IN THE CURRENT OF THE REVOLUTION-THE
SOUTHERN BACKWOODSMEN OVERWHELM THE CHEROKEES‚ 1776.
The great western drift of our people
began almost at the moment when they became Americans,
and ceased to be merely British colonists. They
crossed the great divide which sundered the springs
of the seaboard rivers from the sources of the western
waters about the time that American citizens first
publicly acted as American freemen, knit together
by common ties, and with interests no longer akin to
those of the mother country. The movement which
was to make the future nation a continental power
was begun immediately after the hitherto separate
colonies had taken the first step towards solidification.
While the communities of the sea-coast were yet in
a fever heat from the uprising against the stamp tax,
the first explorers were toiling painfully to Kentucky,
and the first settlers were building their palisaded
hamlets on the banks of the Watauga. The year
that saw the first Continental Congress saw also the
short, grim tragedy of Lord Dunmore’s war.
The early battles of the Revolution were fought while
Boon’s comrades were laying the foundations
of their commonwealth.
Hitherto the two chains of events
had been only remotely connected; but in 1776, the
year of the Declaration of Independence, the struggle
between the king and his rebellious subjects shook
the whole land, and the men of the western border
were drawn headlong into the full current of revolutionary
warfare. From that moment our politics became
national, and the fate of each portion of our country
was thenceforth in some sort dependent upon the welfare
of every other. Each section had its own work
to do; the east won independence while the west began
to conquer the continent. Yet the deeds of each
were of vital consequence to the other. Washington’s
Continentals gave the west its freedom; and took
in return for themselves and their children a share
of the land that had been conquered and held by the
scanty bands of tall backwoodsmen.
The backwoodsmen, the men of the up-country,
were, as a whole, ardent adherents of the patriot
or American side. Yet there were among them many
loyalists or tories; and these tories included in their
ranks much the greatest portion of the vicious and
the disorderly elements. This was the direct
reverse of what obtained along portions of the seaboard,
where large numbers of the peaceable, well-to-do people
stood loyally by the king. In the up-country,
however, the Presbyterian Irish, with their fellows
of Calvinistic stock and faith, formed the back-bone
of the moral and order-loving element; and the Presbyterian
Irish were almost to a man staunch and furious
upholders of the Continental Congress. Naturally,
the large bands of murderers, horse-thieves, and other
wild outlaws, whom these grim friends of order hunted
down with merciless severity, were glad to throw in
their lot with any party that promised revenge upon
their foes. But of course there were lawless
characters on both sides; in certain localities where
the crop of jealousies, always a rank backwoods growth,
had been unusually large, and had therefore produced
long-standing and bitter feuds, the rival families
espoused opposite sides from sheer vindictive hatred
of one another. As a result, the struggle in
the backwoods between tories and whigs, king’s-men
and congress-men, did not merely turn upon the
questions everywhere at stake between the American
and British parties. It was also in part a fight
between the law-abiding and the lawless, and in part
a slaking of savage personal animosities, wherein the
borderers glutted their vengeance on one another.
They exercised without restraint the right of private
warfare, long abandoned in more civilized regions.
It was natural that such a contest should be waged
with appalling ferocity.
Nevertheless this very ferocity was
not only inevitable, but it was in a certain sense
proper; or, at least, even if many of its manifestations
were blamable, the spirit that lay behind them was
right. The backwoodsmen were no sentimentalists;
they were grim, hard, matter-of-fact men, engaged
all their lives long in an unending struggle with
hostile forces, both human and natural; men who in
this struggle had acquired many unamiable qualities,
but who had learned likewise to appreciate at their
full value the inestimable virtues of courage and
common-sense. The crisis demanded that they should
be both strong and good; but, above all things, it
demanded that they should be strong. Weakness
would have ruined them. It was needful that justice
should stand before mercy; and they could no longer
have held their homes, had they not put down their
foes, of every kind, with an iron hand. They did
not have many theories; but they were too genuinely
liberty-loving not to keenly feel that their freedom
was jeopardized as much by domestic disorder as by
foreign aggression.
The tories were obnoxious under two
heads: they were the allies of a tyrant who lived
beyond the sea, and they were the friends of anarchy
at home. They were felt by the frontiersmen to
be criminals rather than ordinary foes. They
included in their ranks the mass of men who had been
guilty of the two worst frontier crimes horse-stealing
and murder; and their own feats were in the eyes of
their neighbors in no way distinguishable from those
of other horse-thieves and murderers. Accordingly
the backwoodsmen soon grew to regard toryism as merely
another crime; and the courts sometimes executed equally
summary justice on tory, desperado, and stock-thief,
holding each as having forfeited his life.
The backwoodsmen were engaged in a
threefold contest. In the first place, they were
occasionally, but not often, opposed to the hired
British and German soldiers of a foreign king.
