As lakes and river-systems are separated
from each other by barriers of land, it might have
been thought that fresh-water productions would not
have ranged widely within the same country, and as
the sea is apparently a still more formidable barrier,
that they would never have extended to distant countries.
But the case is exactly the reverse. Not only
have many fresh-water species, belonging to different
classes, an enormous range, but allied species prevail
in a remarkable manner throughout the world.
When first collecting in the fresh waters of Brazil,
I well remember feeling much surprise at the similarity
of the fresh-water insects, shells, etc., and
at the dissimilarity of the surrounding terrestrial
beings, compared with those of Britain.
But the wide ranging power of fresh-water
productions can, I think, in most cases be explained
by their having become fitted, in a manner highly
useful to them, for short and frequent migrations from
pond to pond, or from stream to stream, within their
own countries; and liability to wide dispersal would
follow from this capacity as an almost necessary consequence.
We can here consider only a few cases; of these, some
of the most difficult to explain are presented by fish.
It was formerly believed that the same fresh-water
species never existed on two continents distant from
each other. But Dr. Gunther has lately shown
that the Galaxias attenuatus inhabits Tasmania,
New Zealand, the Falkland Islands and the mainland
of South America. This is a wonderful case, and
probably indicates dispersal from an Antarctic centre
during a former warm period. This case, however,
is rendered in some degree less surprising by the
species of this genus having the power of crossing
by some unknown means considerable spaces of open
ocean: thus there is one species common to New
Zealand and to the Auckland Islands, though separated
by a distance of about 230 miles. On the same
continent fresh-water fish often range widely, and
as if capriciously; for in two adjoining river systems
some of the species may be the same and some wholly
different.
It is probable that they are occasionally
transported by what may be called accidental means.
Thus fishes still alive are not very rarely dropped
at distant points by whirlwinds; and it is known that
the ova retain their vitality for a considerable time
after removal from the water. Their dispersal
may, however, be mainly attributed to changes in the
level of the land within the recent period, causing
rivers to flow into each other. Instances, also,
could be given of this having occurred during floods,
without any change of level. The wide differences
of the fish on the opposite sides of most mountain-ranges,
which are continuous and consequently must, from an
early period, have completely prevented the inosculation
of the river systems on the two sides, leads to the
same conclusion. Some fresh-water fish belong
to very ancient forms, and in such cases there will
have been ample time for great geographical changes,
and consequently time and means for much migration.
Moreover, Dr. Gunther has recently been led by several
considerations to infer that with fishes the same
forms have a long endurance. Salt-water fish
can with care be slowly accustomed to live in fresh
water; and, according to Valenciennes, there is hardly
a single group of which all the members are confined
to fresh water, so that a marine species belonging
to a fresh-water group might travel far along the shores
of the sea, and could, it is probable, become adapted
without much difficulty to the fresh waters of a distant
land.
Some species of fresh-water shells
have very wide ranges, and allied species which, on
our theory, are descended from a common parent, and
must have proceeded from a single source, prevail throughout
the world. Their distribution at first perplexed
me much, as their ova are not likely to be transported
by birds; and the ova, as well as the adults, are
immediately killed by sea-water. I could not even
understand how some naturalised species have spread
rapidly throughout the same country. But two
facts, which I have observed and many others
no doubt will be discovered throw some
light on this subject. When ducks suddenly emerge
from a pond covered with duck-weed, I have twice seen
these little plants adhering to their backs; and it
has happened to me, in removing a little duck-weed
from one aquarium to another, that I have unintentionally
stocked the one with fresh-water shells from the other.
But another agency is perhaps more effectual:
I suspended the feet of a duck in an aquarium, where
many ova of fresh-water shells were hatching; and
I found that numbers of the extremely minute and just-hatched
shells crawled on the feet, and clung to them so firmly
that when taken out of the water they could not be
jarred off, though at a somewhat more advanced age
they would voluntarily drop off. These just-hatched
molluscs, though aquatic in their nature, survived
on the duck’s feet, in damp air, from twelve
to twenty hours; and in this length of time a duck
or heron might fly at least six or seven hundred miles,
and if blown across the sea to an oceanic island,
or to any other distant point, would be sure to alight
on a pool or rivulet. Sir Charles Lyell informs
me that a Dyticus has been caught with an Ancylus (a
fresh-water shell like a limpet) firmly adhering to
it; and a water-beetle of the same family, a Colymbetes,
once flew on board the “Beagle,” when
forty-five miles distant from the nearest land:
how much farther it might have been blown by a favouring
gale no one can tell.
