the
overlying carboniferous and underlying Silurian systems.
But each fauna is not necessarily exactly intermediate,
as unequal intervals of time have elapsed between
consecutive formations.
It is no real objection to the truth
of the statement that the fauna of each period as
a whole is nearly intermediate in character between
the preceding and succeeding faunas, that certain
genera offer exceptions to the rule. For instance,
the species of mastodons and elephants, when arranged
by Dr. Falconer in two series in the first
place according to their mutual affinities, and in
the second place according to their periods of existence do
not accord in arrangement. The species extreme
in character are not the oldest or the most recent;
nor are those which are intermediate in character,
intermediate in age. But supposing for an instant,
in this and other such cases, that the record of the
first appearance and disappearance of the species
was complete, which is far from the case, we have
no reason to believe that forms successively produced
necessarily endure for corresponding lengths of time.
A very ancient form may occasionally have lasted much
longer than a form elsewhere subsequently produced,
especially in the case of terrestrial productions
inhabiting separated districts. To compare small
things with great; if the principal living and extinct
races of the domestic pigeon were arranged in serial
affinity, this arrangement would not closely accord
with the order in time of their production, and even
less with the order of their disappearance; for the
parent rock-pigeon still lives; and many varieties
between the rock-pigeon and the carrier have become
extinct; and carriers which are extreme in the important
character of length of beak originated earlier than
short-beaked tumblers, which are at the opposite end
of the series in this respect.
Closely connected with the statement,
that the organic remains from an intermediate formation
are in some degree intermediate in character, is the
fact, insisted on by all palaeontologists, that fossils
from two consecutive formations are far more closely
related to each other, than are the fossils from two
remote formations. Pictet gives as a well-known
instance, the general resemblance of the organic remains
from the several stages of the Chalk formation, though
the species are distinct in each stage. This
fact alone, from its generality, seems to have shaken
Professor Pictet in his belief in the immutability
of species. He who is acquainted with the distribution
of existing species over the globe, will not attempt
to account for the close resemblance of distinct species
in closely consecutive formations, by the physical
conditions of the ancient areas having remained nearly
the same. Let it be remembered that the forms
of life, at least those inhabiting the sea, have changed
almost simultaneously throughout the world, and therefore
under the most different climates and conditions.
Consider the prodigious vicissitudes of climate during
the pléistocène period, which includes the whole
glacial epoch, and note how little the specific forms
of the inhabitants of the sea have been affected.
On the theory of descent, the full
meaning of the fossil remains from closely consecutive
formations, being closely related, though ranked as
distinct species, is obvious. As the accumulation
of each formation has often been interrupted, and
as long blank intervals have intervened between successive
formations, we ought not to expect to find, as I attempted
to show in the last chapter, in any one or in any two
formations, all the intermediate varieties between
the species which appeared at the commencement and
close of these periods: but we ought to find
after intervals, very long as measured by years, but
only moderately long as measured geologically, closely
allied forms, or, as they have been called by some
authors, representative species; and these assuredly
we do find. We find, in short, such evidence of
the slow and scarcely sensible mutations of specific
forms, as we have the right to expect.
On the state of
development of ancient compared
with living forms.
We have seen in the fourth chapter
that the degree of differentiation and specialisation
of the parts in organic beings, when arrived at maturity,
is the best standard, as yet suggested, of their degree
of perfection or highness. We have also seen
that, as the specialisation of parts is an advantage
to each being, so natural selection will tend to render
the organisation of each being more specialised and
perfect, and in this sense higher; not but that it
may leave many creatures with simple and unimproved
structures fitted for simple conditions of life, and
in some cases will even degrade or simplify the organisation,
yet leaving such degraded beings better fitted for
their new walks of life. In another and more
general manner, new species become superior to their
predecessors; for they have to beat in the struggle
for life all the older forms, with which they come
into close competition. We may therefore conclude
that if under a nearly similar climate the éocène
inhabitants of the world could be put into competition
with the existing inhabitants, the former would be
beaten and exterminated by the latter, as would the
secondary by the éocène, and the palaeozoic by
the secondary forms. So that by this fundamental
test of victory in the battle for life, as well as
by the standard of the specialisation of organs, modern
forms ought, on the theory of natural selection, to
stand higher than ancient forms. Is this the case?
A large majority of palaeontologists would answer
in the affirmative; and it seems that this answer
must be admitted as true, though difficult of proof.
It is no valid objection to this conclusion,
that certain Brachiopods have been but slightly modified
from an extremely remote geological epoch; and that
certain land and fresh-water shells have remained nearly
the same, from the time when, as far as is known, they
first appeared. It is not an insuperable difficulty
that Foraminifera have not, as insisted on by Dr.