Next, they were engaged in a fierce civil war with
the tories of their own number. Finally, they
were pitted against the Indians, in the ceaseless border
struggle of a rude, vigorous civilization to overcome
an inevitably hostile savagery. The regular British
armies, marching to and fro in the course of their
long campaigns on the seaboard, rarely went far enough
back to threaten the frontiersmen; the latter had
to do chiefly with tories led by British chiefs, and
with Indians instigated by British agents.
Soon after the conflict with the revolted
colonists became one of arms as well as one of opinions
the British began to rouse the Indian tribes to take
their part. In the northwest they were at first
unsuccessful; the memory of Lord Dunmore’s war
was still fresh in the minds of the tribes beyond
the Ohio, and they remained for the most part neutral.
The Shawnees continued even in 1776 to send in to
the Americans white prisoners collected from among
their outlying bands, in accordance with the terms
of the treaty entered into on the Pickaway plains.
But the southwestern Indians were
not held in check by memories of recent defeat, and
they were alarmed by the encroachments of the whites.
Although the Cherokees had regularly ceded to the Watauga
settlers their land, they still continued jealous
of them; and both Creeks and Cherokees were much irritated
at the conduct of some of the lawless Georgian frontiersmen.
The colonial authorities tried to put a stop to this
lawlessness, and one of the chief offenders was actually
seized and hung in the presence of two Indians.
This had a momentary effect on the Creeks, and induced
them for the time being to observe a kind of nominal
neutrality, though they still furnished bodies of warriors
to help the British and Cherokees.
The latter, however, who were the
nearest neighbors of the Americans, promptly took
up the tomahawk at the bidding of the British.
The royal agents among these southern Indians had
so far successfully followed the perfectly cold-blooded
though perhaps necessary policy of exciting the tribes
to war with one another, in order that they might leave
the whites at peace; but now, as they officially reported
to the British commander, General Gage, they deemed
this course no longer wise, and, instead of fomenting,
they endeavored to allay, the strife between the Chickasaws
and Creeks, so as to allow the latter to turn their
full strength against the Georgians. At the same
time every effort was made to induce the Cherokees
to rise, and they were promised gunpowder, blankets,
and the like although some of the promised stores
were seized by the Americans while being forwarded
to the Indians.
In short, the British were active
and successful in rousing the war spirit among Creeks,
Cherokees, Chocktaws, and Chickasaws, having numerous
agents in all these tribes. Their success, and
the consequent ravages of the Indians, maddened the
American frontiersmen upon whom the blow fell, and
changed their resentment against the British king
into a deadly and lasting hatred, which their sons
and grandsons inherited. Indian warfare was of
such peculiar atrocity that the employment of Indians
as allies forbade any further hope of reconciliation.
It is not necessary to accept the American estimate
of the motives inspiring the act in order to sympathize
fully with the horror and anger that it aroused among
the frontiersmen. They saw their homes destroyed,
their wives outraged, their children captured, their
friends butchered and tortured wholesale by Indians
armed with British weapons, bribed by British gold,
and obeying the orders of British agents and commanders.
Their stormy anger was not likely to be allayed by
the consideration that Congress also had at first made
some effort to enlist Indians in the patriot forces,
nor were they apt to bear in mind the fact that the
British, instead of being abnormally cruel, were in
reality less so than our former French and Spanish
opponents.
Looking back it is easy to see that
the Indians were the natural foes of the American
people, and therefore the natural allies of the British
Government. They had constantly to fear the advance
of the Americans, while from the fur traders, Indian
agents, and army officers who alone represented Britain,
they had nothing but coveted treasures of every kind
to expect. They seemed tools forged for the hands
of the royal commanders, whose own people lay far
beyond the reach of reprisals in kind; and it was
perhaps too much to expect that in that age such tools
should not be used. We had less temptation to employ
them, less means wherewith to pay them, and more cause
to be hostile to and dread them; and moreover our
skirts are not quite clear in the matter, after all,
for we more than once showed a tendency to bid for
their support.
But, after all is said, the fact remains
that we have to deal, not with what, under other circumstances,
the Americans might have done, but with what
the British actually did; and for this there
can be many apologies, but no sufficient excuse.
When the commissioners to the southern Indians wrote
to Lord George Germain, “we have been indefatigable
in our endeavors to keep up a constant succession of
parties of Indians to annoy the rebels,” the
writers must have well known, what the king’s
ministers should also have made it their business
to know, that the war-parties whom they thus boasted
of continually sending against the settlements directed
their efforts mainly, indeed almost exclusively, not
against bodies of armed men, but against the husbandmen
as they unsuspectingly tilled the fields, and against
the women and children who cowered helplessly in the
log-cabins. All men knew that the prisoners who
fell into Indian hands, of whatever age or sex, often
suffered a fate hideous and revolting beyond belief
and beyond description. Such a letter as that
quoted above makes the advisers of King George the
Third directly responsible for the manifold and frightful
crimes of their red allies.