With respect to plants, it has long
been known what enormous ranges many fresh-water,
and even marsh-species, have, both over continents
and to the most remote oceanic islands. This
is strikingly illustrated, according to Alph. de Candolle,
in those large groups of terrestrial plants, which
have very few aquatic members; for the latter seem
immediately to acquire, as if in consequence, a wide
range. I think favourable means of dispersal
explain this fact. I have before mentioned that
earth occasionally adheres in some quantity to the
feet and beaks of birds. Wading birds, which
frequent the muddy edges of ponds, if suddenly flushed,
would be the most likely to have muddy feet. Birds
of this order wander more than those of any other;
and are occasionally found on the most remote and
barren islands of the open ocean; they would not be
likely to alight on the surface of the sea, so that
any dirt on their feet would not be washed off; and
when gaining the land, they would be sure to fly to
their natural fresh-water haunts. I do not believe
that botanists are aware how charged the mud of ponds
is with seeds: I have tried several little experiments,
but will here give only the most striking case:
I took in February three tablespoonfuls of mud from
three different points, beneath water, on the edge
of a little pond; this mud when dry weighed only 6
and 3/4 ounces; I kept it covered up in my study for
six months, pulling up and counting each plant as it
grew; the plants were of many kinds, and were altogether
537 in number; and yet the viscid mud was all contained
in a breakfast cup! Considering these facts,
I think it would be an inexplicable circumstance if
water-birds did not transport the seeds of fresh-water
plants to unstocked ponds and streams, situated at
very distant points. The same agency may have
come into play with the eggs of some of the smaller
fresh-water animals.
Other and unknown agencies probably
have also played a part. I have stated that fresh-water
fish eat some kinds of seeds, though they reject many
other kinds after having swallowed them; even small
fish swallow seeds of moderate size, as of the yellow
water-lily and Potamogeton. Herons and other
birds, century after century, have gone on daily devouring
fish; they then take flight and go to other waters,
or are blown across the sea; and we have seen that
seeds retain their power of germination, when rejected
many hours afterwards in pellets or in the excrement.
When I saw the great size of the seeds of that fine
water-lily, the Nelumbium, and remembered Alph. de
Candolle’s remarks on the distribution of this
plant, I thought that the means of its dispersal must
remain inexplicable; but Audubon states that he found
the seeds of the great southern water-lily (probably
according to Dr. Hooker, the Nelumbium luteum)
in a heron’s stomach. Now this bird must
often have flown with its stomach thus well stocked
to distant ponds, and, then getting a hearty meal
of fish, analogy makes me believe that it would have
rejected the seeds in the pellet in a fit state for
germination.
In considering these several means
of distribution, it should be remembered that when
a pond or stream is first formed, for instance on a
rising islet, it will be unoccupied; and a single seed
or egg will have a good chance of succeeding.
Although there will always be a struggle for life
between the inhabitants of the same pond, however few
in kind, yet as the number even in a well-stocked
pond is small in comparison with the number of species
inhabiting an equal area of land, the competition
between them will probably be less severe than between
terrestrial species; consequently an intruder from
the waters of a foreign country would have a better
chance of seizing on a new place, than in the case
of terrestrial colonists. We should also remember
that many fresh-water productions are low in the scale
of nature, and we have reason to believe that such
beings become modified more slowly than the high;
and this will give time for the migration of aquatic
species. We should not forget the probability
of many fresh-water forms having formerly ranged continuously
over immense areas, and then having become extinct
at intermediate points. But the wide distribution
of fresh-water plants, and of the lower animals, whether
retaining the same identical form, or in some degree
modified, apparently depends in main part on the wide
dispersal of their seeds and eggs by animals, more
especially by fresh-water birds, which have great
powers of flight, and naturally travel from one piece
of water to another.
On the inhabitants of oceanic
islands.
We now come to the last of the three
classes of facts, which I have selected as presenting
the greatest amount of difficulty with respect to
distribution, on the view that not only all the individuals
of the same species have migrated from some one area,
but that allied species, although now inhabiting the
most distant points, have proceeded from a single
area, the birthplace of their early progenitors.