Carpenter, progressed in organisation since even the
Laurentian epoch; for some organisms would have to
remain fitted for simple conditions of life, and what
could be better fitted for this end than these lowly
organised Protozoa? Such objections as the above
would be fatal to my view, if it included advance in
organisation as a necessary contingent. They
would likewise be fatal, if the above Foraminifera,
for instance, could be proved to have first come into
existence during the Laurentian epoch, or the above
Brachiopods during the Cambrian formation; for in
this case, there would not have been time sufficient
for the development of these organisms up to the standard
which they had then reached. When advanced up
to any given point, there is no necessity, on the
theory of natural selection, for their further continued
process; though they will, during each successive age,
have to be slightly modified, so as to hold their
places in relation to slight changes in their conditions.
The foregoing objections hinge on the question whether
we really know how old the world is, and at what period
the various forms of life first appeared; and this
may well be disputed.
The problem whether organisation on
the whole has advanced is in many ways excessively
intricate. The geological record, at all times
imperfect, does not extend far enough back to show
with unmistakable clearness that within the known
history of the world organisation has largely advanced.
Even at the present day, looking to members of the
same class, naturalists are not unanimous which forms
ought to be ranked as highest: thus, some look
at the selaceans or sharks, from their approach in
some important points of structure to reptiles, as
the highest fish; others look at the teleosteans as
the highest. The ganoids stand intermediate between
the selaceans and teleosteans; the latter at the present
day are largely preponderant in number; but formerly
selaceans and ganoids alone existed; and in this case,
according to the standard of highness chosen, so will
it be said that fishes have advanced or retrograded
in organisation. To attempt to compare members
of distinct types in the scale of highness seems hopeless;
who will decide whether a cuttle-fish be higher than
a bee that insect which the great Von Baer
believed to be “in fact more highly organised
than a fish, although upon another type?” In
the complex struggle for life it is quite credible
that crustaceans, not very high in their own class,
might beat cephalopods, the highest molluscs; and such
crustaceans, though not highly developed, would stand
very high in the scale of invertebrate animals, if
judged by the most decisive of all trials the
law of battle. Beside these inherent difficulties
in deciding which forms are the most advanced in organisation,
we ought not solely to compare the highest members
of a class at any two periods though undoubtedly
this is one and perhaps the most important element
in striking a balance but we ought to compare
all the members, high and low, at two periods.
At an ancient epoch the highest and lowest molluscoidal
animals, namely, cephalopods and brachiopods, swarmed
in numbers; at the present time both groups are greatly
reduced, while others, intermediate in organisation,
have largely increased; consequently some naturalists
maintain that molluscs were formerly more highly developed
than at present; but a stronger case can be made out
on the opposite side, by considering the vast reduction
of brachiopods, and the fact that our existing cephalopods,
though few in number, are more highly organised than
their ancient representatives. We ought also to
compare the relative proportional numbers, at any two
periods, of the high and low classes throughout the
world: if, for instance, at the present day fifty
thousand kinds of vertebrate animals exist, and if
we knew that at some former period only ten thousand
kinds existed, we ought to look at this increase in
number in the highest class, which implies a great
displacement of lower forms, as a decided advance in
the organisation of the world. We thus see how
hopelessly difficult it is to compare with perfect
fairness, under such extremely complex relations,
the standard of organisation of the imperfectly-known
faunas of successive periods.
We shall appreciate this difficulty
more clearly by looking to certain existing faunas
and floras. From the extraordinary manner
in which European productions have recently spread
over New Zealand, and have seized on places which
must have been previously occupied by the indigenes,
we must believe, that if all the animals and plants
of Great Britain were set free in New Zealand, a multitude
of British forms would in the course of time become
thoroughly naturalized there, and would exterminate
many of the natives. On the other hand, from the
fact that hardly a single inhabitant of the southern
hemisphere has become wild in any part of Europe,
we may well doubt whether, if all the productions
of New Zealand were set free in Great Britain, any
considerable number would be enabled to seize on places
now occupied by our native plants and animals.
Under this point of view, the productions of Great
Britain stand much higher in the scale than those
of New Zealand. Yet the most skilful naturalist,
from an examination of the species of the two countries,
could not have foreseen this result.
Agassiz and several other highly competent
judges insist that ancient animals resemble to a certain
extent the embryos of recent animals belonging to
the same classes; and that the geological succession
of extinct forms is nearly parallel with the embryological
development of existing forms. This view accords
admirably well with our theory. In a future chapter
I shall attempt to show that the adult differs from
its embryo, owing to variations having supervened
at a not early age, and having been inherited at a
corresponding age. This process, whilst it leaves
the embryo almost unaltered, continually adds, in the
course of successive generations, more and more difference
to the adult. Thus the embryo comes to be left
as a sort of picture, preserved by nature, of the
former and less modified condition of the species.