It is small wonder that such a contest
should have roused in the breasts of the frontiersmen
not only ruthless and undying abhorrence of the Indians,
but also a bitterly vindictive feeling of hostility
towards Great Britain; a feeling that was all-powerful
for a generation afterwards, and traces of which linger
even to the present day. Moreover, the Indian
forays, in some ways, damaged the loyalist cause.
The savages had received strict instructions not to
molest any of the king’s friends; but they
were far too intent on plunder and rapine to discriminate
between whig and tory. Accordingly their ravages
drove the best tories, who had at first hailed the
Indian advance with joy, into the patriot ranks, making
the frontier almost solidly whig; save for the refugees,
who were willing to cast in their lot with the savages.
While the Creeks were halting and
considering, and while the Choctaws and Chickasaws
were being visited by British emissaries, the Cherokees
flung themselves on the frontier folk. They had
been short of ammunition; but when the British agents
sent them fifty horse-loads by a pack-train that was
driven through the Creek towns, they no longer hesitated.
The agents showed very poor generalship in making them
rise so early, when there were no British troops in
the southern States, and when the Americans were consequently
unhampered and free to deal with the Indians.
Had the rising been put off until a British army was
in Georgia, it might well have proved successful.
The Cherokee villages stood in that
cluster of high mountain chains which mark the ending
of the present boundaries of Georgia and both Carolinas.
These provinces lay east and southeast of them.
Directly north were the forted villages of the Watauga
pioneers, in the valley of the upper Tennessee, and
beyond these again, in the same valley, the Virginian
outpost settlements. Virginia, North and South
Carolina, and Georgia were alike threatened by the
outbreak, while the Watauga people were certain to
be the chief sufferers. The Cherokees were so
near the settlements that their incursions were doubly
dangerous. On the other hand, there was not nearly
as much difficulty in dealing them a counter-blow
as in the case of the northern Indians, for their towns
lay thickly together and were comparatively easy of
access. Moreover, they were not rated such formidable
fighters. By comparing Lord Dunmore’s war
in 1774 with this struggle against the Cherokees in
1776, it is easy to see the difference between a contest
against the northern and one against the southern
tribes. In 1776 our Indian foes were more numerous
than in 1774, for there were over two thousand Cherokee
warriors perhaps two thousand five hundred, assisted
by a few Creeks and tories; they were closer to the
frontier, and so their ravages were more serious;
but they did not prove such redoubtable foes as Cornstalk’s
warriors, their villages were easier reached, and a
more telling punishment was inflicted.
The Cherokees had been showing signs
of hostility for some time. They had murdered
two Virginians the previous year; and word was
brought to the settlements, early in the summer of
’76, that they were undoubtedly preparing for
war, as they were mending guns, making moccasins and
beating flour for the march. In June their ravages
began. The Otari, or Overhill Cherokees, had sent
runners to the valley towns, asking their people to
wait until all were ready before marching, that the
settlements might be struck simultaneously; but some
of the young braves among the lower towns could not
be restrained, and in consequence the outlying settlers
of Georgia and the Carolinas were the first to be
assailed.
The main attack was made early in
July, the warriors rushing down from their upland
fastnesses in fierce and headlong haste, the different
bands marching north, east, and southeast at the same
moment. From the Holston to the Tugelou, from
southwestern Virginia to northwestern Georgia, the
back-county settlements were instantly wrapped in the
sudden horror of savage warfare.
The Watauga people, the most exposed
of all, received timely warning from a friendly squaw,
to whom the whites ever after showed respect and gratitude.
They at once began to prepare for the stroke; and in
all the western world of woodsmen there were no men
better fitted for such a death grapple. They
still formed a typical pioneer community; and their
number had been swelled from time to time by the arrival
of other bold and restless spirits. Their westernmost
settlement this year was in Carter’s valley;
where four men had cleared a few acres of corn-land,
and had hunted buffalo for their winter’s meat.
As soon as they learned definitely
that the Otari warriors, some seven hundred in number,
were marching against them, they took refuge in their
wooden forts or stations. Among the most important
of these were the one at Watauga, in which Sevier
and Robertson held command, and another known as Baton’s
Station, placed just above the forks of the Holston.
Some six miles from the latter, near the Long Island
or Big Island of the Holston, lay quite a large tract
of level land, covered with an open growth of saplings,
and known as the Island flats.
The Indians were divided into several
bands; some of their number crossed over into Carter’s
valley, and after ravaging it, passed on up the Clinch.
The settlers at once gathered in the little stockades;
those who delayed were surprised by the savages, and
were slain as they fled, or else were captured, perhaps
to die by torture, men, women, and children
alike. The cabins were burnt, the grain destroyed,
the cattle and horses driven off, and the sheep and
hogs shot down with arrows; the Indians carried bows
and arrows for this express purpose, so as to avoid
wasting powder and lead. The bolder war-parties,
in their search for scalps and plunder, penetrated
into Virginia a hundred miles beyond the frontier,
wasting the country with tomahawk and brand up to the
Seven-Mile Ford. The roads leading to the wooden
forts were crowded with settlers, who, in their mortal
need of hurry, had barely time to snatch up a few
of the household goods, and, if especially lucky, to
mount the women and children on horses; as usual in
such a flight, there occurred many deeds of cowardly
selfishness, offset by many feats of courage and self-sacrifice.