I have already given my reasons for disbelieving in
continental extensions within the period of existing
species on so enormous a scale that all the many islands
of the several oceans were thus stocked with their
present terrestrial inhabitants. This view removes
many difficulties, but it does not accord with all
the facts in regard to the productions of islands.
In the following remarks I shall not confine myself
to the mere question of dispersal, but shall consider
some other cases bearing on the truth of the two theories
of independent creation and of descent with modification.
The species of all kinds which inhabit
oceanic islands are few in number compared with those
on equal continental areas: Alph. de Candolle
admits this for plants, and Wollaston for insects.
New Zealand, for instance, with its lofty mountains
and diversified stations, extending over 780 miles
of latitude, together with the outlying islands of
Auckland, Campbell and Chatham, contain altogether
only 960 kinds of flowering plants; if we compare
this moderate number with the species which swarm
over equal areas in Southwestern Australia or at the
Cape of Good Hope, we must admit that some cause,
independently of different physical conditions, has
given rise to so great a difference in number.
Even the uniform county of Cambridge has 847 plants,
and the little island of Anglesea 764, but a few ferns
and a few introduced plants are included in these
numbers, and the comparison in some other respects
is not quite fair. We have evidence that the
barren island of Ascension aboriginally possessed
less than half-a-dozen flowering plants; yet many species
have now become naturalised on it, as they have in
New Zealand and on every other oceanic island which
can be named. In St. Helena there is reason to
believe that the naturalised plants and animals have
nearly or quite exterminated many native productions.
He who admits the doctrine of the creation of each
separate species, will have to admit that a sufficient
number of the best adapted plants and animals were
not created for oceanic islands; for man has unintentionally
stocked them far more fully and perfectly than did
nature.
Although in oceanic islands the species
are few in number, the proportion of endemic kinds
(i.e. those found nowhere else in the world) is often
extremely large. If we compare, for instance,
the number of endemic land-shells in Madeira, or of
endemic birds in the Galapagos Archipelago, with the
number found on any continent, and then compare the
area of the island with that of the continent, we shall
see that this is true. This fact might have been
theoretically expected, for, as already explained,
species occasionally arriving, after long intervals
of time in the new and isolated district, and having
to compete with new associates, would be eminently
liable to modification, and would often produce groups
of modified descendants. But it by no means follows
that, because in an island nearly all the species
of one class are peculiar, those of another class,
or of another section of the same class, are peculiar;
and this difference seems to depend partly on the species
which are not modified having immigrated in a body,
so that their mutual relations have not been much
disturbed; and partly on the frequent arrival of unmodified
immigrants from the mother-country, with which the
insular forms have intercrossed. It should be
borne in mind that the offspring of such crosses would
certainly gain in vigour; so that even an occasional
cross would produce more effect than might have been
anticipated. I will give a few illustrations of
the foregoing remarks: in the Galapagos Islands
there are twenty-six land birds; of these twenty-one
(or perhaps twenty-three) are peculiar; whereas of
the eleven marine birds only two are peculiar; and
it is obvious that marine birds could arrive at these
islands much more easily and frequently than land-birds.
Bermuda, on the other hand, which lies at about the
same distance from North America as the Galapagos
Islands do from South America, and which has a very
peculiar soil, does not possess a single endemic land
bird; and we know from Mr. J.M. Jones’s
admirable account of Bermuda, that very many North
American birds occasionally or even frequently visit
this island. Almost every year, as I am informed
by Mr. E.V. Harcourt, many European and African
birds are blown to Madeira; this island is inhabited
by ninety-nine kinds, of which one alone is peculiar,
though very closely related to a European form; and
three or four other species are confined to this island
and to the Canaries. So that the islands of Bermuda
and Madeira have been stocked from the neighbouring
continents with birds, which for long ages have there
struggled together, and have become mutually co-adapted.
Hence, when settled in their new homes, each kind
will have been kept by the others to its proper place
and habits, and will consequently have been but little
liable to modification. Any tendency to modification
will also have been checked by intercrossing with
the unmodified immigrants, often arriving from the
mother-country. Madeira again is inhabited by
a wonderful number of peculiar land-shells, whereas
not one species of sea-shell is peculiar to its shores:
now, though we do not know how sea-shells are dispersed,
yet we can see that their eggs or larvae, perhaps
attached to seaweed or floating timber, or to the feet
of wading birds, might be transported across three
or four hundred miles of open sea far more easily
than land-shells. The different orders of insects
inhabiting Madeira present nearly parallel cases.