This view may be true, and yet may never be capable
of proof. Seeing, for instance, that the oldest
known mammals, reptiles, and fishes strictly belong
to their proper classes, though some of these old
forms are in a slight degree less distinct from each
other than are the typical members of the same groups
at the present day, it would be vain to look for animals
having the common embryological character of the Vertebrata,
until beds rich in fossils are discovered far beneath
the lowest Cambrian strata a discovery
of which the chance is small.
On the succession of
the same types within the
same areas, during the later
tertiary periods.
Mr. Clift many years ago showed that
the fossil mammals from the Australian caves were
closely allied to the living marsupials of that continent.
In South America, a similar relationship is manifest,
even to an uneducated eye, in the gigantic pieces
of armour, like those of the armadillo, found in several
parts of La Plata; and Professor Owen has shown in
the most striking manner that most of the fossil mammals,
buried there in such numbers, are related to South
American types. This relationship is even more
clearly seen in the wonderful collection of fossil
bones made by mm. Lund and Clausen in the
caves of Brazil. I was so much impressed with
these facts that I strongly insisted, in 1839 and
1845, on this “law of the succession of types,” on
“this wonderful relationship in the same continent
between the dead and the living.” Professor
Owen has subsequently extended the same generalisation
to the mammals of the Old World. We see the same
law in this author’s restorations of the extinct
and gigantic birds of New Zealand. We see it
also in the birds of the caves of Brazil. Mr.
Woodward has shown that the same law holds good with
sea-shells, but, from the wide distribution of most
molluscs, it is not well displayed by them. Other
cases could be added, as the relation between the
extinct and living land-shells of Madeira; and between
the extinct and living brackish water-shells of the
Aralo-Caspian Sea.
Now, what does this remarkable law
of the succession of the same types within the same
areas mean? He would be a bold man who, after
comparing the present climate of Australia and of
parts of South America, under the same latitude, would
attempt to account, on the one hand through dissimilar
physical conditions, for the dissimilarity of the inhabitants
of these two continents; and, on the other hand through
similarity of conditions, for the uniformity of the
same types in each continent during the later tertiary
periods. Nor can it be pretended that it is an
immutable law that marsupials should have been chiefly
or solely produced in Australia; or that Edentata
and other American types should have been solely produced
in South America. For we know that Europe in
ancient times was peopled by numerous marsupials; and
I have shown in the publications above alluded to,
that in America the law of distribution of terrestrial
mammals was formerly different from what it now is.
North America formerly partook strongly of the present
character of the southern half of the continent; and
the southern half was formerly more closely allied,
than it is at present, to the northern half.
In a similar manner we know, from Falconer and Cautley’s
discoveries, that Northern India was formerly more
closely related in its mammals to Africa than it is
at the present time. Analogous facts could be
given in relation to the distribution of marine animals.
On the theory of descent with modification,
the great law of the long enduring, but not immutable,
succession of the same types within the same areas,
is at once explained; for the inhabitants of each quarter
of the world will obviously tend to leave in that
quarter, during the next succeeding period of time,
closely allied though in some degree modified descendants.
If the inhabitants of one continent formerly differed
greatly from those of another continent, so will their
modified descendants still differ in nearly the same
manner and degree. But after very long intervals
of time, and after great geographical changes, permitting
much intermigration, the feebler will yield to the
more dominant forms, and there will be nothing immutable
in the distribution of organic beings.
It may be asked in ridicule whether
I suppose that the mégathérium and other allied
huge monsters, which formerly lived in South America,
have left behind them the sloth, armadillo, and anteater,
as their degenerate descendants. This cannot
for an instant be admitted. These huge animals
have become wholly extinct, and have left no progeny.
But in the caves of Brazil there are many extinct
species which are closely allied in size and in all
other characters to the species still living in South
America; and some of these fossils may have been the
actual progenitors of the living species. It
must not be forgotten that, on our theory, all the
species of the same genus are the descendants of some
one species; so that, if six genera, each having eight
species, be found in one geological formation, and
in a succeeding formation there be six other allied
or representative genera, each with the same number
of species, then we may conclude that generally only
one species of each of the older genera has left modified
descendants, which constitute the new genera containing
the several species; the other seven species of each
old genus having died out and left no progeny.
Or, and this will be a far commoner case, two or three
species in two or three alone of the six older genera
will be the parents of the new genera: the other
species and the other old genera having become utterly
extinct. In failing orders, with the genera and
species decreasing in numbers as is the case with
the Edentata of South America, still fewer genera and
species will leave modified blood-descendants.