Once in the fort, the backwoodsmen often banded into
parties, and sallied out to fall on the Indians.
Sometimes these parties were worsted; at other times
they overcame their foes either by ambush or in fair
fight. One such party from the Wolf Hills fort
killed eleven Indian warriors; and on their return
they hung the scalps of their slain foes, as trophies
of triumph, from a pole over the fort gate. They
were Bible-readers in this fort, and they had their
Presbyterian minister with them, having organized a
special party to bring in the books he had left in
his cabin; they joined in prayer and thanksgiving
for their successes; but this did not hinder them from
scalping the men they killed. They were too well-read
in the merciless wars of the Chosen People to feel
the need of sparing the fallen; indeed they would
have been most foolish had they done so; for they were
battling with a heathen enemy more ruthless and terrible
than ever was Canaanite or Philistine. The two
largest of the invading Indian bands moved, one
by way of the mountains, to fall on the Watauga fort
and its neighbors, and the other, led by the great
war chief, Dragging Canoe, to lay waste the country
guarded by Eaton’s Station.
The white scouts trained
woodsmen, whose lives had been spent in the chase
and in forest warfare kept the commanders
or headmen of the forts well informed of the Indian
advance. As soon as it was known what part was
really threatened, runners were sent to the settlements
near by, calling on the riflemen to gather at Eaton’s
Station; whither they accordingly came in small bodies,
under their respective militia captains.
No man was really in command; the
senior captain exercised a vague kind of right of
advice over the others, and the latter in turn got
from their men such obedience as their own personal
influence was able to procure. But the levy,
if disorderly, was composed of excellent marksmen
and woodsmen, sinewy, hardy, full of fight, and accustomed
to act together. A council was held, and it was
decided not to stay cooped up in the fort, like turkeys
in a pen, while the Indians ravaged the fields and
burnt the homesteads, but to march out at once and
break the shock by a counter-stroke.
Accordingly, on the morning of the
twentieth of July, they filed out of the fort, one
hundred and seventy strong, and bent their steps towards
the Island Flats. Well versed in woodland warfare,
the frontier riflemen marched as well as fought on
a system of their own, much more effective for this
purpose than the discipline of European regulars.
The men of this little levy walked strung out in Indian
file, in two parallel lines, with scouts in front,
and flankers on each side. Marching thus they
could not be surprised, and were ready at any moment
to do battle with the Indians, in open order and taking
shelter behind the trees; while regulars, crowded
together, were helpless before the savages whom the
forest screened from view, and who esteemed it an easy
task to overcome any number of foes if gathered in
a huddle.
When near the Flats the whites, walking
silently with moccasined feet, came suddenly on a
party of twenty Indians, who, on being attacked, fled
in the utmost haste, leaving behind ten of their bundles for
the southern warriors carried with them, when on the
war-path, small bundles containing their few necessaries.
After this trifling success a council
was held, and, as the day was drawing to a close,
it was decided to return to the fort. Some of
the men were dissatisfied with the decision, and there
followed an incident as characteristic in its way
as was the bravery with which the battle was subsequently
fought. The discontented soldiers expressed their
feelings freely, commenting especially upon the supposed
lack of courage on the part of one of the captains.
The latter, after brooding over the matter until the
men had begun to march off the ground towards home,
suddenly halted the line in which he was walking, and
proceeded to harangue the troops in defence of his
own reputation. Apparently no one interfered
to prevent this remarkable piece of military self-justification;
the soldiers were evidently accustomed openly to criticise
the conduct of their commanders, while the latter responded
in any manner they saw fit. As soon as the address
was over, and the lines once more straightened out,
the march was renewed in the original order; and immediately
afterwards the scouts brought news that a considerable
body of Indians, misled by their retreat, was running
rapidly up to assail their rear.
The right file was promptly wheeled
to the right and the left to the left, forming a line
of battle a quarter of a mile long, the men taking
advantage of the cover when possible. There was
at first some confusion and a momentary panic, which
was instantly quelled, the officers and many of the
men joining to encourage and rally the few whom the
suddenness of the attack rendered faint-hearted.
The Otari warriors, instead of showing the usual Indian
caution, came running on at headlong speed, believing
that the whites were fleeing in terror; while still
some three hundred yards off they raised the war-whoop
and charged without halting, the foremost chiefs hallooing
out that the white men were running, and to come on
and scalp them. They were led by Dragging Canoe
himself, and were formed very curiously, their centre
being cone-shaped, while their wings were curved outward;
apparently they believed the white line to be wavering
and hoped to break through its middle at the same
time that they outflanked it, trusting to a single
furious onset instead of to their usual tactics.