Oceanic islands are sometimes deficient
in animals of certain whole classes, and their places
are occupied by other classes; thus in the Galapagos
Islands reptiles, and in New Zealand gigantic wingless
birds, take, or recently took, the place of mammals.
Although New Zealand is here spoken of as an oceanic
island, it is in some degree doubtful whether it should
be so ranked; it is of large size, and is not separated
from Australia by a profoundly deep sea; from its geological
character and the direction of its mountain ranges,
the Rev. W.B. Clarke has lately maintained that
this island, as well as New Caledonia, should be considered
as appurtenances of Australia. Turning to plants,
Dr. Hooker has shown that in the Galapagos Islands
the proportional numbers of the different orders are
very different from what they are elsewhere.
All such differences in number, and the absence of
certain whole groups of animals and plants, are generally
accounted for by supposed differences in the physical
conditions of the islands; but this explanation is
not a little doubtful. Facility of immigration
seems to have been fully as important as the nature
of the conditions.
Many remarkable little facts could
be given with respect to the inhabitants of oceanic
islands. For instance, in certain islands not
tenanted by a single mammal, some of the endemic plants
have beautifully hooked seeds; yet few relations are
more manifest than that hooks serve for the transportal
of seeds in the wool or fur of quadrupeds. But
a hooked seed might be carried to an island by other
means; and the plant then becoming modified would
form an endemic species, still retaining its hooks,
which would form a useless appendage, like the shrivelled
wings under the soldered wing-covers of many insular
beetles. Again, islands often possess trees or
bushes belonging to orders which elsewhere include
only herbaceous species; now trees, as Alph. de Candolle
has shown, generally have, whatever the cause may be,
confined ranges. Hence trees would be little
likely to reach distant oceanic islands; and an herbaceous
plant, which had no chance of successfully competing
with the many fully developed trees growing on a continent,
might, when established on an island, gain an advantage
over other herbaceous plants by growing taller and
taller and overtopping them. In this case, natural
selection would tend to add to the stature of the
plant, to whatever order it belonged, and thus first
convert it into a bush and then into a tree.
Absence of batrachians
and terrestrial mammals on oceanic
islands.
With respect to the absence of whole
orders of animals on oceanic islands, Bory St. Vincent
long ago remarked that Batrachians (frogs, toads,
newts) are never found on any of the many islands with
which the great oceans are studded. I have taken
pains to verify this assertion, and have found it
true, with the exception of New Zealand, New Caledonia,
the Andaman Islands, and perhaps the Solomon Islands
and the Seychelles. But I have already remarked
that it is doubtful whether New Zealand and New Caledonia
ought to be classed as oceanic islands; and this is
still more doubtful with respect to the Andaman and
Solomon groups and the Seychelles. This general
absence of frogs, toads and newts on so many true
oceanic islands cannot be accounted for by their physical
conditions; indeed it seems that islands are peculiarly
fitted for these animals; for frogs have been introduced
into Madeira, the Azores, and Mauritius, and have
multiplied so as to become a nuisance. But as
these animals and their spawn are immediately killed
(with the exception, as far as known, of one Indian
species) by sea-water, there would be great difficulty
in their transportal across the sea, and therefore
we can see why they do not exist on strictly oceanic
islands. But why, on the theory of creation,
they should not have been created there, it would
be very difficult to explain.
Mammals offer another and similar
case. I have carefully searched the oldest voyages,
and have not found a single instance, free from doubt,
of a terrestrial mammal (excluding domesticated animals
kept by the natives) inhabiting an island situated
above 300 miles from a continent or great continental
island; and many islands situated at a much less distance
are equally barren. The Falkland Islands, which
are inhabited by a wolf-like fox, come nearest to
an exception; but this group cannot be considered
as oceanic, as it lies on a bank in connection with
the mainland at a distance of about 280 miles; moreover,
icebergs formerly brought boulders to its western
shores, and they may have formerly transported foxes,
as now frequently happens in the arctic regions.
Yet it cannot be said that small islands will not
support at least small mammals, for they occur in
many parts of the world on very small islands, when
lying close to a continent; and hardly an island can
be named on which our smaller quadrupeds have not
become naturalised and greatly multiplied. It
cannot be said, on the ordinary view of creation,
that there has not been time for the creation of mammals;
many volcanic islands are sufficiently ancient, as
shown by the stupendous degradation which they have
suffered, and by their tertiary strata: there
has also been time for the production of endemic species
belonging to other classes; and on continents it is
known that new species of mammals appear and disappear
at a quicker rate than other and lower animals.
Although terrestrial mammals do not occur on oceanic
islands, aerial mammals do occur on almost every island.
New Zealand possesses two bats found nowhere else
in the world: Norfolk Island, the Viti Archipelago,
the Bonin Islands, the Caroline and Marianne Archipelagoes,
and Mauritius, all possess their peculiar bats.
Why, it may be asked, has the supposed creative force
produced bats and no other mammals on remote islands?
On my view this question can easily be answered; for
no terrestrial mammal can be transported across a
wide space of sea, but bats can fly across. Bats
have been seen wandering by day far over the Atlantic
Ocean; and two North American species, either regularly
or occasionally, visit Bermuda, at the distance of
600 miles from the mainland. I hear from Mr.
Tomes, who has specially studied this family, that
many species have enormous ranges, and are found on
continents and on far distant islands. Hence,
we have only to suppose that such wandering species
have been modified in their new homes in relation to
their new position, and we can understand the presence
of endemic bats on oceanic islands, with the absence
of all other terrestrial mammals.
Another interesting relation exists,
namely, between the depth of the sea separating islands
from each other, or from the nearest continent, and
the degree of affinity of their mammalian inhabitants.
Mr. Windsor Earl has made some striking observations
on this head, since greatly extended by Mr. Wallace’s
admirable researches, in regard to the great Malay
Archipelago, which is traversed near Celebes by a space
of deep ocean, and this separates two widely distinct
mammalian faunas. On either side, the islands
stand on a moderately shallow submarine bank, and
these islands are inhabited by the same or by closely
allied quadrupeds. I have not as yet had time
to follow up this subject in all quarters of the world;
but as far as I have gone, the relation holds good.
For instance, Britain is separated by a shallow channel
from Europe, and the mammals are the same on both
sides; and so it is with all the islands near the
shores of Australia. The West Indian Islands,
on the other hand, stand on a deeply submerged bank,
nearly one thousand fathoms in depth, and here we
find American forms, but the species and even the
genera are quite distinct. As the amount of modification
which animals of all kinds undergo partly depends
on the lapse of time, and as the islands which are
separated from each other, or from the mainland, by
shallow channels, are more likely to have been continuously
united within a recent period than the islands separated
by deeper channels, we can understand how it is that
a relation exists between the depth of the sea separating
two mammalian faunas, and the degree of their
affinity, a relation which is quite inexplicable on
the theory of independent acts of creation.
The foregoing statements in regard
to the inhabitants of oceanic islands, namely, the
fewness of the species, with a large proportion consisting
of endemic forms the members of certain
groups, but not those of other groups in the same
class, having been modified the absence
of certain whole orders, as of batrachians and of terrestrial
mammals, notwithstanding the presence of aerial bats,
the singular proportions of certain orders of plants,
herbaceous forms having been developed into trees,
etc., seem to me to accord better with the belief
in the efficiency of occasional means of transport,
carried on during a long course of time, than with
the belief in the former connection of all oceanic
islands with the nearest continent; for on this latter
view it is probable that the various classes would
have immigrated more uniformly, and from the species
having entered in a body, their mutual relations would
not have been much disturbed, and consequently, they
would either have not been modified, or all the species
in a more equable manner.
I do not deny that there are many
and serious difficulties in understanding how many
of the inhabitants of the more remote islands, whether
still retaining the same specific form or subsequently
modified, have reached their present homes. But
the probability of other islands having once existed
as halting-places, of which not a wreck now remains,
must not be overlooked. I will specify one difficult
case. Almost all oceanic islands, even the most
isolated and smallest, are inhabited by land-shells,
generally by endemic species, but sometimes by species
found elsewhere striking instances of which have been
given by Dr. A.A. Gould in relation to the Pacific.