The result showed their folly. The frontiersmen
on the right and left scattered out still farther,
so that their line could not be outflanked; and waiting
coolly till the Otari were close up, the whites fired
into them. The long rifles cracked like four-horse
whips; they were held in skilful hands, many of the
assailants fell, and the rush was checked at once.
A short fight at close quarters ensued here and there
along the line, Dragging Canoe was struck down and
severely wounded, and then the Indians fled in the
utmost confusion, every man for himself. Yet they
carried off their wounded and perhaps some of their
dead. The whites took thirteen scalps, and of
their own number but four were seriously hurt; they
also took many guns and much plunder.
In this battle of the Island Flats
the whites were slightly superior in number to
their foes; and they won without difficulty, inflicting
a far heavier loss than they received. In this
respect it differs markedly from most other Indian
fights of the same time; and many of its particulars
render it noteworthy. Moreover, it had a very
good effect, cheering the frontiersmen greatly, and
enabling them to make head against the discouraged
Indians.
On the same day the Watauga fort
was attacked by a large force at sunrise. It
was crowded with women and children, but contained
only forty or fifty men. The latter, however,
were not only resolute and well-armed, but were also
on the alert to guard against surprise; the Indians
were discovered as they advanced in the gray light,
and were at once beaten back with loss from the loopholed
stockade. Robertson commanded in the fort, Sevier
acting as his lieutenant. Of course, the only
hope of assistance was from Virginia, North Carolina
being separated from the Watauga people by great mountain
chains; and Sevier had already notified the officers
of Fincastle that the Indians were advancing.
His letter was of laconic brevity, and contained no
demand for help; it was merely a warning that the
Indians were undoubtedly about to start, and that
“they intended to drive the country up to New
River before they returned” so that
it behooved the Fincastle men to look to their own
hearthsides. Sevier was a very fearless, self-reliant
man, and doubtless felt confident that the settlers
themselves could beat back their assailants.
His forecast proved correct; for the Indians, after
maintaining an irregular siege of the fort for some
three weeks, retired, almost at the moment that parties
of frontiersmen came to the rescue from some of the
neighboring forts.
While the foe was still lurking about
the fort the people within were forced to subsist
solely on parched corn; and from time to time some
of them became so irritated by the irksome monotony
of their confinement, that they ventured out heedless
of the danger. Three or four of them were killed
by the Indians, and one boy was carried off to one
of their towns, where he was burnt at the stake; while
a woman who was also captured at this time was only
saved from a like fate by the exertions of the same
Cherokee squaw already mentioned as warning the settlers.
Tradition relates that Sevier, now a young widower,
fell in love with the woman he soon afterwards married
during the siege. Her name was Kate Sherrill.
She was a tall girl, brown-haired, comely, lithe and
supple “as a hickory sapling.” One
day while without the fort she was almost surprised
by some Indians. Running like a deer, she reached
the stockade, sprang up so as to catch the top with
her hands, and drawing herself over, was caught in
Sevier’s arms on the other side; through a loop-hole
he had already shot the headmost of her pursuers.
Soon after the baffled Otari retreated
from Robertson’s fort the other war parties
likewise left the settlements. The Watauga men
together with the immediately adjoining Virginian
frontiersmen had beaten back their foes unaided, save
for some powder and lead they had received from the
older settlements; and moreover had inflicted more
loss than they suffered. They had made an exceedingly
vigorous and successful fight.
The outlying settlements scattered
along the western border of the Carolinas and Georgia
had been attacked somewhat earlier; the Cherokees
from the lower towns, accompanied by some Creeks and
Tories, beginning their ravages in the last days of
June. A small party of Georgians had, just previously,
made a sudden march into the Cherokee country.
They were trying to capture the British agent Cameron,
who, being married to an Indian wife, dwelt in her
town, and owned many negroes, horses, and cattle.
The Cherokees, who had agreed not to interfere, broke
faith and surprised the party, killing some and capturing
others who were tortured to death.
The frontiers were soon in a state
of wild panic; for the Cherokee inroad was marked
by the usual features. Cattle were driven off,
houses burned, plantations laid waste, while the women
and children were massacred indiscriminately with
the men. The people fled from their homes and
crowded into the stockade forts; they were greatly
hampered by the scarcity of guns and ammunition, as
much had been given to the troops called down to the
coast by the war with Britain. All the southern
colonies were maddened by the outbreak; and prepared
for immediate revenge, knowing that if they were quick
they would have time to give the Cherokees a good
drubbing before the British could interfere. The
plan was that they should act together, the Virginians
invading the Overhill country at the same time that
the forces from North and South Carolina and Georgia
destroyed the valley and lower towns. Thus the
Cherokees would be crushed with little danger.
It proved impossible, however, to get the attacks made
quite simultaneously.
The back districts of North Carolina
suffered heavily at the outset; however, the inhabitants
showed that they were able to take care of themselves.
The Cherokees came down the Catawba murdering many
people; but most of the whites took refuge in the
little forts, where they easily withstood the Indian
assaults. General Griffith Rutherford raised
a frontier levy and soon relieved the besieged stations.