Now it is notorious that land-shells are easily killed
by sea-water; their eggs, at least such as I have
tried, sink in it and are killed. Yet there must
be some unknown, but occasionally efficient means
for their transportal. Would the just-hatched
young sometimes adhere to the feet of birds roosting
on the ground and thus get transported? It occurred
to me that land-shells, when hybernating and having
a membranous diaphragm over the mouth of the shell,
might be floated in chinks of drifted timber across
moderately wide arms of the sea. And I find that
several species in this state withstand uninjured
an immersion in sea-water during seven days. One
shell, the Helix pomatia, after having been thus treated,
and again hybernating, was put into sea-water for
twenty days and perfectly recovered. During this
length of time the shell might have been carried by
a marine country of average swiftness to a distance
of 660 geographical miles. As this Helix has
a thick calcareous operculum I removed it, and when
it had formed a new membranous one, I again immersed
it for fourteen days in sea-water, and again it recovered
and crawled away. Baron Aucapitaine has since
tried similar experiments. He placed 100 land-shells,
belonging to ten species, in a box pierced with holes,
and immersed it for a fortnight in the sea. Out
of the hundred shells twenty-seven recovered.
The presence of an operculum seems to have been of
importance, as out of twelve specimens of Cyclostoma
elegans, which is thus furnished, eleven revived.
It is remarkable, seeing how well the Helix pomatia
resisted with me the salt-water, that not one of fifty-four
specimens belonging to four other species of Helix
tried by Aucapitaine recovered. It is, however,
not at all probable that land-shells have often been
thus transported; the feet of birds offer a more probable
method.
On the relations of
the inhabitants of islands to
those of the nearest mainland.
The most striking and important fact
for us is the affinity of the species which inhabit
islands to those of the nearest mainland, without
being actually the same. Numerous instances could
be given. The Galapagos Archipelago, situated
under the equator, lies at a distance of between 500
and 600 miles from the shores of South America.
Here almost every product of the land and of the water
bears the unmistakable stamp of the American continent.
There are twenty-six land birds. Of these twenty-one,
or perhaps twenty-three, are ranked as distinct species,
and would commonly be assumed to have been here created;
yet the close affinity of most of these birds to American
species is manifest in every character in their habits,
gestures, and tones of voice. So it is with the
other animals, and with a large proportion of the plants,
as shown by Dr. Hooker in his admirable Flora of this
archipelago. The naturalist, looking at the inhabitants
of these volcanic islands in the Pacific, distant
several hundred miles from the continent, feels that
he is standing on American land. Why should this
be so? Why should the species which are supposed
to have been created in the Galapagos Archipelago,
and nowhere else, bear so plainly the stamp of affinity
to those created in America? There is nothing
in the conditions of life, in the geological nature
of the islands, in their height or climate, or in
the proportions in which the several classes are associated
together, which closely resembles the conditions of
the South American coast. In fact, there is a
considerable dissimilarity in all these respects.
On the other hand, there is a considerable degree
of resemblance in the volcanic nature of the soil,
in the climate, height, and size of the islands, between
the Galapagos and Cape Verde Archipelagos: but
what an entire and absolute difference in their inhabitants!
The inhabitants of the Cape Verde Islands are related
to those of Africa, like those of the Galapagos to
America. Facts, such as these, admit of no sort
of explanation on the ordinary view of independent
creation; whereas, on the view here maintained, it
is obvious that the Galapagos Islands would be likely
to receive colonists from America, whether by occasional
means of transport or (though I do not believe in
this doctrine) by formerly continuous land, and the
Cape Verde Islands from Africa; such colonists would
be liable to modification the principle
of inheritance still betraying their original birthplace.
Many analogous facts could be given:
indeed it is an almost universal rule that the endemic
productions of islands are related to those of the
nearest continent, or of the nearest large island.
The exceptions are few, and most of them can be explained.
Thus, although Kerguelen Land stands nearer to Africa
than to America, the plants are related, and that
very closely, as we know from Dr. Hooker’s account,
to those of America: but on the view that this
island has been mainly stocked by seeds brought with
earth and stones on icebergs, drifted by the prevailing
currents, this anomaly disappears. New Zealand
in its endemic plants is much more closely related
to Australia, the nearest mainland, than to any other
region: and this is what might have been expected;
but it is also plainly related to South America, which,
although the next nearest continent, is so enormously
remote, that the fact becomes an anomaly. But
this difficulty partially disappears on the view that
New Zealand, South America, and the other southern
lands, have been stocked in part from a nearly intermediate
though distant point, namely, from the antarctic islands,
when they were clothed with vegetation, during a warmer
tertiary period, before the commencement of the last
Glacial period. The affinity, which, though feeble,
I am assured by Dr. Hooker is real, between the flora
of the south-western corner of Australia and of the
Cape of Good Hope, is a far more remarkable case; but
this affinity is confined to the plants, and will,
no doubt, some day be explained.