He sent word to the provincial authorities that if
they could only get powder and lead the men of the
Salisbury district were alone quite capable of beating
off the Indians, but that if it was intended to invade
the Cherokee country he must also have help from the
Hillsborough men. He was promised assistance,
and was told to prepare a force to act on the offensive
with the Virginians and South Carolinians.
Before he could get ready the first
counter-blow had been struck by Georgia and South
Carolina. Georgia was the weakest of all the colonies,
and the part it played in this war was but trifling.
She was threatened by British cruisers along the coast,
and by the Tories of Florida; and there was constant
danger of an uprising of the black slaves, who outnumbered
the whites. The vast herds of cattle and great
rice plantations of the south offered a tempting bait
to every foe. Tories were numerous in the population,
while there were incessant bickerings with the Creeks,
frequently resulting in small local wars, brought on
as often by the faithlessness and brutality of the
white borderers as by the treachery and cruelty of
the red. Indeed the Indians were only kept quiet
by presents, it being an unhappy feature of the frontier
troubles that while lawless whites could not be prevented
from encroaching on the Indian lands, the Indians,
in turn could only be kept at peace with the law-abiding
by being bribed.
Only a small number of warriors invaded
Georgia. Nevertheless they greatly harassed the
settlers, capturing several families and fighting
two or three skirmishes with varying results. By
the middle of July Col. Samuel Jack took
the field with a force of two hundred rangers, all
young men, the old and infirm being left to guard the
forts. The Indians fled as soon as he had embodied
his troops, and towards the end of the month he marched
against one or two of their small lower towns, which
he burned, destroying the grain and driving off the
cattle. No resistance was offered, and he did
not lose a man.
The heaviest blow fell on South Carolina,
where the Cherokees were led by Cameron himself, accompanied
by most of his tories. Some of his warriors came
from the lower towns that lay along the Tugelou and
Keowee, but most were from the middle towns, in the
neighborhood of the Tellico, and from the valley towns
that lay well to the westward of these, among the
mountains, along the branches of the Hiawassee and
Chattahoochee rivers. Falling furiously on the
scattered settlers, they killed them or drove them
into the wooden forts, ravaging, burning, and murdering
as elsewhere, and sparing neither age nor sex.
Col. Andrew Williamson was in command of the
western districts, and he at once began to gather
together a force, taking his station at Picken’s
Fort, with forty men, on July 3d. It was with
the utmost difficulty that he could get troops, guns,
or ammunition; but his strenuous and unceasing efforts
were successful, and his force increased day by day.
It is worth noting that these lowland troops were
for the most part armed with smoothbores, unlike the
rifle-bearing mountaineers. As soon as he could
muster a couple of hundred men he left the fort
and advanced towards the Indians, making continual
halts, so as to allow the numerous volunteers
that were flocking to his standard to reach him.
At the same time the Americans were much encouraged
by the repulse of an assault made just before daylight
on one of the forts. The attacking party was some
two hundred strong, half of them being white men, naked
and painted like the Indians; but after dark, on the
evening before the attack, a band of one hundred and
fifty American militia, on their way to join Williamson,
entered the fort. The assault was made before
dawn; it was promptly repulsed, and at daybreak the
enemy fled, having suffered some loss; thirteen of
the tories were captured, but the more nimble Indians
escaped.
By the end of July, Williamson had
gathered over eleven hundred militia (including
two small rifle companies), and advanced against the
Indian towns, sending his spies and scouts before him.
On the last day of the month he made a rapid night
march, with three hundred and fifty horsemen, to surprise
Cameron, who lay with a party of tories and Indians,
encamped at Oconoree Creek, beyond the Cherokee town
of Eseneka, which commanded the ford of the river
Keowee. The cabins and fenced gardens of the
town lay on both sides of the river. Williamson
had been told by his prisoners that the hither bank
was deserted, and advanced heedlessly, without scouts
or flankers. In consequence he fell into an ambush,
for when he reached the first houses, hidden Indians
suddenly fired on him from front and flank. Many
horses, including that of the commander, were shot
down, and the startled troops began a disorderly retreat,
firing at random. Col. Hammond rallied about
twenty of the coolest, and ordering them to reserve
their fire, he charged the fence from behind which
the heaviest hostile fire came. When up to it,
they shot into the dark figures crouching behind it,
and jumping over charged home. The Indians immediately
fled, leaving one dead and three wounded in the hands
of the whites. The action was over; but the by-no-means-reassured
victors had lost five men mortally and thirteen severely
wounded, and were still rather nervous. At daybreak
Williamson destroyed the houses near by, and started
to cross the ford. But his men, in true militia
style, had become sulky and mutinous, and refused
to cross, until Col. Hammond swore he would go
alone, and plunged into the river, followed by three
volunteers, whereupon the whole army crowded after.