The same law which has determined
the relationship between the inhabitants of islands
and the nearest mainland, is sometimes displayed on
a small scale, but in a most interesting manner, within
the limits of the same archipelago. Thus each
separate island of the Galapagos Archipelago is tenanted,
and the fact is a marvellous one, by many distinct
species; but these species are related to each other
in a very much closer manner than to the inhabitants
of the American continent, or of any other quarter
of the world. This is what might have been expected,
for islands situated so near to each other would almost
necessarily receive immigrants from the same original
source, and from each other. But how is it that
many of the immigrants have been differently modified,
though only in a small degree, in islands situated
within sight of each other, having the same geological
nature, the same height, climate, etc? This long
appeared to me a great difficulty: but it arises
in chief part from the deeply-seated error of considering
the physical conditions of a country as the most important;
whereas it cannot be disputed that the nature of the
other species with which each has to compete, is at
least as important, and generally a far more important
element of success. Now if we look to the species
which inhabit the Galapagos Archipelago, and are likewise
found in other parts of the world, we find that they
differ considerably in the several islands. This
difference might indeed have been expected if the
islands have been stocked by occasional means of transport a
seed, for instance, of one plant having been brought
to one island, and that of another plant to another
island, though all proceeding from the same general
source. Hence, when in former times an immigrant
first settled on one of the islands, or when it subsequently
spread from one to another, it would undoubtedly be
exposed to different conditions in the different islands,
for it would have to compete with a different set of
organisms; a plant, for instance, would find the ground
best-fitted for it occupied by somewhat different
species in the different islands, and would be exposed
to the attacks of somewhat different enemies.
If, then, it varied, natural selection would probably
favour different varieties in the different islands.
Some species, however, might spread and yet retain
the same character throughout the group, just as we
see some species spreading widely throughout a continent
and remaining the same.
The really surprising fact in this
case of the Galapagos Archipelago, and in a lesser
degree in some analogous cases, is that each new species
after being formed in any one island, did not spread
quickly to the other islands. But the islands,
though in sight of each other, are separated by deep
arms of the sea, in most cases wider than the British
Channel, and there is no reason to suppose that they
have at any former period been continuously united.
The currents of the sea are rapid and deep between
the islands, and gales of wind are extraordinarily
rare; so that the islands are far more effectually
separated from each other than they appear on a map.
Nevertheless, some of the species, both of those found
in other parts of the world and of those confined to
the archipelago, are common to the several islands;
and we may infer from the present manner of distribution
that they have spread from one island to the others.
But we often take, I think, an erroneous view of the
probability of closely allied species invading each
other’s territory, when put into free intercommunication.
Undoubtedly, if one species has any advantage over
another, it will in a very brief time wholly or in
part supplant it; but if both are equally well fitted
for their own places, both will probably hold their
separate places for almost any length of time.
Being familiar with the fact that many species, naturalised
through man’s agency, have spread with astonishing
rapidity over wide areas, we are apt to infer that
most species would thus spread; but we should remember
that the species which become naturalised in new countries
are not generally closely allied to the aboriginal
inhabitants, but are very distinct forms, belonging
in a large proportion of cases, as shown by Alph.
de Candolle, to distinct genera. In the Galapagos
Archipelago, many even of the birds, though so well
adapted for flying from island to island, differ on
the different islands; thus there are three closely
allied species of mocking-thrush, each confined to
its own island. Now let us suppose the mocking-thrush
of Chatham Island to be blown to Charles Island, which
has its own mocking-thrush; why should it succeed
in establishing itself there? We may safely infer
that Charles Island is well stocked with its own species,
for annually more eggs are laid and young birds hatched
than can possibly be reared; and we may infer that
the mocking-thrush peculiar to Charles Island is at
least as well fitted for its home as is the species
peculiar to Chatham Island. Sir C. Lyell and Mr.
Wollaston have communicated to me a remarkable fact
bearing on this subject; namely, that Madeira and
the adjoining islet of Porto Santo possess many distinct
but representative species of land-shells, some of
which live in crevices of stone; and although large
quantities of stone are annually transported from
Porto Santo to Madeira, yet this latter island has
not become colonised by the Porto Santo species:
nevertheless, both islands have been colonised by
some European land-shells, which no doubt had some
advantage over the indigenous species. From these
considerations I think we need not greatly marvel at
the endemic species which inhabit the several islands
of the Galapagos Archipelago not having all spread
from island to island. On the same continent,
also, pre-occupation has probably played an important
part in checking the commingling of the species which
inhabit different districts with nearly the same physical
conditions. Thus, the south-east and south-west
corners of Australia have nearly the same physical
conditions, and are united by continuous land, yet
they are inhabited by a vast number of distinct mammals,
birds, and plants; so it is, according to Mr. Bates,
with the butterflies and other animals inhabiting the
great, open, and continuous valley of the Amazons.