The révulsions in their feelings was instantaneous;
once across they seemed to have left all fear as well
as all prudence behind. On the hither side there
had been no getting them to advance; on the farther
there was no keeping them together, and they scattered
everywhere. Luckily the Indians were too few to
retaliate; and besides the Cherokees were not good
marksmen, using so little powder in their guns that
they made very ineffective weapons. After all
the houses had been burned, and some six thousand
bushels of corn, besides peas and beans, destroyed,
Williamson returned to his camp. Next day he renewed
his advance, and sent out detachments against all the
other lower towns, utterly destroying every one by
the middle of August, although not without one or
two smart skirmishes. His troops were very much
elated, and only the lack of provisions prevented his
marching against the middle towns. As it was,
he retired to refit, leaving a garrison of six hundred
men at Eseneka, which he christened Fort Rutledge.
This ended the first stage of the retaliatory campaign,
undertaken by the whites in revenge for the outbreak.
The South Carolinians, assisted slightly by a small
independent command of Georgians, who acted separately,
had destroyed the lower Cherokee towns, at the same
time that the Watauga people repulsed the attack of
the Overhill warriors.
The second and most important movement
was to be made by South Carolina, North Carolina,
and Virginia jointly, each sending a column of two
thousand men, the two former against the middle
and valley, the latter against the Overhill towns.
If the columns acted together the Cherokees would
be overwhelmed by a force three times the number of
all their warriors. The plan succeeded well,
although the Virginia division was delayed so that
its action, though no less effective, was much later
than that of the others, and though the latter likewise
failed to act in perfect unison.
Rutherford and his North Carolinians
were the first to take the field. He had an army
of two thousand gunmen, besides pack-horsemen and
men to tend the drove of bullocks, together with a
few Catawba Indians, a total of twenty-four
hundred. On September 1st he left the head of
the Catawba, and the route he followed was long
known by the name of Rutherford’s trace.
There was not a tent in his army, and but very few
blankets; the pack-horses earned the flour, while the
beef was driven along on the hoof. Officers and
men alike wore homespun hunting-shirts trimmed with
colored cotton; the cloth was made from hemp, tow,
and wild-nettle bark.
He passed over the Blue Ridge at Swananoa
Gap, crossed the French Broad at the Warriors’
Ford, and then went through the mountains to the
middle towns, a detachment of a thousand men making
a forced march in advance. This detachment was
fired at by a small band of Indians from an ambush,
and one man was wounded in the foot; but no further
resistance was made, the towns being abandoned.
The main body coming up, parties of troops were sent
out in every direction, and all of the middle towns
were destroyed. Rutherford had expected to meet
Williamson at this place, but the latter did not appear,
and so the North Carolina commander determined to
proceed alone against the valley towns along the Hiawassee.
Taking with him only nine hundred picked men, he attempted
to cross the rugged mountain chains which separated
him from his destination; but he had no guide, and
missed the regular pass a fortunate thing
for him, as it afterwards turned out, for he thus
escaped falling into an ambush of five hundred Cherokees
who were encamped along it. After in vain trying
to penetrate the tangle of gloomy defiles and wooded
peaks, he returned to the middle towns at Canucca
on September 18th. Here he met Williamson, who
had just arrived, having been delayed so that he could
not leave Fort Rutledge until the 13th. The South
Carolinians, two thousand strong, had crossed the
Blue Ridge near the sources of the Little Tennessee.
While Rutherford rested Williamson,
on the 19th, pushed on through Noewee pass, and fell
into the ambush which had been laid for the former.
The pass was a narrow, open valley, walled in by steep
and lofty mountains. The Indians waited until
the troops were struggling up to the outlet, and then
assailed them with a close and deadly fire. The
surprised soldiers recoiled and fell into confusion;
and they were for the second time saved from disaster
by the gallantry of Colonel Hammond, who with voice
and action rallied them, endeavoring to keep them firm
while a detachment was sent to clamber up the rocks
and outflank the Indians. At the same time Lieutenant
Hampton got twenty men together, out of the rout,
and ran forward, calling out: “Loaded guns
advance, empty guns fall down and load.”
Being joined by some thirty men more he pushed desperately
upwards. The Indians fled from the shock; and
the army thus owed its safety solely to two gallant
officers. Of the whites seventeen were killed
and twenty-nine wounded; they took fourteen scalps.
Although the distance was but twenty
odd miles, it took Williamson five days of incredible
toil before he reached the valley towns. The troops
showed the utmost patience, clearing a path for the
pack-train along the sheer mountain sides and through
the dense, untrodden forests in the valleys.
The trail often wound along cliffs where a single misstep
of a pack-animal resulted in its being dashed to pieces.
But the work, though fatiguing, was healthy; it was
noticed that during the whole expedition not a man
was laid up for any length of time by sickness.
Rutherford joined Williamson immediately
afterwards, and together they utterly laid waste the
valley towns; and then, in the last week of September,
started homewards. All the Cherokee settlements
west of the Appalachians had been destroyed from the
face of the earth, neither crops nor cattle being
left; and most of the inhabitants were obliged to
take refuge with the Creeks.