The same principle which governs the
general character of the inhabitants of oceanic islands,
namely, the relation to the source whence colonists
could have been most easily derived, together with
their subsequent modification, is of the widest application
throughout nature. We see this on every mountain-summit,
in every lake and marsh. For Alpine species,
excepting in as far as the same species have become
widely spread during the Glacial epoch, are related
to those of the surrounding lowlands; thus we have
in South America, Alpine humming-birds, Alpine rodents,
Alpine plants, etc., all strictly belonging to
American forms; and it is obvious that a mountain,
as it became slowly upheaved, would be colonised from
the surrounding lowlands. So it is with the inhabitants
of lakes and marshes, excepting in so far as great
facility of transport has allowed the same forms to
prevail throughout large portions of the world.
We see the same principle in the character of most
of the blind animals inhabiting the caves of America
and of Europe. Other analogous facts could be
given. It will, I believe, be found universally
true, that wherever in two regions, let them be ever
so distant, many closely allied or representative
species occur, there will likewise be found some identical
species; and wherever many closely-allied species occur,
there will be found many forms which some naturalists
rank as distinct species, and others as mere varieties;
these doubtful forms showing us the steps in the process
of modification.
The relation between the power and
extent of migration in certain species, either at
the present or at some former period, and the existence
at remote points of the world of closely allied species,
is shown in another and more general way. Mr.
Gould remarked to me long ago, that in those genera
of birds which range over the world, many of the species
have very wide ranges. I can hardly doubt that
this rule is generally true, though difficult of proof.
Among mammals, we see it strikingly displayed in Bats,
and in a lesser degree in the Felidae and Canidae.
We see the same rule in the distribution of butterflies
and beetles. So it is with most of the inhabitants
of fresh water, for many of the genera in the most
distinct classes range over the world, and many of
the species have enormous ranges. It is not meant
that all, but that some of the species have very wide
ranges in the genera which range very widely.
Nor is it meant that the species in such genera have,
on an average, a very wide range; for this will largely
depend on how far the process of modification has
gone; for instance, two varieties of the same species
inhabit America and Europe, and thus the species has
an immense range; but, if variation were to be carried
a little further, the two varieties would be ranked
as distinct species, and their range would be greatly
reduced. Still less is it meant, that species
which have the capacity of crossing barriers and ranging
widely, as in the case of certain powerfully-winged
birds, will necessarily range widely; for we should
never forget that to range widely implies not only
the power of crossing barriers, but the more important
power of being victorious in distant lands in the
struggle for life with foreign associates. But
according to the view that all the species of a genus,
though distributed to the most remote points of the
world, are descended from a single progenitor, we
ought to find, and I believe as a general rule we
do find, that some at least of the species range very
widely.
We should bear in mind that many genera
in all classes are of ancient origin, and the species
in this case will have had ample time for dispersal
and subsequent modification. There is also reason
to believe, from geological evidence, that within
each great class the lower organisms change at a slower
rate than the higher; consequently they will have
had a better chance of ranging widely and of still
retaining the same specific character. This fact,
together with that of the seeds and eggs of most lowly
organised forms being very minute and better fitted
for distant transportal, probably accounts for a law
which has long been observed, and which has lately
been discussed by Alph. de Candolle in regard to plants,
namely, that the lower any group of organisms stands
the more widely it ranges.
The relations just discussed namely,
lower organisms ranging more widely than the higher some
of the species of widely-ranging genera themselves
ranging widely such facts, as alpine, lacustrine,
and marsh productions being generally related to those
which live on the surrounding low lands and dry lands the
striking relationship between the inhabitants of islands
and those of the nearest mainland the still
closer relationship of the distinct inhabitants of
the islands of the same archipelago are
inexplicable on the ordinary view of the independent
creation of each species, but are explicable if we
admit colonisation from the nearest or readiest source,
together with the subsequent adaptation of the colonists
to their new homes.