Rutherford reached home in safety,
never having experienced any real resistance; he had
lost but three men in all. He had killed twelve
Indians, and had captured nine more, besides seven
whites and four negroes. He had also taken piles
of deerskins, a hundred-weight of gunpowder and twenty-five
hundred pounds of lead; and, moreover, had wasted
and destroyed to his heart’s content.
Williamson, too, reached home without
suffering further damage, entering Fort Rutledge on
October 7th. In his two expeditions he had had
ninety-four men killed and wounded, but he had done
much more harm than any one else to the Indians.
It was said the South Carolinians had taken seventy-five
scalps; at any rate, the South Carolina Legislature
had offered a reward of L75 for every warrior’s
scalp, as well as L100 for every Indian, and L80 for
every tory or negro, taken prisoner. But the troops
were forbidden to sell their prisoners as slaves not
a needless injunction, as is shown by the fact that
when it was issued there had already been at least
one case in Williamson’s own army where a captured
Indian was sold into bondage.
The Virginian troops had meanwhile
been slowly gathering at the Great Island of the Holston,
under Colonel William Christian, preparatory to assaulting
the Overhill Cherokees. While they were assembling
the Indians threatened them from time to time; once
a small party of braves crossed the river and killed
a soldier near the main post of the army, and also
killed a settler; a day or two later another war-party
slipped by towards the settlements, but on being pursued
by a detachment of militia faced about and returned
to their town. On the first of October the army
started, two thousand strong, including some troops
from North Carolina, and all the gunmen who could be
spared from the little stockaded hamlets scattered
along the Watauga, the Holston, and the Clinch.
Except a small force of horse-riflemen the men were
on foot, each with tomahawk, scalping-knife, and long,
grooved flint-lock; all were healthy, well equipped,
and in fine spirits, driving their pack-horses and
bullocks with them. Characteristically enough
a Presbyterian clergyman, following his backwoods
flock, went along with this expedition as chaplain.
The army moved very cautiously, the night encampments
being made behind breastworks of felled timbers.
There was therefore no chance for a surprise; and
their great inferiority in number made it hopeless
for the Cherokees to try a fair fight. In their
despair they asked help from the Creeks; but the latter
replied that they had plucked the thorn of warfare
from their (the Creeks’) foot, and were welcome
to keep it.
The Virginians came steadily on
until they reached the Big Island of the French Broad.
Here the Cherokees had gathered their warriors, and
they sent a tory trader across with a flag of truce.
Christian well knowing that the Virginians greatly
outnumbered the Indians, let the man go through his
camp at will, and sent him back with word that
the Cherokee towns were doomed, for that he would
surely march to them and destroy them. That night
he left half of his men in camp, lying on their arms
by the watch-fires, while with the others he forded
the river below and came round to surprise the Indian
encampment from behind; but he found that the Indians
had fled, for their hearts had become as water, nor
did they venture at any time, during this expedition,
to molest the white forces. Following them up,
Christian reached the towns early in November,
and remained two weeks, sending out parties to burn
the cabins and destroy the stores of corn and potatoes.
The Indians sent in a flag to treat for peace,
surrendering the horses and prisoners they had taken,
and agreeing to fix a boundary and give up to the settlers
the land they already had, as well as some additional
territory. Christian made peace on these terms
and ceased his ravages, but he excepted the town of
Tuskega, whose people had burned alive the boy taken
captive at Watauga. This town he reduced to ashes.
Nor would the chief Dragging Canoe
accept peace at all; but gathering round him the fiercest
and most unruly of the young men, he left the rest
of the tribe and retired to the Chickamauga fastnesses.
When the preliminary truce had been
made Christian marched his forces homeward, and disbanded
them a fortnight before Christmas, leaving a garrison
at Holston, Great Island. During the ensuing spring
and summer peace treaties were definitely concluded
between the Upper Cherokees and Virginia and North
Carolina at the Great Island of the Holston, and
between the Lower Cherokees and South Carolina and
Georgia at De Witt’s Corners. The Cherokees
gave up some of their lands; of the four seacoast
provinces South Carolina gained most, as was proper,
for she had done and suffered most.
The Watauga people and the westerners
generally were the real gainers by the war. Had
the Watauga settlements been destroyed, they would
no longer have covered the Wilderness Road to Kentucky;
and so Kentucky must perforce have been abandoned.
But the followers of Robertson and Sevier stood stoutly
for their homes; not one of them fled over the mountains.
The Cherokees had been so roughly handled that for
several years they did not again go to war as a body;
and this not only gave the settlers a breathing time,
but also enabled them to make themselves so strong
that when the struggle was renewed they could easily
hold their own. The war was thus another and
important link in the chain of events by which the
west was won; and had any link in the chain snapped
during these early years, the peace of 1783 would
probably have seen the trans-Alleghany country
in the hands of a non-American power.